REACTION: Perese and Petaia join Wallabies' devastating injury list as Eddie's England level series

By Tony Harper / Editor

England are back on level terms in the three-Test series against Australia but the cost to the Wallabies was significantly greater than a 25-17 reverse in the second Tests at a heaving Suncorp Stadium.

The Wallabies ranks are thinning ahead of the decider in Sydney next week. The Australians lost Izzy Perese and Cadeyrn Neville to potentially serious knee injuries, while Jordan Perese, playing at fullback for the first time for the Wallabies, lasted just minutes before he was forced off and is likely to be ruled out of next week due to concussion protocols.

And replacement prop Scott Sio added to the carnage going off moments after coming on with an injured shoulder.

If that wasn’t bad enough – with the Wallabies having lost Tom Banks to a broken arm in the win a week earlier – his replacement Andrew Kellaway revealed at halftime that he would be missing for eight weeks with a hamstring injury suffered at training on Tuesday.

“I feel for those guys,” said Samu Kerevi. “They work extremely hard. And to go off like that with HIAs and injuries. It is hard and we will get around them and the squad will be tight.”

The Australians did well to make a game of it despite the injuries and going down 19-0 thanks to poor discipline. They got to five points behind with 15 to play when a poor lineout throw was seized on by the visitors.

England coach Eddie Jones came into the game under immense pressure but maintained his perfect record as an international coach on the ground – ending a run of 10 straight Wallabies wins at their fortress.

Owen Farrell at No.12 was immense controlling the game and keeping the points rolling with 20 of his own.

The try scorer Billy Vunipola said England needed to stand up.

“We got beaten up last week and we talked about fronting up, especially the forwards, and I thought we did that,” he said.

“I had a dressing down from my dad last week. I had to improve my game today and hopefully he is proud and the rest of England is. Today was about the boys. We did at tough last week and we know that Eddie is a nice guy but a tough guy as well.

“We had to perform today.”

There was some heat in the leadup between rival props Taniela Tupou, coming back after eight weeks sidelined with a calf injury, and England’s prickly loosehead Ellis Genge.

And it was Genge who made an instant impact – Tupou’s admission that they would smash each other, and England’s poor performance up front a week earlier, seemingly firing up the big Englishman.

Within minutes of the start Genge ran straight over the top of Michael Hooper, leaving the Wallabies skipper on his backside.

Genge sought out Hooper again soon after when Maro Itoje dragged down a lineout and Billy Vunipola went over from a maul. Genge stood up and smacked Hooper on the chest several times.

Referee Andrew Brace, a former Belgium international, was caning the Australians’ ill-discipline as Genge dominated Tupou in the scrum.

Brace let England’s Jonny Hill off with a penalty for a knock on on an intercept attempt but wasn’t as lenient when Perese did the same thing, sending him to the sin bin.

It’s a law that’s causing plenty of hand wringing.

“Maybe I’m biased. What’s he supposed to do?” said his injured teammate Andrew Kellaway at halftime. “He’s going for the ball and gets sent off. As a fan I hate to see that – as a player I hate to see it. The only people happy with it are England.”

Stan commentator Andrew Mehrtens is an avowed hater of the law.

“This is the absurdity we are seeing at the moment, with no common sense applied to some rulings,” said Mehrtens. “I absolutely take issue with this. That is not a deliberate knock on. There is no way he is thinking to knock that on.”

Former Wallaby Drew Mitchell said the Australians had bigger issues to deal with.

“We can all sit here and wax lyrical about the yellow card,” Mitchell said. “Yes it’s flawed, yes we need to do something about it., but the truth is the Wallabies are getting dominated physically, they’re not in the game, discipline is an issue, Taniela Tupou is getting dominated at scrum time.”

England only scored one try in the first half despite overwhelming dominance of a 7-2 penalty count and the Australians had Hunter Paisami to thanks – a try saving tackle cutting down Jack Nowells after England created a huge overlap.

Tupou finally sparked into action, coming up with a try right on halftime after two battering ram runs from Angus Bell. It had taken Australia 36 minutes to handle the ball in the England 22 for the first time in the game and the 19-7 halftime lead flattered the hosts.

Having lost Kellaway midweek and Tom Banks to a broken arm a week ago, they could barely afford another backline blow, but after Jordan Petaia’s failed HIA in the opening minutes, his replacement Izzy Perese was carried off with what looked a serious knee injury.

Farrell kicked a penalty then Tupou drove at the line coming up just short. From the maul the Australians went wide to the left and Samu Kerevi ploughed over, putting the ball down mere centimetres before the dead ball line.

Tupou and Bell were replaced soon after by James Slipper and Scott Sio, but the latter was replaced soon after with an apparent shoulder injury while Nick Frost came on to replace Cadeyrn Neville who appeared to have seriously hurt his knee.

On 52 minutes momentum shifted again when Marcus Smith was yellow carded for a deliberate knock on.

“That’s just a reflex,” said Mehrtens. “That’s even a worse (call) than the Perese one.”

Australia kicked the penalty as Smith took his sideline seat, closing the gap to 22-17. The hosts gave up another chance at three ponts, but their maul approach was unsuccessful.

A steal from Mat Philip on the hour was wasted as James O’Connor kicked out on the full but a moment of magic from Tom Wright sprinting 50 metres then kicking ahead and dragging Tommy Freeman into touch.

The momentum was immediately blown as replacement hooker Folau Fainga’a’s throw was deemed “clearly not straight” by Brace and instead of facing a rolling maul near their line, the English were off the hook.

Within a minute they were up in Australia’s red zone with Smith taking over to put them inches away from a try to kill the game. Australia conceded a penalty and Farrell’s kick pushed the lead to eight with 13 minutes to go.

“Just a couple of small errors have cost the Wallabies – a lineout throw not straight, a kick out on the full from James O’Connor – crucial errors when you’re on attack,” lamented Tim Horan on Stan.

England captain Courtney Lawes revealed the plan to come out hard early.

“We wanted to come out fast and we knew that in a game like this, which is pretty much, we have to win it, we have to come out of the blocks and get stuck into them,” Lawes said. “We set the tone early and we knew they were coming back. They’re a quality team but managed to stay in there.”

Beaten skipper Hooper was on the back foot from the first minute but was pleased with how his injury-ravaged side responded.

“We wanted to start the game really physical. And I think England won that battle tonight. They were throwing punches and coming down our throat pretty well.,” Hooper said.

“We managed to stop the bleeding and get back into the game. A few big moments at the end when we could have got some points we didn’t get them. The fight in this team to be in it until the end was really pleasing.”

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-12T12:31:02+00:00

Chester B

Roar Rookie


Unfortunately sufficient size and power is a base requirement in test rugby and Jock will likely get rag dolled. A player like Seru Uru for example, has all the skills but is looked upon by the coaches as not being physical enough.

2022-07-12T04:25:41+00:00

djellingjaa

Roar Rookie


I just re-watched Caderyn Neville get smashed side-on in the knee by the England no. 17 - Marco Vunipola. It's in the 55th minute of the second test. And then there is a replay in the 57th minute. Neville copped Vunipola's full body weight side on into his knee in what looked to me liked a deliberate attempt by Vunipola to maim him. It;s hard to see it in any other way. Worth a look if you're interested to see how the English play the game. There's a lot of attention paid to high tackles but Vunipola's action looks like the worst of cage fighting which is all about maiming.

2022-07-11T06:25:10+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


LSL should be there already, arguably. Why wasn’t he? Banks got a jersey on his way os It’s a mystery.

2022-07-11T05:10:44+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


Nah it’s called coulda woulda shoulda theory

2022-07-10T23:46:42+00:00

Doctordbx

Roar Rookie


Slightly worse than Hooper against England.

2022-07-10T23:37:23+00:00

Doctordbx

Roar Rookie


Is this the same multiverse where Glenn McGrath didn't roll his ankle at Headingley?

2022-07-10T22:44:29+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


I really hope Quade is available, but also that we have 5 spare rowers and four spare fullbacks.

2022-07-10T22:20:26+00:00


Very quiet overall. I think having Wilson at 8 could really shake up the back row competition and I’m hoping Holloway is fit although I haven’t heard anything yet. I also saw an article in the SMH from last night claiming LSL could be back in the mix at lock. I think that’d be fitting as he was always great for aus rugby, even though he fell out of favour. Might mean Phillip would have to play the full 80 with Frost to start?

2022-07-10T21:54:58+00:00

James584

Roar Rookie


The game changes completely if a kick for goal is converted. If in doubt, read up on ‘multiverse theory’.

2022-07-10T20:29:22+00:00

Guess

Roar Rookie


It would've been 20-22 still a loss

2022-07-10T12:29:49+00:00

AJ

Guest


You are correct there Mate, points 1, 4 and 5 indisputably so. You forgot 'mauled better'. I was there to witness it. Well done to your small but vocal group of fans at the Milton Road end, they won too.

2022-07-10T12:03:02+00:00

Check-side for the boundary

Roar Rookie


Next real second rower, down the pecking order would be Ryan Smith (Queensland Reds)...

2022-07-10T11:24:57+00:00

Frankly

Guest


Holloway in a decider.? He hasn't even played a test match yet. No way, id have 25 test Ned Hanigan before him.

2022-07-10T11:21:32+00:00

Terry

Guest


Ahhhhhhhh the old Quade woulda coulda shoulda spiel, doesn't play in a losing test, but we still get blokes like you having a subtle dig at him. All speculation again from you as per normal. Noah was the 10 in a dysfunctional Wallaby backline, not Quade. Fact.

2022-07-10T11:20:37+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Where the hell is LSL? And what is going on at Reds?

2022-07-10T11:19:21+00:00

Gaberod

Roar Rookie


Respectfully disagree there. Part of good coaching is also having a solid return to match fitness plan - that includes managing minutes on the park. Reckon if all the injuries didn’t happen JOC wouldn’t have been playing for that same reason. He was very underdone and it showed. Hindsight is 20/20 of course but I reckon if QC had played the first test, JOC might have only gotten maybe 10 mins in second or third test depending on how we went.

2022-07-10T11:00:56+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


I’d have Phipps over McDermott. McDermott falls into the trap of running and then passing. Base case for a 9 is run or pass and pass being the most common option. Running and then passing screws up the backline play and forward runners. McDermotts kicking game also poor for the reds.

2022-07-10T10:58:28+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


Agreed.

2022-07-10T10:57:43+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


Think Hodge got a bad rap. Melbourne were terrible and it’s hard to shine in a team like that with forwards going backward. His boot is such a big advantage that he’s certainly a better option than JOC.

2022-07-10T10:56:01+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


World Cup is a year away though and calf isn’t b going to do that. It’s good enough or it isn’t. They are weight related. Same as Pone.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar