Once again we learned that you should never write off a Queensland side and the Blues will be wondering how they let another series slip. Here is how I rated the players in the decider.
1. James Tedesco
In a beaten side, the NSW Captain was the second best player on the field after Kalyn Ponga. Almost 30 runs for almost 300 metres. Six tackle breaks. He can hold his head very high. 9/10
2. Brian To’o
The lad from the Riff gave it his usual best effort. However, apart from one great run in the 64th minute, his 20 runs were kept to just 136 metres, and he missed four of his six tackles. 6/10
3. Matt Burton
He put up one really good bomb but missed a few tackles. He copped a belting from Dane Gagai and got ten on the pine for good measure. Only 23 metres from his three runs. 5.5/10
4. Stephen Crichton
His best effort for the series that really highlights just what an ordinary series he had. His three missed tackles were costly with his miss on Valentine Holmes leading to the Queensland try in the 14th minute. His brain explosion in the 60th minute gave the Maroons yet another set of six. 4.5/10
5. Daniel Tupou
His 145 metres from 17 runs were offset by his three missed tackles and two errors, with his crucial bomb drop in the 39th minute leading to the Capewell try on halftime. He also took out team mate Lindsay Collins with friendly fire. 5/10
6. Jarome Luai
Standing over the prone Selwyn Cobbo giving him an earful was a bad look. His try in the 18th minute was a good look. He laid on a great kick for a repeat set in the 29th minute, but he also passed into touch in the 55th minute and missed six tackles, including his miss on Ponga in the 61st minute. 6/10
(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)
7. Nathan Cleary
Tried his absolute guts out but just couldn’t control the game like he did so well in game two. He laid on a good kick for the Luai try and did plenty of dirty work with 15 runsbut he also missed four tackles. 7/10
8. Junior Paulo
Started very strongly but faded as the game went on. His 13 runs for 121 metres were good but his drop in the 51st minute was crucial at a time when the Blues really needed the ball. 6.5/10
9. Api Koroisau
The Blues hooker had a really good game until he was replaced in the 53rd minute. His service from dummy half was good and his defence was brave and effective. However, he conceded a couple of penalties. 7/10
10. Jake Trbojevic
The big unit from the Nothern Beaches wasn’t able to emulate his dominant performance from game two. He made 13 runs for 80 metres but made all but one of his 45 tackles. 6.5/10
(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)
11. Cameron Murray
Ruled out after a head clash with Corey Oates in the first minute. N/A
12. Liam Martin
Martin really had a dip and was not disgraced. While he was stripped in 45th minute and missed four tackles, he fought out the match till the end. 6/10
13. Isaah Yeo
Yeo lost no friends in this match or in the series. However, while he toiled as hard as ever, he wasn’t able to make the crucial difference he yearned for. He made 13 dirty runs and laid 46 tackles. 6.5/10
14. Damien Cook
The Rabbitoh rake didn’t come on until the 53rd minute and was all about defence, not missing one of his 27 tackles. He was unable to impose himself on the game as NSW so badly needed him to. 4.5/10
15. Angus Crichton
Came on in the 2nd minute when Cam Murray was subbed out. He had a real dip, breaking five tackles, running ten times for 90 metres. He also laid on a great pass for the Tedesco break in the 21st minute. Copped a knock in the 42nd minute but battled on. 6.5/10
16. Jacob Saifiti
Came on and immediately made an impact with Huge runs that resulted in five tackle breaks and a try. He made 140 metres and laid 26 tackles in a great Origin debut. 7.5/10
17. Siosifa Talakai
Talakai came on just after half time and immediately had an impact in defence, forcing an error from Valentine Holmes in the 48th minute and putting in some great defensive efforts. However, consecutive errors in the 66th and 68th minutes really put a dampener on his game. 5/10
Col in Paradise
Roar Rookie
Yep a few of the top clubs would have seen this and know what to do against the Panthers in the future....keep the pressure on Cleary and Luai and they know nothing but there one and only game plan...
Col in Paradise
Roar Rookie
Teddy gets the plaudits for crabbing sideways, backwards and all over the place and generally ends up tackled and not passing....all that frustrates the NSW attack as they dont know what the helkl jhe is doing - okay breaks a tackle here and there but thats it....as for fullbacks definetly think the likes of Slater, Gary Belcher, Gary Jack, Lockyer, Graham Eadie and even Brett Mullins where better...
Brian Westlake
Roar Rookie
Any of them including Davey Bolton and Tommy... And they're both dead.
matth
Roar Guru
I think QLD came out after half time with such a clear plan that they relentlessly bought into. That’s down to the coach, captain and senior players.
matth
Roar Guru
Whereas Hunt starts producing genius plays and Valentine Holmes gets even quicker
Ben Pobjie
Expert
Tupou’s mistakes were bad, but switching teams in order to be on the same side as Lindsay Collins was unforgivable.
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
Todd Payton's non-recency of unconscious bias devices to inspire insipid and dire riots fails to fire.
KenW
Roar Rookie
Sure, that has an impact. NSW were down a long-minute forward from the first minute of the game too, so the ridiculously high energy of the entire game from both teams was surprising.
jimmmy
Roar Rookie
No but unconscious bias can be recent !
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
Which one?
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
He's more Might and Power than Winx. If Luai doesn't have a rails run two back with cover he drifts back. Talakai and Tupou were Tom Melbourne last night.
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
100% agree. Luai scored two tries in the series and...well that sums it up. Great at the Panthers. His free-wheeling play suits them beautifully. But at origin he can't do his party tricks.
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
Yeah Ponga is pretty pong for the Knights. He likes the pretty stuff but many sets doesn't even touch the ball. I'm a long suffering knights fan and I'm stoked we kept him but he often doesn't play like an origin player at clubland. He's caught Gagaitis
Choppy Zezers
Roar Rookie
Is recency bias unconscious?
zonecadet
Roar Rookie
Don't forget they were down two players and many a forward was putting in extra shifts, I think Billy only made 3 interchanges the whole half. That's why they were a little gassed. They finished the better though. I thought QLD created a lot of first half chances but didn't convert them, it was simply a matter of time.
zonecadet
Roar Rookie
He's a bit of a front runner at times.
zonecadet
Roar Rookie
No-one ever assesses Teddy's defensive flaws and what they cost the teams he plays on. He wanders around back there, or in the line, and hardly ever seems to pull off that fullback try-saver. He runs a lot, backwards a lot as well (wonder if that's still counted as metres?). He's no Billy Slater is what I'm saying. Or Kalyn Ponga it seems.
Larry1950
Guest
I think what a few opposition coaches & senior players will take from the Qld win is that a fair bit of the celebration arrogance by Penrith players of late has got them thinking they’re infallible but under pressure last night Luai, Cleary & Chrichton all came up with critical errors, having got used to everything coming off at club level. Was quite chuffed to see Luai throw that speculator pass to the touch judge & Chrichton to offload onto the ground in his in goal. Thought Cleary started to play as an individual as the screws were tightened & that won’t have gone unnoticed by the other contender’s coaching staff. They’ve had a golden run with injuries so far at the Panthers while the other big guns have been far more severely impacted so it will be interesting how Bellamy & company go at them if they get their own sides back near full strength. Always enjoy watching a cocky upstart like Luai get sat on his backside, just wish Gagai had belted him instead.
Big Daddy
Roar Rookie
Hope this little setback doesn't affect your romantic interests .
Albo
Roar Rookie
Teddy is always "exceptional" , lots of touches and hit ups, but how many tries did he score or create for others in this 3 match series ? Anyone ? Ponga was heavily involved in these things that matter in the result of each match :crying: