Queensland deserve to dominate Kangaroo selections

By The Barry / Roar Guru

State of Origin has been run and won for another year. Queensland has pulled off another famous underdog victory over a more fancied New South Wales outfit. It is now 43 years and counting and it still catches us by surprise!

At the start of this series there was talk that there wouldn’t have been many Queenslanders outside of Cameron Munster who would have been hypothetically picked in the NSW side.

With Munster hauling the Maroons to victory in Game 1 and a dominant Blues victory in Perth, maybe not much would have changed after Game 2. But last night’s win may have changed the landscape significantly.

If I was picking an Australian side, it would look something like this:

1 – James Tedesco (NSW)
Teddy was probably NSW’s best over the series and one of the few who can hold his head up after Game 3. No real serious threats to his spot yet.

2 – Dane Gagai (Qld)
Gagai is probably a better winger at this level than a centre. Brian To’o is unavailable. So is Daniel Tupou, but he’s also unpickable after Game 3. Queensland’s other wingers in Corey Oates, Xavier Coates, Selwyn Cobbo and Murray Tuilagi aren’t quite there.

3 – Valentine Holmes (Qld)
Clearly the form centre of the Origin series and arguably of the NRL. The other option would be Holmes on the wing for Gagai and Jack Wighton into the centres.

Valentine Holmes. (Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

4 – Latrell Mitchell (NSW)
If Tom Trbojevic were fit he slots in the three quarters somewhere – possibly here. As he’s not I think Latrell gets the nod over Jack Wighton and Dane Gagai.

5 – Josh Addo-Carr (NSW)
Maybe I’m biased but I still think he’s the best winger in the country and an incumbent. His non selection for NSW was a big blunder. I think Mal Meninga will pick the Fox.

6 – Cameron Munster (Qld)
Arguably first player selected – and the argument would be pretty brief.

7 – Daly Cherry-Evans (Qld)
He’s the incumbent and while I think Clearly has a greater ceiling and will have the jersey for a long time, I don’t think he’s done enough to win it just yet or DCE to lose it.

Cherry-Evans is in career best form. His kicking game is sublime and he constantly comes up with effort plays. In my team he gets the nod as skipper too.

8 – Tino Fa’asuamaleaui (Qld)
I think he was the best middle forward over the three games after Carrigan. He’s mobile and tough, the prototype for the modern front rower.

9 – Ben Hunt (Qld)
Playing great for the Dragons and has been lifting at rep level for years. The Hunt / Grant rotation worked superbly for Queensland. He adds cover for the halves and can play around the ruck as well. His 40/20 in Game 3 was a game changer.

Billy Slater and Ben Hunt celebrate. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

10 – Payne Haas (NSW)
Struggling with injury so his selection is based on the assumption he’s got time to get fit.

11 – Kurt Capewell (Qld)
Capewell has a great all round game and goes hard on every play. His first half try epitomised the ‘wanting it more’ Origin spirit as he burrowed between two Blues to get to the loose ball.

12 – Cameron Murray (NSW)
Knocked out of Game 3 and a slightly quiet series overall early but brings a lot of skill to the edge and those quick play the balls.

13 – Patrick Carrigan (Qld)
The ‘find’ of the Origin series and well deserved Wally Lewis medal winner. Changed the game for Queensland off the bench in Game 1, held his own in Game 2 and went next level in Game 3.

14 – Harry Grant (Qld)
As above, the bench rotation with Hunt has worked brilliantly. Best hooker in the NRL by some way.

15 – Josh Papali’i (Qld)
With middle third players like Fa’asuamaleaui, Carrigan and Haas, big minutes aren’t needed from the bench. I think Papali’i played well in Origin despite limited minutes and he’s been a favourite of Meninga’s in the past. Maybe he starts with Tino off the bench.

Alternative would be Junior Paulo.

16 – Jake Trbojevic (NSW) or Isaah Yeo (NSWj
Jurbo is a personal favourite of mine and another incumbent – albeit from three years ago. His value was best expressed in the way he was missed by NSW in Game 1. Yeo didn’t have a great series, but wasn’t bad. Who you go with depends on whether you want to tighten the middle or add another attacking element.

Jake Trbojevic. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

17 – Jeremiah Nanai (Qld)
Almost surprised myself that I’ve picked Nanai. His Game 3 was brilliant. Still a lot of rough edges but he comes up with plays that not many other edge forwards are capable of.

Huge future and could be a weapon off the bench.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-17T06:14:13+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Yep. Like certain Souths supporters. Hard to find them when they're not dominating.

AUTHOR

2022-07-17T03:08:46+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


They’ve been quiet haven’t they? After Game 2 every NSWman was supposed to be on hand and knees facing west and genuflecting towards Panthers Leagues Club…

2022-07-16T10:10:44+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


The third Feagai: Luigi

2022-07-16T05:44:21+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


What about Holmes on the wing and try Ponga in the centres?

2022-07-16T05:42:33+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Cleary is a superb front runner, but what happens if we end up in the trenches?

2022-07-16T05:38:13+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Tyson Gamble on the bench for X-Factor

2022-07-16T02:47:33+00:00

R N

Roar Rookie


Moses Mbye on wing?

2022-07-15T16:06:26+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Not doubting his capability, I've been pushing the ponga 5/8 barrow for years. But the shortsighted way we view coaches means it's a risky play for your own career. Especially when it already got one guy sacked. Look at Holbrook, this year was going to be tough with the spine rebuild. If he stood pat aiming for 8-9th he keeps his job but puts a ceiling on the team.

AUTHOR

2022-07-15T08:44:25+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Matty Johns picked his Australian side today. His went: 1 - Teddy 2 - Fox 3 - Holmes 4 - Wighton 5 - Gagai 6 - Munster 7 - DCE 8 - Papali’i 9 - Hunt 10 - Tino 11 - Murray 12 - Nanai 13 - Yeo 14 - Grant 15 - Ponga 16 - Carrigan 17 - Haas So, pretty similar to my team - 15 of the 17 the same. I had Mitchell and Capewell, he had Wighton and Ponga Not sure whether that’s a plus or an embarrassment :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2022-07-15T07:59:21+00:00

Rob

Guest


Tino and Haas are big minutes one out hit up machines. They might not be good together in the same team. It have a negative effect on ball movement ball touches for Yeo, Cleary, Hunt, and Munster with Haas, Tino and Tedesco fighting for a carry every set. They get the ball and its not moving.

2022-07-15T07:49:58+00:00

Rob

Guest


Ponga created most of QLD tries over the 3 games. Only Munster can rival his skills running the football at the line. I actually think the Knights require a different coach?

AUTHOR

2022-07-15T06:55:27+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Yeah, for sure. With guys like Tino, Arrow and Carrigan capable of playing big minutes in the middle third, they didn’t need big minutes from Papali’i There’s a narrative going around that he’s on e the decline. Maybe a little but he’s still playing very good footy and was great in Origin…

2022-07-15T06:21:54+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Problem for Ponga is it (usually) takes a year or two to make that adjustment. And so it's effectively writing your resignation as a coach.

2022-07-15T06:19:53+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


I do think Slater gave him a specific task - play like this for 30 is better that holding back for 50. At the risk of more broken record status, we won this in the coaching box.

2022-07-15T05:42:53+00:00

Tony Dargon

Roar Guru


Yeah, Holmes was one of the stars of the origin series, but certainly knows his way around the wing position.

AUTHOR

2022-07-15T05:30:27+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Yeah, wing ended up being pretty difficult No shortage of wingers used in Origin. To’o, Tupou, Gagai, Tuilagi, Coates, Oates and Cobbo. Either unavailable or not ready On reflection I think Holmes to the wing and Burton or Wighton in the centres makes more sense. I went with Holmes in the centres because he was far and away the pick of the centres. Also influenced by Gagai being the incumbent but not sure how relevant that will be three years after the last game…

AUTHOR

2022-07-15T05:14:21+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Cleary’s Game 2 was better than anything DCE produced but I think DCE was better across the series

2022-07-15T04:32:44+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Absolutely. Ricky still gives him around 50 mins and the only forward team mate who shades him for quality work is Tapine.

2022-07-15T04:27:44+00:00

Tony Dargon

Roar Guru


Hi TB, a good read, thanks. Just on the backs, I reckon Gagai is well past his use by date. Maybe Holmes to the wing and Burton in the centres. I reckon he's the best thing to come along in quite a while. Another option might be Ponga on the wing.

2022-07-15T04:00:41+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I don’t know why Billy restricted Papa so much. He may not give 60 these days but 25 is too little.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar