'I had a dream last night about it': Mal losing sleep over selection drama, but headaches grow after thumping Kangaroos win

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

ST HELENS – It was another easy night at the office for Australia, defeating Lebanon 66-6 – but one that, again, leaves Mal Meninga no further along the journey of picking a team to face Michael Cheika’s Lebanon in the first-quarter final next week.

The Kangaroos coach admitted he still does not know his best 17, and now his problems extend further than the long-running battle between Daly Cherry-Evans and Nathan Cleary for the halfback jumper, with several wingers and back-rowers putting their hands up for Huddersfield next Friday night (Saturday morning AEDT).

“I can’t lose,” said Meninga. “The problem is the player does. That’s the difficult thing. We’ll review the tape, but in the back of your mind you try to pick your best 17 as you go along.

“Honestly, I had a dream last night about what the team should be. You’re constantly thinking about it and you’ve got to settle on something very soon. I’ll make that decision and have that honest conversation with the players.

(Photo by Michael Steele/Getty Images)

“That’s the Kangaroos. It’s wearing the green and gold jersey. We’ve got great depth in our footy team, all 24 players are worthy of playing going forwards. That’s the beauty of it. I have to make those tough decisions very soon.”

Cherry-Evans played the first 40 as five-eighth, with Cleary at halfback, but the pair swapped at half-time. Both registered three try assists and split the kicking nearly 50/50.

“I thought they (Cherry-Evans and Cleary) both handled it really well, they shared the workload and the kicking game,” said Meninga. “We can get better as we start to look at what our best combinations are. I’m happy with the way the players have handled the merry-go-round.”

Angus Crichton, arguably the form edge for the Kangaroos so far, was given the night off but his replacement Cam Murray was excellent and Liam Martin even better.

Jeremiah Nanai was given stadium man of the match and Isaah Yeo was as consistent as ever – though he might have issues in the week after being put on report for a crusher tackle.

The starting wings were also superb. One of Campbell Graham and Murray Taulagi will take the other side to Josh Addo-Carr, but it is now anyone’s guess as to which it might be next Friday night in Huddersfield, though Meninga said Graham had played his way into contention.

One man who will certainly be in is Latrell Mitchell. He has spoken extensively of the awe in which he holds his coach, who is so beloved in St Helens that he has a mural on the side of the stadium, and the older members of the 5,586-strong crowd might have had deja vu at times watching a powerful, silky Australian centre dominate like Mitchell did in the first half.

He was superb, creating two tries for his winger, scoring another insouciantly powerful effort himself before switching to fullback as Mal rang the changes after the break.

James Tedesco, playing against the nation he represented twice at World Cups previously, also impressed but was withdrawn early in the second half.

Hearts were in mouths as it appeared to be due to a knock, but Kangaroos staff confirmed that nothing was awry. Reagan Campbell-Gillard is the only other worry after departing at halftime with a leg cork, though he is expected to play next week.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial for your favourite sport on KAYO

Italy, for their part, never stopped trying and were rewarded with a stirring second half try. Their race was run before tonight, but they kept trying short kickoffs, early shifts and chip chases in an attempt to challenge the Kangaroos.

“I’m pretty proud of that performance, they could’ve buckled and waited for it to end, but I don’t think we did that at all” said coach Leo Epifania.

“We just kept colliding the whole game. We didn’t want to sit there and we wanted to chase it. We didn’t just cop it, we through back with everything we had and tried our best.”

(Photo by Michael Steele/Getty Images)

Australia put the boot in early. DCE chipped for Val Holmes after just six minutes, James Tedesco scored against the nation he represented twice at previous World Cups and Mitchell put Taulagi in for his first on the back of a slick move.

Italy’s commitment to short dropouts was admirable, but resulted in an easy score for Graham, who used all his height to claim and cross untouched.

Mitchell then showed his strength, bouncing Italian tacklers off him en route to the line, before finessing Taulagi over moments later.

The best Aussie try of the night followed, with Tedesco splitting the defence and finding DCE on the inside, who got the ball on to Yeo to cross under the sticks.

Cleary, as if angered by DCE’s moment of class, put Martin through with a picturebook pass, and though the Italians did strike back – Ronny Palumbo touching down a Radean Robinson kick – it was a mere blip, as Murray, Graham again, then Lindsay Collins got onto the board.

The Crowd Says:

2022-10-30T21:31:23+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Baseless claim without the facts. 2022 Cleary kicked 76/89 - 85.4% Holmes kicked 100/122 - 82% 2021 Cleary kicked 94/110 - 85.5% Holmes kicked 54/74 - 73% 2020 Cleary kicked 86/108 - 79.6% Holmes kicked 24/34 - 70.6%

2022-10-30T19:44:10+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


There's always next time

2022-10-30T19:41:43+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


4th weakest for mine

2022-10-30T18:56:26+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Mal, you used Origin as selection trials but then included Addo-Carr and Mitchell anyway, plus Graham. Now you use the Kangaroo matches themselves as selection trials for future Kangaroo games. Most coaches with half a clue would have boarded the plane to UK already knowing what the finals team line up would be. Lead up games merely offering sufficient time on field for the 17, with anyone else just filling in while any of the 17 rested. To get to this point, and admit that you haven't actually finalised the finals team is a joke. To let Cleary and DCE know before game 3, that they would be auditioning against each other, while playing side by side is utter nonsense. Your time as Kangaroo coach 2022 is being outdone by your time in politics, and we all know how that 5 minutes went.

2022-10-30T16:59:20+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


Australian selectors also selected an Australian honour side in 2020 that included Cleary, which at the time was suggested to reflect future incumbency.

2022-10-30T14:43:23+00:00

Mo

Guest


Very early in his test career I’m pretty sure DCE played a superb match at hooker

2022-10-30T12:49:52+00:00

Ben Lewis

Roar Pro


“DCE has done nothing wrong” while I get what you’re saying, that shouldn’t mean diddly squat. No, he hasn’t done anything wrong, but another player has overtaken him as the best halfback in the game. Simple as that.

2022-10-30T11:30:24+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


It's always been a fairly clear conflict of interest (imo). Alexander, Gould, and Lockyer who all hold executive level positions at their clubs, as well as Johns with his consultancy work with teams. They shouldn't be allowed to call games but that's how it is. NRL don't seem to require to follow the same as other corporations. As mentioned, listen to what they say, or don't.

2022-10-30T11:27:57+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Yeah but they switched in the 2nd half, Cherry played on the half back right side for at least the final 40 mins.

2022-10-30T11:03:56+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


I didnt say anything about Alexander. I was responding to your suggestion to turn the sound off if you don’t like the commentary. Oh and btw, if you’re going to attack other posters have the guts to log in and be accountable for your posts.

2022-10-30T10:51:53+00:00

Chris

Guest


Of course you’re a Queenslander . So whatever bias you say Alexander has for anyone Penrith. You have the same bias towards a Queenslander like DCE. I’ve heard Alexander give out plenty of criticism of Penrith players in games in the past. However, of course he’s going to support Penrith players. He was their best ever player, played almost his whole career there. Is a life member & still a big part of the club . What would you expect? Reading what Cam says there about commentators. Ray Warren was quite biased towards Parramatta , though he never played for Parramatta . Kerry O’Keefe just likes to laugh at his own chat & most of what he laughs at is not even funny.

2022-10-30T10:20:54+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Some one has to do it . I was unavailable due to work commitments.

2022-10-30T10:17:50+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Matth, your not far wrong , Chrichton could be the one that may possibly be in the 17 . Whoever they pick should get the job done . The only thing Mal would do to keep everyone happy is pick both DCE and Cleary , put Munster to centre and Holmes on wing . I would hope not as Munster is far more valuable at 6 . It’s a pity we would have to meet NZ in semi as they are best 2 sides and England have been given an armchair ride .

2022-10-30T10:17:15+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


That's.... not reassuring.

2022-10-30T10:09:32+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


And we have Mitchell sucking up to Meninga saying he's in awe of him . One way of making sure you retain your position . Everyone is expecting the performances of the top seeds which is fine but to be honest the opposition is not that crash hot and you wouldn't expect them to be . A lot of squads aren't finalised until NRL grand final is played . Australia will always the benefit as most players have played SOO with or against their team mates. The real stuff starts next week and you would expect Australia, NZ and England to be semi finalists but who will be no 4 .

2022-10-30T10:06:09+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


Yes, got him on a technicality. Well played. So Munster gets punted.

2022-10-30T09:56:29+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Hagan is really the coach. Mal just takes care of the jerseys

2022-10-30T09:54:52+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Or knowing much at all really

2022-10-30T09:53:33+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Mal's never going to get to sleep now

2022-10-30T09:42:53+00:00

Ben Pobjie

Expert


Well DCE isn’t actually the incumbent - the last man to play halfback for Australia is Nathan Cleary. DCE is now the incumbent 5/8.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar