Progress in Paris, now Wallabies need to show it’s not a one off

By Brett McKay / Expert

This one-point loss was a different kind of heartbreak to the Melbourne Bledisloe loss.

Whereas the 39-38 loss to New Zealand left Australians baying for the blood of a Frenchman, the 30-29 loss to a lot more Frenchmen just doesn’t carry the same sort of anger and angst.

Though I’m sure you could pull Jaco Peyper’s handling of the game apart if you really wanted to, this loss came down entirely because of the collective actions of the Wallabies themselves, and not the whim of officialdom.

It was welcome relief on Sunday to see precious little criticism of refereeing after this particular loss.

There was still anger and angst, of course there was, but it was different. This anger and angst feels more self-inflicted, and in a weird kind of way, it makes it a whole lot easier to digest.

I can’t speak for Jim or Harry, but I found this week’s Instant Reaction a lot easier than the Melbourne edition. A lot less ranty, and certainly not directed at one person exclusively. I didn’t feel like I needed a stiff drink.

So when I said on Sunday morning’s podcast that the Wallabies will probably take more out of the Paris loss than out of the Murrayfield win, it wasn’t hard to see why.

An error-strewn outfit, who still missed 28 tackles, and still conceded nine turnovers and eight breakdown steals, and scored one of the tries of 2022, nearly beat Les Bleus at the Stade de France where they haven’t lost since March last year.

And there is still so much to improve, that maybe that’s why there’s far more upside to this performance than the win over the Scots.

But now the Aussies have got to show the improvements. There can’t be any regression against Italy.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Love the one percenters
One of the staple pieces of vision of any AFL team training at any point of the year is groups of players – anywhere from three up to probably six or eight – standing in a pretty tight circular configuration and bumping short handballs to the bloke beside them.

To the left, then to the right, or vice versa, and back again. Often a couple of balls going at once. All designed to make short, sharp, instinctive handballs in traffic an unconscious act. Muscle memory, almost.

Every player will do that same drill multiple times a week, every week of the year from preseason to grand final day.

Tom Fullarton (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

I’m sure the Wallabies – and all our professional teams, for that matter – do lots of skill-building drills every week for the same reasons as any other professional sporting pursuit. I’d be stunned if they weren’t.

But there’s always room for improvement.

So many of Australia’s turnover errors were little things – misdirected passes, poor ruck-ball presentation, lineout throws, shanked kicks, misdirected kicks, all of them.

Can the Wallabies say they were happy with their execution of the ‘little things’ against France? I’d be surprised.

Will they spend this week and every week from here re-loving the one percenters? I’d hope so.

All we are saying… is give youth a chance
I feel like I’m repeating myself with this, so I’ll keep it to the point.

The young guys must play this week against Italy. There are still seven on tour yet to see any action, and that can’t be allowed to extend into a fourth week.

Play the youngsters against Italy, then dangle the carrot of Ireland at Lansdowne Road in front of them. Be bold or willing enough to let them earn another game next week. And then the week after that in Cardiff.

I don’t know where I read it on Sunday but I absolutely agree with it: we can cop rookie mistakes from actual rookies. So let them learn their lessons and add to their development on the pitch wearing a gold jersey.

Enough holding tackle pads in training shirts when experience amounts to nothing on the field.

There is no ‘try’ in the set piece
“Do or do not. There is no try.”

Wise words from an old master, training his frustrated underling in a swamp far, far away.

But that has to be the attitude around the set piece, because it remains a continual source of possible exploitation for opposition forward packs.

While ever scrums remain at the whim of referees, every scrum needs to be accurate in terms of the picture presented.

Lineouts in the final minutes have to be viewed the same way as a lineout in the first. Arguably, they’re even more important when trying to close out a game with a narrow lead. There cannot be too many variables, or too much drop off in quality once the bench is in play.

Never mind World Cup ambitions, you might not win even just a Test with an accurate set piece – but you definitely won’t win one without it.

Turn pressure into more pressure
Too many times in the last two weeks, the Wallabies have fallen to their own scoreboard pressure while leading in the last ten minutes of games, when it really should be the other way around.

Last week against Scotland, it was lost restarts, knock-ons, scrum penalties, running out of room against sidelines, deliberate knockdowns and ruck penalties. All while leading.

This weekend against France it was similar. Tackles off the ball, hitting lineout jumpers before mauls were set, kicks charged down followed by even worse kicks with players in front, and shanked restarts. Again, all while leading.

It’s bad enough when decision making is poor when trailing on the scoreboard, but it’s surely worse when that poor decision-making comes while leading on the scoreboard.

The non-negotiable for Italy
Must. Start. Well.

That simple. There’s too much evidence around this playing group over the last two years being poor game-chasers, so the last thing they can let the Azzurri do is front-run.

Of the 14 losses over the last two seasons, the Wallabies trailed at halftime in 13 of them, and the other one was a draw. Of the 11 wins in that same period, they’ve come from behind just twice.

There was so much to take out of the France loss, and it will remain a game they really should have won.

So they must start well against Italy. They can’t afford not to.

The Crowd Says:

2022-11-09T06:54:26+00:00

Ben Pobjie

Expert


Incidentally anyone notice the UK commentator in the France game referring to Tom Wright as “the former NRL superstar”? I laughed.

2022-11-09T00:21:19+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Looks like we best agree to disagree disagree to agree there Waxy. :laughing: :laughing:

2022-11-08T20:12:37+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


You may or may not remember but I’ve been a critic of our non-playmaking playmaker for about 8 years. (This is the guy Cheika welded a 10 jersey to, after telling Quade to ‘work on his passing’, oh the irony) To be fair W’head, I have only seen long shots of the moment. It may well have been a Hail Mary from Foley, so I won’t argue too strongly in defence of him. However poor the pass though, it was the right idea to exploit that space on the left. And it made Ikitau look good. :happy:

2022-11-08T20:03:24+00:00

Noodles

Roar Rookie


Lose-lose situation I guess Numpty. In any case Rennie has said he is selecting for Italy mindful of the games ahead. So I imagine he's chosen the riskier option.

2022-11-08T19:36:46+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Brett yes true but .....does anyone expect WBs to progress past the quarter final at RWC ??

2022-11-08T19:31:31+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Ken The great long range try was started by a bit of amazing skill from Ikitau. Foley did another panicky hail mary pass and Ikitau magically saved it and started the movement. Aust/Foley were very lucky Ikitau didn't spill that bad panic pass and did not gift a 2nd 7 pointer to France. He's had a looong consistent history of doing exactly that :laughing:

2022-11-08T19:24:06+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Jacko I totally disagree with your statement hehehe :laughing:

2022-11-08T19:20:28+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


Well absolutely but if you compare those Wallabies to the dominant AB teams the ABs were far more ruthless in putting less talented teams to the sword. The point I tried to make was that even in their dominant era the Wallabies lacked that ruthless edge. The most disappointing aspect in recent times is that the Wallabies have produced the odd outstanding display and then regress dramatically in the next match.

2022-11-08T18:56:10+00:00

Martah26

Guest


The Wallabies are in pretty good shape, they just have to believe it, the ARU has to believe it, and the Oz fans have to believe it. Out here they play against teams, AB's,Boks & Puma's, who don't fall for the publicity hype of the NH it's a high bar and you're ruthlessly exposed. But it pays dividends when you come up against the rest of the world, as we saw against France. Don't stress I reckon next year will be another SH vs SH RWC final.

2022-11-08T18:35:37+00:00

Connor33

Guest


I actually think it's be the results below that deliver wins next year - and I reckon Italy, Ireland and Wales will be worried. Ikitau and Tupou could easily become the best in their position by then, Koribete already is, and Valentini has gotta be top 3. Plus AU's still the only team that's beaten France in the last 16-17 months, and then come to within a point of France in Paris when France belted the Abs last year. I remain hopeful: They should have beaten France They should have beaten the ABs earlier this year Should have won 2-1 against England Should have beaten Scotland and wales last tour Shouldn’t have drawn twice against the pumas the previous rugby championship

2022-11-08T18:29:18+00:00

Connor33

Guest


That's my prediction, too. By thirty or out in flames. But I sense that there's a subtle, new mentality in the team I reckon, i.e., to play a little more freely and have a crack. Florence will be dry and 18 C on Saturday - conditions not unlike Adelaide. Provided that they have their first team on the bench, and if I had to choose, I reckon 42 - 12. (20-12 at half time).

2022-11-08T18:19:05+00:00

Connor33

Guest


True, Ken. He actually saw the space out wide before he twisted and tapped back to start the Foketi try. Had he not done that, there was no try and the French are all over him--ruck--and perhaps score a try regardless. I saw that tap back also used for bombs. But yeah, folks are quick to criticise Foley, but not point out the positive that he does across the park. Hasn't he only missed one kick all season>

2022-11-08T17:30:13+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


“ Even in the McQueen era the Wallabies were inconsistent.” scrum, I would offer that back then it was more disciplined and measured. They would just beat teams that the ABs would demolish, sure. But I think that was part of the plan. McQueen crafted wins in battle, but always with an eye on the war.

2022-11-08T17:22:04+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Foley’s twisting pass was the start of that long range try, no? I wondered what was going on there, it was only one dropped ball away from a French try. But it stuck, all the way to Foketi’s try.

2022-11-08T14:37:19+00:00

Brendan NH Fan

Roar Rookie


different situations. RA has a historical legacy to deal with, where as most of the Italian fans and players would be new since 2000. Even in Italy the top10 complained and they where taking the best talent from them some they have adjusted it again. It does help having your two pro teams only 2.5 hours apart and having one of those being majority private funded. But yes all these players are now in much better training, matches etc then 20 years ago. The problem RA has like NZRU and SARU which is 20 years ago they had the best environment. SANZAAR needs to give the RC teams the same competitions 6Ns gives otherwise RA players don't get the same development.

2022-11-08T14:20:23+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Old saying, “It’s harder to win a test series than the WC.”

2022-11-08T14:18:08+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


AAA on the bench. No need for Banks as Hodge can cover a lot more, especially if DR goes 6:2. Therefore Campbell stays and gets the exposure to international football that he needs and deserves.

2022-11-08T14:11:26+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Then there are the Harry Wilson’s of the world, left out of tour for “work ons”, top SR stats, get 40 minutes, don’t perform as the “miracle man” and get, not dropped but, discarded. Great way to develop depth and confidence.

2022-11-08T14:02:08+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Are we playing them, ABs and SA, too much? Concentrating on a game plan to take on those two and not changing tactic for other opponents, expecting to beat other teams with a game plan that’s not really suitable?

2022-11-08T13:58:23+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Thanks BNHF. Sounds as though the Italians are really getting their act together and seriously growing the game. Maybe AR should have someone over there learning from the Italian experience.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar