Warner’s epic 200 gives him chance to retire on top rather than risk sour ending in India or England

By Paul Suttor / Expert

David Warner can now retire on a high after turning back the clock with his magnificent double-century in his 100th Test against South Africa on Tuesday at the MCG. 

It’s time to get out while the going is good by making next week’s SCG Test his last one.

This inspirational knock, fighting cramps in the extreme heat as well as the effects of several blows to the NSW left-hander’s body, is the kind of Hollywood script fodder that would make a perfect ending to an against-the-odds sports movie.

But even though Warner’s well-documented century drought stretching back nearly three years is over, that doesn’t mean, at 36 no less, he will now suddenly discover the secrets to scoring runs in India and England, the two destinations where he has struggled for nearly a decade.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

Reality is much harsher than a Hollywood script.

David Warner celebrates his double century. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

In his eight Tests in India from 2013-17, he has just three half-centuries from 16 innings, a top score of 71 and an average of 24.25. 

As for England, he went to the crease 25 times from 2013-19 without ever making a ton. He’s managed seven half-centuries but averages just 26.04 with a highest of 85. 

And his last tour was a nightmare – 95 runs at 9.5 with 61 of them coming from a single innings.

Stuart Broad was his nemesis four years ago and will be waiting for him again at the top of his mark, around the wicket.

It was pleasing to see an all-time great of Australian cricket, one who has often been unfairly maligned for his bullish nature, show that he was not a spent force.

And not only did Warner reach triple figures but he showed that old dominance to double that figure before ongoing cramps forced him to retire hurt.

It was very on brand of Warner to drop to his knees and celebrate his 200, then try to launch into a celebratory leap even though he had already been cramping up and he knew deep down that the theatrics were probably not the best idea.

But it’s that same stubbornness which has led him to a stellar career at international level after he was initially seen as T20 specialist who would become famous for novelty shots and bludgeoning power rather than the traditional skills that make batters great.

It was in just his second Test when he proved he was made of the right stuff – an unbeaten 123 against New Zealand in a rare home loss to the Black Caps at Hobart in 2011. 

Warner carried his bat in his fourth-innings vigil of more than six hours, ending up with a score more than double any other batter in the game to win player of the match honours despite being on the losing team.

If he had failed in Melbourne and Sydney following the 16 previous Tests without a century, the current group of trigger-shy selectors would have been forced to let him know that they could no longer wait for him to come good. 

Past players frequently say that it’s better to retire a year too early than a year too late. You want people to say why did you give it away when you did rather than why did you wait until it was too late.

Warner now has that opportunity to go out on his own terms.

David Warner raises his bat after scoring 100. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

After all the recent dramas surrounding his appeal and subsequent retraction over his lifetime leadership ban for the ball-tampering dramas of 2018, being in control of his exit from Test cricket should be more important than risking it all by trying to reverse history at his two least-productive ports of call.

India have leapfrogged South Africa to second spot in the World Test Championship. They will likely have Jasprit Bumrah back from injury and Australia cannot afford to carry an underperforming veteran. 

As for who should replace him, the selectors do have options with Matt Renshaw, Marcus Harris and Cameron Bancroft in form in the Sheffield Shield ranks this summer.

Each of them has learned a lot about their game since their first forays at Test level. It would be tough for them to come back into the team for tours to India and England, with a World Test Championship final likely in between, but there is rarely an easy time to work your way into the Test team. Players either sink or swim if they’re good enough or not. 

Each of these openers has had a chance and have worked hard to potentially get another one to prove their careers shouldn’t drown without a trace.

The likely scenario, however, is that Warner will plough on. That same bullish nature which has taken him past 8000 runs in his century of Tests.

And even though the odds will be against him overcoming his poor record in India and England, he will either succeed or go down swinging, just like he has for his entire career.

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-29T15:20:53+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Bang on. We finally have Head firing at his potential in the right spot. Never, ever try to fix one problem by creating another.

2022-12-29T15:16:38+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


No, he wasn't. Ponting just got worse and worse, that final ton further and further away. Very few, almost none, go out near their peak. Greg Chappell comes to mind

2022-12-29T02:51:57+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


No chance of Warner retiring ever. The Australian central contract is still the biggest money spinner possible for him. Warner has twice pulled the rabbit out of the hat. The T20 world cup in 2021, where he scored big to get a decent new contract in the IPL. This test match where I think he was not going to play in Sydney if he failed again. Whats really indicative of Warners mindset is all his warnings to Green to be careful of his workload , in other words avoid the IPL.

2022-12-28T22:04:55+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


Yawn zzzzzzzzzzzzz

2022-12-28T20:37:10+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Wouldn’t just official matching polo shirts and shorts be more appropriate? For some. The more appropriate attire for some would be matching restraints and gag...

2022-12-28T16:04:20+00:00

Nobody likes a smarta*s

Roar Rookie


I would like to see Warner go out now – we need to get some more 20-somethings in the top 4. Renshaw for mine.

2022-12-28T12:38:51+00:00

Grand Panjandrum

Guest


Yeah, I agree. This 200 is a good knock, but it's an example of infinite monkey theorem He eventually was going to score a century if given infinite chances to do so.

2022-12-28T07:48:11+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Yes, I've never understood that obsession with fancy suits & ties. Wouldn't just official matching polo shirts and shorts be more appropriate?

2022-12-28T07:22:37+00:00

Grand Panjandrum

Guest


Unless the selectors have had the chat behind closed doors to Warner indicating they are going to tap him on the shoulder after Sydney (ala the selectors with Steve Waugh), only a fool would retire early. This is not a profession like law or academia where you can take a few years out, reassess and then come back in At his age, once he is out of the team that's it. No coming back. Play for as long as the selectors are willing to select you, and as long as your employer is willing to pay you. You owe no-one nothing.

2022-12-28T07:18:20+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Fair point. But my honest opinion is that Warner should've been dropped before the opportunity to retire in any case.

2022-12-28T07:12:45+00:00

Grand Panjandrum

Guest


I think he should retire immediately after this test if he wasn’t going to be selfish and give his replacement the Sydney Test to bed themselves into the test side before the India tour. Not one single Australian cricketer (or any cricketer really) has been that selfless, so it's hard to see why David Warner should be. I think Damien Martyn was the last player I can think of who snap retired mid-season/mid-series and in their pomp.

2022-12-28T06:47:15+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


...probably not in the media either. I don't know how you can say that when you recall some of our current and recent talking heads. And speaking of... I wish the TV stations who stuff their comms into suits & ties would stop. It looks awkward and inappropriate.

2022-12-28T04:42:20+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


I would think Warner would want to play in the Test final which we will likely make. There is no apparent replacement that can take the game on and dominate or dominate a game for us. But Harris and Renshaw appear to be next in and have probably earnt a spot. Both need to succeed next time around and I think they will.

2022-12-28T04:14:34+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


I think he should retire immediately after this test if he wasn't going to be selfish and give his replacement the Sydney Test to bed themselves into the test side before the India tour. But I guess we're resigned to expecting him to have the dream to play both the Indian & Ashes tours now. :thumbdown:

2022-12-28T04:04:11+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Warner shouldn't be having anything to do with the Ashes!!!

2022-12-28T03:56:16+00:00

Pop

Roar Rookie


Warner wouldn’t like the thought that he may be considered a failure in India and England. His determination to go out on top with a good series in England, in particular, I believe is there. He also would be part of Australia’s response to “Bazball”, if Australia decide to go toe to toe with England with that strategy. However I could understand him retiring after Sydney, particularly after scoring a 200 against arguably the best and fastest attack in he world. What a memory for all of us!

2022-12-28T03:44:55+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


You maybe right but l think he'll do like Walt in "Gran Torino"

2022-12-28T03:33:57+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


No he won’t, he said weeks ago he wanted to finish after the Ashes. Candace won’t tell him otherwise

2022-12-28T03:32:48+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


No, after the Ashes. Start with Renshaw to replace Warner then.

2022-12-28T03:11:04+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Warner should bow out on his home deck next week and then play T20. However he will plough on and we know how the movie will end in India and in Ashes with Broad licking his lips. Or perhaps maybe just maybe the old dog has one last trick and surprise us all and conquer his batting everests.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar