Northern View: 6N a 'fantasy land of twists and turns' but one game was so grim 'the thousands who were blotto were the lucky ones'

By Mick Cleary / Expert

Meanwhile, in other news, Ireland battle through in Rome, England silence the Principality in a dirge-fest while France and Scotland serve up a delight in Paris. And, by goodness, did we need those rays of sporting sunshine at the Stade de France, a fleeting interlude of magical possibility.

The Great Escape that sport usually provides found itself headed down a cul-de-sac last week, fenced in on all sides by the gloomy realities of daily life. The misguided old platitude that sport and politics should never mix, trotted out so often years ago by those short-sighted reactionaries when trying to justify rebel tours to apartheid-plagued South Africa, got a modern-day airing when the Wales players starkly reflected the mood of the time in strike-afflicted UK when threatening to withdraw their labour in much the way that train staff, nurses, doctors and teachers have been doing. And they all have due cause.

The issue was resolved but it hasn’t gone away. And it doesn’t just affect Wales. There is little doubt that rugby has a money problem. Put simply, there isn’t enough of it to go around. Or not at the wage levels that players have been used to. Even the supposed fat cats, the English, have seen two clubs, Worcester and Wasps, go bust while mighty Leicester have recently declared that they need a £13million hand-out from two benefactors to avoid financial meltdown.

England head coach, Steve Borthwick, has been bemoaning the fact that he might be without several players in the future when they hot-foot it to France after the World Cup in search of greater riches than are currently on offer in the salary-cap restricted Premiership.

The RFU will have to change its policy of not picking players who opt for elsewhere or find some more loot for the Premiership. Australian rugby is hoping for a much-needed uplift from Circus Ringmaster, Eddie Jones, to get their code making back-page waves once again and getting fans through the turnstiles to help replenish the coffers.

South African players have long had to head north to find gainful employment while even New Zealand has had to resort to selling off space on the cherished black jersey. It is not what you might call a buoyant scene. It’s as if (ex-Prime Minister) Liz Truss were in charge of the sport.

The international game is a money-spinner. There were gate receipts of £9million ($A16m) on the line at the Principality Stadium, a decent enough wedge to persuade the powerbrokers to get round the table and chisel a deal. Even so, there will be a reckoning at some point for players.

Rugby does have a fit and proper role in the market place as shown by the millions that tuned into the action from Cardiff while there are only positive vibes emanating from Ireland and France these days, off the field as much as on it. But the strongest are also defined by the weakest. If rugby in Wales or Australia goes to the wall, everyone suffers.

Enough of harsh truths and stern realities. We’ve got two more years left of a Tory government so the wider miseries are likely to continue. We’re going to need our dose of escapism.

At least the Six Nations is delivering on that front, a Fantasy land of twists and turns, plot lines that Hans Christian Andersen would be proud to spin in order to tease our imaginations and nowhere more so than in Paris on Sunday afternoon. We had beauty, we had beasts (two red cards within the opening 12 minutes), we had joie de vivre from both teams, muscle, marvel and, most importantly, uncertainty until the closing moments. Bravo France. And Bravo Scotland. Who would bet against them derailing Ireland’s Grand Slam Holy Grail quest at Murrayfield in a fortnight’s time ? Not on this evidence, that’s for sure.

Such scares, such challenges to any presumptuousness on behalf of any of Les Bleus whose thoughts might be turning to a coronation parade at their home World Cup (England 2015, pal, is sure to be on Shaun Edwards lips on a daily basis) will have been well served by the thrilling fightback of the Scots. For the jour de gloire to arrive for France, they are going to have to fight for every inch of their home turf.

One man unlikely to see any of that tournament is prop, Mohamed Haouas, who was sent off for the second time in three years against Scotland. Quel Plonker. Earlier Scotland lock, Grant Gilchrist, was wild and reckless when clattering Anthony Jelonch. Both red cards were 100% the correct call. When will players ever learn?

It was more the Brothers Grimm than Hans Christian from the Principality Stadium as Wales and England kicked the leather off the ball and achieved the unimaginable in reducing the usual boisterous (ok, yes, pissed-up) crowd to mere whimpers and groans. The many thousands who were blotto were the lucky ones as they won’t be able to remember anything.

Owen Farrell of England talks to Alun Wyn Jones of Wales following the Six Nations Rugby match between Wales and England at Principality Stadium  (Photo by Dan Mullan – RFU/The RFU Collection via Ge

England are trundling down the back-to-basics route with no apologies to those who might reckon that the game right now might need to get as many bums on seats as it can if it is to pay its way. Given the upheaval of the last days of the Eddie Empire, perhaps they have every right to go about their business as, for example, the Springboks have – be true to type and heed no-one.

England had enough about them to score three tries, one a well-crafted beauty from Anthony Watson, back in the Six Nations fold for the first time in a couple of years. Wales, meanwhile, managed an interception try from Gloucester flyer, Louis Rees-Zammit and bugger-all else. Warren Gatland must wonder what he has let himself in for. Well, apart from a salary of several hundred thousand pounds a year. He’ll earn every penny.

Italy are fully invested in dreams of improbable feats, trusting in the future by bringing through young talent and daring to give it a crack on the field. Of course their stats make for rather gloomy reading – their 34-20 loss to Ireland was their 24th Six Nations defeat in a row at home – but the scoreboard does not tell the full tale.

Ireland, even though they had made seven changes following their seminal win over France, still came to the Stadio Olimpico with the status of the world’s highest ranked side, hard-nosed as ever, toughing it out even when Italy closed to within four points in the second-half.

Ireland plough ever further forward on their Grand Slam quest – and deservedly so – but Italy, with their clever, enterprising play ought to be welcome in anyone’s TV living room during this Six Nations championship.
Two rounds to come, two more weekends to close the curtains and shut out the bad news. This Championship keeps on giving.

The Crowd Says:

2023-03-02T05:00:34+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


maybe u didnot understand my question does the Laws say the hooter is the final whistle ? or when the ref blows and says half time. coz i have seen may games where the ref plays on even after hooter - ACCORDING TO HIS WATCH !!! even French captain was confused with that one.

2023-03-01T23:40:22+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


Yes, a bit of fun. Both teams are at a bit of a low point so the bagging of the game in this article appealed to me. I like to keep up to date with 6 nations but wasn’t sure I had the time to see the whole game, I was surprised by how short the highlights were. With Wales in our pool, it is interesting to follow how they are travelling. The pay dispute could not have helped.

2023-03-01T02:55:35+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


I'm all for poking fun at NH teams but I found it to be quite a good game. The Eng team played a brutal game through the middle and really attacked the defensive ruck. Steward played his usual brilliant aerial and counter attack role and Watson, Lawrence and Malins all ran well. The Welsh also played good rugby and constantly threatened but lacked penetration. Their new 10-12 might come good with time The were only two low points for me. 1. Farrell - who I am biased against as I don't like him - who couldn't kick straight and therefore his game is reduced to just shoulder charging alone. 2. Raynal - who I am also biased against and don't like -who had no idea and is a complete potato. He reversed his view of the scrum after the Welsh prop corrected him and he failed to call a penalty for crawling on the first English try with the whistle only going halfway to his mouth before he had an episode of brain failure and forgot what was happening

2023-02-28T20:56:04+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


From memory, the ball went out over the sideline after the siren which means half time. France then took a quick throw and scored which was disallowed Not as bizarre for me as the first try which was fine but then play was called way back for the initial hit up red card resulting in a penalty to France from that spot even though the subsequent try stood. Back to the future stuff

2023-02-28T10:19:13+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


WRT money, surely we are reaching a tipping point where supply outweighs demand and so salaries have only one way to go?

2023-02-28T10:18:31+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Gatland has a difficult challenge but the way he's going about it is about 5/6 years out of date. There is talent available for selection and there is a game plan they could attempt, although flyhalf is a bigger problem for Wales than it is for Australia, he just chooses to go with what he knows.

2023-02-28T08:29:14+00:00

adastra32

Roar Rookie


Nice soundbites Mick, but it's a full reboot situation, not business as usual. For England, it is learn how to win (again), then entertain. At the moment, it looks like it is starting to come together. However, the biggest challenges now await....

2023-02-28T08:06:46+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


Please , can some expert on Laws explain to me how that 40th minute try scored by France was nullified by the ref - saying the hooter had gone off ? form the very little i know - it is the referee on field who decides he time and hooter is just an indicator. has this changed now ? so if the hooter goes off the game ends as soon as there is a break in play ? rugger laws are so hard to keep up with :sick: :sick: :sick:

2023-02-28T07:21:08+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


Was thinking that JD. They've also already passed the total number of tries scored last 6N campaign by three. Although with France and Ireland to come, they may be at far more of a premium ....

2023-02-28T03:54:47+00:00

Shag Haitaitai

Guest


Just long enough to send me to sleep.

2023-02-28T00:03:45+00:00

Malo

Guest


England and Wales are too slow , gone why have such slow forwards , poor selections

2023-02-27T23:19:46+00:00

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie


There's plenty of money in rugby. Unfortunately too high a proportion is spent in Japanese and French clubs!

2023-02-27T23:09:46+00:00

JD Kiwi

Roar Rookie


I wonder when last England scored three or more tries in three 6n matches. There are definitely improvements on attack.

2023-02-27T16:46:12+00:00

Brendan NH Fan

Roar Rookie


Leicester lost two home games due to Wasps and Worcester folding. That has to hurt after struggling through the Covid years. Add in that their TV deal dropped by 25% and you see the cashflow problems. As one of the highest attended clubs they should be fine. Wales is another story, their income is about 50% more than RA and on par with NZR and IRFU and they only need to run 4 teams, 3 of which are meant to be private. But paying fat cats and letting the old clubs divide the money and not understanding how professional sports work has seen them underfund the URC teams meaning young players go to England. Until the WRU do what SRU and FIR did and make the hard calls and sort out their structure they are going to continue the decline. if they sort things out they can run surpluses like those two unions that allow them to make changes.

2023-02-27T13:23:18+00:00

Neil Back

Roar Rookie


Eddie's gone. It's a similar relief to when I had less likelihood of encountering Trumps increasing brain farts in a pronouncement of power. Everything after that is a win, regardless of the alternative.

2023-02-27T05:24:48+00:00

Malo

Guest


I’ve thought the six nations games have been tough , fast and fantastic. Loving it and believe the World Cup will be held by and one of Four six nations side, with France and Ireland most likely with Scotland the dark outsider. Russell is a magician.

2023-02-27T04:06:52+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Wales have good players... their centres and Zammit are young and good... their forwards are... lacking a bit... but foundations are solid. I think this year was going to be a bust year no matter what, given the contract negotiations going so badly outside of the actual rugby. Boy, they look sad.

2023-02-27T01:32:36+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


I watched the Stan highlights package, the highlights of the first half was about 3 minutes long.

Read more at The Roar