Reds need someone to cut through the bulls--t: Cheika is the right choice at right time

By Christy Doran / Editor

COMMENT: Whether or not Brad Thorn sees out the year as Reds coach is irrelevant. For the rest of the year, the Reds will be treading water.

Without a fit tight five, the Reds have Buckley’s of giving this year’s Super Rugby competition a shake.

What the Queensland Rugby Union needs is a coach with international pedigree and someone who can do three things.

First, make the Reds not just finals contenders but Super Rugby champions.

Second, get fans – and the media – excited to watch them play and read about them.

Third, ensure the players pulling on the jersey get back on track in an upwards trajectory rather than stagnate.

While the Reds want Robbie Deans as their next coach, the QRU should sign Michael Cheika. Photo: Charlie Crowhurst/Getty Images

Former Wallabies coach Robbie Deans might well be able to fulfil those criteria. But, realistically, the chances of the QRU signing Deans is slim given the successful career he has carved out in Japan.

With somewhat of a rebuilding mission required, Deans would be taking a massive gamble of trying to turn the Reds around. And for what point? Deans won’t return as Wallabies coach.

Instead, the QRU should put aside their egos, forget about politics and go hard after another former Wallabies coach. Michael Cheika.

The Reds need a heavy hitter and no one on the open market comes bigger than Cheika, with the Argentina coach likely to step away from Los Pumas following this year’s World Cup.

Before you spit out your coffee, hear me out.

Cheika has gravitas.

Like Eddie Jones, Cheika commands a room. When he speaks, you listen.

The moment he appeared on Stan Sport, the broadcaster’s quality rose exponentially.

Naysayers even got an insight into Cheika’s tactical nous. Who’d have thought?

Michael Cheika should become the Reds’ next coach. Photo: Dan Mullan/Getty Images

Rugby in Australia also needs characters. Without them, it’ll die a death. The money from private equity and a World Cup every two decades will run only so far.

Cheika versus Jones was a battle in itself when the two coaches went toe-for-toe in 2016.

Jones won on and off the field, but the two former Randwick forwards put Australian rugby front and centre of the sporting landscape in Australia.

The Reds need a circuit breaker, too.

While Thorn got the Reds back on track, they have gone backwards over the past 18 months.

Before then, the QRU stuffed up their coaching appointments.

The one move they got right was appointing a Victorian-born, New South Welshman-schooled, Ewen McKenzie, in late 2009.

In the space of two years, McKenzie, a man with almost a decade of head coaching experience and Jones’ former right-hand man at the 2003 World Cup, oversaw the Reds’ transformation from cellar-dwellers to champions.

Perhaps McKenzie benefitted from a side that was primed to succeed after being thrown in the deep end by Jones and developed by Phil Mooney, but some coaches can get more out of others. McKenzie could, and so can Cheika.

Former Reds coach Ewen McKenzie saw the franchise go from cellar-dwellers to champions in the space of two years. Photo Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

The Reds need to move away from tradition and throw the kitchen sink at landing Cheika.

Cheika has form turning underperforming sides into champions.

He cut through the bullshit at Leinster to lead the Dublin-based side to the top of Europe.

Ditto, the Waratahs.

He even found instant success at the Wallabies before losing his way.

Since leaving the Wallabies he has turned Argentina into a World Cup bolter.

Last year, Los Pumas defeated the Wallabies by a record margin at home, beat the All Blacks in New Zealand for the first time and knocked off Jones’ England at Twickenham.

What’s more, Cheika is an Australian. He loves the underdog status. He’s a match made in heaven for Queenslanders.

Michael Cheika (L) the Argentina head coach celebrates with captain Julian Montoya after their victory over England at Twickenham. Photo: David Rogers/Getty Images

So, what’s in it for Cheika?

Well, Cheika wants to coach the Wallabies again down the track.

What better way than rebuilding your reputation in Australia and turning the Reds into a formidable outfit in the same way he did the Waratahs.

While there aren’t rivers of gold in Queensland, surely RA can get Stan involved. After all, he was on their broadcast team in previous years.

The Reds need a head coach who will pull the playing group into line and give them a purpose to play.

They don’t need an assistant coach learning on the run with little to no international experience.

They need a head coach.

The Crowd Says:

2023-04-17T10:11:45+00:00

cs

Roar Guru


When Tooly says the answer is obvious, he's just throwing a dummy. Yet the general point is sharp and easily overlooked. I'd also love to see Jake White mess further with the presently apparently dazed Queensland mind. Comical would be envious of a rival headline stealer. He's wrong about Cheika of course.

2023-04-17T00:50:46+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


EJ

2023-04-17T00:05:42+00:00

Jimbo81

Roar Rookie


The Brumbies are an extremely cynical team that kill the contest. For that I have never liked them. The reason I don't like Dan McKeller is that he picked 18 Brumbies in 2022 and they lost 62% of Tests. You get pretty fed up watching the Wallabies lose and the main reason is biased selections.

2023-04-16T23:25:04+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


I don't think that that was his fault alone. You had an axe to grind before he was appointed to the Wallabies gig.

2023-04-16T21:24:45+00:00

numpty

Roar Rookie


That's a very simplistic view. He's now been successful at 4 different teams, you don't just fluke that. Every coach needs good assistants. Agree they are his main strengths though.

2023-04-16T06:58:24+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Thanks for providing all the evidence anyone would need Hooter. What evidence do I have to support the "Disruptive force"? Wel just google "Toxic environment" and consider the whole scenario. I rest my case your honour!!! Just google QC Stouch with Toulon if you want more info.

2023-04-16T04:55:53+00:00

Big Dave

Roar Rookie


Yes, would be interested to see a chart mapping reds W/L against wallabies W/L.

2023-04-16T02:57:36+00:00

CW Moss

Roar Rookie


The Brumbies are up there with QLD State of Origin. :happy: I'm from down south so mixed feelings but when the Reds are winning so do the WB's.

2023-04-16T02:33:35+00:00

Jimbo81

Roar Rookie


38% is not well

2023-04-16T02:11:08+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2023-04-16T02:10:30+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Not too many coaches you can name that have a positive winning percentage against the All Blacks. Wallabies play the All Blacks, Springboks and the poms more than any other sides and the they are the three hardest to beat.

2023-04-16T02:06:51+00:00

Big Dave

Roar Rookie


Yeah it's intriguing, wish we could bottle whatever they have down there in Canberra....

2023-04-16T01:49:08+00:00

Uriah Heep

Roar Rookie


You talking EJ or Greg Smith ?

2023-04-16T01:05:18+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Lost me at "Tactically decent". Run at all costs and physicality are not good tactics. You hire Cheika for his ability to manage players and recruit players. I think he needs really good assistant coaches to manage the game plan and the tactics.

2023-04-16T01:03:05+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Nice one Train but Tooheys is a really bad beer.

2023-04-16T01:00:58+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Jimbo, I don't think I have ever seen your explanation for such anti McKellar statements. He did well at the Brumbies, and I don't think he was terrible at the Wallabies. Did he run over your dog?

2023-04-16T00:58:22+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Really good comment T Bradley. Hit the nail on the head :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:

2023-04-16T00:56:50+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


I agree with you Kai however some players are picked later in life and don't have exposures to the early skills development. It is the champion players that work to improve their core skills, no matter how good they are that become the greats e.g Jonny Wilkinson, Stephen Larkham etc. On the flip side you have the naturally gifted players that get picked that do not improve and seem to make no attempt to get better, The Fullback Who Will Not Be Named is a classic example - in a six-year career as a professional rugby player he failed to develop his defensive skills, positional play, passing or kicking skills and in two years of AFL failed to get the skills required for success there either.

2023-04-16T00:45:16+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Didn't agree with your first post but think there is merit in this one. :thumbup: :thumbup:

2023-04-16T00:44:33+00:00

Hooter

Roar Rookie


Tin foil hat too tight Pete?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar