The unique phenomenon of sports rivalries

By Jess Weimer / Roar Rookie

There is really nothing else that can quite capture the feeling you get from wholeheartedly believing in a sports team or player. The feeling of wanting them to succeed at all costs.

It’s something intangible that you can’t control or properly explain. Something that can be completely irrational. Something deep down inside of every one of us fans that just wants the team we love to crush all rivals.

The introduction of the Dolphins into the NRL this year has given me (a die hard Brisbane Broncos fan) a fresh personal perspective into these rivalries.

Rivalries of course aren’t limited to the NRL. I think about the Wallabies and All Blacks. Boston Celtics and the LA Lakers. Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen in the F1 arena. The legendary rivalry of Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal. The list is infinite.

These rivalries then bleed into relationships in day to day life. They often make even the most level headed of us do or say things totally out of character. It’s not uncommon to hear stories of ill fated tattoo bets among friends that see the loser forever branded with the mark of a team they despise.

I was there Round 4 at Suncorp Stadium to see the much hyped sell out “Battle of Brisbane”. It saw the first clash of the new Queensland rivals fighting over the symbolic ownership of the hallowed Lang Park turf.

Jamayne Isaako is tackled. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

As great as the game was, the lead up was just as engaging.

So-called Broncos supporters were jumping on the Dolphins bandwagon. Dolphins fans waltzing around yelling “phins up” at the supermarket, the schoolyard, the pub. Dividing allegiances among families. Mate against mate. The country was simply buzzing about this match. It was outstanding.

Battle lines were drawn for a friend who’s husband suddenly decided that the Broncos, who he was a lifelong fan of, were suddenly on the outer. Maroon and gold in the bin and the red was in.

Her and their two children who remain true to their Broncos roots were certainly seeing red. There were talks of changing the house locks and exiling him out to the shed. I rather liked my suggestion of moving him to the pool where his “phins” could be put to good use.

My dads chosen rival is often not one from the opposing team. He is a fairly quiet man under normal circumstances but when we sit at Suncorp that persona goes out the window.

The ref and touch judge are the ones in the firing line. “Where’s your glasses mate” is one of many clever sledges that come flying out in their direction.

Then there’s one of my work mates. He is a serial performer of the irritating Viking clap which is synonymous with being a Canberra Raiders supporter.

Last week leading up to the clash of my Broncos and his Raiders I let his repeated performances of the Raiders tradition bait me into agreeing to a good old fashioned jersey swap bet.

Ha! Easy bet! Brisbane were unbeaten and flying high sitting atop the ladder; Raiders were languishing in the dungeon.

Oh dear, oh no. It did not end well for me. An entire day wearing that lime green monstrosity in public will be one of the most dejecting experiences of my life.

To the non sports fan you’d think “big deal”. Those of us who bleed the colours of our team understand the horror. That is sure to be a fun experience this weekend.

And lastly let’s talk about the players themselves.

In the lead up to the “Battle of Brisbane” both coaches attempted to deem the match as not being overly significant.

Brisbane coach Kevvie Walters played down the clash to the media the week prior claiming “I haven’t even thought about next week”.

Broncos coach Kevin Walters. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

The stadium full of fans and Brisbane centre Kotoni Staggs certainly didn’t seem to agree with that sentiment.

77th minute. Match in the balance.

Staggs collects a grubber kick in the Dolphins in goal and starts evading defenders.

He runs the length of the field to score the match winner. Red “Phins” rain down from the top tier. Staggs declares Suncorp Stadium as “our f**king home”.

Broncos fans rise as one. Dolphins fans drop, heads in hands. Pure elation and utter devastation in equal measures.

A new rivalry was alive.

It’s moments like these that make sporting rivalries an unmatchable life experience for me.

Unexplainable, irrational, euphoric and at times heartbreaking, stressful, soul crushing experiences.

How good.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2023-04-17T09:09:02+00:00

David Roderick

Roar Rookie


I was also at the game ... grew up at Redcliffe and played my junior league there, so the Dolphins passion runs deep ... but also have loved the Broncs since they joined the Big League . I hoped the Phins would win but wasn't too upset when the BBs got up at the end ... it was a wonderful game with a lot to enjoy ... going home on a packed train afterwards a security guard said to me he'd never seen such a happy crowd ... everyone was in good spirits, despite a majority being in Dolphin shirts. I hope the rivalry remains a friendly rivalry, where we want our teams to win, but ok if not ... Hopefully everyone in Bris can support both teams, and we can enjoy a friendly rivalry .... with our hatred reserved for those who truly deserve it (All Sydney teams plus Canberra).

2023-04-14T06:37:06+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


You might be right. My BRL team, Valleys, was universally loathed. They have been around since 1909 and enjoyed their share of success.

2023-04-14T05:12:00+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


for a long time it was Collingwood vs Fitzroy because they neighboured each other and depending what side of the street you lived would dictate who you played for. Some shenanigans around getting kids to live with their grandmother instead if that would change the residential zoning.

2023-04-14T03:34:28+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


RL and all sport is built on tribalism and neighborly hate.

2023-04-14T03:33:08+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


Give it some time Nat, like 100 years. In that time, Bris v Redcliffe will resemble Easts v Souths, Saints v Cronulla, Liverpool v Everton, Yankees v Dodgers, Carlton v Collingwood.

2023-04-14T00:27:42+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I was at the game and, like you, a Bronco fan for life. I hold no grudges against the Dolphins but it was a little unnerving when the Dolphins chant went up but equally as proud when the Broncos chant drowned them out. It’s interesting to me that in Qld we play our rivalries with respect and good spirit but in NSW they have an absolute dislike of each other. Yet come Origin time they think it is a rep game but Qlders turn into Spartans. (I may have watched 300 recently :silly: ) Do we still consider the ABs and Wallabies a rivalry?

2023-04-14T00:22:29+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


My favourite rivalries: Canterbury v Parra, Canterbury v Easts (grand finals 74, 80, 2004). Melbourne v Manly. Good article Jess.

2023-04-14T00:01:00+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Great article Jess ! Captured the local rivalries that abound in our great game.

2023-04-13T23:01:15+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


I can imagine your growing sense of horror watching the Broncos game last week. Must have seemed a sure thing, that bet. At least no money was at stake.

2023-04-13T22:56:11+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


Titans v Tigers is an alphabetical local derby that always gets the blood pumping.

Read more at The Roar