Bad news for Blues after Panthers announce Cleary hamstring scan results: 'Some serious issues there'

By The Roar / Editor

Nathan Cleary is out for the next six weeks, ruling him out of the rest of NSW’s State of Origin campaign after he limped off in the early stages of Penrith’s scrappy 26-18 win over St George Illawarra on Sunday night.

The star halfback clutched at his left hamstring after pulling up while trying to make a cover tackle in the 16th minute and was taken to the sheds straight away for treatment.

He is not only out of game two at Suncorp Stadium on June 21 but the series finale in Sydney next month as the Blues they try to bounce back following Queensland’s 26-16 triumph in Adelaide on Wednesday night.

“We’re going to be without him for a while”, Panthers coach Ivan Cleary said. “I’m not a doctor but it’s a significant injury. We’ll get scans tomorrow and we’ll know more. I think he’d be very unlikely.”

And those scans reveled a tear that will sideline him for six weeks in a bitter blow to the Blues and Penrith’s mid-season chances.

Nathan Cleary clutches at his hamstring. (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

Blues chief advisor Greg Alexander said straight after it happened that it did not appear to be a minor injury. “You could tell that he was in trouble immediately,” he said on Fox League.

“You could see by the look on his face that he knows it’s more than just a twinge. He tried to take off and then you could see him hobbling back into place. When it was tested he was immediately off the field.

“To force him off and be so noticeably bad there’s got to be some serious issues there.

“It’s tough to speculate on the seriousness of it before he’s got scans. But looking at those images, I guess everyone at Penrith is trying to be as positive as possible and hoping it’s low-grade. I’m hoping (for) the same thing.”

He was shown in the sheds limping around in obvious discomfort after taking off his playing gear and had his leg heavily wrapped as he watched the rest of the match from the bench.

Cleary was heavily criticised for his performance in game one for the Blues after the team collapsed in the final 10 minutes to concede two tries.

They need to win the remaining two matches to ensure Queensland don’t retain the shield for a second straight year.

Sharks star Nicho Hynes, who was a bench utility in Origin I, is likely to start at half for the Brisbane clash.

“He’s been in tremendous form for the Sharks,” said former Maroons half Cooper Cronk on Fox League, who also nominated Brisbane veteran Adam Reynolds and Eels playmaker Mitchell Moses as candidates.

Panthers winger Brian To’o said Hynes was ready after making his Blues debut last week off the bench.

“Nicho is definitely someone who takes a lot of pride in playing footy and he can live up to the jersey and do his job for the team,” the NSW speedster said.

Nicho Hynes was 18th man for the Blues in 2022. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Cleary looked angry as he walked off midway through the first half – the match was poised at 6-6 at that stage after Mikaele Ravalawa scored for the Dragons to cancel out an early touchdown to Brian To’o.

The opposing wingers again touched down later in the first half – To’o latching onto a cross kick from Jack Cogger, who came off the bench to make his Panthers debut by replacing Cleary at half.

There was another heart-in-mouth moment for the Blues when Penrith’s NSW five-eighth Jarome Luai rolled his ankle but he was able to play on.

From 12-12 at half-time, the match remained deadlocked when touch judge Wyatt Raymond controversially flagged for a knock-on by Dragons winger Mat Feagai which referee Chris Sutton had signalled play on.

On the next set, Sunia Turuva touched down for the Panthers.

“I saw the referee call ‘Gone backwards’ three times; he makes the call and then it gets changed,” said interim Dragons coach Ryan Carr.

“It’s a huge moment and they score off that set, but we couldn’t challenge it because it was too late.”

Play was held up for several minutes after Dragons forward Jack de Belin was knocked out after trying to make a tackle on Panthers prop Lindsay Smith.

He returned to the bench by full-time and looked to be in good spirits despite the heavy blow.

St George Illawarra centre Zac Lomax soared high to again square the ledger 15 minutes from full-time but Kiwi prop Moses Leota was the unlikely scorer of the match-winning try in the 70th minute.

The Dragons looked like they equalised late in the contest when Tyrell Sloan stepped his way past a few Panthers to score under the posts but Ben Murdoch-Masila was pinged for an obstruction after the veteran forward stopped in the defensive line.

A late penalty goal calmed Penrith’s nerves and sealed an eight-point win to retain a share of top spot with Brisbane.

with AAP

The Crowd Says:

2023-06-11T21:21:48+00:00

Slammin_Sam

Roar Rookie


I don't think he folds as much as your 5/8 in big games....

2023-06-08T11:06:48+00:00

Muzz Manyana

Roar Rookie


Hi Max, I thought Hynes struggled in last seasons final series. He didn’t handle the pressure very well.

2023-06-08T09:13:44+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


2022 Munster out Dearden in, 22 years old and had a blinder. NSW indecision is negating Nick Hynes potential, two weeks of media speculation ? The Panthers duo need to step up or step out. NSWRL

2023-06-06T22:40:08+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Yet the King no longer plays. So it’s like the King is dead. Long live the King? :laughing:

2023-06-06T10:19:52+00:00

Tetley

Roar Rookie


I agree Hynes does have a lot to prove. I’m absolutely positive he feels that way too. He’s probably thinking how can I prove myself if no one gives me a shot? I mean the guy has done pretty much all he can do to get selected – and it begs the question if he can’t get selected in this situation (i.e. with Cleary out of the picture and him already in the squad) at what point does he get selected? NSW is actually in a pretty good position selection-wise. There’s a heap of halves in great form behind Cleary. None of them seem risky propositions. You’re throwing them into the blast furnace of Suncorp, to be sure, but I reckon all of them would feel ready to deal with it.

2023-06-06T07:04:31+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


What happened in the final and who were the opposition? When it really mattered Luai folded like a lawn chair. Just like in Origin.

2023-06-06T07:03:18+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


With that hair he looked more like the Bride. :laughing:

2023-06-06T04:24:38+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


But, but, but he made a bad best man’s speech…

2023-06-06T02:37:01+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


I didn’t say that I thought Hynes was a bad player. Think he’s a good player, just yet to prove a lot. Not too sure ? I think I’d go with Walker at 5/8 & Reynolds at half this time. Both in good form & have played as a partnership before. However, I like Moses long kicking game too. I wouldn’t mind having Burton there as a centre or bench player. As he also has a kicking game to worry the opposition & could be an alternate kicker. It’s a lot of pressure to put on whoever goes in this game, so maybe someone who has done the job before.

2023-06-06T00:33:25+00:00

Tetley

Roar Rookie


A friendly ribbing. I meant no harm. But with the “unquestionable one” now injured NSW have got to pick someone to replace him right? I’m just suggesting Nicho gets that’s job. Who do you want in there?

2023-06-05T23:59:57+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Oh jeez don’t bring that up. The only time in my life I’ve been to a loading origin game at Lang Park.

2023-06-05T23:44:05+00:00

TJ

Roar Rookie


The Dally M certainly has it's flaws but I don't think there's any arguing that Hynes has been one of the best players in the NRL over the last 18 months. Reynolds has been very good in that period as well but Hynes has been on another level IMO.

2023-06-05T23:18:53+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Many think Cleary still has a lot to prove? Fair enough! So going by his record at halfback, compared to Hynes record at halfback. Clearly , Hynes hasn’t achieved anything as yet in comparison to Cleary. Makes your original comment look ridiculous, as to how you feel about Hynes . With him having nothing to prove . You can see that too. That’s why you replied with a petty remark. :thumbup:

2023-06-05T22:48:32+00:00

Slammin_Sam

Roar Rookie


Lets get our facts straight i think its closer to 51 years what Luai has done in the last couple unless the bunnies want to count Charity Shields as premierships...

2023-06-05T21:24:44+00:00

Tetley

Roar Rookie


Poor Nathan! So many milestones but he's yet to reach the final frontier of enduring, unquestioning and universal adulation ... ;-)

2023-06-05T19:40:33+00:00

Robbo

Roar Rookie


As a Qlder I dont want to see Moses lining up at 7

2023-06-05T12:12:25+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Despite Hynes still having a few defensive issues. He created holes in the Broncos defence multiple times. The fact that Cronulla didn’t finish these breaks off with tries doesn’t change that fact.

2023-06-05T12:06:59+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Really. If a halfback wins a a few SOO series, wins a couple GF’s , makes it to 3 GF’s, leads the country to a World Cup win & looks like one of the best halves around in another season, before getting an injury. Many raise questions about whether they are a good player or not? So given that…Hynes has a lot to prove yet, as a halfback. :laughing:

2023-06-05T11:07:25+00:00

Renegade

Roar Guru


I’m sure cleary would go great playing at right centre… I would expect better knowledge from you Albo :thumbdown:

2023-06-05T09:53:31+00:00

Robert Garratt

Roar Rookie


Poor Nathan

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar