It's up to fans to play their part in building our football culture

By Mike Tuckerman / Expert

Perhaps the biggest lesson to take from an intriguing week of Australia Cup quarter-finals came from a state league ground in Melbourne’s western suburbs.

Melbourne Knights’ 3-2 win over fellow Victorian Premier League side Heidelberg United wasn’t just the most dramatic result of what was an enthralling round of cup action.

The Knights needed a 90th-minute equaliser from Swedish striker Lars Kinnander after the Bergers had midfielder Antony Lesiotis sent off 10 minutes from full-time, before Mitch Hore struck a swerving extra-time winner to send Somers Street into delirium.

The fence underneath the Mark Viduka Stand collapsed under the weight of supporters when the Knights scored their last-minute equaliser, with more than 2200 spectators generating a raucous atmosphere inside a ground owned and built by the club.

And when Hore arced home a long-range winner in extra-time, they almost blew the roof off the joint.

It was cup football at its most dramatic and a reminder of what it is that makes football special.

Less impressive was the suggestion by South Australian NPL side North Eastern Metro Stars that A-League outfit Melbourne City had skipped out on a traditional post-match meal after City’s fractious 2-1 win in front of another 2000-strong crowd at Shutter Reserve on Wednesday night.

City needed late goals from Curtis Good and new German midfielder Tolgay Arslan to see off the stubborn South Australians, with Arslan converting a stoppage-time winner at the second attempt after goalkeeper Isaac Carmody got down low to save his initial spot-kick.

City substitute Terry Antonis was spotted giving it large to the home fans behind the goal following Arslan’s winner, with MetroStars tweeting that City skipped out on the post-match meal the South Australian side had prepared for them.

Visiting Director of Football Michael Petrillo later countered by saying that City’s players and staff had been abused by MetroStars officials – with the whole thing a bit of an unedifying end to what was another cracking cup tie.

It was a reminder, at least, of the passion generated by the Australia Cup – even if some of it often feels misdirected.

You have to wonder what sort of connection there could ever be between the A-League Men and this mooted National Second Division when just about every Australia Cup tie prompts an endless barrage of ‘franchise football’ vitriol from fans of lower league sides.

Nowhere else in the world do you find such aggressive hostility between supporters of clubs in competing divisions.

At any rate, it was a fallen A-League giant who led the way in terms of atmosphere when Brisbane Roar downed Western Sydney Wanderers 4-2 at a packed Perry Park on Saturday night.

The travelling Wanderers fans played their part – urging their side on in a frenetic first half and generating plenty of noise, which in turn prompted the Brisbane Roar supporters behind the goal to get loud themselves.

The locals ended up having plenty to cheer about as Carlo Armiento cancelled out Marcus Antonsson’s opener for the visitors, before teenage striker Thomas Waddingham flicked the Roar in front.

(Photo by Albert Perez/Getty Images)

Even after Jack Clisby had pulled Western Sydney level in a pulsating tie, Ross Aloisi’s side refused to lie down, as diminutive Joe Caletti and finally Henry Hore – whose brother Mitch scored the winner for Melbourne Knights a few days earlier – put the seal on proceedings.

It was a hugely entertaining night of football and one that sadly wasn’t replicated on Sunday afternoon, as Sydney FC steamrolled Western United 3-0 under a blazing hot September sun at Leichhardt Oval.

It ended up being an advertisement of everything that’s wrong with Australian football, as fans sought shade on the broadcast side while the two teams did their best to play attacking football on a rock-hard pitch blighted by rugby league markings.

Football’s administrators continue to make baffling decisions – the Australia Cup Final is literally scheduled to take place on the same weekend as a truck rally at AAMI Park – and we can’t trust them to do what’s right for the game.

But you can make your own fun in the Australia Cup – something a handful of small but vocal crowds proved this week.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2023-10-03T01:08:06+00:00

JoshW

Roar Rookie


The West isn't known for that though.

2023-09-23T21:46:13+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


These players will be interesting to watch this year - possible Bobo and Delpierre or not!

2023-09-23T21:43:17+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


Your figures are normally rubbery. Perhaps more than a scholarship player. And you have to remember – the A Leagues is only one of the steps in a football career. No AFL player, man or woman, can ever have the same fame and usually fortune of a Sam Kerr, Ellie Carpenter, etc. Our Matildas have world wide fame and sponsorships and are more well known than any AFL player – so if you want to set your benchmark low in terms of achievement, then play AFL and not football.

2023-09-23T21:11:35+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


Most people from the west are decent, educated and law abiding people so “pretend ultras” or a more correct term d1ck heads don’t represent them.

2023-09-21T04:04:17+00:00

NoMates

Roar Rookie


Funny how AFLW are now paid higher then ALM in some cases. They just had a $2.2bil shake up for wages. How the APL can only dream.

2023-09-20T06:38:07+00:00

Garry

Roar Rookie


Dont forget..para plus 8pm tonight for Asian games

2023-09-20T01:19:16+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


There's nothing on Keepup!! Nothing in the MSM. How are people meant to know. I rely on Twitter but many don't.

2023-09-20T01:11:37+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


Those people really need to be weeded out. Drastic action needs to be taken. I am so sick of these nutcases giving ammunition to the mainstream media. They do not care about the harm this does to the game so I say 1) use surveillance cameras to ejecting them from the ground. If there are no cameras then it is worth investing in some 2) give them a heavy fine

2023-09-19T22:53:06+00:00

Ferno

Roar Rookie


Tonight, Melbourne City at Asia Champions League. CCM tonight and Macarthur tomorrow at AFC Cup. Good lucky to them. Their success would be good for Australian football.

2023-09-19T20:56:16+00:00

JoshW

Roar Rookie


There'll never be 'safe smoke' at WSW games, the current pyromaniacs would never agree to it.

2023-09-19T15:21:00+00:00

Rodger King

Roar Rookie


This is why you can't have direct promotion to the A League based only on a seasons on field performance. There are so many other factors that have to be taken into consideration. But this isn't the correct forum to discuss how P&R could be implemented.

2023-09-19T12:50:10+00:00

NickA

Roar Rookie


Fair enough. Not knocking the kid! Just hope it isn't tokenistic.

2023-09-19T10:21:38+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


Nick, Quinny"s been at Roar academy since age 13. Always stood out. First came to note when Charlie Austin noticed him and took him aside afzer training, stepped him around the box in front of goal coachong him from different shots on goal.

2023-09-19T09:24:31+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


5 hours and I expect to he home tomorrow nihht. Not really the place to ppst thus but it helps me a lot. Look after your health men, don't linger on seeing your gp.

2023-09-19T08:49:59+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


I mean the administrators of the domestic leagues in Australia. Pretty sure that was obvious…

2023-09-19T08:40:59+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


Exactly right Brainstrust. Some still talk about many of these ethnic clubs like they have thousands of supporters. Sorry, I don't see them. If they exist they certainly don't attend. If they only get 2k in a one off Australia Cup match, how many will they get in the NSD week in week out? Meanwhile, the people we should be looking to attract, even as semi regular attendees, are some of those that attended the WWC. Not all obviously because many were event goers but a lot were current grassroots players and their families.

2023-09-19T08:23:24+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


I hope all went well and you’re out and about soon.

2023-09-19T08:21:16+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


Lionheart, I've said it before and will say it again. I'm not sure if any of the clubs currently wanting to join the NSD have the finances o be involved. They're all waiting for someone else to pay for it. For this reason, I believe the NSD will have a Champions League format, unless the FA somehow subsidises it via a potential increase in sponsorship they might gain after the success of the WWC but I doubt it.

2023-09-19T07:18:30+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


I think it speaks volumes for Roar. Unlesss he’s a dud, which I doubt, Cahill would be quitr selective. To add, made mjy day really as I lie in horpital after major surgery, expect to go home tomorrow though. #GOROAR wife may not be impressed I’m talijng Roar

2023-09-19T07:00:54+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


A lot of pressure on a footballer who is the son of Tim - hopefully it works out. You’d imagine that Tim thinks it’s a good move for him because if he’s there on name only he’ll be quickly found out.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar