'How much does Australian rugby want to learn from the world?': Why you've got to stay tuned into World Cup

By Brett McKay / Expert

Here’s a hot take to kick off a column: Australian rugby fans tuning out of the Rugby World Cup now are only going to punish themselves.

The Wallabies, of course, were ‘all but’ out of contention heading into the final weekend of pool matches, and their rugby purgatory was officially ended – not without drama – in Toulouse on Sunday night.

But knowing all this coming into the weekend, I think I was looking forward to the rugby more than at any point of the tournament so far. Why? Because suddenly I could watch what was always going to be fantastic rugby with no emotional angst or stress.

And I wasn’t disappointed. It was as thoroughly enjoyable as I hoped it would be.

Wales and Georgia turned out to be a surprisingly good contest. Wales were never really in danger of losing, but Georgia sure as hell made them work for it. It might be the sort of hit-out Wales will be very thankful for next week.

Samoa very nearly brought the first upset of the tournament, and had they have managed it, it would only have made Owen Farrell being timed out of a penalty goal attempt because he was too busy arguing a point with referee Andrew Brace all the funnier.

But for the avoidance of doubt, Samoa have been a touch disappointing so far, to my viewing at least, with their performances not really matching their promise coming into the tournament. But pushing England as far as they did definitely amplifies the argument that the supposed ‘Tier 2’ teams definitely do need more scheduling assistance from World Rugby.

The Wallabies following their World Cup loss to Wales in Lyon. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

The mooted Nations Championship being conveniently ring-fenced until 2030 at the earliest isn’t a great look either.

Ireland and Scotland was every bit the cracker we all hoped it would be.

The mostly South African conspiracy theories were amusing during the week, what with the references to the Celts joining forces on the battlefield to double-cross a tyrant Braveheart style, and the acknowledged irony of Nic Berry being placed in charge of a game that could impact the Springboks indirectly.

But the theories were dented early when James Lowe crossed in the second minute, wounded significantly when Hugo Keenan scored a wonderful set-piece try in the same corner in the 26th minute, and finished off mercifully when Ireland scored twice more before the break to lead 24-0 at halftime.

A reminder, tinfoil hats can be recycled, ‘Boks fans.

Keenan had a double by oranges, but the aforementioned 26th minute try came from some simply beautiful play, featuring connection between flyhalf and midfield not seen in Australian colours at all this season, and a pair of offloads from Bundee Aki and Gary Ringrose that – to use a cliché very well-worn this last month – should both be hung in the Louvre.

Ireland’s defence was suffocating, their breakdown work overbearing, and their lineout impenetrable – a significant point to note considering how very hold and cold it had been through the early pool games. It will face an even sterner test now, in earning a Quarter Final date with New Zealand next Saturday night.

Emiliano Boffelli celebrates after scoring his team’s fourth try against Japan at Stade de la Beaujoire on October 08, 2023 in Nantes. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Argentina produced their best performance of the tournament to progress from Pool D, and they needed to, because Japan also produced their best performance of the tournament to almost stop them. In a truly intriguing contest, both teams looked at different points like they would go on with the job and/or completely both it.

It the end, Mateo Carreras completing his hat-trick was the catalyst for Argentina to skip far enough ahead, setting up a really interesting Quarter Final clash with Wales in Marseille on Saturday evening.

Did I say without the stress?

That was the case right up until the point chaos broke out in Toulouse, where after Fiji and Portugal went to the sheds locked at three-all, three converted tries and a yellow card in eight minutes turned a thoroughly gripping contest on its head while simultaneously waking Australia up from its rugby slumber.

Could Os Lobos actually win this? Never mind, Fiji is back. No, they’re not, Portugal is back in front. Nope, Fiji is in again. And now they’ve kicked a penalty. And another one. Oh well, might as well have some breakfast.

Wait, WHAT IS HAPPENING?!? Raffaele Storti scoots into space down the short side, finds his mate Rodrigo Marta who SCORES!! Can they actually win this?

Yes, they can, Samuel Marques converts from out wide! PORTUGAL WIN!!

But not by enough. Remember the maths? The cruellest of irony was always going to involve Portugal beating Fiji for the first real upset of RWC 2023, but not by enough for the Wallabies to limp through, tail between their legs and with a growing injury list.

Raffaele Storti of Portugal scored his team’s first try against Fiji at Stadium de Toulouse on October 08, 2023 in Toulouse. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)

So here we are. The Wallabies are on their way home or wherever their end-of-season trips takes them, Eddie Jones may or may not stopover in Japan, and Australian coverage of the remainder of the tournament is now at the behest and the generosity of editors.

Jones has discovered this already when he spoke to less than half a dozen (and almost certainly only Australian) journos at the Wallabies resumption of training late last week.

But for fans who’ve been crying out for great rugby to watch, now is actually the time to tune in properly.

These next three weeks are going to feature the kind of rugby that Australia had the players to be part of as recently as July, but not the selection patience by August to preserve.

The various levels of state scepticism, anguish and distrust now in play around the centralisation plans are a flow-on from this dramatic and severe case of self-harm.

But while Australian rugby enters a new era of shooting itself in the foot, the Rugby World Cup will only get better from here.

The question then becomes, how much does Australian rugby want to learn from the rest of the world?

The Crowd Says:

2023-10-15T21:25:52+00:00

Around the Ankles

Roar Rookie


The age group super games are a good start but they really shrink the pool. NSW could field 2 or 3 more teams of the same quality as the one tuning around. Again, in France their is a national age group comp loosely based around the T14 and some D2/ 3 teams. Increase opportunities, don’t shrink them.

2023-10-13T16:15:19+00:00

Thing Me

Roar Rookie


Let me have the last word. No!

2023-10-13T16:12:43+00:00

Thing Me

Roar Rookie


And there are not only thousands of Kiwis living there but South Africans. we need to keep plugging away with the Rebels and the Force. Perth had the biggest crowd ever at their new stadium watching the rugby. Not those other codes but rugby union.

2023-10-13T16:06:22+00:00

Thing Me

Roar Rookie


I live in an area where there are thousands of Kiwis are living. They know they're never going to get a lookin so they join the more reputable league clubs instead. It's a big country and talent abounds but for some reason unless you live in Sydney or Brisbane you're never ever going to be selected State or nationally.

2023-10-12T20:44:46+00:00

Lorry

Roar Rookie


Noone from Sydney cares about the GWS though... maybe particularly in the area theyre based... it's league territory. Swans of course are completely different. If GWS weren't winning matches due to favourable draft system, they would have the lowest support in the AFL

2023-10-12T11:23:45+00:00

Jonathon Wallace

Roar Rookie


Honestly, I don't enjoy the game nearly as much as I used to. There's more penalties, cards and TMO interventions then ever. It's never been more defensive. It's slow, turgid stuff.

2023-10-12T01:08:14+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Yes I think we are in agreeance. The Force do a lot of work with the WA juniors, not sure what happens elsewhere. The age group super comps that have been running are a good start

2023-10-11T23:21:50+00:00

Around the Ankles

Roar Rookie


Perhaps we are talking about the same thing. There needs to be more scope for Tier 2 and 3 to run at the same time so developing players can be given incremental exposure to T2. The T14 teams in France regularly bring up U20 players into the senior squad for a week or 2, expose them to pressure then let them go back to U20 to work on what they need. We don't have that opportunity available. It is mostly cotton wool or playing time, the better a player is the fewer games they will play and most of their playing time won't be under much pressure. So for SR to work for Australia and NZ then the links between T2 and T3 need to be far more organised.

2023-10-11T07:36:32+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


That's a failure of RA to institute a proper third tier, not of SR. Expecting kids to go from club to SR against NZ players who've come from long NPC experience is too much

2023-10-11T07:33:50+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Fans are heading for the exit in droves because the quality isn’t there. Diluting it even more is a death sentence. I really wish people would stop repeating this like it's a solution and not just restating the problem

2023-10-11T06:11:19+00:00

moaman

Roar Guru


To all you Aussie Roarers out there; Now your nag has finally been dispatched to the glue factory (and hopefully that annoying little jockey goes too eh?) how about throwing your weight behind your little old neighbour? Not only is your neighbour good-looking (in a humble sort of way) but also happens to be the underdog too when going up against a mighty big Irish Wolfhound. Don't forget too your Wallaroos will soon be in action again when the inaugural WXV commences on the 20th.

2023-10-11T03:22:19+00:00

Around the Ankles

Roar Rookie


SR doesn't work, it hasn't for a long time. The players signed to the SR clubs simply don't play enough, particularly if they are development players. Compared to France's T14, SR is bad and getting worse. It fails in terms of product and it fails in terms of development. There is no quick fix, a major renovation is required.

2023-10-11T01:59:00+00:00

Lukas

Roar Pro


I'm now very skeptical that there is enough money or good will to start an NRC. My point is that even without that tier, I feel like there's a lot of scope to do things better with the structures we have. Arrest the steep decline.

2023-10-11T01:33:49+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Have a quick look through the history of Wallaby results on wiki, and note the improvement shown almost immediately following the NRCs inception (reinception) in 2014. Coincidence maybe, or evidence that NRC works?

2023-10-11T01:31:33+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


debateable

2023-10-11T01:20:41+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Jez North that is a very ignorant view of WA rugby.

2023-10-11T01:18:54+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


FF you arnt getting it right. Their "Clubs" are no different to our SR franchises. Just a different way of referring to them. These "Clubs" play in the major comp at SR level. You cannot compare Leinster to Manly. Thats like comparing the Qld Reds to Brothers.

2023-10-11T01:16:17+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Why cant RA make it work like NZR does? NZR has an NPC which gives all its non test guys another 10-12 weeks of rugby and its done ok in the last 100+ years in different forms. Fiji has come straight in and made their national team better in 2 years of SR. Its not the comp or the rugby its RAs incompetence. Just to give an example I watched the NZ v Aus women this year only to find out it was 30mins up the road and I would have gone had I known. Not 1 thing from RA and yet Im on their mailing list. They fail at pretty-much every job they are responsible for.

2023-10-11T01:13:15+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Yes we all know what you think mate. You once again ignore the fact we were eliminated and had to start from scratch, were beginning to produce top level talent and had to go back to the beginning. Are producing it again now and the same clowns are looking to do the same thing again. It’s just sad how entitled your lot are acting. I have an image of you stuck on a mountainside after a plane crash, bashing a guy on the head so you can eat him and complaining “why are you so entitled!?”

2023-10-11T01:12:00+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


I’m genuinely not sure what comp you are referring to. SR - the fact it's not working right now doesn't change the fact it has and can, we need to stop looking for constant quick fixes

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar