In the immortal words of LL Cool J, don’t call it a comeback.
Australia’s breakthrough win gives them a chance to salvage their World Cup mission but they still have a long way to go before they can be considered legitimate contenders for the trophy.
Their win over a struggling and under-strength Sri Lankan side has lifted them to the not so dizzying heights of eighth on the standings with a 1-2 record but it merely papered over the cracks of their myriad problems.
They were close to going into the match without a specialist spinner with the sole tweaker in their squad, Adam Zampa, needing to pass a fitness test to play after suffering back spasms.
All-rounder Glenn Maxwell did a solid job with the ball for the third straight match but the selection panel’s befuddling decision to roll with just Zampa in the touring party continues to be an issue.
Sean Abbott seems to be in the squad as a specialist sub fielder – even when the Aussies take on a lower-ranked nation later in the tournament and one of the main three quicks have a rest, his services do not seem to be particularly needed.
If he were to “suffer” and “injury” while fielding or running out the drinks in Friday’s match against Pakistan at Bengaluru, the Australians would have a much better balanced squad if Tanveer Sangha or Ashton Agar, if he’s recovered from his calf strain, were brought in to replace Abbott.
The Aussies are hopeful Travis Head will be back on deck for next Wednesday’s encounter in Delhi with the Netherlands.
Once he’s back at the top of the order, Mitchell Marsh will slot back in at first drop with Steve Smith at four and Marnus Labuschagne potentially squeezed out.
There is a case to be made that Marsh would be better off in the middle order at five with Josh Inglis and Maxwell to follow before the bowlers.
With Maxwell excelling with his off-spinners, Marcus Stoinis could end up being the odd one out at the selection table but with Marsh sending down just one over in his past 13 ODIs, it would be a gamble to rely on him as the sixth option if one of the main bowlers has an off day.
Australia clawed back a little of their mojo in the five-wicket win over Sri Lanka at Lucknow.
After looking lackadaisical in the field in the losses to India and South Africa, there was an intensity to the Australians again even if they weren’t perfect – Inglis shelled a nick off Maxwell while Labuschagne was unable to pull in a speccy at midwicket.
They had looked too casual on several occasions in the loss to the Proteas but the angry Aussies were back against the Sri Lankans.
There was an intensity about them in the field, Mitchell Starc warned opener Kusal Perera about backing up too far at the non-striker’s end on three occasions and Pat Cummins was proactive with his bowling changes, shuffling his six bowlers, including himself, in short spells until he got the breakthrough to end the opening stand on 125.
“We’d mentioned it out there,” Zampa said in his post-match media conference when asked about maintaining their intensity in the field even when the Sri Lankan openers were well on top.
“The first two games, we’d known that we’d been a bit flat and then that (partnership) happened again. The conversation around the drinks breaks and even the early wickets there was to lift the energy a bit and I thought the fielders did a really good job of that.”
From there the Sri Lankans wilted as Zampa found his groove after his recent lean trot while Cummins (with his bowling and a run-out of Dunith Wellalage) and Starc were too accurate for the careless batters.
“Pat led from the front. His spell changed the momentum of the game,” Zampa added. “And then same as in the field, that run-out, those little things can turn scores from 210 to 260 and it’s game on.”
The batting showed some backbone with Marsh, Inglis and Labuchagne digging in after David Warner was dismissed by a Joel Wilson classic (just clipping leg stump) and Steve Smith was trapped by a delivery so plumb that even he didn’t review it.
The Sri Lankan seamers gifted Inglis several short deliveries, a no-no when you are bowling to a player who has grown up on Perth’s bouncy wickets and it put the nervous keeper at ease as he pulled and cut his way to the boundary.
Despite cruising to victory with 14 overs to spare, the Australians shouldn’t kid themselves. The Sri Lankans had also lost their first two matches, were without captain Dasun Shanaka due to a thigh injury and entered this tournament without fast bowler Dushmantha Chameera (pectoral) and all-rounder Wanindu Hasaranga (hamstring).
Pakistan, despite their heavy loss to India, will be a much sterner opponent on Friday with the ability to go big with the bat, as they did when they chased down a target of 345 against Sri Lanka, or rip through Australia with the ball due to their varied attack led by Shaheen Shah Afridi.
Australia won a match they had to win after their abysmal first two displays but they’re still a long way off the pacesetters at this tournament, namely India, New Zealand and South Africa (that was, until they lost to the Dutch … the Proteas are choking early this time around).
England’s upset loss to Afghanistan helps Australia’s chances of sneaking into the semis but they will need further exponential improvement to be any hope of getting their hands on the trophy.
Tim Carter
Roar Pro
I'm more concerned about the comment in the article, which wasn't by Warner. You can somewhat forgive players speaking in the heat of the moment. Journalists, however, have no such leeway.
Targa
Roar Rookie
As well as being a top class fielder and a devastating hitter, Maxwell has been Australia's best bowler: 0 for 33 off 10 vs India 2 for 34 off 10 vs South Africa 1 for 36 off 9.3 v Sri Lanka 1st picked in the team
Bunney
Roar Rookie
Yes, I'm a Warner fan, but he acted like a complete pillock when DRS proved him out. Looked out to me live too. He's got nothing to whinge about
matth
Roar Guru
Agar is just as likely to do a hammy getting on the plane. He’d have to be in the grand final of getting regularly injured at just the wrong time.
Jeff
Roar Rookie
And, it was the players, at the drinks break of game 3, who had to "coach themselves" into a more positive mindset?
Tim Carter
Roar Pro
"David Warner was dismissed by a Joel Wilson classic (just clipping leg stump)..." Are you seriously ridiculing Wilson for making a correct decision???
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
Good thoughts regarding "consistency". The context of a dismissal is important. Mind you, consistent failure is a different story.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
Yes. A capable coach would. An engaged captain would. Didn't happen.
zeus_kris
Roar Rookie
Marsh should bat at 3 with Smith or Marnus at 4. This gives freedom to Head and Warner to go hard in powerplay and if a wicket falls Marsh is still there to go hard. If Smith comes in, it will drop the RR in the powerplay (first 10-15 overs) which is crucial time to score runs in India.
Jeff
Roar Rookie
“The first two games, we’d known that we’d been a bit flat and then that (partnership) happened again. The conversation around the drinks breaks and even the early wickets there was to lift the energy a bit and I thought the fielders did a really good job of that.” It's a World Cup and the team recognise they've been "a bit flat" for the first 2 and a half games? Why were they not geed up from ball 1 of game 1? Isn't this the key role of the coaching staff in international cricket, to get the team to the point of peak performance re extracting maximum use of the payers' talents...before the tournament starts?
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
Australian U19 batsman, Corey Wasley, has just scored 200 in 214 balls for WA in the second eleven game against SA. The talent just keeps on rolling.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
McAndrew (mixed him up with Qld McSweeney). Manenti was just a grade player in NSW. His Shield career (and ODD career) began in Tassie.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
Life back in the game at the WACA. Corey Rocchiccioli 1-0 with a new ball. Liam Haskett (built like Chris Matthews) 2-0. Mind you, one of the wickets, Silk was caught at short leg off his thigh pad but, serve him right. His snail pace, two day innings almost killed the game. I think Sam Nojowski didn't want to go through that again.
Bunney
Roar Rookie
I agree that McAndrew was dudded on MOTM honours. 10-61 and you miss out. Harsh. Which SA bowlers are from QLD & Tas?? SA used 4 bowlers this last match - McAndrew, Conway, Manenti (all NSW) and Agar (Vic)
Bunney
Roar Rookie
Are we contenders? Of course we are. We just haven't shown much form yet. But there's a long way to go in this tournament, and due some upsets, we're still close to the top 4. If NZ beat Afghanistan tonight and India beat Bangladesh tomorrow night, as expected, and the Aussies beat Pakistan heavily, we could be in 4th place by the weekend. South Africa, currently in 3rd place on the table are 2-and-1, while we're 1-and-2. Nothing in it Just need to beat the Pakis on Friday.
Don Freo
Roar Rookie
Yep. Cummins has pulled a heart muscle...send him home.
Bunney
Roar Rookie
Let's get Agar back in the squad
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
Nice idea about replacing Abbott with Agar. But going on again about the lackadaisical fielding against South .Africa? Was this the infamous six “chances” that weren’t taken? Three either weren’t chances or were actually caught, one was extremely difficult and one was a drop when Starc’s hands hit the ground. But keep adding 2 and 2 to make 5. Or should I say 1 + 1 = 6? Might as well say Marnus was lackadaisical for a ball bursting through his fingers against SL.
Wikipetia
Roar Rookie
it's an OK betting lineup on paper, noting that Warner and Smith would strengthen it. but poor old Kurtis Patterson, he can't buy a run most weeks. Edwards and Sangha. double blot from the fine but ancient Moises. Hughes in some form but at 34 and averaging 38 is he the best we have here...? on Hughes, and with deference to Clem Hill, I just realised that, across the formats, before today's failure, his last scores were 21, 22, 22*... then 58, 69, 59, 59 and 58. much to read into that, some of it serious (what a waster of starts), some less so ( what a star for non-randoming so beautifully) basically he sincerely imitates himself
Ouch
Roar Rookie
off topic but a pretty cool move by CA https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2023/oct/18/australia-netball-players-pay-wage-dispute-financial-support-from-cricket