Festive A-League report cards: The Dux's and duds as the season approaches the New Year

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

It is that time of year, when A-League clubs receive their Roar report cards heading into the festive season, as they plan for a prosperous New Year.

Some teams will be chuffed with the teachers’ comments, whilst others will be furiously self-conscious about the honest appraisal of just how off the pace they have been through the first third of the season.

Here are the grades awarded to the twelve teams on their ‘official’ report cards, as the competition heads into its festive period.

Wellington Phoenix – A

Despite not being the most popular or fashionable member of the class, Wellington has worked diligently and looms as a potential dux of the cohort.

Just one poor assessment has held his grade back from the highest achievable and it was particularly pleasing to note Wellington’s ability to ignore all the bravado emanating from the in-crowd, and the pre-season expectations around a few students who are clearly struggling.

The school has never had a Kiwi dux and the executive is excited by the thought of breaking that drought.

Melbourne Victory – A

It is wonderful to see Victory back in the playground and enjoying himself once again. For some time he has been hiding in the toilets and proving particularly anti-social, yet it is nice to finally see a return of the confidence he once had.

It is a little concerning just how well he is performing in Uruguayan Advanced at the expense of other subjects, yet overall, the college is pleased to have Victory back in the schoolyard and out of the counsellor’s office.

Western Sydney – A

As one of the most unpopular members of the cohort, we are thrilled to see Western Sydney excelling, despite the obvious dislike many other students have towards them.

It has been many a school year since a positive report has been sent home, yet it finally does seem as though he has turned the corner. Holding Western Sydney back is support from the outside.

I would encourage all those who jumped on the bandwagon back in Year 7 to reconnect and believe in his senior years with as much vigour.

It could make all the difference.

Macarthur – B+

It is always tough to join a school from another; make friends and develop a supportive group around oneself.

Macarthur has struggled to do this, yet somehow produced very good results thus far this semester. Frankly, the staff are suspicious and concerned about plagiarism.

Hopefully, Macarthur can soon find a group of friends and cease sitting in the corner of the lunch room ringing an annoying bell and reading a book from the library about Mexico.

Brisbane Roar – B

The consensus amongst staff is that Brisbane is on drugs. Little else could explain his erratic behaviour and penchant for looking like a genius one minute and a special education student the next.

The appropriate authorities have been contacted and all efforts will be made to get to the bottom of the biggest mystery facing the institution at this time.

Melbourne City – B-

It is very pleasing to see City struggling with his work this year. For too long he has had things easy and occupied a false position at the top of the class, without doing anything to really deserve it.

Heading into the final examinations, City is generally found out to be a fraud, with a lack of soul and heart exposing him when the stakes are the highest.

Whilst this may sound like a tough message, deal with it City, very few of your classmates give two hoots about you.

Adelaide United – B

Adelaide is underperforming and badly. It is time he stood up and got serious about the year ahead; realising that he has all the talent in the world and that others are trumping assessments thanks to his sloppiness and lack of discipline.

Wake up Adelaide and seize the day.

Newcastle Jets – B-

It is good to see Newcastle out of our learning support department and beginning to tackle the outcomes set for mainstream students more consistently.

Frankly, we thought Newcastle might be in need of some NDIS assistance, however, he now sits near the middle of the class and well above where even his own parents thought he would be at this stage of the school year.

Well done Newcastle, keep it up.

Central Coast Mariners – B-

I guess being the dux of Year 11 made you think you had it all and that your final year would be a walk in the park. Well, guess what, you have lost a few key brain cells and the curriculum has pulled you into line.

Two successful assessments out of eight are simply not good enough and, pardon the expression, you need to pull your finger out quickly before the chances of an award on presentation this time around have well and truly disappeared.

Sydney FC – C

We had high hopes for Sydney as a student, yet now realise that we were misled by his enrolment interview where he told us how smart he was and his mum and dad’s net worth.

To put it bluntly, he is struggling across all sections of the curriculum and seeing the other students mocking his marks is actually kind of enjoyable and satisfying.

Western United – C
A recent assessment task has given Western some hope for a late-year resurgence, however, very few in the staff room believe it to be possible. The careers counsellor has been contacted, as we feel Western might be pursuing a vocation for which they are simply not cut out.

It might also be best if his father stops kicking furniture during parent/teacher interviews.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Perth Glory – D

It is likely that Perth will be repeating the year, so poor is their work and sloppy their ability to finish off assessments successfully.

It has been tough watching Perth’s stepdad come in and attempt to rebuild the family, however, a spot in the remedial class has been suggested by more than one teacher, in the hope of avoiding the entire year being nothing but a waste.

The Crowd Says:

2023-12-20T23:59:47+00:00

coolncold

Roar Rookie


Brisbane Roar has had too many injuries to make like needing to go to special school. Before this report by Stuart Thomas, there was the thinking of the performance of Jay O'Shea. Some think that he can't be compared with Broich as there is no Berisha for O'Shea to feed. Anyway, O'Shea's scoring rate of 17% per match is 2 times higher than Broich's 8.3% per match. Hope can stays. Waddingham is Ross's student and favourite. Thus he will stay. The overseas position is about to be taken up by the Japanese Daizo Horikoshi who is playing for Kaya–Iloilo in Philipine. Ross's mentor, Muscat has had a good look on him during the match Kaya-Iloilo vs Yokohama F. Marinos vs in the AFC Champions League last month, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVOQTfwTbJo. The other Ross's favurite is Caletti, but he is no comparision to Massimo Murdocca who is stronger, faster and more active. When Berenguer and Hore return, the special education is for the gifted. Special education is not necessarily for low or autism only. It can be for gifted, https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/gifted-education-is-special-education-1bd95633aa7.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T07:38:34+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Thanks Buddy. Has been a tough year, but battling into the next. Hold your loved ones close this holiday period mate. As Bruce Springsteen recently wrote......."One minute you're here, next minute your gone."

2023-12-20T06:12:18+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


Definitely fine for teachers to accuse parents of all sorts of things. In my experience they are usually pretty close to the truth :happy:

2023-12-20T06:10:58+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


No googling around here Stuart and I couldn’t tell you if it is the correct spelling but it sounds right!By the way - A very happy Christmas to you and thankyou for all your articles throughout the year.

2023-12-20T05:58:22+00:00

jupiter53

Roar Pro


Sydney men lucky to get a C. I hope Talay has the chutzpah to stop picking the ineffective imports and old men and give youth a chance. They can hardly do worse. Sydney women on the other hand get an A. Despite losing their defensive kingpin Tobin in the first game, they are solid defensively. They defend as a team; Princess Ibini has copped a lot of flak over the years for alleged laziness, but as captain her hard work getting back sets an example. Not properly clicking in attack yet, but that will come. And Ante Juric is fearless when it comes to picking young players - 16 year old Caspers got a contract, played the next week [in central midfield] most of the game against Newcastle, then all against Perth. She really looks the goods, excellent skill and vision. I really look forward to seeing how she goes with game experience.

2023-12-20T04:12:40+00:00

Brisbanefan93

Roar Rookie


Brisbane a B while Adelaide is the same and City and CCM are B- is absolutely wild to me You got a side who missed out on finals the last two season under a rookie manager who’s been in a cup final and been consistently in the finals spot so far this season. While the other 3 are coming off the back of a number of good seasons. Ones been pumped at home, one didn’t win in a month and one who has sacked their coach. Difference in the report card mark isn’t consistent with where they started or what they have done so far.

2023-12-20T03:22:58+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


some truth, but I also look at the nrl's history where clubs outside Sydney, Penrith, Cronulla initially but ultimately Qld, were treated as outsiders and had to bash down the door with their performances. They did so well they simply could not be ignored.

2023-12-20T03:17:07+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


Thanks. I move to the next layer in the treatment set of tricks early in the new year.

2023-12-20T03:00:38+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


Just once, could you wear sensible footwear, Stuart? :silly:

2023-12-20T02:49:09+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I’d be going Mariners :laughing:

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:47:47+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Actual quote from my Year 11 mathematics report card......."There was one occasion where he passed wind in class." I can assure the woman in question that there was far more than one occasion where this occured. :laughing: :laughing:

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:45:30+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Fair enough, but I escaped the classroom back in 2017, this report comes from newly appointed Principal Lowy.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:44:08+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


If you spelt that without googling I'm very impressed. I would not have even tried.....not knowing the movie or the song that well.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:43:18+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Word on the street is that Brisbane are messing with the hard stuff. We are thinking of moving them in the classroom and placing them next to a good influence....Western Sydney.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:41:40+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Might have been a bit generous, but they look pretty good to me and if they hammer City this weekend, would have a case to be favourites after a third of the season.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:39:05+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Sydney were close to a D but a few wins and the odd decent performance had me wary of another win this week and a team still capable of knocking off a few as the season unfolds.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:38:10+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Looks like they do need Better Homes and Gardens and/or Selling Houses Australia to get started on that decked walkway though. My stiletto's would slip right through it!

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:36:56+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Me too Lionheart.

2023-12-20T02:36:43+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


The more I read comments by people such as yourself, Waz, Secret Scout, etc the more I also believe that fixtures, timetabling, etc needs to be looked at. I’m not sure it’s east coast bias, but even perception of bias needs to be thought about more by our administration.

AUTHOR

2023-12-20T02:35:39+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Carefully thinking out my tip for Thursday night.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar