Super Rugby Round 15: A split in the ranks

By Brett McKay / Expert

So then, the final full round before the last ever June Test window, and it’s an interesting week among the tipping fraternity.

I wasn’t sure there would be much difference between our tips this week – maybe one game might split us, I thought – because it just felt like one of those weeks where tips seemed fairly obvious.

But in the end, four of the seven games are carrying differences, which is really surprising. And to be fair, most of those differences are in Harry’s column, but he’s desperate and I can empathise with the big fella. Most years in recent memory, actually.

So maybe this round isn’t as obvious as I thought?

LAST WEEK: Brett 6; Digger, Nobes, Geoff and The Crowd 5; Harry 4.

OVERALL: Nobes 62; Geoff 61; The Crowd 58; Digger and Brett 56; Harry 54.

Brett
TIPS: Hurricanes, Rebels, Jaguares, Waratahs, Highlanders, Bulls, Lions

Hard to know what I was most proud about last week, there was just so much: obviously the Sunwolves getting up, my moral victory in suggesting “a Waratahs win would not surprise me one bit”, or gapping Harry. How can I choose just one?

This week. Well, you all know my tips for this week – and next, for that matter – because I laid this out on Tuesday.

The Crusaders without a couple of naughty All Black props would’ve been up against it, but take Tim Perry, Sam Whitelock and Ryan Crotty out of the equation as well, and it’s all that much harder again. ‘Canes by less than plenty, but by enough.

Rebels will be too good for the Mighty Moondogs, ditto the Jaguares for the Sharks. And the Bulls. And the Lions. Lions by plenty, actually.

The relief around the Waratahs is very evident now, but a build-up without talk of ‘The Streak’ – may it Rest in Peace – cannot be underestimated. But I suspect the Australian ‘hoodoo’ over New Zealand sides will end at two, with the Highlanders not wanting to become the first Kiwi side in years to lose two on the bounce to Australian sides.

The Waratahs finally broke Australia’s hoodoo against Kiwi Super sides on the weekend. (Photo by Speed Media/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

SURE THING: Harry to remain on his ‘Pat Malone’, for reasons that will become apparent in just a moment…

Geoff
TIPS: Hurricanes, Rebels, Jaguares, Waratahs, Highlanders, Bulls, Lions

A week on and I’m still angry at myself for not tipping the Tahs – it’s actually all Ned Hanigan’s fault!

The Crusaders seem a bit light on for personnel this week, so it’s the Canes to win the top of the table clash. Three wins on the trot is surely beyond the Sunwolves and this is a match the Rebels simply must win. On the other hand, I see no reason why the Jaguares can’t continue their winning streak.

Agustin Creevy of the Jaguares (Photo by Gabriel Rossi/Getty Images)

The Chiefs will be better for being back at home, but the Waratahs are a confidence side and their self-belief will be through the roof right now. Make that two New Zealand scalps in succession. Will the Reds join the Aussie resurrection party? Quite possibly, but they aren’t as good as the Tahs and the Highlanders, without Bruce Lee this week, will be better. This one goes to the tradies.

The Brumbies showed well overdue improvement last week, but it has to be the Bulls at home. And despite the Stormers being at home, the Lions know more about how to win more often.

SURE THING: Australia’s leading rugby coaches are meeting to design the perfect ‘player of the future’, a back with the body-height and strength of a forward at clean-out, combined with a forward with the evasion, speed and skill of a back.

Meanwhile, Matt Dunning announces he is coming out of retirement. Surely no coincidence.

Nobes
TIPS: Hurricanes, Rebels, Jaguares, Chiefs, Reds, Bulls, Lions.

Another week and another quiz, some difficult calls to be made, for some teams is do or die and a few irrelevant games that are hard to tip.

The game that most of us have been waiting between the number one and two rated teams has some circumstances that calls for unconventional tipping behaviour. Who would dare to tip against the Crusaders at home? But due to sanctions and injuries they have been depleted of their front row, and on the other hand, the Hurricanes are suffering injuries in back line. I am going to go with the visitors in this one for what they have done on the field throughout the season.

Ben Lam of the Hurricanes (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

Rebels at home should have taken care of business. Jaguares will continue to show that they are for real, and probably will win this one against the off-loads leaders of Super Rugby.

Chiefs will be back in almost full gear and will test the Waratahs in must win situation that they will only accomplish if they manage to keep fifteen men on the turf.

One of the most difficult calls this week is the Reds and the Highlanders game, I think it is the time for another team from Australia to beat a kiwi team. Reds.

Bulls will redeem in front of their fans and will remind us all that they still in contention. They say that Stormers are unbeatable in Newlands, but the Lions have what it takes to challenge that myth. They are at full force for his Head Coach to choose what to place on the field. Not many teams have that luxury by Round 15.

SURE THING: It will be drama and I hope it falls my way.

Digger
TIPS: Hurricanes, Rebels, Jaguares, Chiefs, Highlanders, Bulls, Lions

‘Canes by plenty.

Rebels should canter in at home to get their season back on track, while I will back the Jaguares at home to continue their good form and break their duck against the Sharks.

The Bulls in Pretoria seem the likely bet against the Brumbies on their second match on tour and the Lions should have too much for their local rivals, even at Newlands.

The two games I am finding hardest to settle on are the trans-Tasman encounters and in the end, I will back the Kiwi sides. The Chiefs should be reinforced with quality personal and will be wide awake to the threat the Waratahs pose, while I am picking the Highlanders as they tend to bounce back well, and the Reds have shown themselves to be inconsistent at times this year.

Ash Dixon of the Highlanders (Photo by Rob Jefferies/Getty Images)

SURE THING: BLAM (say that loudly in your head) will break the season try scoring record this weekend, while this round should also be kung fu-free. Though plenty more cards are likely.

Harry
TIPS: Hurricanes, Rebels, Sharks, Chiefs, Highlanders, Bulls, Stormers.

In the thrilling race to avoid eating pudding with a wooden spoon, between B-Mac and me, this is do-or-die time. Laidlaw has been relying on a Moondawg strategy. The Sunwolves come to Melbourne this round, in an intriguing test of their new resurgence. I think McKay will stick with the Dogs.

Brett’s note: HA!

With that premise, here I go:

– Hurricanes over the Crusaders because TJP and Jordie Barrett will control the proceedings.
– Rebels by plenty over the Sunwolves; the result of the Australian conference still has some doubt.
– The Sharks have a golden opportunity to put themselves in the quarter-finals in BA up against the form team in the competition; I say they shock us all.
– The Chiefs will chuck gravel at the pretty Waratahs; there will be cards and controversy. Chiefs by a few.
– The Highlanders will squeak by the Reds in Brisbane because of superior tactical kicking and catching.
– The jetlagged Bulls will out-maul the Brumbies, but it won’t be easy. Naas Botha will probably have an opinion, which he may or may not share.
– Nobody will pick the Stormers except me, but ok, I will. Stormers by three Dillyn Leyds’ miracle tries.

SURE THING: Leyds has raised his hand for Bok selection, with superb cover defence, miraculous tries created out of nothing, and nobody has pulled his hair this season. If you ever miss a match live, just watch the Leyds highlights for a real show.

Get your votes in now – The Crowd’s tips will be revealed Friday afternoon AEST.

Who have you got, Roarers? Who gets your tip? Got a sure thing yourself? Let us know in the comments below, and enjoy your rugby this weekend…

The Crowd Says:

2018-05-25T10:46:02+00:00

ThugbyFan

Guest


You're correct Brett. Fancy a Tah boy like me choosing the Highlanders when in Sydney. Hang my head in shame. :( Am confident of the Sharks, on their NZ trip they played good footy. The Reds is just a wild punt.

2018-05-25T01:17:38+00:00

woodart

Guest


good point. under the current playoff system, it may make very good sense for the chiefs and highlanders to drop down the table now, to avoid playoffs against hurricanes and crusaders until the last couple of games. keep your powder dry.....

AUTHOR

2018-05-24T23:32:47+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Thugby, out of interest, what was your one wrong? Waratahs too? Sharks AND Reds is bold strategy, Cotton!

2018-05-24T22:35:34+00:00

Wal

Roar Guru


I think his official name Speed Bump, just got a lot harder to as they have lost Taufua too. I have to say have been excited about Ennor getting a decent run but perhaps not against BLam

2018-05-24T15:43:50+00:00

Carlos The Argie

Guest


Is he Diego's alter ego?

2018-05-24T14:44:18+00:00

Cuw

Guest


Whitelock will be missed only from a leadership point of view. and that maay be a big miss - given the accountant is not there Marino is a big boy who hammered counterparts at under 20 world cup. he can play - and well.

2018-05-24T14:41:51+00:00

Cuw

Guest


given this silly structure - will teams under the top 3 really think about where they end up and rest players ? it was not about the position - but when the Lions rested players one season they lost to a low-ranked team i think. another thing i wonder - will those guys selected for NZ team start going " safety first " ? i mean already Tim Perry is injured , so .....

2018-05-24T14:37:25+00:00

Cuw

Guest


more like a guest appearance - like Julia Roberts in FRIENDS :P

2018-05-24T14:09:54+00:00

Origin

Roar Rookie


Vamos Jags, from here to Sweden!

2018-05-24T13:45:49+00:00

Nobrain

Roar Guru


You are right. It was just done in a fun way.

2018-05-24T13:40:57+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


That is right Maikel, I am definitely having an affair with the Jags right now ;) It is impossible to not feel warm in the heart by the beautiful rugby the play and the journey they have done this season. VAMOS!

2018-05-24T13:28:51+00:00

Nobrain

Roar Guru


thanks Maikel

2018-05-24T12:58:11+00:00

Maikél

Guest


Hello Nobrain, I wrote you in your answer to The neutral view from Sweden, which does not prove to be as neutral as its name implies. You are not alone, I also type for the Reds. A hug and a kiss on the forehead to your talisman.

2018-05-24T12:41:20+00:00

Maikél

Guest


Hello Nobrain, according to your answer, you can not generalize on some topics. On the other hand, I congratulate you for your work and also the pack of wolves that chases the two rabbits that escape with good advantage. Luckily your 10 year old daughter helps a lot with the tips in which you are in doubt. A big hug for everyone from ARGENTINA.

2018-05-24T12:35:22+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Correct ... my apologies Mataale just thought he was 'a Bruce Lee' and damaged his hammy ... :)

2018-05-24T12:34:08+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Like Brett I got 6/7 last week, which helps recover from the disaster 2/7 of the previous week. Punished by Gaea for tipping against the Tahs in Sydney, oh what a fool am I! But what a wonderful weekend was Round 14 as 3 Kiwi teams lost, may there be many more such weekends. This week could be glorious or like Icarus fly too close to the Sun. - Hurricanes must feel like they won the lottery, meeting the Crusaders sans half their team. - Rebels should win but wow the Sunwolves are on fire. Rebels have rested J.DeZebra and put Reece Hodge at 5/8, and DHP returns to fb while J.Maddocks back to wing. A.Coleman and M.Philip will be too much for the Tokyoboyz. - Los Jaguares are playing really well but I suspect the Sharks will put the bite on them in a Must-Win showdown. - Gaea will frown on me, but a Chiefs outfit at home with rested AB's and big Brodie powering up the middle should just take the biscuits from the Mighty Tahs. - Am going to follow the revered Argentine Tipster Nobrain here and suggest the Reds are going to make it 2-0 against the Kiwis. B.Thorn has lived up to his word wrt good defence. F.Daugunu, who missed a couple on B.Lam, is replaced by Izaia Perese who can definitely tackle. C.Timu is also back (reserve backrower). - Brumbies are done and dusted after losing another two starters last week (R.Arnold for his "cuddle" on Elton Jantjies and R.Valentini knee troubles again). Expect the Bulls to think they are at Pamplona and go on a rampage. - Stormers will try to rain on the parade, but the Lions are hungry and should win easily. In short: Canes, Rebels, Sharks, Chiefs, Reds, Bulls and Lions. Sure thing: The Roar will melt down with Kiwi smugness when the next trans-Tasman match "flukes" a win to the Kiwi team. (ducks !).

2018-05-24T11:50:57+00:00

Nobrain

Roar Guru


You will represent me as my lawyer. You are the only one backing my claim.?

2018-05-24T11:31:21+00:00

Origin

Roar Rookie


Perhaps Nabura himself can serve as TMO at Nobes’ very fair case. I guess Nabura will be mercy with the line-man

2018-05-24T10:38:40+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


The Stormers attend the playoffs, as if they are the DJ or bartender ...

2018-05-24T10:28:43+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Interesting that Macca and Geoff have tipped the Tahs again. The Chiefs have some troops back and will take some beating. Just hope the Tahs can put in one more big shift against an NZ team. It has been a very challenging month with 4 straight games against Kiwi sides. A return of 2 wins from 4 would be fantastic.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar