Five talking points from Australia vs Sri Lanka second Test

By Scott Pryde / Expert

Australia’s domination job of Sri Lanka is complete, but there are still plenty of questions to be answered ahead of the World Cup and Ashes after a tough summer. Here are all the big talking points from the match.

This series doesn’t help pick the Ashes squad
Let’s not kid ourselves. These Sri Lankan results aren’t going to pick the Test team for our next series, the Ashes.

What it is going to do is probably pick a few spots on the plane for the A tour to England in the lead-up to the Ashes.

Set to be played concurrently with the World Cup and end with a match against the Australian side, the A team will have chances to push for spots in the eventual Ashes squad in conditions which are of use for selections and form against high-quality opposition.

In truth, the selectors will have just about forgotten about this series by the time the Ashes do roll around, with David Warner and Steve Smith also set to make their returns to the team.

What we do know is that if Marcus Harris and Marnus Labuschagne are picked to go to England on the A tour, they are going to need a truckload of runs to force their way into the eventual squad.

However, Kurtis Patterson can cancel his off-season plans, because he will undoubtedly be travelling to England along with Joe Burns, while Travis Head will be in the World Cup squad.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

The interesting one is Matt Renshaw, who is still chasing a county contract. One way or another, he needs to be in England if he is to make the Ashes squad, but getting game time on the A tour might be a problem for him.

Jhye Richardson is another who will probably be in the World Cup squad, while the quicks will all play limited overs cricket, and Jhye Richardson will also get to England one way or another.

You’d also have to expect Will Pucovski and a host of other hopefuls to spend the winter in England, giving plenty of time for selectors to try and answer questions about their eventual squad.

Sri Lanka need to be better
No one wants to see one-sided cricket. While Australia needed the confidence-building scores, wickets and match results, there is no getting around the fact Sri Lanka were extremely poor.

The tourists, both in Brisbane and here in Sydney, struggled big time, but with some of the names in their squad, they shouldn’t have been nearly as bad as they were.

Sure, losing their quicks hurt in Canberra and the retirement of Rangana Herath didn’t help, but when Kusal Mendus and Dimuth Karunaratne have scored stacks of runs in the last 12 months and they also have the experience of Dinesh Chandimal (who had an extremely poor series) to draw on, the way they were beaten was bad.

A 2-0 series result was expected, but not in this manner, and Sri Lanka must be better moving forward as the divide seemingly continues to grow between the top and bottom teams in world cricket, despite the promising performances of upcoming nations like Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Ireland.

Usman Khawaja and Mitchell Starc needed these results for confidence if nothing else
While you can’t let one Test and their scores against a minnow overlook an entire summer, the ten-wicket haul from Mitchell Starc and second innings century from Usman Khawaja were both enormous in terms of confidence for two players who are senior members of the team, but struggled to stand up throughout the summer.

If Australia are to be successful during what is going to be an extremely busy winter of cricket, they need Khawaja and Starc firing on all cylinders.

(AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)

As the old saying goes, you can only play what’s in front of you, and from Starc’s point of view especially, it was the first time in quite a significant amount of time he was able to bowl accurately and consistently wth real pace, fire and bounce. This was especially impressive on a pretty flat pitch which was good to bat on.

Khawaja’s second-innings century in the grand scheme of things probably has less going for it, given the Sri Lankan attack were second string and inconsistent, but he still had to get through some tough times as wickets fell around him at the start of the innings.

Given what he has been through off the field, this should just remind him that he can compete at the top level, and set him up for a big winter at number three.

Marcus Harris might be finished at Test level… For now
This was a crucial series for besieged opening batsman Marcus Harris. The Victorian has had the entire summer to score runs and make the opening spot his own, but he has struggled to do so.

While no one will question that he looks the part in the Baggy Green, there will be plenty of arguments raised as to whether his spot is a deserved one moving forward.

He finishes the summer with a whole bunch of starts, some failures (including twin failures in this final Test of the summer), but no big score.

It’s the no big score part, as well as the method of his dismissals which is a cause of concern heading to England.

(AAP Image/Richard Wainwright)

Too often, Harris has been caught slashing at balls outside the off stump which, early in his innings, he needs to leave.

While a compact technique gets him going, the problems are going to be profound in England where the decision to leave or play becomes tougher with a swinging Duke ball and English attack who are always on the money.

His lack of runs at the end of the summer have come at an awful time, with David Warner and Cameron Bancroft both available for selection, and Joe Burns hitting a blistering 170.

It’s going to take a stack of runs in the remaining Sheffield Shield games for him to make a case for selection moving forward.

Test cricket will be back in Canberra
If there is a location which should have hosted Test cricket before now, it’s Canberra.

Manuka Oval has had redevelopments, granted, and the pitch might need some work moving forward, but it’s a lovely venue for cricket where Australia know they aren’t going to draw huge crowds at bigger stadiums in other locations.

Day 2 and 3 in particular were well supported in Canberra, and a big crowd at a small stadium is better than trying to get by with a big stadium one fifth full.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

When teams like Sri Lanka, the West Indies, Bangladesh or, into the future, Afghanistan tour, Manuka Oval should be the prime location used for those matches. It’s size and the obvious enjoyment of the people in Canberra, as well as the want to go to the cricket can’t be taken for granted.

If you look at crowds in Hobart, they are small, and while poor opposition has been used as an excuse, Canberra locals didn’t let that become a problem for them this week.

The Crowd Says:

2019-02-05T00:43:55+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Joey just needs to work on letting that wide of off stump nagging length ball go. He still gets out a lot caught in to minds on footwork, hanging the bat out there. If he sorts that out I think he would be in the top three bats in the country.

2019-02-05T00:27:10+00:00

Matt H

Roar Guru


Burns is a bit of a nicker as well, so the door is not shut. However Burns' test and Shield record should make him the front runner. Bancroft is the interesting one. If he has a big second half of the Shield, I could see Langer pushing hard for him.

2019-02-05T00:22:37+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


And that's before you factor in Bancroft or Labuschagne, who are no doubt still in the selectors' minds (probably moreso than Maxwell, unfortunately).

2019-02-04T17:04:48+00:00

Samlaurence26

Roar Rookie


This last test specifically was super significant for Khawaja's future. There is a lot of talk about dropping Harris to include Warner, and this wouldn't be so widely assumed if Khawaja had failed again in this test. It's proven to be very important.

2019-02-04T17:02:22+00:00

Samlaurence26

Roar Rookie


Yeah I agree. He's only 20, he's got loads of time to continue to get better.

2019-02-04T12:58:46+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Don't think Pucovski should be too disappointed. His selection in the squad was recognition that he is on the selectors radar. He has plenty of time to develop his batting skills to the point where he has to be selected.

2019-02-04T12:51:22+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


I agree DJ squared – I think this series will help a lot in determining who goes on the Ashes tour so I’m not sure where Scott is going with that comment. Burns, Patterson, Head and Khawaja have shored up their places on the plane as a result of their performances in these two tests as has Jyhe Richardson. There are still some question marks over Harris and Labuschagne which have not been fully resolved – and Renshaw, Pucovski, Maxwell and Stoinis all have chances to impress the selectors in the remaining shield games or international ODIs. The Canberra faithful, interstate guests and a host of Sri Lankan supporters provided a wonderful atmosphere at Manuka. Made a pleasant change to see cricket played in such and intimate environment with spectators very close to the action in contrast to the big stadiums of the larger capital cities. Lets hope its the first of many tests to come for Canberra.

2019-02-04T12:36:16+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


In late January there were up to six English counties with a vacancy for a batsman, but to be eligible you need to have played for your country. Unfortunately I can’t see how Pucovski can play county cricket given he hasn’t played for Australia as yet. The selectors needed to pick him for either the first or second test against Sri Lanka for him to be eligible.

2019-02-04T12:26:38+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


Burns plays in England. Good Shield player and seems to be a pretty decent Test player as well with four centuries from limited opportunities. We're not looking for the next Ponting or Hayden, just someone better than Finch, Shaun Marsh, Labuschagne, he's got the edge on Khawaja now, he looks better than Harris. Labuschagne is below Head, Renshaw, Patterson. Suddenly we're spoiled for choices going into the Ashes. Go back to the MCG Test where were blown off the park and 3 of our top 6 simply weren't Test standard batsmen. No wonder we were humiliated. To me that's unforgivable to stain our proud home record against the Indians because of dumb ego picks.

2019-02-04T12:25:56+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


100% Bazza. There's also the 'first test' factor. Let's see how many they get to a test match pre-Christmas when it's raining and the novelty has worn off. For context, the average crowd over the 4 days at Manuka was about 7.5k. If you look back at the last Hobart test (vs SA) they got crowds of 7929 and 6283 on days 1 and 3, which were the only days where they got any significant amount of play in. Sure, SA are a bigger drawcard than SL but it was cold and wet (in November!) and Australia lost the test inside the first session. I didn't see anything at Manuka that suggested it should permanently usurp Hobart as the sixth test venue. The honour should be shared going forward.

2019-02-04T11:56:51+00:00

Nick

Guest


Probably also not helped by the media hyping him up as the new mesiah. For someone who is fragile imagine having the high expectations thrust upon you from the media and many in the cricketing public. Think it was good that he was allowed to mix with the guys and see what goes on in a test environment. At least then he knows what he's getting in to.

2019-02-04T11:32:37+00:00

Peter Warrington

Guest


Shaun Young, when Sean Young was available Almost Hussey (poor Hodgey)

2019-02-04T10:51:46+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


So how many in the Ashes Squad? 16 or 17? Will they have the Mike Whitney Memorial Reserve Squad lying around to come in as required?

2019-02-04T10:44:51+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Not helped by ridiculously getting his hopes up only to disguard him and not having him play.

2019-02-04T10:43:01+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


I think you under estimate this series....” it doesn’t help pick an ashes squad”. Not true. Yes it was one sided but it resulted in a number conclusions not even our selectors can stuff up—- In the first ashes test... - burns will start - conditions were quite “English-like” early on day 1 which makes burns even more of a lock in (seems obvious now but quite frankly it’s been obvious all season) - stark will start in at least the first two tests - Harris may struggle in English conditions (see above) - Patterson will be #6 - if we win , Richardson may struggle to get a run but most likely he will play a test or two - Marnus shouldn’t cancel is current plans to be at home in the Aussie winter....

2019-02-04T09:55:03+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


I hope they play in Manaka again. Good venue.

2019-02-04T09:50:47+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Sri Lanka were also missing their no 1 batsman Angelo Mathews.

2019-02-04T08:47:11+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


And looks to have a fairly awful way of "handling" the short ball.

2019-02-04T08:37:03+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


“While no one will question that he looks the part in the Baggy Green”. I would for one. Very few players, almost none, have had successful careers on the back of a first class average of 35 after 5 seasons. He was lucky against India, and got away with the worst shot of the series- a windy woof first ball against Jadeja - to get to his top score in Sydney. He looked clueless against spin.

2019-02-04T07:24:09+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


I don’t think Australia need Pucovski now either – between Warner, Smith, Khawaja, Head, Patterson, Burns, Renshaw, Harris and Maxwell they have 9 solid-to-excellent batting options they should be focusing on over the next 2 years or so. That’s a decent “squad” of Test batsmen to choose from depending on conditions/form. Let Pucovski hopefully resolve his issues, develop as a cricketer and be part of the next wave of Test candidates after that, potentially alongside other young guys like Inglis, Green, McDermott, Bell, Heazlett, Doran, Sangha etc.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar