Does a sex tape make you king of the dressing room?

By Mary Konstantopoulos / Expert

There are just eleven sleeps until the NRL season starts again and for this I’m very grateful.

Not just because it means footy will be back on my television screen, but also because I’m hopeful that the actual footy will give fans something else to focus on, rather than the raging bin fire that has been the most recent off-season.

There’s no other way to sell it – this off-season the NRL has literally lurched from one disaster to another and I think close to irreparable damage has been done.

The last six months have had it all – sex tapes featuring players, several allegations against players of very serious offences, a coach deregistered indefinitely and substantive breaches of the salary cap by the Wests Tigers and the Cronulla Sharks, with suggestion that the Melbourne Storm are also having challenges around the cap.

When Todd Greenberg and Peter Beattie fronted the media last week they were left with no choice other than to change the current policy. Enough is enough.

Via a press conference, it was announced that the Australian Rugby League Commission will stand down players facing serious indictable offences on full pay while they are before the courts without any presumption of guilt or innocence. A serious indictable offence is one that carries a maximum jail term of at least 11 years.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Club CEOs also have the discretion to stand down players if the maximum penalty is less than 11 years and given that this is discretionary, I feel like this is the area where we may see some inconsistency between clubs about how the policy is imposed.

But given many club CEOs have come out and backed the new policy, they are perhaps also of the understanding that change needs to happen.

Already this new policy has seen Jack de Belin from the St George Illawarra Dragons stood down as well as Dylan Walker from the Manly Sea Eagles. Scott Bolton from the North Queensland Cowboys has been suspended for five games and fined and Dylan Napa from the Canterbury Bulldogs fined.

Was I happy when the changes were introduced? Happy is not the right word. Relieved is perhaps more appropriate and also sad that it has come to this and that the game’s reputation has been tarnished by the actions of so few.

This has been a no-win situation for the NRL. These are not easy issues to grapple with and even though there are no winners here, I feel like the NRL has got it right and set a standard which will hopefully be consistently applied going forward.

At the very least I was hopeful and still am hopeful that the changes to the policy will send a clear message to players about the standards of behaviour expected of them (which really, are the same standards expected of you and I).

But only a couple of hours after the sanctions against Walker and Napa were announced rumours began which suggested that another sex tape was being circulated, this time featuring a player from the Penrith Panthers.

Now please don’t get me wrong. Compared to some of the behaviours we have seen over the off-season, sex tapes are tiddlywinks.

Additionally, based on the assumption that the acts being filmed are consensual, that the people involved know that they are being filmed and are aware that there are other people in the room, the behaviour that I find most reprehensible is that the tapes are released (I’m guessing without consent).

The videos might be good for a cheap laugh, but the overwhelming feeling I have after watching these videos is sadness because it reminds me how much work we still have to do as a society around respectful relationships.

If people want to film themselves having sex then that is a decision for them and the other person in the video. But my question is why is sex is being filmed and then shared with other people?

The details around this video allegedly featuring a Penrith player are still sketchy, but in the case of Napa, his video had been circulated in a group chat with several other players.

Content put on the internet or shared via social media has a permanent footprint. Players need to understand this and recognise that loyalties can change very quickly and not every person that will receive their video is their mate.

Is this sort of behaviour respected? Is calling a woman a ‘ratbag’ funny? Do players share these videos to get a ‘yeah the boys’ reaction from their teammates? And if that’s the case, then I find it devastatingly sad that to gain respect or get a high five from teammates that this is what players feel that they need to do.

It’s also disappointing that players would risk their reputation and their livelihood for a couple of cheap laughs.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

I’m generalising here, I know. This offseason has reinforced that it is always the actions of the few that most heavily impact the situation of the many. It is a shame that plenty of positive work that has been done over the offseason has barely seen the light of day because of the other issues the game is grappling with.

But the fact that I know there are several other players with concerns because there are similar videos of them around is a concern.

The behaviour in the videos suggest a lack of respect to me and seem to mimic actions widely consumed in pornography.

This is not a rugby league problem. This is a problem with our society. We need to talk to young men and women so they have an understanding about what respectful relationships can look like.

We need to look at pornography available and talk to the people around us and make sure that they understand that porn is a performance and not what happens in the real world.

We need to start to change the conversation and in particular what gets a high five in the dressing sheds.

The Crowd Says:

2019-03-06T22:45:55+00:00

#Longstone

Roar Rookie


Thanks NRL for getting hard on those players.

2019-03-06T01:10:18+00:00

Jay Wright

Roar Rookie


Agree Duncan we are could of been sparred Kim’s sex tape. Paris Hilton’s also. Both talentless hacks that feed off thier father’s fame. One got OJ off the other owned Hotels

2019-03-05T10:06:06+00:00

William Dalton Davis

Roar Rookie


Yeah it’s just a buzz word people like to throw around I think. Especially as it relates to the famous for being famous crowd.

2019-03-05T09:40:49+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


"Steals your child" Are you Linday Chamberlain? It would be really tough to show up to court with stolen child and expect it to end well.

2019-03-05T09:34:08+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


How does that work, asset inflation means everyone was self made? It’s a pretty superfluous title if it applies to everyone.

2019-03-05T09:26:48+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


So people have a right to film even if they don't seek consent of the other party. Sweet

2019-03-05T09:15:38+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Really? you didn't write the article! Gee that clears so much up. Here I was thinking you wrote it

2019-03-05T05:22:40+00:00

Homers Son

Guest


There are plenty within the political left that openly despise sports, and its no coincidence that the same group spend plenty of time and money attacking men.

2019-03-05T00:28:29+00:00

Meatpy Sausageraul

Roar Rookie


Wherever you are in this debate – and it’s a complex one – it’s got to be a good thing it’s now being debated at some level. Part of the problem is that the people running the game (and a lot of us I’d wager) haven’t wanted to properly acknowledge these issues, let alone seriously debate them. It’s easier to see each instance as black and white – fans and media conducting their own trials, the NRL lurching into punitive action, or taking little or no action (with a good deal of inconsistency) – rather than trying to systematically treat the some of the root causes. Because maybe that’d be too complicated and we kinda just want the whole thing to go away. That said, we need to be real here and recognise that you can’t purge the world of terrible people. The game (albeit in a slightly skewed way) reflects society, warts n all.

2019-03-04T23:35:40+00:00

Birdy

Roar Rookie


Feel free to attack me anytime you like JJ, but at least have the decency to get your facts right from the start. Me at protests, doubt it. More like Anzac dawn service or the odd may day rally. Much prefer to sit down and enjoy a double bacon and egg roll and have a good laugh at a Pat Condall video on YouTube .

2019-03-04T23:33:19+00:00

Spanner

Roar Rookie


It's not just NRL Jimbo, this lady puts a feminist slant on a number of Roar platforms without, it must be said, a lot of substance. As they say, money talks !

2019-03-04T23:07:25+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Desired result for who?

2019-03-04T22:30:48+00:00

JimboJones

Guest


" Time for everyone to grow up and take responsibility for their actions". That's hilarious . Some lowlife jumps through ya window to steal your child , and cuts his arm , and he can sue you . Those days are goooooooone .

2019-03-04T22:26:48+00:00

JimboJones

Guest


In my opinion , your last line is exactly what the desired result is. Peter Beattie was gifted his position for a reason , and that reason is to systematically pluck the game , one feather at a time . The tirade of bad publicity is no coincidence , and now theyre talking about making the game uncompetitive until the kids reach 13 ? W T F ? Whos going to play a game for 5 , 6 , 7 yrs for fun ?...No one , that's who . That's how ya do it my boy , ya poison the roots , ya poison the leaves and in the end it dies . League will be in tatters by the time he waltzes off into the sunset with a cuppla mill in his sky rocket .

2019-03-04T21:39:52+00:00

elvis

Roar Rookie


What an absolute load of rubbish Mary. You are so out of touch with young people it isn't funny. Or maybe that's just people. "Respectful relationships" my foot, some people just want to have casual sex and not be judged by prudes like you. Have you seen how much amateur porn there is on the internet? Someone must be making it, and someone else must be watching it. Sending nudes is becoming mainstream, when people are born with cameras in their hands what else do you think is going to happen?

2019-03-04T21:39:47+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


I'll mention him whenever I see fit. There is no better case to refer to , you're not the only one reading the Roar either and based on the comments many seem to be completely ignorant of the past. Ignore the past at your peril.

2019-03-04T21:28:08+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You’ve mentioned Brett Stewart on a daily basis for two months. What makes you think I’m unaware of it?

2019-03-04T21:25:32+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


You seem to be unaware that the majority of the recent cases of fake allegations in the NRL were by the players partner and the one that wasn't was Brett Stewart walking up to his apartment door.

2019-03-04T21:19:29+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Well hopefully players will be very careful not to get themselves into high risk situations on the eve of the semi finals.

2019-03-04T21:07:50+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


So what , I thought JDB would be allowed to play on and I was wrong. You can't even understand that if a player is charged with an offence which carries an 11 year or more sentence that they are automatically suspended until the trial is finished. There is no way they will be following your fairy tale above of gathering facts, following some mystery process and making an informed decision. It's automatic. Try to focus instead of rabbiting on with twisted tales. You believe that the NRL will ignore their own rules and conduct a long investigation and allow a player charged with rape to play in the GF, that is beyond hilarious. If you think there will be hordes of rape victims before the semis then good luck to you.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar