Hard work and discipline has to be the new Australian way

By Brett McKay / Expert

If a week is a long time in rugby, then in Australia it’s an eternity.

This time a week ago, we were praising the Rebels’ ability to claw back into a contest through superb game management while simultaneously wondering how the Brumbies could so quickly turn such a good first half into such a lacklustre second half.

We were admiring the sharpness of a Waratahs attack that went forward first and not wide, but then wondered how the Reds could manage very little in attack despite their forwards pack competing very well across the park.

This week, it’s literally the opposite. Up is down; right is left.

The Rebels were excellent, then terrible. The Brumbies took time to get into the contest, but then dictated terms.

The Waratahs started kind of ok, but the gave nothing. The Reds looked set for a touch-up at halftime before turning the game on its head to win a thriller.

Harry Hockings of the Reds (Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

Of the winners, the common denominator of the Brumbies and Reds was that, as teams, they were prepared to roll up the sleeves when the game didn’t start the way they wanted it to, and just got on with playing the game in a way that allowed them to get on top.

For the Brumbies, this had pretty well happened inside twenty minutes.

After the Waratahs scored through the most obscure of ways – Bernard Foley reigniting his fascination with hitting the posts and Michael Hooper reviving memories of Ray Price in scoring off the rebound – the Brumbies slowly but surely dragged the contest back into the middle channels and turned it into a set piece battle.

Their ball carrying forwards took charge up the post-to-post corridor. James Slipper, Rory Arnold, and Sam Carter all carried well in this area, even if they weren’t peeling off massive metres. Their impact was more about drawing Waratahs defenders into the context, which in turn created room out wide if they chose to go that way.

Aside from Hooper and Ned Hanigan, the Tahs just didn’t have the same sort of grunt work output from their forwards, and their general lack of go-forward was only exacerbated by the chronically lateral nature of their attack when they tried to force the issue.

And that was an issue in itself. It seems crazy that for a playing group who have played as much rugby together at the Waratahs backs have, that losing Karmichael Hunt who’s been with them for a month would be so pivotal in them lacking any semblance of shape in attack.

Paul Cully’s Saturday morning assessment of the Waratahs’ senior players in the Fairfax press, that “too many Wallabies in the Waratahs are sleepwalking” was as scathing as it was surgically accurate.

And as much as I think Wallabies selections in March are all a bit pointless, Cully’s take on Kurtley Beale is difficult to argue, too:

“Beale, in particular, has had an underwhelming start to the year and if a Wallabies team was picked on form today he wouldn’t be in the match-day 23.”

Hunt can’t return quick enough for NSW. He was already shaping as the buy of the year, but his absence has made him only more valuable again.

On the other side of the result, the Brumbies’ 19-13 win was about as far removed as it gets from the eight-try rampage over the Chiefs back in Round 2. But you get the sense it will be every bit as important as a seasonal benchmark.

The same has to be said of the Reds’ comeback against the Sunwolves, where approaching the hour mark and still down 21-5, it was hard to see how they could hit back at the fast-paced Japanese side.

Something clicked, though. The Reds’ forwards got cracking on the pick-and-drive and their lineout drive delivered, too, with hooker Brandon Paenga-Amosa snaring two of the three converted tries scored in seven minutes.

It’s worth mentioning the performance of Hamish Stewart at fullback here, as well. Whether it’s a better understanding of his contribution to the general playmaking of the Reds, whether it was an awakening that his place in the side was under serious threat, it all played out the same way.

A composed injection from the back, as well as deliberately methodical goal-kicking as the Reds drew level and then overtook the Sunwolves at home.

From the flatlining showing against the Waratahs at the SCG a week before, this was a massive and encouraging turnaround from the Queenslanders.

Waratahs player Jed Holloway (4) goes up for the ball (Photo by Speed Media/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

The turnaround from the Rebels in Johannesburg was similarly massive, but not in a good way.

My Twitter followers might be familiar with my curiosity as to how a penalty count could be so one-sided, but extreme doubt about the Lions’ apparent angel status aside, the Rebels’ second-half discipline was nothing short of horrendous. And not new, given they were the most penalised team in Super Rugby last season, as well as the equal most yellow-carded side as well. They already have a share of the most yellows in 2019, too.

The way the Rebels were able to build a sizeable lead largely against the run of play will be incredibly pleasing for coach Dave Wessels. But the way they threw that lead away so quickly and so frivolously through some seriously ordinary discipline will have eroded their coach’s pleasure in minutes.

The Rebels missed the playoffs last season by a hair. You really hope that Ellis Park loss doesn’t come back to bite.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2019-03-20T17:08:10+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Some nellies are anaerobic James. They can be negative even without oxygen.

2019-03-20T16:53:52+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Brett, I have never met Price, though a mate of mine has got to know him on the NSW north coast. It seems there are plenty in this country still reminiscing in his presence. My favourite, as he was lacing his boots in a nervous dressing room prior to a test against the All Blacks, he displayed a deliberate ignorance amongst his quivering teammates: “as far as I was concerned they were just 15 nobodies” For the record I think the Wallabies won that one.

2019-03-20T16:46:09+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Brett, “2-4 I’m not really worrying about in mid-March.” Fair enough on face value, but some input into point 3 has been made long before this season. Foley’s long-term form for instance.

2019-03-20T09:06:15+00:00

Big Dave

Roar Rookie


No I can take criticism. Brett was critical in the article and that was fine, because he made an argument.

2019-03-20T09:03:33+00:00

Big Dave

Roar Rookie


I don't get personally offended. I get frustrated because it's so hard to have a sensible conversation without someone like you coming in and dribbling all over it. I love rugby and I love to talk about it. You personally make it unpleasant.

2019-03-20T07:30:12+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Dave, as a Tah fan (one who triaged the Wallabies first, granted) I think you are confusing criticism with ‘ad hominems’ There have been plenty of ad hominems at myself and others who argue in the positive for non Tahs. There are plenty of Tah fans here. There may not be plenty of Tah fans here who agree with your selections though.

2019-03-20T00:55:29+00:00

Rhys Bosley

Roar Pro


Too bad, so sad. A lack of continuity doesn’t make Beale too lazy to chase an opposing player after a line break, like he failed to do with Chris Feua-Sautia during the Reds match. This bloke is totally overrated but believes his own propaganda, if the way he publicly sooks about selection issues is anything to go by.

2019-03-19T21:05:35+00:00

Stu

Roar Rookie


Will be interesting though to see if the penalty scoreboard is as lopsided as this when the intelligent teams (ie the Kiwi ones) go there and play against the same team, same ref. One would expect they'll systematically find an intelligent way to play, to negate the ref's clear bias and earn a more favourable count, and display for us the all-important difference in rugby intelligence between their sides and ours. Or maybe theyll just get flogged regardless? That'll be an interesting scoreboard to watch.

2019-03-19T18:25:58+00:00

tsuru

Roar Rookie


Actually I found that 1st penalty the most bewildering of all. It seemed that Hodge made the tackle and rolled away, Wilkin came in and pilfered and got penalised for no clear release. I must have misunderstood.

2019-03-19T14:42:37+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


I thought the Rebels scrum was clearly dominant in the first 55:00, and was hard done by on those penalties. I watched the game again, to look at the penalties, and quite frankly, it was a weird match. The Lions formed so many more rucks than the Rebels and this ref was only pinging defensive ruck infringements. Genia should have not boxed so much, kept ball in hand, and I think Marx and Kwagga would've been pinged 3-4 times.

2019-03-19T11:09:50+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


We obviously took him too early, should have left him in situ and harvested once he'd spent some time in the finishing paddock.

2019-03-19T11:07:14+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


That’s because he can’t find a proper braai.

2019-03-19T11:05:32+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


....but only 97kg :D

2019-03-19T10:59:29+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


He’s tall enough ...

2019-03-19T10:56:03+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Liam Wright. I’ve seen him play 5 as well as 6.

2019-03-19T09:37:08+00:00

peterj

Guest


Brilliant article Brett! I really like your style, succinct and to the point but also allows for further discussion. As a U.K. based Aussie it's hard for me to watch Super Rugby. The small sample size I've seen I agree wholeheartedly with what you've written. Hunt provides such directness and abrasiveness and is definitely up there for buy of the year. Beale appears to have dropped off completely and he needs to get his mojo back quickly. What did you make of Luke Jones' performance? I thought he was class and definitely making the #6 jersey interesting for the WB's. Keep up the good work!

2019-03-19T09:34:22+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


Sorry, Freudian slip. Either way – having Waratah players criticised seem to bother PeterK, Jeznez, KCOL, for example. Perhaps there’s something wrong if people get personally offended by players critiquing the rugby abilities of players that happen to play for the team they support. The same on GAGR. Rebels, Force, Reds, Brumbies. That sure looks like four of the five Australian teams to me.

2019-03-19T09:29:55+00:00

Big Dave

Roar Rookie


We were talking about the tahs, not Cheika. But you’re right as always, most Tahs fans love having their team and players dumped on week in and week out.

2019-03-19T09:13:11+00:00

Irish Sam

Roar Rookie


Beale appears to be wanting to maintain selection consistency. Drew Mitchell on the last night wrap mention the same thing. It appears from Kurtley claims the number 12 requires more time in the saddle which could be seen as a plea for patience. If Hunt comes off the bench with only having a precautionary week off that alone would tell me your midfield case at the Tahs just turned to custard.

2019-03-19T07:53:41+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Yep Brett, back in the day, it wasn't unusual to cop a quick kick up the " Jacksie", if one stuffed up on the training track. From discipline, comes respect, as I really learnt from my time in the military, but then school, in those days inflicted discipline pretty well too.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar