AFL Power Rankings 2019: Round 3

By Liam Salter / Roar Guru

Round 3 is done and dusted. It was a good round of football, and we’re starting to get a clearer sense of the rankings. And, yes, the reigning premiers have soared a whole lot higher.


Last week: 3

I made a quip last week about how reports of Geelong’s demise were greatly exaggerated, and their emphatic win only further reinforced that. The Cats’ win was based on a fierce first half – which admittedly wasn’t entirely reflected on the scoreboard – and their busy midfield stocks. And that holds them in good stead in 2019.


Last week: 1

This was probably their most impressive win out of their three. Port’s been a difficult team for the Lions to beat in recent years, which is why the manner of their fourth-quarter victory is deeply impressive. As a Freo fan, though, seeing Lachie Neale flourish at his new club leaves me conflicted: his 43 touches were impactful and made me pleased, but Brisbane’s evidently a much better fit for the midfielder.


Last week: 5

Fine effort, and very fine win. The Giants’ victory was clearly underpinned by their heavy scoring, and they’ve got the duo of Jeremys to thank for that. Huge clash against the Cats next weekend.


Last week: 13

Andrew Gaff’s back, the Eagles win at the MCG again, and they defeat their grand final rivals in pretty convincing fashion. Not a bad Saturday night for the reigning premiers! I’ll admit I’ve placed the Eagles far too low the past fortnight. A win of this style is an apt opportunity to bump way them up the rankings. Where they deserve to be.


Last week: 2

Being down 24 points at quarter time would’ve been surprising. Being down 16 at half time after a period of dominance would’ve been annoying. Being down by five come the final siren would’ve been heartbreaking. Three different margins, three different contextual analyses of the Bulldogs’ first loss of the year.


Last week: 6

I know the term ‘honourable loss’ has been essentially become Carlton jargon of late, but that is a very apt way to describe Port’s loss on Saturday night. Port were more than competitive and had genuine chances to win the clash. Connor Rozee is looking like a genuine star – his five majors second only to Brisbane’s Eric Hipwood, who booted six.


Last week: 4

Two contrasting styles in Sunday’s clash: the Roos’ fast start versus Hawthorn’s slow burn. Seriously impressive debut for Chad Wingard.


Last week: 10

I wanna heap praise on the Suns’ first quarter: that was sen-bloody-sational. It’s not often that the Suns can get such a jump start interstate, and I’d pinpoint those first six goals which meant their margin was largely never threatened. Three in a row, given Carlton next week? Maybe.


Last week: 11

A bad loss, but not a terrible loss. They were well in the game at times, but psychologically the clash will be a bitter pill to take. That’s four straight losses to the Eagles. And given the likeliness of meeting in finals, that’s a bad thing.


Last week: 7

Both the Dockers and the Saints epitomised mediocrity at times, but St Kilda should’ve been the one singing the team song on Sunday evening. An old St Kilda cliche developed: inaccuracy. That’s a pity, because this side could’ve been 3-0.


Last week: 8

On the actual ladder, they’re third. I’m pleased with that. On this ladder, I can’t see ‘em in the top eight. They were just far too bad against the Suns, and far too indifferent against an inaccurate Saints. Luke Ryan at half back though, phwoar. He’s a good one.


Last week: 12

Frustrating loss. But Adelaide’s statistical deficit wasn’t all bad – they gained more disposals and went forward more – but Geelong looked the more polished team. I’m still willing to back the Crows for finals, but just how good is this team?


Last week: 9

Richmond’s not in the best place at the moment. The club is stranded on the one win against the Blues, and have now lost conservative matches against what you could argue to be fellow top-eight contenders. It’s that point that worries me: how much will their much publicised injuries hurt them, and how many more can they afford to lose before the finals vultures start circling?


Last week: 15

Did what they had to do. Once the domain of Lance Franklin, the Swans forward line was flooded with small options this week. Given Franklin’s indifferent start to the season, Heeney, Papley et al. will continue to star. I’m still not at all convinced by the Swans this season, though they are notoriously slow starters.


Last week: 18

Well, they get a bit of a reprieve with their genuinely good win over the Demons. Entertaining game, and the Bombers will be pleased the pressure has been released… just a tad. Twenty goals was lovely to see – perhaps AFL House will be pleased with their Friday night offering.


Last week: 14

I’ll absolutely admit to being one of the many who joined the bandwagon declaring Carlton were likely to win against the Swans. That did fail to materialise, yet Carlton made it look possible for a few moments. Rectifying some damning inaccuracy would’ve made the Swans nervous. Nevertheless, they’re wooden-spoon favourites.


Last week: 16

So they’re zero and three. Did enjoy their first quarter, but they were unable to hold off a fast-finishing Hawthorn, not dissimilar to the Brisbane game last weekend.


Last week: 17

Where to from here? No doubt they contributed to Friday’s surprisingly entertaining affair, but the loss leaves them in a dangerous position. Sydney and St Kilda in the next two weeks allows for some potential wins, but could turn disastrous if they’re not careful.

The Crowd Says:

2019-04-10T03:22:17+00:00

Birdman

Roar Rookie


their tall forwards have also fallen off a cliff - time for Fogarty to come back in

2019-04-09T07:43:44+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Cats came off a 5 day break ... and were the traveling side. Terrible game planing to ignore Dangerfield for the entire game.

2019-04-09T03:35:44+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


Clearly Eddie hasn't been the same person since Pyke's infamous training camp. His form has fallen off a cliff. Losing Cameron was big too, but clearly Pyke is culpable here for destroying morale.

2019-04-09T01:41:23+00:00

IAP

Guest


A terrible forward line gifted Geelong the 4 points: - Tex - has one effort in him then he goes missing. Can only run in straight lines. - Jenkins - just stands out the back and waves his arms hoping someone will kick it to him. Should be dropped. - Eddie - G.O.R.N. Should've retired at the end of last year. Adelaide has serious problems; and that's without starting on their plodding midfield.

2019-04-09T00:22:11+00:00

Timbo's rules

Guest


Crows had consecutive 6 day breaks. I've never seen them win when that happens. First quarter both captains gave up goals with stupid 50 metre penalties and no-one stood Dangerfield at the stoppages. Weariness gifts Geelong the 4 points.

2019-04-09T00:22:01+00:00

sammy

Guest


It’ll be a struggle from here to get ahead of any of them Hope so..pick 1 here we come

2019-04-08T23:21:25+00:00

Paul D

Roar Rookie


Ah dear Christopher. His wit shall be missed. There's a tremendous dearth of humour in the starting 22 for the Libs with his departure. Hopefully they draft well at the pre-selection draft, but I sense a rebuild coming on. I can't fault any of the rankings my lad. Some embittered types below who seem perpetually jealous they're not receiving the big pay cheques or asked to do the rankings themselves, but you wind up with all sorts of embittered souls over the fact that glory isn't theirs - many of them are in the members reserve, relentlessly social climbing all the while. Frankly as far as the Fuchsias go the off-field action is more entertaining, I can only assume that the dredging up of the tanking saga again is to serve as distraction for the exact same behaviour that is currently going on at the moment - if the grand old flag keeps serving this up you're going to see a whole panzer division of Toorak tanks advancing en masse on Perisher come June.

2019-04-08T16:00:28+00:00

mike

Guest


The irony - Carlton as a feeder club after their long VFL history of taking from the WAFL, SANFL and VFL feeder club.

2019-04-08T12:26:41+00:00

Powa

Roar Rookie


the crows higher than port? they are perennially overrated

2019-04-08T12:25:19+00:00

Powa

Roar Rookie


port will probably make the 8 this year with their draw, which makes the Lions win pretty impressive

2019-04-08T09:44:20+00:00

Matches

Roar Rookie


I understand your point but it's indicative of where Carlton are and why they are at risk of becoming a 'feeder club' for the big clubs. i.e. who wants to beat the also-rans when you can soar with the Eagles. It's a simple choice for players like Redden, Jetta, Yeo ... and Jamie Cripps (Patrick's brother Jamie came home after the 2012 season) Patrick Cripps is contracted to the end of 2020 when he becomes a free agent. So imagine Kelly joins the Eagles for 2020 and Cripps for 2021.

2019-04-08T09:21:01+00:00

User

Roar Rookie


That fortnight they spent in WA playing your boys and wce stuffed them royally

2019-04-08T09:19:26+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


They are still experts in their profession – which happens to be guessing what will happen months from now. Tell me, who is doing better?

AUTHOR

2019-04-08T09:11:14+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


The Suns were 2-1 at this corresponding round last year, bud. They lost against Freo in the third round after wins against North and Carlton.

2019-04-08T08:49:49+00:00

fractal pixie

Guest


Yes the Suns were 3-0 this time last year, and that is why I never believed that they would not win a game this year. Carlton need to win this week if they are going to have any chance of notching up seven wins. Their form against the Suns is better up there than down here. They have shown plenty of spirit but they need to find ways to win. They have let two opportunities slip which at the moment looks costly, given that both St Kilda and the Suns have capitalized on their opportunities against better opposition.

2019-04-08T06:52:33+00:00

Brian

Guest


1. West Coast 2. Geelong 3. GWS 4. Collingwood 5. Brisbane 6. Adelaide 7. Hawthorn 8. Richmond 9. Port Adelaide 10. Essendon 11. Western 12. Sydney 13. Fremantle 14. St Kilda 15. Gold Coast 16. Melbourne 17. North Melboure 18. Carlton

2019-04-08T06:51:36+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


They lost in Perth to West Coast but many teams will. GWS would be heavy favourite to beat Lions at Spotless, and slight favourite at the Gabba.

2019-04-08T06:33:43+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


What was the Suns win loss after 3 rounds last year? Are you suggesting the blues won't win "up to 7 games"? Will they win more?

2019-04-08T05:03:58+00:00

Maurice

Guest


2 home wins against who care about teams for GWS , aint,t that impressive put them at 4 and give bris some glory until they start to losing. Anon

2019-04-08T04:16:43+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


P.olly - what did you expect from the first three rounds from the blues?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar