Three New Zealanders, one Australian and an Irishman sounds like the start of a bad pub joke. In reality, it nominates the nationalities of the next five voted into The Roar’s top 50 Rugby World Cup players.
In terms of positions, we have one durable lock, a cheeky first five, a combative hooker, and two of the finest centres to have graced the field.
» How The Roar’s top 50 RWC players works
Each nominated player has appeared in at least two of rugby’s showpiece (one made it to four), with two also captaining their sides in the tournament.
Sam Whitelock certainly fits the picture of a grizzled, hardened, country boy lock New Zealanders are accustomed to locking their scrum. He is also a surprisingly mobile and dynamic player who has proved his worth and durability time and again, including playing in all of the All Blacks’ World Cup games in 2011 (as a relative rookie) and 2015.
Whitelock heads into the 2019 tournament as the All Blacks’ most-capped lock and is in an elite club of only 20 players to have been a part of two successful World Cup campaigns.
Whitelock’s presence in the middle of the All Black pack in 2011 and 2015 played a significant role in New Zealand’s back-to-back victories. He and Brodie Retallick were without peer in the latter campaign, forming one of the greatest All Black locking duos of all time.
His lineout take from Victor Matfield at a pivotal moment in the 2015 semi-final will live long in the memory as a match-winning play from that hard-fought match. New Zealand will be hoping for more of the same from their veteran as he aims for a third World Cup victory for the All Blacks in Japan.
They say one man’s misery is another man’s gain, and so it proved for the start of Sean Fitzpatrick’s All Black career. An injury to incumbent captain and hooker Andy Dalton in 1987 provided Fitzpatrick with an opportunity which he duly seized, playing through that tournament as David Kirk’s famous side became the first holders of the William Webb Ellis trophy.
Further luck would befall Fitzpatrick when, after a disappointing World Cup campaign in 1991, he was appointed captain the following year led his side in South Africa with fierce determination despite some up-and-down results leading into the 1995 showpiece. The All Blacks rolled through that tournament only to fall in dramatic circumstances to the Springboks in the final.
Three World Cups, one as captain, and a winner’s medal to boot certainly mark Fitzpatrick as one of the tournament’s greats.
Andrew Mehrtens was a first five who displayed rare skill for his time in the position, combining the expected prodigious kicking game with a unique attacking skill set which lit up many memorable All Black performances, none more so that at the 1995 World Cup.
His superb domestic form saw him catapulted into contention for the ’95 side where Mehrtens had a fantastic tournament, his vision and tactical awareness often setting free a rampant backline containing the likes of Jonah Lomu.
That side captured the imagination of rugby fans worldwide despite falling short in arguably the greatest final ever played. The home side finished triumphant, although Mehrtens was so close to pulling it out of the fire as a last-minute drop goal attempt drifted agonisingly wide.
Despite losing that final, Mehrtens was part of a contingent of new players to breathe life back into the All Blacks’ World Cup hopes after a dire outing – by New Zealand’s standards at least – in 1991. They set the tone for future black-clad sides, while Mehrtens himself created a template for first-five play leading into rugby’s professional era.
Jason Little was a centre who shot to prominence during Australia’s triumphant World Cup campaign in 1991 where he, along with his centre partner Tim Horan, were the dominant 12-13 combination. Not only were they considered the best pairing, but also the best individual players in their respective positions at that World Cup, and throughout the majority of the decade.
While other individuals are singled out for praise for Australia’s successful title win in 1991 such as David Campese and Horan, Horan himself will point to Little’s stability and strength on defence as a major catalyst for Wallaby success, not just during that tournament but throughout the early ’90s as well.
Little would also go on to represent Australia in the next two World Cups, demonstrating his durability and class, and though not considered a sure starter for the ’99 tournament, he still played significant minutes, adding a second winner’s medal to his list of achievements while becoming one of the first dual world champions along with four of his Wallaby teammates.
Brian O’Driscoll was a mainstay at centre for Ireland from 1999 until his eventual retirement in 2014, appearing in four World Cups, two as captain.
Widely regarded as one of the best centres – if not the best – to have ever played the game, it is perhaps O’Driscoll’s feats outside World Cups that he is best known for, but his performances for a side that tended to be middling at best show his true quality.
O’Driscoll’s best outing at the World Cup came against host nation and eventual finalist Australia during the 2003 edition, when he scored a superb try and even landed a drop goal to almost cause one of the great tournament upsets, falling just a single point short.
His longevity and sheer class mark O’Driscoll as one of the game’s greats.
The Roar’s 50 greatest players in Rugby World Cup history
50. Jannie de Beer (South Africa)
49. David Kirk (New Zealand)
48. Zinzan Brooke (New Zealand)
47. Richard Hill (England)
46. Jason Robinson (England)
45. Sam Whitelock (New Zealand)
44. Sean Fitzpatrick (New Zealand)
43. Andrew Mehrtens (New Zealand)
42. Jason Little (Australia)
41. Brian O’Driscoll (Ireland)
40. Brian Lima (Samoa)
39. Christophe Lamaison (France)
38. David Pocock (Australia)
37. Chester Williams (South Africa)
36. Shane Williams (Wales)
35. Matt Burke (Australia)
34. Conrad Smith (New Zealand)
33. Keven Mealamu (New Zealand)
32. Kieran Read (New Zealand)
31. Schalk Burger (South Africa)
30. Jerome Kaino (New Zealand)
29. Os du Randt (South Africa)
28. Thierry Dusautoir (France)
27. Ma’a Nonu (New Zealand)
26. Serge Blanco (France)
25. Nick Farr-Jones (Australia)
24. Fourie du Preez (South Africa)
23. Grant Fox (New Zealand)
22. Stephen Larkham (Australia)
21. Lawrence Dallaglio (England)
20. Gavin Hastings (Scotland)
19. Jason Leonard (England)
18. Joel Stransky (South Africa)
17. Michael Jones (New Zealand)
16. John Kirwan (New Zealand)
15. Michael Lynagh (Australia)
14. John Smit (South Africa)
13. Victor Matfield (South Africa)
12. George Gregan (Australia)
11. Tim Horan (Australia)
10. Bryan Habana (South Africa)
9. Joost van der Westhuizen (South Africa)
8. Dan Carter (New Zealand)
7. David Campese (Australia)
6. John Eales (Australia)
5. Francois Pienaar (South Africa)
4. Martin Johnson (England)
3. Jonny Wilkinson (England)
2. Richie McCaw (New Zealand)
1. Jonah Lomu (New Zealand)
DP
Guest
Honey ballsac was pants
HenryHoneyBalls
Guest
Mike Gibson may have been Ireland's best ever centre but they both are all time greats of the game.
HenryHoneyBalls
Guest
I think most people can see O'Driscoll's value albeit a sense of jealousy does seem to prevail in some quarters in NZ for some reason. Keith Wood was awarded world player of the year award in 2001 and is the only hooker to score 4 tries at a RWC in one game. His overall record of 15 international tries is still the most for any international tight five player world wide. Im pretty sure his name would be in the conversation too.
HenryHoneyBalls
Guest
Me too :silly:
piru
Roar Rookie
He injured his groin during the world cup, so obviously played some part
piru
Roar Rookie
A lot of these things tend to give the NH more credit than they’ve earned by results Much like the rankings......
soapit
Roar Guru
We'll see what the top 20 looks like I suppose. A lot of these things tend to give the NH more credit than they've earned by results
jeznez
Roar Guru
Good call - was a quick effort and I freely admit that there will be some pretty obvious ones I missed. Pichot and Gregan in for Genia and Weepu
Davico
Roar Pro
Gregan not in your 6 best Scrum Halfs? Big Call. I would have have him and Joost ahead of Genia and Weepu at least!
Davico
Roar Pro
Exactly. If you want to make a "Best Players of All-Time" list then do that, but if you are going to do a WC list then it has to be recognised that the SH and SH players have been dominant!
piru
Roar Rookie
It's not unreasonable to expect SH players to dominate a RWC list when SH teams have dominated the tournament for it's duration, though
sheek
Roar Guru
Piru, No, I never said BOD was the best. Certainly the best 13 Ireland has produced, but not all-time, or even last 50 years. I haven't thought about this much in recent times, but Gerber (SA) & Sella (France) immediately come to mind. Then there's Robertson, Bunce & C.Smith from NZ, 'Snoz' O'Connor (dual international) & Little from Australia.
Jamie
Guest
Dan Carter played no part in the 2011 World cup win as he injured his groin during kicking practice.
piru
Roar Rookie
For Stirling Mortlock maybe… Hit him right on the chest! Special credit to Smoking Joe who pulled up with 40 odd metres to go, no doubt assuming we'd put another 40 pts on and that try wouldn't matter
piru
Roar Rookie
fair enough Sheek, agree with that. For some reason I had thought you'd named him the 'greatest ever' in your comment and was responding to that declaration, but I must have got my wires crossed as I see you never said that.
sheek
Roar Guru
Piru, O'Driscoll & Mortlock are very different players, despite them both playing the same possie. BOD is twinkle toes on his feet, while Sterlo is bash & barge. Who I picked might depend on the other backs surrounding them. I'm a huge believer in picking players who complement each other rather than being the same prototypes. I'm into ying & yang. So I would have them together with one of them playing 12. But if competing against each other for 13, it would also depend on other selections.
piru
Roar Rookie
I have something against him, yes, but that's quite separate to judgment of his ability (at least I hope it is). Leaving NZ bias out of it, would you really take him ahead of Mortlock?
piru
Roar Rookie
Carter wasn’t even the clear 1st Choice 5/8 for the ABs in 2015 yeah, he absolutely was
jeznez
Roar Guru
Not the guy I’m thinking of. Have exhausted my Google skills and can’t find him. Starting to question whether he played for a different country. Can see Lobbe and Sporleder are the most capped Puma locks and they played in the period I thought this guy was the captain in. Definitely something wrong with my memory here.
Carlos the Argie
Roar Guru
Hernandez as 10 was awesome that RWC. I think you mean Martin, but he was 8.