Haters take note: Ricky Stuart is an indisputably awesome coach

By Tim Gore / Expert

There are two bronze statues at GIO Stadium in Canberra.

One is of the clubs greatest ever player and rugby league immortal, Mal Meninga. The other is of former Raiders captain and star, Laurie Daley.

There now must be a third.

Raiders coach Ricky Stuart needs to be immortalised in bronze for his incredible service to the Canberra Raiders. While there is no question he was a superb player – and one of the best Raiders ever – it is as their coach that Stuart has truly earned the honour.

Our prodigal son returned to us at our lowest ebb as a club. The very club that brutally stripped the captaincy from him in 1996. The same club that cruelly cast him away in 1998 after eleven seasons of loyal service.

In spite of that history, Stuart returned to us in our hour of need and has dragged the club back to relevance.

He is now so close – and yet so far – from his second premiership as a coach.

Canberra Raiders coach Ricky Stuart isn’t happy. (AAP Image/Lukas Coch)

The coming match is the biggest challenge he has ever faced as a coach.

This Sunday the Raiders play against the Sydney Roosters in the decider.

The Chooks are a formidable outfit. All killer, no filler. I predicted them to be the 2019 premiers before a ball was kicked this season and I’ve seen no reason to change my views. I’ve also found myself admiring the Bondi Boys and their club.

No side has gone back to back since the Broncos of 1992-1993 but I think the Chooks are very likely to break that duck.

The Raiders are right up against it. However, this season they have established that they are no one’s bitch.

And that can be put down to Stuart’s stewardship of the team.

It has been 25 long years since my club last visited this stage. Back in those days I used to organise a group of ten or more of us to go sit on the old hill lawn for home games. We’d have to get there early to be assured of getting a chunk of grass to sit on, so big were the crowds back in the day.

We’d then watch in awe at Ricky’s skills. His passing – long and short – was superb. Further, his kicking game was the very best. He could chip to perfection. His long, raking field position kicks would have yielded hundreds of 40/20s if that rule had existed in his day. He could land his huge bombs on a dime.

One of his key skills was his ability to have his teammates actually believe that he could put the ball exactly where he said he would put it, and that it would be there when they arrived. The likes of Brett Mullins and Laurie Daley reaped the benefits of that belief on many occasions.

Ricky Stuart in his playing days (Photo by Getty Images)

At the representative level he formed a great combination with Dean Pay which involved putting a hard, flat pass directly on the now Bulldogs coach’s chest, in heavy traffic, to put him through the line. He could also organise a defensive line like no one else.

In 1993 he was at his peak. He was brilliant. Maybe too brilliant. When he broke his ankle in Round 21 of that year the Raiders were on top of the ladder. Without him the side – which still contained Mal Meninga, Gary Belcher, Laurie Daley and Brad Clyde – were rudderless and lost three games straight to be bundled out.

By 1996 I was the lone ranger on the hill lawn. The Super League war – mixed with the rise of the ACT Brumbies – killed off so much interest among my friends. But it didn’t kill mine. I ended up just going by myself. I remained devoted to the Raiders.

I stayed to witness the Raiders’ decline and malaise. I stayed through all the dark years of mediocrity and ineptitude. I witnessed the false dawns and I devoted myself to many messiahs who inevitably proved to be just mortal men who weren’t able to single handedly drag us back to credibility and relevance, or whose poor character meant that they stopped playing for my club.

For mine the beginning of the rot really happened in August 1998 when then Raiders CEO Kevin Neil cut Ricky Stuart and Brad Clyde from the team.

The Raiders. (Photo by Getty Images)

As I told Kevin Neil and Robert Finch at the time, not showing loyalty to those two elite players who had done so much for the club told every junior, established player and potential recruit that there was no loyalty in the nation’s capital.

The Raiders’ ability to attract and retain players suffered horribly from that point. After Laurie Daley, Ben Kennedy, Brett Mullins and David Furner left the club in 2000, the Raiders quickly disappeared from relevance. They now had no star power to attract new players.

We were making up the numbers. From that point we seemed to qualify for the finals in alternate years but were always making up the numbers.

In 2008 our under 20s side – featuring a young Jarrod Croker – won the Toyota Cup and we were filled with hope to partially offset the despair of Todd Carney’s sacking.

2010 and 2012 were both filled with optimism as we made the second week of the finals on the back of some great late season form. However, in both cases that optimism was smashed by the cruel reality that we just weren’t quite good enough…

Then in 2013 the wheels fell right off the wagon. At the beginning of the year the Raiders fought off the Eels – and Ricky Stuart ironically – to retain the then 20-year-old wunderkind forward Josh Papalii. But that was the only thing that went right.

Blake Ferguson and Josh Dugan effectively walked out on the club early in the season and the results weren’t good.

And then they got worse. Much worse.

I was riding the sideline for ABC Grandstand for the Raiders’ Round 21 clash against the Melbourne Storm when we suffered our biggest ever defeat, 68-4. The Raiders let in 12 tries. The gutted players then had to stay on the ground while a trophy presentation was made to the Storm side. It was horrible.

The Green Machine lost the last six straight games to finish a very poor 13th. In among that run David Furner – a beloved son of the club and an awesome guy – became the first ever Raiders coach to be sacked.

It was the club’s lowest ebb. The roster was poor and demoralised, the marquee player had a bad knee and now the club was searching for a new coach.

Who in the world would want that poisoned chalice?

Who would have the guts and courage to take on that task?

Enter the Prodigal Son. Enter Ricky Stuart.

His return to the club in 2014 was met with great hope by the long-suffering supporters. Yet there were still many detractors.

Canberra Raiders coach Ricky Stuart. (AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

Stuart the player was prickly, arrogant and ultra-competitive. It was a large part of what made him such a good player.

As a coach he hasn’t been able to always hide those characteristics. That has always got a lot of hackles up. As Cameron Smith has found out, the longer you stick around, the more detractors you are likely to get.

This is Stuart’s fourth decade of involvement with top level rugby league and there are an awful lot of haters of him out there.

While his record shows that as a coach he has won an NRL premiership, ten matches as Kangaroos coach, and a series as the coach of NSW, the haters say he can’t coach. That he’s a myth…

The most common thing I hear is that his only success was the Roosters premiership in 2002 – and that was down to Brad Fittler and Graham Murray.

While he got a very ordinary roster at the Sharks to the 2008 preliminary final, he has never been given credit for that feat. Much was made, too, of his short stint at the perennial underachievers that are the Parramatta Eels.

But here’s the thing: this Raiders side that takes the field on Sunday evening is totally Stuart’s Green Machine. He has built this team from the ground up. Of the 26 players used in first grade this season, only four of them were at the club before Stuart arrived in 2014. Apart from Croker, Jack Wighton, Papalii and Sam Williams, Stuart has created this side.

In his first year at the helm he lost gun junior Anthony Milford and was knocked back by Kevin Proctor, Jared Warea-Hargreaves, Josh Mansour and James Tedesco. He had to get very creative to build a competitive side.

Don Furner Sr and Wayne Bennett sourced players from Queensland in the 1980s to build their roster. Tim Sheens looked to New Zealand to rebuild after the salary cap scandal of 1991.

Ricky Stuart went to England and found Josh Hodgson, Elliot Whitehead, Ryan Sutton and John Bateman. Along the way he picked up Kiwis Joseph Tapine, Jordan Rapana, Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad and Bailey Simonsson.

He resurrected Sia Soliola and Dunamis Lui. He has brought through juniors like Nic Cotric, Corey Horsburgh and Emre Guler.

He recruited Joey Leilua, Aidan Sezer and Saliva Havili. Sure, Stuart has had great assistance from the likes of Peter Mulholland and Andrew McFadden to do it. He has surrounded himself with experts and he takes their advice. But make no mistake: he is steering the ship.

The Raiders under Ricky Stuart are a real chance of winning the competition. (AAP Image/Lukas Coch)

He has made a team that is a force to be reckoned with. They are more than the sum of their parts.

It is very clear from this feat that not only can he coach but he is in fact extremely good at it.

While I loved Ricky the player, I never thought he was that good of a bloke back in the 1990s. However, age and fatherhood has mellowed Stuart.

Regardless of what you might think, he is a very likeable, kind and considerate man. Yet he lives constantly under a siege mentality. That he ever smiles is amazing considering the hate and derision that is heaped upon him – as well as the glee with which his disappointments and frustrations are received by his many detractors.

Sure, he gets grouchy at the media when they ask him questions about perceived weaknesses in his side. But that is because he loves his team. He has poured his heart and soul into it – and them. Those are his boys and if you have a go at them then Ricky will go your throat.

John Bateman (AAP Image/Dave Hunt)

And you know when you are on Stuart’s team that he has your back. He might give you an earful in private, but he’ll defend you to the hilt in public.

And it is that love and dedication that has bonded this team into a band of brothers.

Win or lose, this Raiders side is one to be proud of. They have brought real respect back to the jumper and the club. They may even usher in a new golden era of success, like the one Stuart played in.

And if they do it will be down to Stuart and his brilliant coaching.

And all you haters can go please yourselves.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-06T11:47:56+00:00

Gold Coast Bunny

Roar Rookie


Hit the nail on the head but for once it actual may have been!

2019-10-06T09:30:05+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


Anyone given that much time might make it.

2019-10-04T12:48:35+00:00

Rob

Guest


Imagine if Ricky had of raided the Raiders and got Papalii in blue and gold before jumping ship?

2019-10-04T02:53:33+00:00

Rob

Guest


Well I hope they’re not unlucky if that helps fella’s. It appears you boys have taken great offensive to a comment I was saying in reference to Ricky not being an “indisputable awesome coach”. I think Papa, Crocker, Hodgson. Batsman, Wightion and young Kockstad have been great this season. My knowledge of the game? Maybe i’m not a good student of Tim’s teachings but I hope for his sake Leilua doesn’t have to many brain explosions because it’s curiously coincidental he has played limited football this season and the Raiders have done well? I wish McGuire had stayed with the Broncos or a least been suspended for a long period. I wish the Cowboys had kept Horsbrugh instead. He might be Raider’s Steve Jackson on Sunday I hope.

2019-10-04T02:16:39+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I agree in that assessment of Stuart, but cops a huge amount of vitriol - more than coaches with comparable records. Look down the comments here - you get things like “if you don’t count his premiership he hasn’t won a premiership” or “if you don’t count his record at the Roosters he has a winning % of ......” You don’t get “take out his record at Parra and his win % goes up to .....” Graham Murray gets credit for Stuart’s premiership but doesn’t get criticism for not winning one himself despite also inheriting a very good team from Gould. It’s inconsistent. I’m not ready to start casting the bronze statue but I think overall the comments about Stuart’s coaching record are pretty imbalanced.

2019-10-04T02:02:59+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


I think the amount of credit for the roosters ‘ship probably sits somewhere between the critics and this. Why didn't Murray win well a lot of those players were still developing (croker, cross, mini and wing) and Morley hadn't adjusted yet to the NRL. We also only won two more games during the year so it wasn't some transcendent difference. Before I get the "but he won the premiership" yeah sure, but to be honest knock out one off finals aren’t really a great indication of the best team anyway and if coaching moves the dial on this why did he not win with better teams in the ensuing years? I don’t think Ricky is terrible or amazing. He seems competent and I’m impressed by the raiders willingness to adhere to sensibility over popularity and valuing stability in the coaching staff.

2019-10-04T01:50:11+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Bit harsh on the 2008 sharks roster. Had 3 Australian players, a few more origin guys and a kiwi international

2019-10-04T00:39:12+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


It was indeed inspired, Geoff. Was it really Ricky inspired ? My point was more to the good fortune of having all 4 firing consistently & generally avoiding any long term injuries this year, as compared to say, the Chooks with their prize import, Ryan Hall, or the impact last year of the long term loss of Hodgson. All three playing on Sunday will hold the key to the Raiders chances. And as you say they got extra lucky also in missing out on Mansour ! Unlucky for us . That's footy.

2019-10-04T00:16:15+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Thanks kk ! I enjoy your posts too, and I particularly like your often cryptic style. I think we might have some similar views on our great game. Back in 1967 when the Panthers first entered the league, I was just kid and it was the pre-season and Souths had come out to the old Penrith Park for some trial games. My dad pointed out a bunch of old Souths footballers sitting nearby watching the trials. I had a new autograph book and approached these guys for a signature . First to sign my book was Richie Powell, followed by Chicka Cowie & Ian Moir.

2019-10-03T22:21:27+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Everything up until the BJ pass, yes. I'm not having a go here mind you. Every team needs a bit of luck throughout the year and in past years if the Raiders luck was anything to go by the ball would have flown backwards to the Storm and they would have made a line break and run 90 metres to put the game to bed and Hodgson would have torn a hamstring trying to run him down. I think you mistake my intentions on here quite often. I actually like the Raiders. I lived in Canberra for 6 years up until recently and went to many, many Raiders games. I was actually at the capitulation to the Storm in 2013. It was embarrassing and Ricky has done an overall fantastic job over that time. Doesn't mean I have to drink the kool aid and pretend that 2017 and 2018 didn't happen nor pretend that some luck didn't finally find it's way down the Hume Highway.

2019-10-03T21:55:29+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Did take them to a GF though. Surely the way he rode a successful side well into the ground counts against him?

2019-10-03T21:54:47+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Because it's true...

2019-10-03T21:53:54+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


No. I'm saying a coach that needs to recruit a specific group of players to be able to coach them to any form of success must be a limited coach. As I already said, not every group is capable of a grand final. But if Stuart is a good coach, why did he take over and take a low finishing team (13th) and slide back further (15th). If he's a good coach, or a top coach, he should be able to take any group of NRL players and immediately make them into a team pushing for finals. Some years that may mean 9th or 10th. If Stuart was a good coach, he'd have taken the team to the finals most years. He wouldn't need his perfect (in terms of a salary cap sport) roster to be able to even achieve that. Good coaches take teams to the top 8. Cronulla made the 8 1/4 years he coached. Parra 0/1. Canberra are 2/6. Take out the Roosters making the finals 3/5 years and he has a horrible record. Even with it he's coached teams to the finals 6 times in 16 seasons. More often his teams have missed than made the finals. It would seem that he's getting better results at Canberra than he did previously, but still his record, even just at the Raiders, has the hallmark of a poorly coached team. Inconsistency. Dude... You are actually saying that a guy who has just scraped a 50% coaching record together now and whose teams miss the finals more than they erratically make them is a really good coach? Really? Seriously? You actually think that dreadful logic has any credibility?!? Dude…

2019-10-03T21:39:43+00:00

Geoff from Bruce Stadium

Roar Rookie


Hi Taree - yeah I was ripping into Ricky last year as well and I think he deserved it - but credit is due to him this year at the way he's turned things around. Obviously a lot of thought went into the make up of the squad and the structure of the team in the off season as well as tactically in focusing more on defence and finding ways to ice games in the last 20 minutes. Ricky and the players have done amazingly well this year and I expect them to do really well this Sunday. You can go through every player in the team and there is a good news story. Getting a premiership could be a great way to farewell players like Sezer, BJ and Jordy Rapana if they end up leaving. I'd love it if they all stayed. There is a bond between these blokes that looks unbreakable. Even the young ones. And blokes like Sam Williams, Sutton and Oldfield who have played their part during the season but won't get to play. Like you I've been through the tough times supporting this team - the heartbreak of the 2016 prelim loss and all those close games we lost in 2017 and 2018. As a supporter I can remember being devastated by some of those losses at home. But those experiences build character, resilience and determination. I think the team deserves their chance on Sunday. I can't believe the bookies have them at $3 given their wins against the Storm and Souths. I'm confident they will win.

2019-10-03T21:15:53+00:00

Taree Raider

Guest


Geoff, Ricky is too loyal, if that's a fault I can only hope that it's a good one. On Sunday we'll find out. I believe that as a Raiders tragic I have the right to question tactics, selections & player behaviour. I must also respect the fact that Ricky has stayed strong & they have made it to the big dance. Was my criticism of Ricky wrong? I don't believe so. But I admire what he has achieved. I can't wait for the GF. I know that they will be in it all the way. I just love the NRL & Raiders. After Sunday my Fox subscription goes to limp mode. Can't wait until March 2020. George Williams at halfback!

2019-10-03T18:52:12+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Not haters if they disagree with you. The facts say he's won one comp in nearly 20 years yet you're saying he's an awesome coach. You need to calm down

2019-10-03T14:56:06+00:00

Roar GOAT

Roar Rookie


Loved Ricky as a player, hate him as a full-time whinger and part-time coach. Disagree with the entire premise. Ricky has proved over 20 years he’s a fairly average coach. I think he’s done a great job but I’m not entirely convinced about the level of credit he deserves. I’ll give him some credit for sending Papali back to the Reggie’s 18 months ago as he has been a revelation (or rejuvenation) this year. I’m not convinced Stuart is very good at developing players and ironically, his history of developing halves is abysmal. All that said, I think he’s done a great job in bringing this team together this year. On paper I still don’t really rate them, Papali and Hodgson aside it’s not a massively strong squad - certainly over achieved this year, which is a rarity for Stuart coaches team. Go the raiders! I hate the chooks and also couldn’t bare the whinging from Sticky if they lose.

2019-10-03T13:44:56+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Gould and Murray couldn’t win comps with that Roosters side so I guess they’re not half decent coaches...

2019-10-03T12:05:40+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Maybe two Raiders coaches will follow a similar path and win a title out of the blue. Sheens and Stuart had stellar winning % when they had stellar rosters and when they went to wobbly outfits , the winning % went all wobbly. The focus on winning percentages is not rational at all and never will be. It's not a level playing field.

2019-10-03T11:52:48+00:00

Rob

Guest


They were lucky Hodgson wasn’t taken from the field for a HIA against Souths and then a dropped ball land fortuitously on Wightings foot after hitting his knee stopping in perfect position on the Try line. I get the passion (Cowboys 2017) save some for Sunday boys.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar