The top 50 NRL players of 2019: 50-41

By Scott Pryde / Expert

Another NRL season is in the books, and while the wash-up and fall-out to the grand final continues, it’s time to start our top 50 player countdown.

This will be a five-part series, with ten players released each day in reverse order, starting today with players 50 to 41 on the list.

There probably isn’t too much guessing about who is going to come in at number one on this list, but the rest could be argued, and I found it harder to put this together than I did 12 months ago, which is really saying something.

Without any further ado, let’s get into the 2019 countdown.

50. Daniel Tupou (Sydney Roosters)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: N/A

Tupou has been in the wilderness for a couple of years when it comes to the games elite wingers. He has struggled with injury at points, and form at others, despite the incredibly consistent performances of his Roosters side.

This year, though, he was back at his dangerous back.

Tupou has the much-talked-about height advantage, and put it to good use this year, regularly causing opposition wingers nightmares, but he was also a lot more involved in running out of his own end, picking up a lot of the slack left in the giant hole created by the departure of Blake Ferguson.

His 15 tries only tell part of the story, and while he is still error-prone, Tupou’s upwards trajectory really should only see him going further up this list next season.

49. Cody Walker (South Sydney Rabbitohs)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: 17

If you had have put this list together halfway through the season, there is no question Walker would have been a lot higher up it. At the point he made his State of Origin debut, he was worthy of the bench spot, which became a starting gig when injuries occurred all around him.

Unfortunately, he fell apart after Origin. He wasn’t helped by the slow nature of South Sydney’s playstyle, but errors and poor decisions were trademarks of his game during the second half of the season.

He makes the list because he was still a part of Souths, and had an incredibly good first half of the season.

(AAP Image/Daniel Muñoz)

48. Josh Morris (Cronulla Sharks)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: N/A

The stats won’t tell you what sort of impact Josh Morris had on the Sharks this year, in what was his best season in years.

Morris has always been a good defensive presence in the centres, but that went to another level throughout 2019, while his attack was just about as good as it has ever been throughout the year.

Some will look at this selection and wonder why, but the spot for Morris is well earned.

47. Shaun Lane (Parramatta Eels)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: N/A

The signing of Lane by the Eels last off-season was one of the most underrated, and it proved to be that way time and time again during the season as he played a huge part in getting Parramatta to the top eight and into the finals.

While the big second rower didn’t have huge running metres, it was the danger of each run he made which makes him the player he is, often threatening to break tackles, bend the line, draw extra numbers into a tackle or get rid of an offload.

Lane isn’t quite in the top echelon of second rowers, but he isn’t far away and a big 2020 could have him a lot further up the tree.

46. Clint Gutherson (Parramatta Eels)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: N/A

Gutherson had an up and down 2019, which, to be fair, most of the Eels did. At Bankwest Stadium, he was phenomenal. Away from home though, he tended to fall apart.

While he was generally pretty safe at the back for Parramatta, it was his attack and the involvement level in it which seemed to fluctuate dramatically at times for Parramatta.

Still, a solid season for the man they hail as king in Sydney’s west.

45. Mitchell Pearce (Newcastle Knights)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: 33

Whether Mitchell Pearce would be happy with his season is up for debate. He was in such good form during the first half of the season that he ended up getting his eight millionth recall to State of Origin, finally delivering a series win for the Blues.

But, at club land, his form in the lead-up to that was inconsistently good, and after, inconsistently poor, with many ordinary performances creeping in.

He wasn’t helped by a lingering injury of course, but when Newcastle were on, so was Pearce, and in the end, it’s hard to say he had a bad season.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

44. Siosiua Taukeiaho (Sydney Roosters)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: N/A

During the first two months of the season, Taukeiaho was at the forefront of the game when it came to in-form props. His performance to rip the Dragons in half on Anzac Day sticks in the memory bank, however, he had so many like it.

Unfortunately, injury hurt his second half of the season and probably stopped him from being a lot further up this list, but Taukeiaho is a very dangerous prop and set the tempo for his side multiple times in 2019, before doing his job off the bench during the finals.

43. Josh Jackson (Canterbury Bulldogs)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: 24

Unfortunately, I couldn’t find a way to move Jackson further up the list, based on the Bulldogs struggles in 2019, of which the Canterbury captain could do nothing about.

He lost his Origin spot as well, but Jackson is the picture of consistency.

That is shown by the fact he made over 900 tackles for the year, tackling at north of 90 per cent, while he also ran the ball hard and never stopped trying for his beloved blue and white.

There were a number of players who could have been in contention for these final spots in the 50, but it’s so difficult to leave Jackson out.

42. Wade Graham (Cronulla Sharks)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: 50

While Graham missed much of the first half of the year and only ended up with ten NRL appearances when he made it back, he was phenomenal in the games he did play for the Sharks.

You can always judge a player’s impact to his side by the way they play when he is out, and Cronulla’s performance always took a hit when Graham wasn’t there.

He had eight offloads, four line breaks and a pair of try assists, but it’s what he does in the lead-up to scoring plays or breaks, his quick passing, solid kicking game and extra creative option which is the biggest element of his game.

Will be back in Origin next year if he can be fit.

(AAP Image/Craig Golding)

41. Jai Arrow (Gold Coast Titans)
My ranking at the beginning of 2019: 37

The Titans had what can only be described as a very difficult season. They finished last on the ladder, and barely looked like winning a game at times.

Their one bright light though was Jai Arrow, and when he was out injured, it made a considerable difference to the intensity and effort they were able to display against their consistently more fancied opposition.

He tackled effectively in a team which generally didn’t, and ran for almost 140 metres per game in a team who played without the footy for a large chunk of the season.

Be sure to check back in tomorrow when players 31-40 are unveiled as we count down the top 50 players from the 2019 NRL season.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-15T08:58:59+00:00

Renegade

Roar Guru


There isn't a better second rower in the competition.... I think the fact he didn't play most of the year is why the origin performance had plenty talking him up this year, he sat out for 9 months comes back and dominates his first NRL game back and then the following weeks does the same in Origin 2...... he has been that good for the best part of the last 4-5 years but probably didn't receive the recognition, no doubt that he is the Sharks MVP. He is also still only 28 although it seems like he has been playing for 20 years...so the best of wade is still to come.

2019-10-15T08:44:20+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


There’s an example of you doing it right here that I was specifically commenting on. Scott’s article zero mention of Manly players. Your post three mentions of Manly. I think your problem is you immediately forget what you posted earlier. It’s the only thing that explains how you can sit there saying “you’re a liar” when the evidence sits about 15 cms above my comment you say is a lie I don’t twist anything you say. I just present it back to you, if it seems absurd that’s because it usually is. You go down the same old path every time, write something silly, get called on it by multiple people but then it’s only because I’ve twisted your words or I’m micromanaging your opinion (whatever that means) You’re one of the most bland, pointless, clueless people I’ve ever had the misfortune of encountering.

2019-10-15T01:33:11+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


It's not mild and it's not an exaggeration, it's a lie. If you're not distorting the facts and twisting what I say , you are telling Porkies. Donald Trump does the same thing and it's a good way of getting support but it's a bit on the hollow side isn't it?

2019-10-14T23:22:54+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


I agree. But Mitchell can win matches on his own when his head is right. That sort of player is very few and far between. All Clubs would risk his inconsistency and hope to man manage him well , for the sake of cashing in regularly on his talents.

2019-10-14T22:48:59+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


What porkies...? That you reference Manly in every comment? That’s a mild exaggeration not a lie.

2019-10-14T11:04:06+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


A nine year old would have a valid excuse to be telling porkies to try and win approval because they are immature, you don't have an excuse.

2019-10-14T10:52:39+00:00

Noosa Duck

Roar Rookie


Albo, my concern about Latrell is that he goes MIA far too much. He does not go looking for the ball and plays well when he is spoon fed. You see Topau coming in off the wing and helping out , you see Jackson do some hard yards and when Ryan Hall played in the centres for a couple of games he made terrific metres just doing that hard yakka and giving the middle blokes a bit of a rest. I liked SKD as a player because he went looking for the ball and did some hard yards up the middle to help out . Sure Mitchell is great when things light up but sometimes you got to do a bit to make that happen.

2019-10-14T10:50:40+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


“I’ve had a few debates on topics regarding NRL” Where do you find nine year old NRL fans that you can match wits with...?

2019-10-14T08:11:50+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Yep game 2 this year has blown things out. QLD were so shot that even Will Chambers, had he switched teams, could have laid on a few tries for NSW in that game, actually I think he did...

2019-10-14T08:08:54+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Don't buy lane, we’d be paying full freight – maybe even paying for unrealistic upside at this point. You let Parra, or the Tigers or the Dragons pay for lane and then we’ll buy their top three juniors have spare change under the cap and roll the dice.

2019-10-14T08:06:28+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


I've had a few debates on topics regarding NRL but I've never seen so one so desperate to win as you. Desperately searching for the most trivial flaws in someones comment that doesn't exist don't make you a winner , it's just desperation. Once again you are blatantly lying ''you can't make any sort of point or comment without relating it back to Manly'' Completely false and even if it were true , the easy solution would be to avoid reading my posts . I don't read most of yours so it's not that difficult. You have some strange notion that you are running the site. I'll post how I want, so stop this boring campaign. If a Sharks fan approaches me with his opinion that Wade Graham is the ants pants and compares Jurbo to him and the lack of skills Jurbo has I don't go on with some nonsense about them being in a different role , I answer his opinion with a sensible one of my own. I enjoyed the talk and welcome more. There is nothing I enjoy about your attempt at micromanaging my opinion with trivial babble.

2019-10-14T07:41:39+00:00

AJ Mithen

Expert


It’s only fair. I might slide Taukeiaho just ahead of the Mounties boys

2019-10-14T07:26:53+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Everyone knows why you compared Graham to Jurbo. It’s because you can’t make any sort of a point or a comment without relating it back to Manly. This article contains no references to Manly or Manly players but your comment contains one reference to Manly and two to Jurbo It makes sense that if you’re pointing out why you’re not of the Graham bandwagon that you’d compare his skill set to a player in the same position as a point of comparison. Of course this article will make comparisons to different players in different positions. But that’s not what you were doing. You’re specifically comparing their skill sets (or “bag of tricks”) To extrapolate your Tedesco / Klemmer example it’s like saying, “I don’t think Klemmer’s a good prop because Tedesco is better at taking bombs and chiming into a backline” Now you’re trying to hide behind “they’re both backrowers” when even you know that a middle third lock is not at all like an edge backrower. Sometimes your irrelevance knows no bounds.

2019-10-14T06:56:43+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Well Aubo only has a season or two ahead... Eyes to the future...

AUTHOR

2019-10-14T06:32:52+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


You just wanted 17 Raiders players, followed by their wider squad, then the Mounties NSW Cup team, didn't you?

2019-10-14T06:02:33+00:00

AJ Mithen

Expert


Siosiua Taukeiaho at 44 is an absolute disgrace Scott. I’m drafting an angry letter to the editor this instant!!

2019-10-14T05:38:10+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


You couldn’t go wrong ! He is a beauty. Can play anywhere in your pack, and has 80 minutes in him. But then it still depends what your team needs in new personnel. Take my mob the Panthers, we could probably use most of that great Chooks team including Butcher, but I’d be particularly keen on all their backs from 1, 2,3,4,5,6, plus the 9 (Verrills). I guess if you can only afford one , I’d opt for Teddy, Mitchell or Verrills in the end.

2019-10-14T05:29:40+00:00

Fraser

Roar Rookie


Yeah I think Graham is the most overrated player in the competition. No fault of his though - he is a very good player. But for some reason the commentary around him is just amazingly over the top.

2019-10-14T05:28:42+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


I thought Cook peaked a while back as a player , it was a high peak but I thought the defences would start to work him out more and without a dominant pack he is a touch limited perhaps.

2019-10-14T05:24:48+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


If I was a rival recruiter looking to pluck the eyes out of the Rooster pack Butcher would be the one that I want.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar