My NRL team of 2019

By The Barry / Roar Guru

Season 2019 is done and dusted so it’s time to look at my NRL team of the year.

Fullback – James Tedesco (Roosters)
The easiest position to decide. Statistically Tedesco is a freak. Third in the NRL for tries, first for line breaks, first for tackle breaks, he had 13 line break assists and 13 try assists. He was second for run metres and second for kick return metres.

But then you watch him play. In the preliminary final against the Storm, he came up with an incredible tackle to hold Brandon Smith up over the line and then minutes later scored the match-winning try. He has also been outstanding at Origin level.

Honourable mentions: Roger Tuivasa-Sheck, Tom Trbojevic, Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad

Wing – Daniel Tupou (Roosters)
Tupou got tagged as a lazy player a few years ago and that label has unfairly stuck, but he was excellent in 2019. There’s the obvious aerial threat he represents with his height, vertical leap and ability to take bombs over his head.

But he’s also a great finisher and selects his time to come in off his wing in defence clinically. But his best work is often at the other end of the park and often unsung. He makes a lot of tough metres coming out of his own end. He was fifth in the league for run metres and third for post-contact metres.

Wing – Ken Maumalo (Warriors)
Maika Sivo had a pretty eye-catching season but for every couple of good things he does there’s a bad.

Maumalo gives a lot of what Sivo does to a team and then some. Maumalo was fourth in the NRL for tries, third for run metres and first for post-contact metres. Like Tupou, a player that delivers at both ends of the park.

Honourable mentions: Blake Ferguson, Maika Sivo, Reuben Garrick

Centre – Latrell Mitchell (Roosters)
People will point to Mitchell’s Origin sacking and put forward a completely valid argument that his teammate Joseph Manu had a better season.

Mitchell has still been incredible this year and put several teams to the sword. He just has a pretty big gap between his best and worst. Mitchell was the season’s leading point-scorer and second for tries. He had more try assists than any other centre and was top ten for line breaks.

Centre – Kotoni Staggs (Broncos)
Centre is a challenging position. When you go through the lists there aren’t a lot of standouts.

Staggs really announced himself as an NRL quality player, particularly in the second half of the season, when he started finding the line regularly. I like how he does everything at pace.

I’m not entirely convinced he was better than Manu or Hopoate and I’m prepared for a bit of blow back here but it felt like a really important year for Staggs.

Honourable mentions: Joseph Manu, Will Hopoate, Jarrod Croker

Five-eighth – Luke Keary (Roosters)
Cameron Munster and Cody Walker were brilliant in the first half of 2019 but tapered away after Origin for different reasons. Jack Wighton grew into his season.

Luke Keary had a bit of a stop-start year with injuries but was great overall and built on his Churchill-winning 2018. Second in the league for try assists and first for line break assists. Keary was a lock for Origin selection until he was ruled out with injury.

Honourable mentions: Cameron Munster, Cody Walker, Jack Wighton

Halfback – Daly Cherry-Evans (Sea Eagles)
Manly did brilliantly to finish so high on the table and get to the second week of semis when you look at the key players they were missing for so much of the season. DCE was the consistent link.

(Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Third for try assists, sixth for line break assists and kick metres and led the league in 40/20’s. Mitchell Moses fans could make a convincing case, but for me, DCE’s big-game temperament gives him the edge.

Honourable mentions: Mitchell Moses, Cooper Cronk, Michell Pearce

Prop – Josh Papalii (Raiders)
Papalii has led the way for the new-look, more mobile Raiders pack. Papalii features prominently in the run metres (second for props) and post-contact metres (third for props) as you’d expect but there’s also a lot of less tangible elements to his game in the way he leads the Raiders and Queensland packs. A standout for mine as the best prop.

Prop – Payne Haas (Broncos)
Uncanny returns and performances from a 19-year-old playing in the toughest position on the field. First for run metres and post-contact metres for props.

Did I mention he’s 19? What will his returns look like in a decade? While he’s capable of playing massive minutes, he’ll be better served in the long term by being used a bit more selectively than being ground into the dirt.

Honourable mentions: James Fisher-Harris, Jared Waerea-Hargreaves, Matt Lodge, David Klemmer, Nelson Asofa-Solomona

Hooker – Cameron Smith (Storm)
I came so close to making a case for Josh Hodgson but I still think Smith is the best number nine in the game.

(Photo by Michael Dodge/Getty Images)

As good a season as Hodgson had and as much as Canberra rely on him, Smith still had more try assists, line break assists, run metres, tackles and forced dropouts than Hodgson. That’s how good Smith is – an opponent has an outstanding, breakout season but still doesn’t quite measure up.

Honourable mentions: Josh Hodgson, Damien Cook

Second row – John Bateman (Raiders)
This bloke won me over pretty quickly. I love players like him who put everything into every play they make. Looked at home on an edge, in the middle and even playing in the centres.

Even though he posted some impressive numbers – 116 metres and 36 tackles per game along with five tries, four line breaks, four line break assists and 40 offloads for the season – stats don’t tell the full story of his involvement.

Second row – Ryan Matterson (Tigers)
This was a tough position to pick with plenty of outstanding candidates, but I just loved what Matterson did this year. He can play a number of roles: workhorse, hard-running edge back-rower, ball-playing lock and even fill in at six or in the centres.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Matterson averaged 131 metres and 36 tackles and had five tries. He was the league leader for second-rowers in run metres and post-contact metres.

Honourable mentions: Boyd Cordner, Angus Crichton, Manu Ma’u, Josh Jackson, Briton Nikora

Lock – Cameron Murray (Rabbitohs)
It’s great to see the lock position evolving from effectively a third prop back to a more mobile and skilled forward. Murray is the prototype.

Top ten in the competition for tackles and his running game is surprisingly effective for a smaller man in the middle. So much has been made of his quick play-the-balls. He seems to have a knack for getting his body in the right position in the tackle so he lands on his front. He also scored 12 tries and made 47 line breaks in 2019.

Honourable mentions: Jake Trbojevic, Jason Taumalolo, Dale Finucane

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-31T13:16:59+00:00

PT

Guest


seems like you're judging more on spectacle than actual form...Sivo was good but he was inconsistent, sometimes wasn't even sighted. Tupou has been brilliant, and most importantly consistent, something which Sivo lacked this year

2019-10-31T03:43:12+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


ill add that Sivo is already 26. He is pretty much physically as good as he will get, unlike say Garrick, Coates, Lomax or any other young debutant winger who still needs to mature physically, which is why I don't get the hype for his potential 'upside'. I also don't buy the whole still learning the game argument. He played 3 years in NSW cup and a season of country footy before that. He may still have a little improvement left in him with experience at the top level and certainly no reason why he couldn't evolve his game to do more tough carries, but I think he is more or less as good as he will get. Don't get me wrong he is a very good winger, maybe in the top 5, certainly in the top 10, I just don't think he justifies the hype around him.

2019-10-31T03:02:14+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


I said Sivo has a great highlights reel but even still the majority of his tries and linebreaks weren't anything any other winger wouldn't have done, also just running into space. A bit like Robert Jennings in 2018. Sivo just doesn't do the hard work that Tupou does. Tupou regularly takes the tough carries one out from his own end, more so than any winger other than Maumalo. Sivo doesnt provides the aerial threat that others do, of which Tupou is the best in the comp. Sivo may have a higher tackle efficiency, but id say this comes from flying up and in and smashing people (completing the tackle), whereas roosters hold their line and slide (harder to complete the tackle). But with this comes missed tackles (of which he has more) leaving the line exposed and worse still two suspensions.

AUTHOR

2019-10-30T19:55:28+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


The second row came down to three for me...Bateman, Matterson or Ma’u I went for Matterson because of the variety he has in his game and he also gets through a huge amount of work. I certainly wouldn’t argue with anyone giving Ma’u the nod. He’s been a favourite player of mine for years. Suli’s not a bad shout either.

2019-10-30T14:56:46+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Sivo ‘19 highlights on YouTube are sensational...Tupous are really,really average, 90% of Tups tries come from kicks or from sideline space provided by Keary or Mitchell where he runs onto a ball and beats no one..can’t fathom what criteria you’re using to rate Tupou higher Sivo features in best fends, best flattening tackles, best steamrolling and 50% more tries than Tupou, in his rookie season..Tupou also has a pretty miserable tackle efficiency of 54%, on Sivo’s 84% ,with the Eel doubling the Roosters line breaks..a real grunt, with no brake who welcomes the hard stuff.. Take Tupou out, Roosters still win the comp...there was no Sivo and Fergo in ‘18 and you know what happened.

2019-10-30T10:02:45+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


Great team, can understand reasoning for all selections. Only changes idve made are: Mau in for Matterson. To me Mau was absolutely unstoppable. I think his line running in attacking and body guard efforts in defence was a big reason for the rise of Moses this year. I expect eels will regress without him. Hoppa in for Staggs for reasons you've already commented on. I also don't mind Suli as an honourable mention. IMO he ended the season alongside Staggs as the form centre in the comp. Am definitely with you on Tupou, only id have him behind Maumalo for best winger in the game. I think Maumalo is all Tupou is but breaks a few more tackles as well. I really don't understand why there is so much hype around Sivo. Best winger in the game?? hes not even the best winger at the eels. He had a good year no doubt, especially for a rookie season and his highlight reel is great, but still plenty of errors and some poor defensive decisions.

2019-10-30T02:45:10+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Yeah I was on the Radley bandwagon, more because I just liked watching him throw himself into his work and he has a few ball skills as well. But yeah, Murray announced himself in 2019 for sure. H e has aspects to his game like a young Burgess without the size advantage. PTB is incredible for his size and his versatility saved Souths a few times this season.

AUTHOR

2019-10-30T02:25:37+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Ive always thought Murray was better than Radley. I think Radley was a little overhyped because of his big hits in defence. It will be interesting to see what happens at 13. I think there’s a trend to more mobile, skilled players as opposed to third props. I think we’re even seeing it at prop a little bit.

2019-10-30T02:02:35+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Good team TB. Obviously I like the Staggs selection but another young center I thought showed himself this year was Momirovski for WT. Agreed on the lock position, although I think this kid is one out of the box as opposed to a trend back to ball-playing locks. I'm looking forward to Radley going back to #13 more consistently next year now Easts have hooker covered 2 ways. If not for Friend's injury Murray may not have seen a Blues jumper, IMO.

AUTHOR

2019-10-29T21:00:31+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


:stoked: I don’t think the quality centre is dead, I just think in the modern game they don’t get the same opportunities as a half, fullback or hooker therefore it’s hard to justify the million a year price tag regardless of how good they are. Same as the talk with Fifita. He’s a very exciting player. At 18 now, he could be anything in the future. But as good as he is and as good as he might become I just can’t see how he can be valued at a million bucks and more importantly how he can provide a million bucks worth of value playing as an edge forward. Same with Latrell. As exciting a player as I can remember seeing - but I don’t see 1M value there at the moment. If you’re paying your edge players 1M, there has to be an imbalance in your squad somewhere else.

2019-10-29T20:52:33+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


sadly I couldn't remember their names!!

AUTHOR

2019-10-29T19:44:35+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Poor old Neil Hunt and Paul Taylor never get a mention !

2019-10-29T08:40:22+00:00

John

Guest


The most depressing part of the Molan video popping up for me, is this is the one of the only videos I can actually view on the Roar since everything else is region locked.

AUTHOR

2019-10-29T08:03:19+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Fair points. For me, it was Tupou way out in front for this season. Maumalo and Fergo were pretty close. Sivo has the most upside of all of them but is still very, very raw and I don’t think is as good as the other three for now...

AUTHOR

2019-10-29T06:45:30+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I don’t want to get a cranky old man offside I rate Whitehead but I just wouldn’t have him ahead of any of those second rowers mentioned. He probably doesn’t miss by much and I’d be more than happy with him playing for my side...

2019-10-29T06:28:21+00:00

crankyoldman

Roar Rookie


Maybe it is just me, but I can't believe that Elliott Whitehead doesn't come into calculations. Down the bottom you mention three possibles sides and he still didn't get a mention.

2019-10-29T05:49:42+00:00

Bunney

Roar Rookie


Good team TB. Shocked Shaun Lane didn't get an honourable mention though...!! :laughing:

2019-10-29T05:09:56+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I hope the direction of the games changes Barry, so these positions can revert to something like what they used to be when the ETs, Meninga's, etc were such a force in the game. I still remember that great Parra backline of Sterling, Kenny, Steve Ella, Cronin, Groethe. Nowadays it's Tedesco, Keary, Cronk & Verrills.

2019-10-29T03:56:47+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


All good conversation, but I find it really hard to leave out the wingers who took their club from spoon to finals..Sivo, nobody has run thru walls like him on the wing since the Guru . And how’s Fergo as mad now as he’s ever been but never leaves nothing in the tank..wouldn’t think of stepping over him to get to Maumalo or Toops, best season sure, but different class..

2019-10-29T02:27:39+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Huge fan of ma'u can't believe his heading to England, surely the eels should have resigned him.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar