My top 10 AFL finals of the decade

By Donal Wilson / Roar Rookie

There have been some very memorable finals over this decade, so I’ve decided to make a list of my top ten finals – just a quick note, this is from a neutral point of view as I support the Brisbane Lions who only played two finals this decade.

10. 2011 Semi-final – West Coast Eagles versus Carlton
A high scoring shootout which was played at a frantic pace throughout the whole game. With goals coming in bursts, West Coast’s accuracy in the first half was telling – converting eight goals straight in the second quarter.

The Eagles extended their lead to 21 points midway through the last quarter before – in keeping with the pattern of the game – Carlton rattled on three quick goals to set up a grandstand finish in which West Coast prevailed.

9. 2017 Elimination final – Port Adelaide versus West Coast
An epic elimination final that was won by a goal after the extra time siren from West Coast’s Luke Shuey. Eric Mackenzie saved the game for the Eagles during normal time – with scores level and time ticking down, the ball was heading through for a crucial Port Adelaide behind.

Mackenzie had the presence of mind to crash into the post with the ball going out of bounds and resulting in a throw in, setting up the opportunity for Shuey to be the hero.

(AAP Image/David Mariuz)

8. 2012 Preliminary final – Hawthorn versus Adelaide
Hawthorn came into this game as massive favourites to progress through to the grand final. Despite the Hawks’ six goal third quarter putting them 16 points up at the final change, Adelaide stormed back into the game – taking the lead through sub Graham Johncock.

Immediately, Shaun Burgoyne put himself in at the center bounce and won the all important clearance before kicking the ball deep forward where Cyril Rioli marked and put Hawthorn back in front. The Hawks were going to the grand final.

7. 2013 Elimination final – Carlton versus Richmond
Richmond were finally back in September action in front of 94,000 – and they were up against arch nemesis Carlton in unforeseen circumstances. The Tigers were dominating proceedings early on – getting as much as 32 points in front during the start of the third quarter – but a Chris Judd inspired second half performance led Carlton to a miracle comeback which was capped off when Judd himself scored the sealer in the last quarter.

6. 2011 Preliminary final – Collingwood versus Hawthorn
This was a tense contest between two fierce teams. Collingwood went into the last quarter trailing by 17 points, but moments of individual brilliance across the ground made for a remarkable comeback. Deep into the last quarter Lance Franklin pushed off Chris Tarrant, gathered the ball running towards the boundary line and dribbled a goal through. However, Luke Ball bobbed up minutes later kicking the winning goal for the Magpies.

5. 2013 Preliminary final – Hawthorn versus Geelong
An epic game between two great teams had a fitting finish. Hawthorn stormed back from a three quarter time 20-point deficient thanks to the ever reliable big game player Shaun Burgoyne putting the Hawks back in front.

They went onto break on the Kennett’s curse, beating Geelong for the first time since 2008 grand final.

4. 2012 Grand final – Hawthorn versus Sydney
This was a grand final of vast momentum swings in an epic encounter. Hawthorn had the momentum to begin, with ending the first quarter with a flurry of goals. Sydney then stole the momentum back and ran with it, piling on eight goals in a row.

Hawthorn were on the ropes before the momentum swung again – with the Hawks kicking another five unanswered goals. But in the end, Hawthorn’s inaccuracy cost them dearly in the last quarter as Sydney recorded a memorable win.

3. 2010 Grand final – Collingwood versus St. Kilda
The last drawn grand final we’ll ever see, it was a phenomenal spectacle both teams giving their all. Opposing captains Nick Maxwell and Nick Riewoldt lead the way for their respective teams and Saints duo Lenny Hayes and Brendan Goddard were instrumental in getting St. Kilda back into the game. It was one of those games where there didn’t deserve to be a winner and a loser.

2. 2016 Preliminary final – Greater Western Sydney versus Western Bulldogs
It was the new up against the old in one of the toughest fought games ever played. Yet another game of incredible moments with lots of goals to be celebrated – plus injuries to both Callan Ward and Jordan Roughead were big loses for both sides. The Bulldogs scored a team-lifting goal just prior to three quarter time thanks to the crashing and bashing of tough nut Caleb Daniel.

Whilst others were tiring, Jason Johannisen was running all over the ground – even setting up a goal to Marcus Bontempelli which put the Bulldogs in front. The Giants hit right back to make scores level again, but Tom Liberatore saw Jack Macrae out the back of a pack and hit him on the chest – and Macrae made no mistake in converting. The Western Bulldogs had broken the drought of losing preliminary finals in one of the best ways ever.

(AAP Image/Craig Golding)

1. 2018 Grand final – Collingwood versus West Coast
This was truly a grand final that had it all. Collingwood raced out of the blocks kicking the first five goals, but West Coast restored the margin at quarter time – somewhat fortunately as Willie Rioli scored a goal with the back of his heel. The Eagles then came out more aggressive in the second quarter with Liam Ryan landing a big bump on Brayden Maynard.

With scores level at the last break a rush of goals came from the likes Jordan de Goey and big American Mason Cox to put the Magpies 11 points in front. Despite West Coast pushing, they just couldn’t find that goal to take the lead back.

With two minutes left, Jeremy McGovern left his opponent to take a big mark. He immediately played on, kicking lace out to Vardy, who kicked high to half forward were ‘Flyin Ryan’ soared and took a spectacular grab. He played on quickly to find Dom Sheed right up against the boundary – and with under two minutes left, they had to take this chance. Sheed delivered the perfect drop punt right through the middle to seal a memorable premiership for West Coast.

The Crowd Says:

2020-01-22T02:49:37+00:00

Gerard Klomp

Guest


Who remembers the 2007 Final Eagles vs Collingwood. With 2 extra 15 minutes at the end of the game. it was amazing game. It was a petty that the Cold pies won the game but is was a great game. I was there. it was the last game Juddy ever played for the eagles as well.

2019-12-26T06:50:47+00:00

Mark.

Roar Rookie


Think you might be a bit biased there and I the same as Dogs were the noted prelim chokers while I’ve seen my Swans lose 4 GFs. Rather go out in the penultimate round.

2019-12-24T10:47:46+00:00

Fairsuckofthesav

Roar Rookie


The prelim Hawks Crows should also be remembered for the mistake riddled umpiring that favoured the home team 23 to 11 free kicks. The umpiring fraternity even apologised to the Crows but the damage was done.

2019-12-23T12:16:17+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


not much to disagree with here

2019-12-22T10:05:04+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Jeez he is just married with his first child.

2019-12-22T10:00:38+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


I and say from experience the in Geelong beating hurt. I never want play a Geelong ground final again.

2019-12-22T09:28:07+00:00

Lukey Miller

Guest


....as for the Freo Dorks best big finals - ahhh, not many. Beating the Cats in Geelong was about it, but then they should have beaten Hawks in the GF only they choked very badly. With the many big finals for West Coast, including 6 Grand Finals and 4 premierships, you would expect a few sad ones, but overall it has been a ripping ride. The 2018 GF must have been real a hoot for you. How do the Dorks compare to all that then?

2019-12-19T06:12:11+00:00

6x6 perkele

Roar Rookie


Yeah the two bye weeks we had weren't that great.

2019-12-19T05:18:53+00:00

Jonathon Nobleman

Guest


A great read, nice work

2019-12-19T05:14:43+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Two unfortunate events, then?

2019-12-19T02:33:21+00:00

John Noble

Guest


A lovely read ????

2019-12-19T00:58:14+00:00

6x6 perkele

Roar Rookie


Wce still crack a mention in the best month of your life so I won't complain, I got married again in September 2018 so my wce month is way better mate

2019-12-18T23:18:24+00:00

WCE

Roar Rookie


What Eric Mackenzie did in the 2017 final against port will go down in folklore. Any "normal" player would have rushed the ball through the points to gain possession, however, that would have meant port would have won because the siren blew not long after. His courageous effort and intelligent thinking made the game a cracker of a final with extra time on , then boots kicked the wining goal after the siren to win the game. The 2011 final against the blues at Subi oval was as exciting as ever, from memory the last quarter went for something like 35 or 36 minutes with the Eagles wining by 2 or 3 points and probably the loudest Subi crowd until the final against the Hawks in 2015 at Subi

2019-12-18T22:20:01+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


Oh yeah, I forgot about the Eagles final as well. That was fun to watch, yes.

2019-12-18T22:13:38+00:00

IAP

Guest


The Hawks semi was good, but giving the hapless Weagles and absolute flogging on their home ground was even better; they couldn't even blame the travel or VFL bias for that drubbing; just cry silently into their midstrength beers as it dawned on them that the world doesn't revolve around their team. It was beautiful to watch the silence from the crowd. That was probably the best month of my life.

2019-12-18T22:03:20+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


North over Essendon 2014 was a goodie. Down by 27 at 1/2 time.

2019-12-18T21:18:01+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


Nice piece. From a personal experience, the Port v Weagles semi final in '17 was among the best - purely because I was blogging it on here. So much intensity, so much pressure. Was awesome. But as a fan, I'd join the bandwagon here and say that Bulldogs v Giants final was superb. But, whilst the Bulldogs v Hawks semi final the week before wasn't as close, but that was one where I knew the Doggies were a real deal - eliminating the heavily favoured Hawks. Both of them are special finals in my mind.

2019-12-18T20:28:51+00:00

IAP

Guest


As Dogs supporter that was the most tense game of footy I've ever watched. It was drama from the opening bounce. I was more relaxed for the grand final. I think Prelims just about always produce the best games - they have the most to lose so they turn into a frenzy. Losing a prelim always feels worse than losing a grand final.

2019-12-18T17:41:48+00:00

Cracka

Roar Rookie


GWS Vs Bulldogs for me as #1 final very exciting as a neutral supporter. They the bulldogs played very exciting footy throughout the year which the Tigers have managed to reproduce in 2017 and 2019, Bevo should get more credit for the game plan he produced.

Read more at The Roar