The sports media must promote inclusivity

By Mary Konstantopoulos / Expert

It’s rare I choose to tune into Q+A on the ABC, but with a topic like the future of sport, this week was hard to miss.

On this week’s show there were panellists from a variety of sports covering the spectrum of sport, from players and administrators to journalists. One of the panellists was Andrew Abdo, acting CEO at the NRL.

Given global events at the moment, where thousands of people have taken to the streets to reinforce the message that black lives matter, it came as no surprise to me that one of the first questions asked of Abdo and also of Brendon Gale (CEO of the Richmond Tigers) was at what point do our major sporting codes see themselves as active participants in the structural racism that exists in this country, and take accountability and even lead us in the dismantling processes we need.

Not satisfied with the initial response from the panel, this question was followed up with a very passionate question from another member of the audience about how the NRL can police the media, in particular, when the media zeroes in on a particular player in what can seem like a relentless attack.

The question I want to ask is when is the media going to stand up and take responsibility for the role that they play in this?

(Kelly Defina/Getty Images)

The NRL can only do so much and the media is complicit and responsible for much of the narrative that the wider public consumes.

For the NRL, one of its key values is inclusivity and reinforcing to all Australians that no matter who you are, no matter your race, gender, sexual orientation, age or ability, that there is a place for you in the rugby league family.

The way the NRL demonstrates its commitment to inclusivity, particularly of our Indigenous players, is an example of leadership in sport in this country.

Take the comments made by the NRL in the last year in relation to the national anthem and supporting those players who made a decision not to sing the anthem at the State of Origin last year.

Additionally, the NRL regularly consults our Indigenous players and the role of the Australian Rugby League Indigenous Council is an important one.

This group played a key role in facilitating conversation earlier this year when a decision was made by the Australian Rugby League Commission to not play the Australian national anthem at the Indigenous All Stars game.

(Photo by Ashley Feder/Getty Images)

The majority of our fans are for inclusivity too.

There are racist people in this country. We see it in comments on social media, we hear it on our streets and we hear it in our stadiums.

However, on countless occasions when racist commentary has been heard in our stadiums, other members of the crowd have stood up and said this is not okay.

I recall an incident involving Greg Inglis at Panthers Stadium several years ago. The two men found to be at the centre of the incident were banned indefinitely from attending NRL games.

Can we do more? Absolutely.

Is the NRL open to listening, collaborating and continuing to work with our Indigenous players to ensure they continued to feel included and welcome in our game? I believe the answer is yes.

However, the media also play a role in this and inform how fans perceive the game.

It isn’t just a rugby league issue.

I find it staggering that until recently, a man like Alan Jones was one of the most powerful voices Aussies heard in the media. He has a history of making distasteful comments.

(AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts)

Yet the response from Jones, when called out on it, is a half-hearted apology from which he is always allowed to move on.

He is not the only person in the media that contributed to the state of affairs.

Last week, Channel Nine announced that Sam Newman was returning to the Sunday Footy Show with his own segment. How can we make progress when men like this are in positions of authority?

Rugby league is not immune from this.

Last year, the decision by several Indigenous players not to sing the national anthem was nation-wide news. Players have not been singing the anthem for decades, but this issue came to the fore when a journalist noticed that some players were not singing in Game 1 and asked why?

I have no problem with this. It gave us all an opportunity to listen and understand and perhaps learn something about why our national anthem does not speak to all who live in this country.

The players did not bring it up. They did not make a big deal about it. They did so silently and respectfully.

Yet in the weeks that followed, I saw countless articles accusing these players of being prima donnas who didn’t respect this country.

Similarly, earlier this year when the NRL made a decision to feature Latrell Mitchell in the ad for the new season, somehow Mitchell standing in the ocean draped in an Aboriginal flag was divisive and political.

Latrell Mitchell (left) and Souths teammate Cody Walker attend a rally on January 26 this year. (Photo by Don Arnold/Getty Images)

Mitchell has been one of the most reported-on players in the media this year.

The media seem obsessed with his contract negotiations, his weight on return to pre-season and his learning of the fullback position. Is this simply coincidence?

Our sports are leaders and can be powerful agents of change.

However, the media in this country certainly has a role to play.

We need to demand better of our media agencies and question why some are given a greater platform than others, particularly when those people seem at odds with the values like inclusivity, which so many of our sports hold so dear.

The Crowd Says:

2020-06-22T07:21:23+00:00

Placepunter

Roar Rookie


Let me get my head around this............When an NRL player signs a contract is he expected to honour the contract? It sounds like DCE signed a contract and didn't honour it. He is an NRL player and therefore does or doesn't need to honour his contract? Now, as far as Latrell wanting to test his value in the marketplace, it wasn't that he just wanted more money, it was his desire to play fullback and not centre..............I take it that fullbacks and centres get the same money.

2020-06-20T11:29:32+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Keep politics out of sport. Rugby league has been inclusive since the 80s and absolutely nothing has changed. No point in ramming the idea down people’s throats for rainbows and unicorns

2020-06-19T12:39:38+00:00

Spiro Zavos

Guest


Mary, Rugby Australia's Code of Conduct for players specifically guaranteed the right of players to express their religious beliefs. In my opinion, this is why Israel Folau won his case against Rugby Australia and why he was paid several millions of dollars in compensation and he and his wife were given an apology by Rugby Australia. You are a lawyer. Just because the Code of Conduct is used as a pretext to censor a player for saying something that, say, a sponsor might not like, it does not follow that the Code of Conduct has been violated. I also think it is a stretch to equate saying that certain behaviour could result in a person going to hell as being the equivalent of anti-Semitism. The irony here is that Folau was exposed to the most virulent anti-Christianity rhetoric that equated with the sort of anti-Semitism that you find unacceptable. Folau was actually used by Rugby Australia to promote the Bingham Cup, the international gay rugby tournament where he was praised by Sydney's gay media for his (successful) efforts to promote the tournament. In all the controversy, Folau never smeared a single person. He promoted the Bingham Cup tournament, hardly the behaviour of a 'homophobe.' Yet he was mercilessly smeared as a homophobe - see the email below - by Rugby Australia, the rugby media and activists. Real diversity means diversity of opinion being allowed, something that was denied to Folau.

2020-06-19T08:15:43+00:00

The Set Peace

Roar Rookie


I agree with Spiros Mary, Australia should have allowed that outright homophobe to play so they didn’t have any excuses when we flogged the Wallabies.

2020-06-19T07:00:12+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Not really because in Mitchell’s case it was the club that wanted him to leave.

2020-06-19T06:42:08+00:00

elvis

Roar Rookie


I always feel somewhat dirty after reading his columns.

2020-06-19T04:48:28+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


If Bolt came back in that condition and killed it, his weight and ability would still be part of the story. Had Mitchell floated into Souths FB role and was devastating it would be the same narative as Bolt but he didn't. I can see your busy on the AFL thread. Good piece btw.

AUTHOR

2020-06-19T03:58:24+00:00

Mary Konstantopoulos

Expert


Every single player has political beliefs of some kind. Every single one.

AUTHOR

2020-06-19T03:56:14+00:00

Mary Konstantopoulos

Expert


No I don't think so - there are limits to all our freedoms. Just like I don't expect organisations or sports to tolerate people who make anti-Semitic comments. Additionally, Folau was not sacked for his 'belief in Christianity', he was sacked for breach of contract. There are many men and women of Christian faith in the rugby community - none of them have been sacked for their Christian beliefs.

2020-06-19T03:07:06+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


I'm sure the comments here will be gracious, constructive and full of reasoned, civilised debate. Oh...

2020-06-19T01:40:28+00:00

Spiro Zavos

Guest


Mary, You supported Rugby Australia sacking Israel Folau over the public expression of his Christian beliefs. Where was the 'inclusivity' in your condemnation of Folau, a Pasifika Christian. Shouldn't real 'inclusivity' allow for the expression of an opinion or a belief that some of us might not agree with? Just saying.

2020-06-19T00:58:37+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


She hasn't dared share any messages of inequality that you don't want to hear so you are fine with that.

2020-06-19T00:53:38+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


And we should only care if it impacts performance. If Bolt came back 3-4 kgs heavier, but still ran 9.8 then no one would batter an eyelid. Jordan comes back and still pots 40...no one would care. Mitchell wasn't the only one who came back overweight btw.

2020-06-19T00:50:08+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


Mate, he came back at 108kg. His playing weight 102kg. This isn't his first run around so it was noticable. Bennett even commented that "his fitness isn't where it needed to be". Hayne got hammered for the same thing. If Bolt, RAFA or Jordan showed up to their events 6kg heavier the sporting world would notice because they are athletes.

2020-06-19T00:49:42+00:00

Herewegoagain

Guest


Winning gold medals ? Yes I’m fine with that . Cathy Freeman was idolised as a result, but you don’t want to hear a story like that . You really are beyond stoopid.

2020-06-19T00:45:02+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


He makes sense to himself. Apparently he thinks someone who is 100% PI heritage is a white supremacist or something.

2020-06-19T00:27:35+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


You and I have a very different view then - but I respect that. I don't think they are asking anyone to follow their political views, they are theirs alone. The Anthem thing, a reporter asks Walker if he was going to sing, he said no and explained his reasons. Wthin those reasons he specifically said these were his views alone. Surely we can respect his opinion without following it yourself? As for the club, IMO, there is no player bigger than the club. The players who fill those jerseys come and go. Some you'll like but not others but they should be judged by the effort on the park, that's why they came to the club.

2020-06-19T00:26:24+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


"Hey, I'm a PI so I can't be racist".

2020-06-19T00:14:20+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


No. If they presented a good, convincing argument I would listen. If they presented a weak argument, I would criticise it. Then you would have your usual self righteous little tantrum. By the way, what are 'my views' on the topic, as you claim to know them? And how did Mary 'challenge them?'

2020-06-18T23:45:12+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Exactly as I said above. You’re fine with indigenous people if they “know their place and don’t speak up about their experiences.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar