Perfect timing: The round that has Super Rugby AU at sixes and sevens

By Brett McKay / Expert

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote of Round 3 being the weekend that made Super Rugby AU, the round in which Queensland and the Western Force played out a belter on the Friday night, and New South Wales and the Brumbies followed up with a one-point thriller on the Saturday night.

It was probably the weekend where the penny dropped in some ways; where if worse comes to worst around the trans-Tasman talks and Australian rugby does need to continue down this same domestic route for 2021, the quality of the rugby being served up is actually pretty bloody good.

And it’s only got better since.

So it was oh, so appropriate that the weekend just gone – Round 6 – was the one that turned the competition on its head. Everything we thought we knew has to be questioned going into this weekend coming’s Round 7, and the competition’s remaining rounds are now in a complete state of flux.

Everyone’s tipping took a hit, but the competition itself is the big winner.

For one thing, we now definitely have four teams eyeing off the three playoff spots, and you don’t have to go back too far at all to recall a time when it was more about which order were the Brumbies, Reds, and Rebels were going to finish in.

The Waratahs’ handsome win over Queensland at the SCG dropped the Reds from second to fourth in forty minutes of first half destruction that I’m not sure even family and friends saw coming. And now, the Waratahs, Reds, and Rebels are separated by just three points.

The Western Force aren’t entirely out of the equation, but their objective is pretty simple. The only team with four games to play, the Force would need to beat all four teams to get to at least 18 points, and then rely on two of the Reds, Waratahs, and Rebels directly above them on the table winning only one of their remaining three games.

Can the Force turn things around? (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

A loss this weekend to the Waratahs up on the Gold Coast would just about consign their finals aspirations to the too hard basket.

The Waratahs’ big win jolted them ahead of the Reds ahead up to third on the table on for-and-against, and will undoubtedly be eyeing off more table movement over their remaining games, starting with the Force on Friday night.

After that, the Tahs face the Brumbies in Canberra in Round 8, and the Rebels at a venue yet to be determined, but likely to be in Sydney again. They have a bye in Round 10, and will have to sit back and watch final round games to know whether or not they’ll be required for the second versus third playoff.

But as impressive as their win was over Queensland, it almost feels like it has glossed over the magnitude of their comeback, having been totally outclassed by the Rebels at the SCG a fortnight ago.

Going down 29-10, and being held scoreless by the Rebels for the last 58 minutes, there was a real concern in the aftermath just how the Waratahs were going to find points, never mind challenge the three teams above them.

A bye week and a red-hot first half put paid to all that, and all the very valid questions that existed about creating opportunities without front-foot ball have for this week at least been shifted north of the Tweed River. I don’t think we can overstate the confidence boost that comes with a win like that one on Saturday night.

Two wins out of their next three would get NSW to at least 19 points, but any bonus points accumulated along the way will come in very handy.

That same equation applies to Queensland, who host the fired-up Rebels this weekend followed by the Force on the Gold Coast next weekend. They have a bye Round 9, before facing the Brumbies in the final round before the playoffs.

The Reds’ biggest question remains around their set piece, and specifically their lineout throwing, where in recent games they’ve shelled five of their own throws against the Waratahs, and another five against the Brumbies. As good as they might be around the breakdown, no-one can be affording to give up that kind of ball at set piece.

A win over the Reds this weekend would push the Rebels to at least 18 points and could well put a toe in the playoffs door, though if this last weekend taught us anything, it’s that there’s plenty of life in Super Rugby AU yet.

No doubt, Dave Wessels will give plenty of thought around keeping Matt To’omua at inside centre – To’omua himself conceded that might happen, such was Andrew Deegan’s game at 10 – but the Reds’ biggest challenge is going to be containing Matt Phillip, who was outstanding in the Rebels demolition of the Brumbies pack.

The Brumbies themselves have probably gone into a bye week at precisely the right time, and will be hoping they can turn their form around in a similar fashion the week after the next.

The Brumbies in good times. (Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)

They’ve got a big question on their hands ahead of their next game, against the Waratahs in Round 8: with Noah Lolesio still likely another month away, what can they do find some spark in their attack again?

Bayley Kuenzle found the going tough behind a well-beaten pack last week, and there was an evident disconnection with the midfielders in attack. But with Lolesio out, the only other option to Kuenzle would be to start Mack Hansen. And the Brumbies don’t strike me as a team to make knee-jerk reactions after a loss.

The bye this week will probably help this. And so will a bit of remedial tactical kicking work over the next week or so, because this was arguably the Brumbies biggest failing on a wet night at Leichhardt Oval. While the Rebels were hell-bent on pinning the Brumbies back in their 22, the Brumbies kept putting up poorly placed kicks in midfield that weren’t chased particularly well either.

It all produced a set of results that no-one tipped but everyone enjoyed, simply because of what it’s done for the competition going into the last four rounds.

What originally looked reasonably obvious suddenly looks anything but. And that’s not a bad thing at all.

The Crowd Says:

2020-08-13T11:34:04+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


Get the swabs ready Jacko Tahs very rarely back up a good performance

2020-08-12T08:37:21+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


In the Aotearoa competition teams can fly in on the day, play the game and fly back to their base. They do not have to live in hotels and are not on tour. Kitch Christie, the only Bok coach with a 100% win record, stated in his book that he believed that part of his success as coach was not to disrupt family life, let the players sleep in their beds, eat breakfast at home and even fly to the game in the morning of the game. What I want to achieve is to illustrate how much harder it is for teams that are on tour to win against those that play at home especially if you play every single game on tour. Once people have an appreciation of the how the odds are stacked against touring teams they will not put weight on results of such an uneven and unfair competition. Rugby Australia could have even up the odds a little by setting up a better draw however decided to use the draw to make it even worst.

2020-08-12T08:21:10+00:00

Ex force fan

Guest


There is not many statistics to estimate what the impact is to be away from home for such a long period, eating hotel food, sleeping in hotel beds with team mates away from your family. I would imagine it wouldn't get easier the longer it gets.

2020-08-11T21:26:20+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Yeah... heard about this late last night, buddy. Fingers crossed!

2020-08-11T19:46:25+00:00

moaman

Roar Guru


Sad news from here last night Chook. A family of four has been identified as having coronavirus in the Auckland community.First cases for 102 days. Auckland will go into partial and temporary (3 days) lockdown as of midday today. Doesn't augur well for proposed events later in he year. :shocked:

2020-08-11T12:54:08+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Yeah given how HJH is going at TH, he’d have to be ok at LH. Slipper, Sio, JP Smith, HJH, Bell.

2020-08-11T10:54:26+00:00

Adsa

Roar Rookie


No Chook, I was more shocked than rapt with the Tahs performance.

2020-08-11T10:38:19+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


You might take notice of the Golf. They don’t win or make the cut every week . Last week is irrelevant.

AUTHOR

2020-08-11T10:31:28+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Except that that's not how 2020 has played out. Up to the suspension of Super Rugby, the home/away split was 26/20. In nine rounds of Aotearoa, it's 10/8. In AU, it's 7/4 (1 draw), and only one of those four - the Rebels beating the Force at Leichhardt - doesn't fit the 'true' meaning of an away win, in that both the Force and Rebels are on tour. But you've been banging on about this for six rounds, so I can't imagine this will stop you. I don't really see what you're trying to achieve, if I'm honest..

2020-08-11T09:26:59+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Okay Brett I take back all those mean, snide and cynical comments I've made about Ned over the years.... :laughing:

2020-08-11T09:24:48+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


If your from Melbourne, what could be more wonderful than hanging out in Sydney for a couple of weeks in the depth of winter and bonus than Sydney has had some wet weather come game time!

2020-08-11T09:20:29+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


I think you're right Rob C, this may be the best Rebels forward pack in a while,. Orr, Hosea, Philip, Kemeny, & Niasarani are a good core group, good to see Brad Wilkin get a run too....

2020-08-11T09:13:02+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


I was desperate to reactive my Kayo subscription, three months of watching classic matches does that to oneself! :laughing:

2020-08-11T09:07:07+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Hey James, you may have hit the nail on the head. If most of the old guard us gone, then there are less older guys to get to complacency vibe from. I've been impressed with several players as they've improved since the start of SR. A forward pack that was on roller skates 6 months ago was excellent against a strong Reds scrum. HJH is now a decent enough tight head to get a place in a Wallaby squad, Staniforth, Gordon and Dempsey (even Ned!) played with confidence and enthusiasm. Do you know what Karmichael Hunt is doing next year? I gather the Tahs have recruited Kyle Godwin to replace him but have no idea about Hunt's plans.

2020-08-11T08:44:10+00:00

Phantom

Roar Rookie


Wait til next game.

2020-08-11T08:38:30+00:00

moaman

Roar Guru


Brett/Jez I thought the gremlins had taken that post--which I was glad about upon reflection because I started coming up with a few of those myself!!! Ha! :laughing:

2020-08-11T08:37:50+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


That’s on the basis of being home then away and disruption in routine. This isn’t the case for teams permanently on the road

2020-08-11T08:33:30+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


He was really good vs the Brumbies too I thought

2020-08-11T08:31:25+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


I was just having a bit of fun with you mate haha!

2020-08-11T08:28:26+00:00

Pinetree

Roar Rookie


I thought you were asking for the Brumbies/Rebels record for all time, but on 2nd take, I think you were just being facetious :laughing:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar