The 2020 NRL premiers? It's the Panthers, dummy

By Tim Gore / Expert

Any way you look at it, the Penrith Panthers are streaks ahead of the pack and only bad luck can stop them from claiming their first title since 2003.

This is a bizarre season.

While our beloved leader Peter V’landys has managed to keep the NRL rolling unbelievably well through his sheer force of will, COVID-19 has still wreaked havoc.

To keep the competition rolling:
• Two sides have had to relocate – and bless you Storm and Warriors for doing that, every one of us appreciates it so much (PS Cam Smith, this does not mean that we like you)
• All the sides have had to go into ‘bubbles’ to remain COVID free
• The crowds have been limited, if not disproportionately noisy
• The draw was redone and redistributed most of the free to air games back to the usual suspects
• We’ve gone back to one referee – and no one really seems to mind

In spite of all of this there is little talk of this season’s eventual champion having an asterisk placed next to them, signifying that lifting the Provan-Summons Trophy was somehow devalued in 2020.

It is the opposite.

The team that wins this year will have faced down greater adversity than usual to do so. With all the upheaval going on, any side that can keep going with consistently good results is doing an amazing job.

Only one team this year can be said to really have achieved that end: the Panthers.

Yes – guilty – I am an unabashed Ivan Cleary fan and have been for some time. Whether it was in his first iteration with the Panthers or his stint with the Wests Tigers, I really love the cut of his jib.

After their tenth place finish in 2019 a lot of people were openly questioning Cleary’s credentials. But they shouldn’t have been. In his first season back at Penrith his team had seemingly underachieved.

However, it wasn’t yet Ivan’s team.

Between September 2019 and March 2020, Cleary made changes that have meant that all those in his squad wanted to be on his ‘bus’. Like the Storm players do with Craig Bellamy, the Roosters squad with Trent Robinson and the Raiders boys with Ricky Stuart, all the Panther players have fallen completely into line with Ivan’s way.

Since his arrival, Waqa Blake, Reagan Campbell-Gillard, Dallin Watene-Zelezniak and James Maloney have departed. While Cleary made a number of great pick-ups in Zane Tetevano, Api Koroisau and Kurt Capewell, what he has really done is made the team perform as a very well drilled, focused and disciplined unit.

Last weekend they despatched the Wests Tigers 30-6. However, the Campbelltown team did not capitulate – they fought hard. Penrith were just far too good.

In attack – where they are the second-best in the NRL, averaging 26 points a game – and in defence, where they are also the second-best, letting in an average of just 13 points a game.

Against the Tigers, they were without Villiame Kikau and Api Koroisau and their machine rolled on mercilessly.

There are stars all across the field.

Dylan Edwards is playing his best ever football at the back. The wings have evergreen Josh Mansour back in top form, with the likes of Charlie Staines, Brian To’o and Brent Naden also executing superbly.

Young Stephen Crichton in the centres is an absolute revelation in attack but also solid as anything in defence. A future representative player for sure.

The combination of Nathan Cleary and Jerome Luai has a combined 29 try assists and 30 line break assists between them – easily the most dangerous halves partnership in the NRL.

(Photo by Mark Evans/Getty Images)

Then there is the pack. We already knew James Fisher-Harris was a machine. And Isaah Yeo is no longer seen as a squad player by anyone. His attack and defence has been stellar. More and more his ball playing is proving deadly.

Kikau is a monster in attack and James Tamou has wound back the clock to put in his best games since 2015. Koroisau has proven an astute buy too, giving superb direction around the ruck.

And where exactly did Liam Martin come from? He is proving a massive handful for all opponents.

The Panthers will win the minor premiership in a canter. Already three points clear, they now meet the Broncos, Eels, Cowboys and Bulldogs.

The Brisbane and North Queensland games will be the first time apart from their Round 14 game against the Warriors that the Panthers will leave Sydney.

Unlike the Warriors, Raiders and Storm (along with the Queensland teams) who have had to endure masses of travel, Penrith have not had to endure such disruptions.

But they are far from flat-track bullies. Of their 16 games this season, eight of them have been against other top-eight sides. They have a record of six wins, one draw and the single 16-10 loss to the Eels in Round 5. Their average score against those opponents is 26-15, only slightly worse in defence from their overall for and against.

They are currently on a run of 11 straight wins. Should they complete the season undefeated it will see them with 18 straight wins, just behind the 19 straight of the legendary 1975 Eastern Suburbs Roosters.

However, you can bet the coach will be smacking down any such talk. He knows just how quickly things can change.

But who can possibly beat them? There are really only five options, as the Knights and Sharks just don’t have enough.

Obviously Melbourne are a great chance. In second spot, they keep replacing their injured players with players who are up for the task. However, the injuries keep coming.

Already without Kenny Bromwich, Nelson Asofa-Solomona, Brandon Smith, Suliasi Vunivalu, Dale Finucane, Tui Kamikamica and Paul Momirovski, they’ve now lost Marion Seve for the season. And they are based on the Sunshine Coast. But if any side can overcome those issues it is the Storm.

Parramatta have enjoyed a similar lack of travel to their wester Sydney neighbours and are the only top-eight side to have beaten Penrith this year. However, their recent form – especially the flogging at the hands of the Rabbitohs – sees them unlikely to challenge.

The Roosters have had injuries coming out their ears. Boyd Cordner, Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Luke Keary have had – or are having – stints on the sidelines. The loss of Sam Verrills and Victor Radley have been extremely costly. However, they will surely be a side that will take it right up to the Chocolate Soldiers, given the chance.

The Raiders’ attack just hasn’t clicked into gear and while their defence has been pretty good, they’ve had some poor patches – such as their first half against the Panthers. While they could give Penrith some issues, without talisman hooker Josh Hodgson it is hard to see that happening.

Souths losing Latrell Mitchell will really hurt what was looking like a really good charge to the finals. Without his x-factor they may not have the firepower required.

So really when you look at it, the 2020 NRL premiership is the Penrith Panthers’ for the taking and only serious misfortune will stop that coming true.

The Crowd Says:

2020-09-03T08:18:20+00:00

Lloyd

Guest


Tim, I can’t agree. There will be somewhat of an asterisk next to the Panthers’ name should they win the premiership. To date, they’ve left Greater Sydney for a match once this season. Let that sink in: once (twice if you include the commute to Gosford). On the run home, they travel to Brisbane (tonight) and Townsville - hardly daunting road trips given the Panthers are flying high and those Queensland clubs are in a massive rut. No premiership winning team in the NRL has had a leg up this size. Conversely, teams like the Raiders, Storm and Warriors have faced adversity the likes of Penrith, the Roosters and Parramatta cannot fathom. From rounds 2-9, the Raiders spent a minimum 6 hours in transit to and from games (even if they were home games!). The Warriors... well, everyone knows what they’ve sacrificed. And the Storm have completely relocated (not to mention made a handful of trips to Sydney and beyond earlier in the season).

2020-09-03T00:04:17+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


The immediate situation is obviously escalated to a far more serious situation than in Australia. But compare Doc Rivers to Ivan Cleary who basically dismissed what happened to Naden and just said "he'll be right", and it is chalk and cheese.

2020-09-01T22:08:50+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


I used to be an Ivan fan until he questioned the refs integrity against the Raiders a few rounds ago, why? cause we kept his panthers try-less in the second half. He also questioned refs at halftime last season against the Raiders cause his "pass to kikau" gameplan wasn't working. Then there's the mess he left the Tigers in...

2020-09-01T21:52:15+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Panthers will won the MP and deservedly so after an outstanding season. My concerns are whether or not they can sustain this form for the next couple of months which I highly doubt. Secondly, if Cleary goes down, so do the Panthers, similar to Manly when they lost Turbo. Having said that it's great to see a side that isn't Melbourne or the Roosters dominate and they have some fantastic young players in their team

2020-09-01T21:08:45+00:00

Landcruiser79

Guest


Cmon , what about the disadvantage the Roosters are at ? Every time they take the field they know that, all but there own fans every single NRL fan is willing them to lose . And even if there are massive injustices throughout the game that go against them , somehow people are able to justify them. Oh the pain !

2020-09-01T14:08:45+00:00

Pomoz

Roar Rookie


The five day turnaround has no impact. It has been proven to be statistically insignificant as to whether you win or lose. Have a look at this analysis https://rugbyleagueeyetest.wordpress.com/2020/07/28/round-11-notes-and-trends/

2020-09-01T11:53:46+00:00

Bob

Guest


I much prefer the way ivan has handled it then coaches and athletes in the US as you say. Would u like them to refuse to play?

2020-09-01T09:15:46+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


What team do you go for Freddie? Let me guess...Sou ffs. FYI, Robbo has only made 1 complaint against a ref in the 7 years he's been at Easts. That was against Ben Cummins after an Anzac game in 2015 I think. That's not too bad, considering Easts lose the penalty count and the 6 agains virtually every game.

2020-09-01T08:44:37+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


At least you're honest Tim. :happy:

2020-09-01T08:40:37+00:00

Freddie

Guest


Panthers - take note of 2019 MP. Melbourne bundled out in 2 weeks. Bring it on!!

2020-09-01T08:31:13+00:00

Freddie

Guest


Robinson/Politis - one and the same. Both sooks one mouthpiece. Just wait. If the Roosters ever get done over by crap ref decisions......it'd be whinge on. But that won't happen. Never happen. And why?? 'Nuff said.

2020-09-01T08:23:08+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


I don't think the average between games stat matters that much, only the number of 5 day turnarounds as that increases the likelihood of a loss due to tiredness. The difference between the average would be when they played their first round game i.e. if they played on the Thursday or the Sunday. They'll all pretty much play the same number of games over the same number of weeks.

2020-09-01T08:09:33+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


Tim. I can't fault your analysis and agree Panthers are red hot favourites. Having said that if the GF was to be played today between Penrith v Rabbitohs, judging on the Bunnies recent hot form ( 5 consecutive wins and scoring 56 against Manly and 38-0 against the Eels) i think the Panthers would have their work cut out for them and the in-form Bunnies could topple the Panthers. But the GF is still along way off so no such luck. My view, the last man standing will win the GF, whichever of Pen-Sto-Par-Roo-Rai-Rab end up playing with the least injuries to key players will win. Penrith without Nathan are a different team, just as I think the Rabbitohs without Mitchell are; Roosters without Tedesco/Keary; Parra without Gutho, etc

2020-09-01T07:27:33+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


How about 'Strutting Rooster, Hungry Viking' You must be a mind reader, Nat. Tossing up to buy The Simpsons Box Set. It's the best reference manual on Rugby League etiquette.

2020-09-01T06:27:54+00:00

ja ja klazo

Guest


How is Robbo a sook? He very rarely blames the refs. Maybe did a bit at the beginning of his career, but not any more than the average coach, but in recent years he's definitely moved to owning each and every result.

2020-09-01T05:42:20+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


I can just picture you running through every Simpsons episode in your head for that reference there... :laughing: Did you think 'The Strut', Eye of the Tiger' or "Right through the neck"?

2020-09-01T05:40:39+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


I can’t warm to Ivan Cleary. But he can coach. Clearly... And hopefully we see fitter Roosters, Storm and Raiders sides and Alex Johnston brains it at fullback for Souths. I reckon the Storm or Roosters at their best, even with the long term injured missing can certainly beat the Panthers. Their points differential should take healthy jump after this week playing the Broncos. Would love to see the Storm win and Smith go out with a Premiership after such a difficult year for the side.

2020-09-01T05:36:29+00:00

Nat

Roar Rookie


The one random stat Freddie pulled from his A - Father/son... :laughing:

AUTHOR

2020-09-01T05:27:07+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Correct. Because it's the Roosters. I'm not sure what you don't understand about that...

2020-09-01T05:18:51+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Hear hear. The game will be better when he retires/loses his voice box.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar