My five favourite English players of all time

By peterj / Roar Rookie

After completing the first three of my articles, I have now decided to move up to the northern hemisphere.

I am aware that Argentina is located in the southern hemisphere, but I wanted to move up north before coming back down again.

One of the greatest English rugby teams of all time was the 2003 Rugby World Cup-winning team and their presence is felt heavily within my list. I had the (mis)fortune of living in England during this year and felt as though I bore the brunt of the post Rugby World Cup flak from every Englishman.

However, I did get to see all of the Six Nations matches that year and a lot of premiership rugby as well. This list is heavily dominated by that team, yet there is one notable omission, a certain number ten who kicked the most famous drop goal in English rugby history.

This is not a sour grapes moment and I respect Jonny Wilkinson greatly. However, he was not one of my favourite players so did not make the cut. Nevertheless, here we go.

Martin Johnson
There are many things that I loved about the man they refer to as ‘Johnno’, from his physical prowess through ball carrying and lineout work.

His ability to get every player in his team to raise that extra five percent was another one.

Number one though was his unflappability in the face of his opposition. Nothing fazed him. He was the ultimate leader. I would strongly recommend watching the British and Irish Lions documentary from the 1997 tour; it sheds a lot of light onto him and his presence.

Sure, he was built like a tank which definitely helped but he was the consummate professional. Captaining England on an unbeaten tour of New Zealand and Australia certainly made me stand up and notice and realise that these guys were the real deal.

We all know what the Johnson-led team achieved a few months later. The image of Johnson holding the Webb-Ellis trophy above his head with the team around him is one of the sport’s most enduring. As much as it pains me to admit it, they were the best team in the world at that point in time and Johnson led them superbly from the front.

Laurence Dallaglio
Another member of the 2003 Rugby World Cup-winning team and a vital component at that. The number eight in a tough and uncompromising back row of Neil Back and Richard Hill, Dallaglio was an outstanding rugby player and one of many unofficial leaders in that team.

A team that was built on forward dominance, the likes of which Dallaglio thrived in. Dallaglio played every minute of their campaign and when you consider how he played the game, that is very impressive.

A three-time member of a Lions squad, and a member of the Rugby World Cup Hall of Fame and multiple Six Nations winner, his resume is impressive.

A former England captain, some of Dallaglio’s biggest achievements were actually in club land where he captained his beloved Wasps to multiple premierships and Heineken Cup victories in Europe. His autobiography is definitely worth a read and in it Dallaglio mentions that early on in his career he was approached by Italy about representing them.

A sliding doors moment? Dallalgio rejected the offer as he was passionate about playing for England and didn’t want to compromise the playing shirt for Italy by playing and not really believing in it. Says it all really.

Jason Robinson
The last member of the 2003 Rugby World Cup team and the only back in the whole list. Robinson was an absolutely outstanding player.

The greatest “space manager” I have ever seen and the scorer of some simply breathtaking tries. The two which stand out for me are probably very similar for most rugby fans. The first one was his try in the 2003 Rugby World Cup final.

Set up from an excellent run by (ahem) Dallaglio who then passes out to Wilkinson who then finds Robinson who runs the final 20m beating Wendall and Rogers to the line. Not a particularly memorable try but in the context of the match and English rugby history it was huge.

I love the celebration and the excitement on his face too (definitely didn’t at the time though!). The other try was the one that really announced himself to Australia. The 2001 Lions tour where Robinson received the ball from a rather innocuous looking pass.

The Wallabies were manned up in defence and it looked business as usual. Except no one told Robinson who put on some of the flashest footwork seen and completely stood up Chris Latham and scored.

I remember at the time, turning to dad and asking “what the hell just happened?”. A scintillating try scored by a scintillating player.

Maro Itoje
Moving away from the 2003 team and into the more recent one. I have spent the last four and half years living and working in London and one of the great pleasures has been watching Maro Itoje play. The hype around him was big before he even made his debut.

When he was named to make his debut it went into overdrive. We are all aware of the U.K press’ propensity for bigging up players, however, after his debut everyone could see this was warranted.

Maro Itoje runs the ball for England. (Photo by Adam Davy/PA Images via Getty Images)

Named man of the match in his second outing against Wales, Itoje was earmarked for big things. His athleticism is freakish, his hands are outstanding but I think his strongest attribute is his rugby brain. Reminiscent of Victor Matfield he is excellent at lodging himself in the opposition hooker’s head.

Named a starting British and Irish Lion in only his second season of international rugby, Itoje was taught a lesson in NZ. However, this only drove him to improve to greater things and he was one of the outstanding players at the 2019 Rugby World Cup.

Itoje has been earmarked as the captain of the Lions for the tour of South Africa next year where he will be desperate to prove himself against the world champion Boks.

Billy Vunipola
A somewhat controversial choice I would imagine, but Billy Vunipola is someone I have loved watching over the past few years. Sadly for Billy he has spent many of the past few years on the sidelines, yet when he is playing is certainly worth watching.

He is destructive. Opposition teams are terrified when they are defending a five metre scrum on their own line. Vunipola loves running over the top of people but also possesses a very neat short-passing game. I just love watching a big forward go on a run and Vunipola delivers this regularly.

I fear that a lot of southern hemisphere fans would not have seen the best of Billy due to geographical distances but also the aforementioned injury woes he has suffered.

It has been under Eddie Jone where Vunipola has realised his potential and Jones has often rushed him back into the starting team where possible, albeit, sometimes to his own detriment. I hope for his sake he is able to have an injury free run because he really has the potential to be one of the best players in the world.

There you have it Roarers, my favourite English rugby players. Who are yours?

The Crowd Says:

2021-02-07T03:41:13+00:00

Hanibal

Roar Rookie


Only just seen this so my comment 5 months later probably won’t be seen but any list of the greatest English players must include Roger Uttley and Fran Cotton, key members of the greatest rugby team ever (by far) - the 1974 British Lions.

2020-11-13T17:49:58+00:00

Gonzo99

Roar Rookie


Nice to see Peter Dixon’s name on your list. My dad played no. 10 in that Gosforth (now Newcastle Falcons) team of the late 60s with Peter. Roger Uttley & Malcolm Young were in that side too. Dominated the north before the advent of professionalism. :thumbup:

2020-10-04T04:40:10+00:00

Gun Dog

Roar Rookie


Wilkinson, Tualagi, May, Johnson, Dallaglio...

2020-10-01T16:48:45+00:00

Rich1234

Roar Rookie


Thanks Peter for posting. From the modern era, I agree with you but certainly a number of others who could make the list. There are some great names mentioned by others of previous players who are certainly favourites as well. A quick story. Many years ago, I was invited by a work colleague of mine to travel to Salisbury Rugby a Club to attend the Martin Johnson testimonial dinner just after he had retired. This was a dry run for the much bigger events he later held. As the token Aussie in attendance, they sat me next to him. He is a very friendly guy, funny and was great company. He had a book printed for the occasion, and I asked him to sign it. He turned the pages to the middle of the book where there was a magnificent photo of him in full flight, ball under the arm and about to run over the top of a poor Wallaby who was bracing himself for the impending carnage. Martin pulled out a sharpie and did the biggest autograph I have ever seen across the two pages. It was a little over the top but in a funny way, and I said thank you. He smiled and said that he loved playing the wallabies as they were very fair, tough, competitive and extremely skilful and great blokes of the pitch. He also apologised but said he also liked winding up the Aussies hence the massive autograph. He was an absolute gentleman and reminded me a lot of Eales. Very different to how (e looked on the pitch. Cheers

2020-09-30T03:26:28+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Ackford was good. Were they all traffic cops on the M25?

2020-09-30T03:23:11+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


God list Ben! Ben Clarke was excellent and Dean Richards was effective if unspectacular. I think Leicester need him back as head coach.

2020-09-30T03:21:40+00:00

Armchair Halfback

Roar Rookie


Hi Peter, I think you were on firmer ground with your Welsh list! :laughing: My choice: Jason Robinson - brilliant winger Johnny Wilkinson - consummate professional Jason Leonard - brilliant prop Neil Back - Half pint, brave and durable Chris Oti - England's first black player in 80 years I think Dallaglio was poorly treated after he got into a bit of trouble and suddenly became "Italian"! Mike Teague was amazing on the 1988 Lions tour but not averse to a little bit of skullduggery. It's hard not to go past their winning RWC team for most names. I'm looking forward to your list of favourite Scottish players. Go Hoggy!

AUTHOR

2020-09-19T09:49:29+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Jason Leonard was a warrior phenomenal player.

AUTHOR

2020-09-19T09:48:52+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Robinson def. the best of the cross coders, followed by Thorn then SBW

AUTHOR

2020-09-19T09:48:11+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Hi Ulrich, These aren’t the people I’m saying the best ever England players are but just my personal favourites of which Itoje is certainly one. Would absolutely put him as the equal of some of the ones you’ve listed and better than some also.

AUTHOR

2020-09-19T09:46:45+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the kind words I understand the sentiment towards England but I’ve put personal feelings aside in this one. Watson was very close for me. I love watching him play and he seems like a great bloke as well.

2020-09-18T23:29:35+00:00

Sheikh

Roar Rookie


Martin Johnson - for so many of the reasons already mentioned. Jason Leonard - possibly the finest scrummager I've ever seen in an England shirt Brian Moore - not just one of the great hookers, but erudite and professional as a commentator, too. Dusty Hare - a dead-shot kicker before people realised how important they were and still holds the record for most points scored during a career. The player who got me interested in rugby. Oh, and played 1st class cricket as a hobby! Jonny Wilkinson - played for my club; I'm 6 years older and he played 3 years behind me - we knew he'd be good even then!

2020-09-16T05:33:39+00:00

bandicoot

Guest


Mine would be: Jason Robinson - not much needs to be said, absolute magic! Dean Richards - imo the best no8 of his era, and hard as nails. bloodgate ruined a hero for me... Jerry Guscott - was a class act in the 3/4s Iain Balshaw - probably the most exciting broken-play runner England ever had, but never really made the most of him Neil Back - such a good reader of the game. I'd watch him thinking "where the hell is he going, the play is over there" only for the run of play to shift and he'd be right there ready for it And an honourable mention for Will Greenwood, who was also a very classy centre

2020-09-15T23:21:40+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Oh, PeterJ... man I hate England and everything about them in every sport I watch... I barrack for ANYONE over England. But Wilkinson is one of my all time favourite players, and I am amazed he didn't make the cut here. Bloke was a defensive weapon at a time when 10s were not made to be so brutal. Had a horror debut in the 76-0 thrashing the Wallabies dished out, but was class his whole career. Apart from him, I liked Haskell, but he is far from peak performer in the world scope of things. Jason Leonard was always good, and didn't seem to resort to rubbish scrummaging tricks. Johnson. He was just no fuss wasn't he. Just hard as nails. Robinson. He was possibly the greatest transition player? Maybe SBW for the skills he has, but Robinson made the best fist of his change over from league. He was lightening. I like your lists PeterJ... Keep them coming.

2020-09-15T18:22:53+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


Nice try but. There are no favorite English players. Not now, not ever. Some less disapproving than others. I "may" save Wilkinson from the pile. May. Now I feel disgusted.

2020-09-15T16:03:59+00:00

Ulrich

Roar Rookie


Don't know if Itoje belongs there just yet. He may well get there though. There are a number of giants from the SH in the lock position over the last 15-20 years including Whitelock, Matfield, Botha, Etzebeth, Snyman, Retallick, and de Jager. Also too young to comment on prior generations. In my limited lifetime certainly, Martin Johnson and Johnny Wilkinson are up there with the best.

2020-09-15T11:58:36+00:00

BuffaloTheorist

Roar Rookie


Hi peterj, really been enjoying the articles, looking forward to the rest. To continue on from what others have said, it is really difficult to favourite a English rugby player, especially while they are still active. Us Aussies reserve a special amount of hatred for the motherland. As someone of a similar vintage to yourself, I could never admit to enjoying Wilkinson in his prime, but on reflection my respect for him only grows as time goes on. Because of his technically superb kicking game, it’s easy to forget how good his all round game was. Of the modern players, I have a soft spot for Watson and would do for Itoje if he cut out the carry on. I’d like to say Robinson, but I just forgive him for standing up Latham at the Gabba in 2001.

2020-09-15T06:48:30+00:00

Mark Richmond

Roar Guru


Wade Dooley ‘The Blackpool Tower’….. :stoked: , Rory Underwood , Brian Moore, Iain Balshaw, Jonny Wilkinson .

2020-09-14T21:59:19+00:00

Adsa

Roar Rookie


Steve Thompson, Dean Richards, Johnny Wilkinson, Richard Hill, Martin Johnson. And really need to mention Jason Leonard.

2020-09-14T19:09:27+00:00

Ben

Guest


Just like he does female police officers and taxi drivers...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar