My thoughts on each Round 4 NRL match

By Christo / Roar Guru

The fourth round of the NRL season has just concluded. Here are my thoughts.

Sea Eagles versus Panthers
On Thursday night the winless Manly Sea Eagles took on the Penrith Panthers in a contest that was practically over before halftime. The Panthers led 22 points to nil after just 25 minutes of play.

It was another dominant performance by superstar Nathan Cleary, along with arguably the better half on the night, Jerome Luai who had three try assists.

The man that stole the show however was Brian To’o who produced two fantastic tries along with 205 running metres and 80 post-contact metres. The Manly Sea Eagles continue to look horrible as they fall to the bottom of the ladder.

My Player of the match: Brian To’o

South Sydney Rabbitohs versus Canterbury Bulldogs
I do not think I need to dive too far into this game as it was pretty much exactly what people expected, which was a whitewash.

This annual ‘Good Friday’ match is usually a close and gritty match, however that was not what people came to expect this year or in recent years as the Bulldogs lately have rarely brought any competition to their opposition.

The game played out how we though it would as the Rabbits took home a 38-0 win which keeps the Bulldogs scoreless for three weeks straight.

Canterbury did show some fight in the first half as they kept South Sydney contained, however they had opportunities to score but just did not capitalise.

My player of the Match: Cody Walker

Melbourne Storm versus Brisbane Broncos
On Friday night it was another destruction as the Melbourne Storm defeated my Broncos by 34 points. From the perspective of a Broncos fan, I actually had high hopes that we could somehow give Craig Bellamy and the Storm some worries as we were leading by a try after 30 minutes of play.

Wow was my mind changed after the next ten minutes of the game.

Brisbane were holding the defence and actually putting up a great attempt against the Storm until we let Ryan Papenhuyzen score four quick tries within a blink. We just shut down as that is exactly what we did in that period of each game all of last year. There was no coming back from those four outstanding tries as the Storm ran away with the game by scoring 38 un-answered points.

Ryan Papenhuyzen of the Storm kicks a penalty goal during round one NRL match between the Melbourne Storm and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at AAMI Park, on March 11, 2021, in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

My Player of the match: Ryan Papenhuyzen

Cronulla Sharks versus North Queensland Cowboys
The theme of beat downs by teams continued on Saturday as the North Queensland Cowboys had 40+ points put on them for the second straight week.

With everyone talking about how woeful the Cowboys are playing, let me tell you how good the Sharks looked on the weekend. They played outstanding with unbelievable ball movement and just some awesome attack in general.

Their defence was on point as well because they kept the cowboys to as low as 1500 running metres. The Cowboys on the other hand have shown us so far nothing, except wooden spoon contender.

My Player of the match: Chad Townsend

Gold Coast Titans versus Canberra Raiders
Finally, a match this week that was not too much of a blowout. This contest between the Titans and the Raiders was a tight one throughout, however the Raiders were just too much for this young Gold Coast team in the end, as Ryan Sutton scored in the 77th minute to seal the deal for a Canberra win.

Josh Papalii did his job unbelievably once again as he toped the Raiders running metres as he ran for 194 metres, to go along with a try. Tino Faasuamaleaui was able to run even further with a superb 201 running metres.

This was a great bounce back game for Canberra after they were defeated by the Warriors the week before in a valiant effort, given they were left to as low as one player remaining on the bench.

My Player of the match: Josh Papalii

Newcastle Knights versus Illawarra Dragons
The Newcastle Knights and the Illawarra Dragons show the definition of Sunday afternoon footy as they put on a show for the fans in Newcastle on Sunday.

It was a Tariq Sims’ charge down try that was the game changer as it put the Dragons ahead in the second half and put them in a position to win their third straight match of the season.

There were major injury concerns for the Knights as former NSW half, Mitchell Pearce tore his pectoral muscle when making a clumsy tackle and this could be as bad as a season-ending injury according to the former Origin player.

Tex Hoy also suffered what looks to be an ACL tear. To be honest the Dragons have really surprised me so far this year as I had them to finish as wooden spooners, but they have come out of the gates firing and were able to add an exclamation point when they beat Newcastle without Ben Hunt.

My Player of the Match: Tariq Sims

Tariq Sims. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Sydney Roosters versus New Zealand Warriors
This game was a weird one as it was a slight Roosters blow out in the end, however a lot of people had the Warriors to upset the Chooks, but that did not prevail. Sam Walker looked great in his much-anticipated debut as he picked up a try assist and looked calm out in the middle.

My Player of the Match: Brett Morris

Parramatta Eels versus Wests Tigers
The Parramatta Eels and the Wests Tigers provided us with some entertaining ‘Easter Monday’ footy as it was a fast start from the Eels before the Tigers hit back with two consecutive tries.

The game was within two points with five minutes remaining, before Clint Gutherson put the dagger into the hearts of the Tigers with at try with three minutes left to put them in front by a commanding eight points.

The Tigers have much improved over the last two weeks though with a near second straight win.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2021-04-07T09:35:15+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


Yes

AUTHOR

2021-04-07T09:34:59+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


At this moment unfortunately for Manly I see no light at the end of the tunnel, well at least they haven't shown a signal sign that there is yet.

2021-04-07T03:51:47+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


It’s as if you have read my mind Spartacus.

2021-04-07T03:47:15+00:00

Crow

Roar Pro


Purple patch for Papenhuyzen

AUTHOR

2021-04-06T23:56:26+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


Yes i agree Paul, the refs get slammed for not calling the pass forward in the raiders vs warriors match so the next week they think that calling every pass that is flat at worst forward will make the fans happy.

2021-04-06T22:36:08+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I sometimes feel sorry for the refs. Perenara was nailed to a cross by his boss Annerseley over a forward pass decision, so now these are in the spotlight and the refs & touch judges are making "scared decisions". On the weekend, I saw at least two passes called forward that were flat at worst and certainly not forward.

AUTHOR

2021-04-06T22:32:18+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


I don’t understand either, I think he is pretty underrated

AUTHOR

2021-04-06T22:31:34+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


Yes the Broncos, Cows, dogs and Eagles are certainly not making the eight. I think the team that will just slide in will be the Sharks, warriors or Titans

AUTHOR

2021-04-06T22:29:02+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


I though the reffing was pretty poor, especially with the foward pass calls

AUTHOR

2021-04-06T22:28:20+00:00

Christo

Roar Guru


Hey sorry I forgot to add my man of the match to the last match, in my opinion it was Reed Mahoney

2021-04-06T20:25:03+00:00

Soda

Roar Rookie


Yeah I know Spartacus, I am in no way booking my tickets to the finals already. I am just relieved that I can watch a team actually putting in. Something that they haven't done for a long long time. Regarding context, everyone had dragons as wooden spooners for 2021 so I will enjoy these victories and even though there were injuries I though the knights played well and would have beaten a lot of other teams in that situation. Dragons get credit for out enthusing the knights from the first whistle before the attrition started to take effect. Great game of footy.

2021-04-06T13:39:16+00:00

Walter Black

Guest


"imagine what would happen if they threw chips all over the field. " That would resemble an AFL game.

2021-04-06T11:38:08+00:00

Spartacus

Roar Rookie


Get Walker out of FB and play Josh Schuster there until Turbo returns. Then move Schuster to 5/8 and drop Foran. Move Walker to centre and keep Morgan Harper in the centres. Flick Lachlan Croker and just play Cade Cust there until Manly can recruit a real dummy half. Cust can cover both hooker and the halves. Trial some new back rowers instead of Jack Gosiewski and Josh Schuster. I suggested putting Moses Suli there, but he is injured this week. Going forward he could be a Luciano Leilua clone. The same thing with Jorge Taufua who is due back in rounds 5-6. Curtis Sironen is due back a week or two later. Manly need some muscle and steal in their middle third and on their edges. At present, it is paper thin. I'd start there. Oh, and get Geoff Toovey back involved at the club as assistant coach and ready to take over for Des if... Des decides to "explore new opportunities".

2021-04-06T11:28:48+00:00

Spartacus

Roar Rookie


Do that Walter and you might finally see the seagulls come to life. After all, if they go crazy over just one chip imagine what would happen if they threw chips all over the field. There would be a frenzy of seagulls come to life! :laughing:

2021-04-06T11:25:25+00:00

Spartacus

Roar Rookie


Congrats Soda. While I don’t wish you rain on your parade while the Dragons were missing Hunt the Knights were missing Kayln Ponga, Bradman Best Ederick Lee and lost Mitchell Pearce, Kurt Mann and Tex Hoy to injury during the game. As we saw with the Warriors vs the Raiders having a squad of 14 vs 17 virtually assures that the team with numerical superiority are the victors. And yes, we also saw that with the Rabbitohs vs the Roosters, but Souths were clearly well on top before the Roosters’ injury woes began. Enjoy the win mate but context and perspective are important I think.

2021-04-06T08:26:50+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


Good article. Do you see any light at the end of the tunnel for the Sea Eagles?

2021-04-06T02:38:43+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Lodge and Haas came back into the run on side. I assume TPJ is being used as an impact player.

2021-04-06T01:55:29+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Why did Pangai jr only get 31 minutes in the Storm game..just picked it up ?

2021-04-06T01:36:30+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


And what a battle it will be!!

2021-04-06T00:23:26+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


Based on Round 4 performances, I thought the Tigers, Dragons, Sharks, Warriors all showed promise as potential top 8 contenders (apart from the usual suspects Panthers, Rabbitohs, Storm, Raiders, Roosters and Eels). The Titans may be there, but I am not convinced they'll make the 8. The Knights are goners, and the Broncos, Cows, Dogs and Eagles will battle for the wooden spoon.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar