Will the Swans be Melbourne’s greatest test this season?

By Aaron Di Placido / Roar Rookie

They’ve proven themselves against Geelong and quite convincingly dismantled a battered Richmond side, but is Melbourne’s greatest test this season going to come against a limber Swans side?

Sitting nice and comfortably atop the AFL ladder, Melbourne are 7–0, playing some of their best competitive football in years and are showing signs of a young side that has matured and is ready to go deep into finals.

The Swans are not too dissimilar to the same Melbourne side that made their way into the preliminary final back in 2018, only to have their hopes cut short thanks to the eventual premiers in West Coast.

Sydney’s squad runs quite parallel to that Melbourne side, with a strong bunch of young and inexperienced players who are ready to compete at the highest level, genuine stars in their prime with Tom Papley and Isaac Heeney, and of course, a handful of veterans who bolster the attack in Franklin and Kennedy.

This Melbourne side has been on quite a journey since that prelim, being unable to replicate the form that that side had in the 2019 and 2020 seasons, almost bottoming out in the former and narrowly missing finals in the latter.

The Demons’ bounce back has been exceptional, though, making a strong statement in the opening rounds and following on with big wins at the G.

This is a team that isn’t far off the side that lost to the Eagles back in 2018, with 11 of the 22 that lost against the Eagles playing against North Melbourne over the weekend — and a handful more still on the Melbourne list.

Melbourne have once again been able to show signs of a top-four contender with a brilliant and exciting attacking playing style that embraces the run and carry in Christian Petracca off exceptional ruck work from Max Gawn.

Max Gawn (Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

It’s inspiring to see a side re-engage like they have after a rough couple of years.

And it’s expected; this is a team that has needed time to nurture and grow their younger stars, while also adapting to the ever-changing nature of AFL.

It’s no lie that after their huge win against Richmond, the Dees became a serious contender, and while Richmond was never going to be an easy hurdle to overcome, this weekend’s match-up against Sydney may prove to be the tougher contest.

Sydney has ground out tough battles against Essendon, Brisbane and most recently, Geelong. And like Melbourne, they became a real talking point when they managed to defeat the benchmark of the competition back in Round 3.

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

That game will be one of the most important points of reference for the Swans leading into Saturday night’s clash at the G and should propel their confidence in being able to play a possession heavy game at the home of football.

Melbourne will be looking into this and will take note of Sydney’s favour for kicking and keeping a much more stop-start run of play than the usual AFL side.

Sydney will be looking to use the space at the MCG, similar to what they did to Richmond and control the play with a tactical build rather than burst plays.

Sydney registered almost 70 more kicks than the Tigers and 46 more marks, showing that they’re not afraid to back their skills in disposing the ball into marking territory.

For Melbourne, this game will be about the rebound and applying pressure on the ground at the right time.

Sydney are a skilled side, especially with a returning Buddy Franklin, but Melbourne’s focus will be around their inside 50 pressure.

Putting the heat on in the Swans back half will be necessary to allow the ball to spill over.

Gold Coast did this brilliantly in their win over the Swans, registering 21 tackles inside 50 and applying a load of pressure from the front.

With players like Bayley Fritsch, Kysaiah Pickett and Jayden Hunt in great form, you can see the Dees being able to apply some serious squeeze defensively.

On the attack, the Demons are ranked number one for inside 50s, so there shouldn’t be an entry issue – it’ll be locking the ball in that’s the challenge.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

It’s the great test for Melbourne at the moment to continue their momentum against a side that is not too dissimilar to them on paper and has the same level of energy and youthful exuberance to take the game head-on with anyone.

Sydney will be looking for another scalp, and what better one to take than that of the only undefeated side in the competition?

Both sides have star power, as well as a new generation of exciting young talent, and it sets itself up for the match of the round.

If Melbourne are to set themselves up for the next few weeks, it starts with a firm win over a team that shares a similar list and looks to be a side overflowing with promise in the next year or so.

Melbourne have made a strong claim as real premiership contenders over the past month, with Sportsbet even paying out those who placed their bets on them at the beginning of the season.

But Saturday night will be a real opportunity for this exciting football side to elevate and stamp their authority on a team that isn’t too far off the mark either.

The Crowd Says:

2021-05-10T23:43:09+00:00

Gerry

Roar Rookie


No the biggest test will be Eagles at Optus.

AUTHOR

2021-05-05T13:35:54+00:00

Aaron Di Placido

Roar Rookie


And I think with the side Melbourne have they’re more than capable of doing this well. Obviously Geelong were an umpires call away from the game, but their forward’s pressure is quite different which probably didn’t help last week.

AUTHOR

2021-05-05T13:33:50+00:00

Aaron Di Placido

Roar Rookie


Yeah definitely agree, it’s one of the best stories to come out of the first couple of rounds. The Swans have switched their playing style up a bit as well which has made for a much more exciting brand with a nice blend of young and old - you love to see it. I just don’t think anyone really saw this game being as big as it is prior to the season’s start, which makes it all the more interesting come Saturday night.

AUTHOR

2021-05-05T13:31:42+00:00

Aaron Di Placido

Roar Rookie


Same here, a nice and tight contest that goes into the final quarter to keep fans guessing would be great! It’s hard to tell which way it’s going to go in my opinion, but on paper you’d back the Dees.

2021-05-05T12:35:49+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


You nailed it with the commentary about the Suns win against the Swans. If Melbourne’s forward pressure can force Sydney into turning the ball over coming out if defence, it’s game over.

2021-05-05T08:45:15+00:00

Mark.

Roar Rookie


So if Sydney lose because they celebrated a win? Lol

2021-05-05T07:54:36+00:00

dab

Roar Rookie


vandenberg is under-rated.

2021-05-05T07:47:32+00:00

CloudRunner

Roar Rookie


I don't know if vandenberg has played this year, but he's not in our best 22. Fritsch was the other out initially until his suspension was suspended itself.

2021-05-05T04:07:01+00:00

okapiman

Roar Rookie


I would love an upset, however Melbourne in a canter. Two elements Sydney over celebrated against Geelong. Every time I see an over celebration the team loses the following week, even if playing the bottom sides. Second Melbourne has good strong hard bodies now, Sydney will stay with them to halftime, or even halfway through the third, and then Melbourne will canter away. Should be a great game to watch skill-wise. Far better than Collingwood v any team.

2021-05-05T03:58:37+00:00

XI

Roar Guru


Hoping for a high-quality game to match some hype. Something similar to the Swans-Cats or Bombers-Blues would do nicely. I think the Demons by like 3 goals

2021-05-05T03:41:32+00:00

MG

Roar Rookie


Tomlinson, vandenBerg and Viney best 22 outs (?) for the Demons. Melican and Reid for the Swans. Hewett, Rampe and Franklin expected to come in. Rampe and Franklin probably perform well but not so sure with Hewett after a nasty concussion. Both lists in pretty good health so not a huge factor. Very hard to tip.

2021-05-05T03:29:48+00:00

MG

Roar Rookie


Swans lost by 2 points to GWS in the last minute. 40 point loss to the Suns.

2021-05-05T02:09:23+00:00

Angela

Roar Rookie


Hmm, should be a good match. How amazing that it’s even being considered that the Swans could beat the number one team at the bloody old G in 2021. How wonderful it is for Swans fans to see the hitherto unlikely leap from the bottom of the ladder to up near the top. Quite extraordinary actually. Coach and associates deserve massive praise (for taking on Tom Hickey apart from anything else). I’d love them to win but suspect Melbourne will prevail (and isn’t it good to see a new face atop the ladder). Can handle a loss as long as they fight like they have in most of the matches so far (trusting the GC loss was an aberration).

2021-05-05T01:24:08+00:00

Kick to Kick

Roar Rookie


Interesting that in the Longmire decade, the Demons have only beaten the Swans once. John Longmire’s first game as head coach in round 1, 2011 was a tie. It took until the 2019 season for Melbourne to post a victory. Last year the Swans prevailed finding space in Cazaly Stadium Cairns, one of the biggest of AFL grounds. But this year the Demons have stretched themselves to be the most successful pressure team in the league including in a clutch of games at the also large MCG. If the Demons can close down space on Saturday night they should beat the less experienced Swans. If their effort is down at all the Swans have a chance.

2021-05-05T01:19:51+00:00

Roger of Sydney

Roar Rookie


Hard to call, I think if the Swans will be allowed to run that might be Melbournes downfall. The Swans are not big bodied and GWS showed they could break tackles so if it run against run game I back the Swans, but if Melbourne tackle hard and apply pressure you would have to back Melbourne

2021-05-04T23:31:09+00:00

dab

Roar Rookie


IF Melbourne do the right thing and play red hot Weideman (and Sparrow), then Melbourne else Swans. But Melbourne selectors are not renowned for doing the right thing. It is another tricky pick. Pies/Norf. Tiges/Cats, Suns/Saints are the other chancy picks.

2021-05-04T23:18:54+00:00

Anna

Guest


Swans by 5 goals

AUTHOR

2021-05-04T23:16:02+00:00

Aaron Di Placido

Roar Rookie


Yeah I think the ruck battle will be something to look out for, especially because both sides rely so heavily on them two performing. Geelong aren't an easy side to beat, so I think the tails will be up for the Swans especially with Buddy back and confidence in that Richmond win at the G. It makes for a cracking contest either way.

AUTHOR

2021-05-04T23:13:44+00:00

Aaron Di Placido

Roar Rookie


Same here, my Demon friends are waiting very cautiously at the moment.

2021-05-04T22:35:04+00:00

dab

Roar Rookie


I was surprised they beat the Cats, Tiges and GWS. They could surprise again.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar