North Melbourne aren't as bad as you think

By Aidan Sinclair / Roar Pro

Zero points, zero wins and almost zero hope. North Melbourne have struggled their way through the 2021 season on the back of a mediocre 2020 campaign.

But not all hope is lost. In recent weeks we’ve seen some fight from the Shinboners, and their fans are beginning to look at the signs that point to them winning their first game of the season very soon.

Round 7 saw the Roos fall short of the Demons by five goals. Yes, we can analyse the final score and say that they weren’t that close. However, nine minutes into the final term, Ben Cunnington was able to slot a goal that would draw the margin back to just seven points with plenty of time to play and with momentum flooding the way of North Melbourne.

The Kangaroos led by 19 points at halftime and looked well and truly in control of the contest against a great side that was 6-0 going into the game. Unfortunately they fell off, as they’ve done in numerous games so far, including their clash against the Crows at Marvel Stadium a few weeks earlier. This was their chance to finally get that win on the board and break the drought against a Crows side that was actually in from at the time.

(Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

It was a similar story in Round 8 for the Roos, falling short of a troubled Collingwood side by an even three goals. Collingwood looked as if they would kick away through some dominance from Jordan de Goey, and the Pies were able to extend the margin to 30 points at halftime after four unanswered goals.

But David Noble’s Roos weren’t done yet, and they came out after halftime and flipped the game on its head, kicking four unanswered goals of their own. It was a hard-fought game from there, and the Pies were able to edge North Melbourne purely by being that slight bit classier in terms of ball movement and efficiency.

In stats like marking and tackling, North Melbourne are able to compete with most of the other sides in the competition, ranking seventh and ninth respectively – although you would assume with their lack of disposals and possessions they would then be forced to tackle more.

They are ranked 17th in inside 50s and 18th in clearances, demonstrating that it all starts with their midfield. Being ranked equal last in contested marks and second last in marks inside 50 shows how easily they are being outmarked or spoilt. The loss of Ben Brown to the Dees is obviously huge in these facets of the game.

With all of these poor rankings, North Melbourne have still managed to be in half their games this season before running out of juice. It does, however, pose the question as to what they do to improve in these aspects of the contest.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Ben Cunnington has been among North’s best this year up to this point despite playing only six games. But he hasn’t had the impact the Roos would have hoped for in the midfield with Jack Ziebell dropping back to the halfback line. Cunnington has had to stand up, and he leads the side in clearances, is ranked second for tackles and is also averaging more than 25 disposals per game.

That said, he hasn’t had much help. Luke Davies-Uniacke hasn’t hit even close to the form that he was expected to reach this season. Davies-Uniacke, like Cunnington, has played only six games but is ranked 100th in tackles and 111th in clearances and has averaged only 18 disposals. He’s kicked only one goal, which seems to be a common issue among the North mids, as they are unable to hit the scoreboard.

On the bright side, Tom Powell has been very impressive in his first year for North. Charlie Lazzaro and Will Phillips have also shown very positive signs in the games they’ve played. The opportunity for youth in the side is fantastic, and it’s great to see young first and second-year players getting to play plenty of football.

Nick Larkey is a massive asset to North Melbourne, and now it’s up to him to lead that forward line that was steered by Ben Brown for so long. He scored 26 goals in 2019, growing into a player North Melbourne needed behind Ben Brown as the second tall forward. After playing just ten games last year, Larkey has played every game so far this season and has kicked ten majors. He will be hoping to improve on his 2019 campaign as he continues to work on his craft and become one of the better key forwards of the competition.

The North Melbourne injury list is one of the more extensive in the competition. Robbie Tarrant, Jaidyn Stephenson, Jared Polec, Luke McDonald, Aidan Corr, Aidan Bonar and Jed Anderson are the key players that the Roos will look forward to getting back eventually. The VFL side finished their recent game against Southport with just 17 players, highlighting how bad their injury issues are right now.

After being very positive in their previous two games, North Melbourne will look forward to the challenges that lie ahead. They play Hawthorn, Essendon and St Kilda before the bye in Round 12. These are all winnable games based on the way these sides have been playing this season. The Hawks aren’t in great touch after being beaten comprehensively by St Kilda and West Coast in their last two games, so the Roos have every chance to snatch their first win of the year this Saturday.

On the back of one win from their last 23 AFL games, it makes sense for North to be essentially the laughing stock of the competition. However, David Noble is rebuilding his side, and so the expectations must be kept low.

They’ve competed very strongly in the last couple of weeks, including against the Demons, the best side in the league at the moment, so it’s fair to say North Melbourne aren’t the easybeats almost everyone is making them out to be.

The Crowd Says:

2021-05-16T13:06:41+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Because Ben has done so well for Melbourne? We essentially traded a 28 year old with a suspect knee for 21 year old Jaidyn Stephenson. It was more good luck than good management but I will take that trade. Jaidyn is a serious talent and has done more in eight games this year than Ben did last year plus this year.

2021-05-16T02:29:39+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


You are forgetting Collingwood

2021-05-15T11:31:22+00:00

Kanga Supporter

Roar Rookie


Yes, we're better off.

2021-05-15T10:42:39+00:00

shifty

Roar Rookie


Man I hate being right

2021-05-15T09:20:33+00:00

Kick to Kick

Roar Rookie


Take it all back. Hawthorn are now the worst side in the comp this year.

2021-05-15T08:01:07+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Looks like you were right dude they won

2021-05-15T07:45:03+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


I take back my previous blog, North just beat my Hawks. I’m going into hiding

2021-05-15T07:31:12+00:00

okapiman

Roar Rookie


Congrats on the win. Great comeback.

2021-05-15T01:15:56+00:00

Kick to Kick

Roar Rookie


Love the passion of a fan. I recall being a Swans supporter back in 1993. One win. 63%. One of the clubs worst seasons in its history and it hurts. But the stats you cite make the point. After round 8 2011 GC were only 14th on the ladder, 2 wins and a percentage point above the Roos now. And they had the excuse of being a team full of callow but talented draftees. Do you really think the Roos are better off after round 8 in 2021?

2021-05-14T12:53:18+00:00

Kanga Supporter

Roar Rookie


Granted Kick to Kick is right on the majority of points. Nonetheless, I take umbrage at his assurance in Gold Coast "tracking better" in their inaugural year who received a smashing 3 times in 7 games to Round 8 (bizarrely, they didn't begin until Round 2, having byes in Round 1 and again in Round 9). Round 2 Saturday, 2 April (6:40 pm) Gold Coast 7.10 (52) def. by Carlton 26.15 (171) The Gabba Round 3 Saturday, 9 April (2:10 pm) Western Bulldogs 18.14 (122) def. Gold Coast 7.9 (51) Round 4 Sunday, 17 April (2:10 pm) Gold Coast 9.15 (69) def. by Melbourne 23.21 (159) The Gabba Round 5 Saturday, 23 April (2:40 pm) Port Adelaide 15.11 (101) def. by Gold Coast 15.14 (104) Round 6 Sunday, 1 May (1:10 pm) Essendon 31.11 (197) def. Gold Coast 8.10 (58) Etihad Round 7 Saturday, 7 May (7:10 pm) Gold Coast 18.16 (124) def. Brisbane Lions 17.14 (116) The Round 8 Saturday, 14 May (2:40 pm) Adelaide 20.10 (130) def. Gold Coast 9.19 (73) AAMI For sure, our percentage is dire (I'm a Kanga supporter); we've won no games; we can only point to player improvement. However, Gold Coast (even when winning 2 games by Round 8 of 2011) had a truly bad first up year (after Round 8 they would win one more game, against Richmond ironically, before going on to be smashed 2 mores times and heavily defeated 6 more times after that round of football). "Tracked better" has a lot of truthiness to it - to do with the percentage I suppose. Would I swap our year for Gold Coast's 2011? Hell no.

2021-05-14T09:35:27+00:00

okapiman

Roar Rookie


Aidan, you can sell snow to eskimo's. You can sell Donald Trump is honest. Go get em.

2021-05-14T05:08:59+00:00

Kick to Kick

Roar Rookie


Second Roar article in recent times claiming North are not so bad, one even claiming they will not be wooden spooners. But they are winless in 16 straight matches. Their percentage of 52.7 is from what I can see the worst of the AFL era with the exception of the Giants in their inaugural year and Fitzroy in its final year of existence. Even the Gold Coast in its first year playing kids tracked better. Essendon in the year 12 of its players were banned for drug taking had a percentage of 61. In other words apart from two teams, one in the undertaker’s hands and another in the hands of the midwife, this is the worst performing team in AFL history. Club management has an enormous amount to answer for. A club that played in 3 final series from 2014-16 has plummeted to a shocking nadir. Granted none of this is David Noble’s fault and the past two weeks may show some improvement, but if it’s too early to write off Richmond it’s equally too early to proclaim green shoots poking through at North Melbourne.

2021-05-14T04:20:16+00:00

Brian

Guest


Nah you'll be right. Last win of the year coming up and then lets see who we get with Pick 2 in the draft.

2021-05-14T04:08:45+00:00

berrlins

Roar Pro


North have shot themselves in the foot so many times it now resembles a bloody stump, but at least they aren't Collingwood.

2021-05-14T03:57:25+00:00

Chris Lewis

Roar Guru


another 50-50 match this weekend, good stuff. I have gone for the Hawks, but a North win would be good for the club.

2021-05-14T03:53:11+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


North could be the first team for a long time to go through a season winless. As for Saturday, both teams are pretty even, but the Hawks have two huge advantages. A massive home ground advantage, and having a multiple premiership winning coach, compared to Nobles eight games.

2021-05-14T03:32:33+00:00

Fish

Roar Rookie


Their injuries have exacerbated North's lack of depth - take three out of five of the best placed B&F finishers from any club and they would struggle (McDonald, Anderson, Dumont). Fixture hasn't been kind to North either (played the top 4). Too many caveats at the moment to really get a read on just how bad North is (worst side this year Vs worst side this decade etc).

2021-05-14T03:28:51+00:00

Fish

Roar Rookie


I think only getting in a 2nd round pick for him is the ridiculous part - with the way the ball comes into North's forward line (or the lack of it) even Brown would be having a very lean year.

2021-05-13T23:44:57+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


I do love the Hawks games. Yep. Utter madness.

2021-05-13T23:44:50+00:00

Republican

Guest


.....I hope you are right but I am not so confident that they will.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar