What the hell were the Dragons players thinking?

By AJ Mithen / Expert

A group of players get together at a teammate’s house, sink some beers, have a barbie and some laughs, eventually making enough noise as the night rolls on to get neighbours to call the police, who come along and send everyone on their way.

In 2019, this probably barely rates a mention in the gossip column on a Wednesday. But this is 2021 and times are very, very different.

What an idiotic thing this Dragons dozen have done, and of all the times to do it.

NRL Chief Executive Officer Andrew Abdo made a rare public appearance to register his disappointment and say ‘significant sanctions’ are on the table, pending the outcome of an NRL integrity unit investigation.

There’s reports around the place the players are arguing they didn’t know the rules, which just makes this whole thing even stupider.

Obviously they weren’t paying attention when the Bulldogs stood down five players for breaking the rules, resulting in a $50,000 fine for the club, fines for the players and a whopper of a 66-0 belting at the hands of Manly.

And they weren’t paying attention when Cronulla’s Josh Dugan was sprung at a restaurant with mates, resulting in him being tagged with 14 days isolation away from his team and a threatened $25,000 fine to be decided on this week.

And Paul Vaughan – the bloody host of the shindig – obviously wasn’t paying attention last year when he breached the bubble protocols, was stood down for three games while he isolated, and copped a $10,000 fine.

How could they have possibly thought this was a good idea?

Some are taking early reports there were no members of the public present to mean there’s been no ‘real’ breach of the NRL guidelines, just a minor enough breach of the NSW Government’s lockdown rules.

It doesn’t matter if there’s only NRL players and close partners there, it’s an incredible display of stupidity and a lack of self-awareness.

The New South Wales government’s website states:

“If you are in Greater Sydney, you must comply with the stay at home rules. If you want to visit another person you will need a reasonable excuse to be away from your place of residence.”

I thoroughly checked the government’s list of reasonable excuses to see if ‘getting on the piss with mates’ was there – it was not.

It’s also not on the ‘acceptable list of reasons to enter Greater Sydney including the Blue Mountains, Central Coast, Wollongong and Shellharbour’.

The NRL’s own level 4 protocols require players to remain at home unless training, playing or completing an essential household task, and they’re not allowed to have visitors in their homes.

It’s fair enough to argue this was only teammates, who are in their bubble all the time, catching up for a drink and a feed before their bye week, but this overlooks one critical point.

That critical point is this is a much, much bigger deal than just a breach of state COVID-19 rules.

Even if there was no NRL bubble breach, and at the time of writing, nothing has been confirmed to that effect, just look at the reaction of the NRL administration.

They’ve been busting their arses to get plans and travel arrangements approved by state governments who are increasingly trigger-happy about shutting borders or requiring quarantine on arrival.

Then they get the news of this breathtaking stupidity.

Like it or not, shutting borders or enforcing restrictions to keep dirty interstaters out or having them quarantine has been an election-winning strategy in Australia and it continues to be met with support, particularly in Queensland.

So politicians won’t need a second invitation to make an example of the NRL, traditionally looked down upon by those who think they know better.

Something like this could make these discussions between the NRL and their stakeholders incredibly difficult. It puts the game at a disadvantage

There’s also money on the line for the players, who will have a slightly less sturdy position to negotiate with the NRL when player payment negotiations come around next year.

So it’s not as simple as boys being boys and the police’s $1,000 fine being the end of the matter.

Paul Vaughan. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Having said all that, I don’t buy into the whole ‘NRL season in crisis’ being pushed around. I’m confident this moronic act won’t be the death knell for the season.

But swap that for ‘Dragons’ season in crisis’ and I’ll agree without hesitation.

If isolation is required, that’s a dozen players off the list for their next game against a rampant Manly, who can do serious damage to St George’s points differential in the run to the finals.

If the NRL decides to put a stake in the ground and hand out suspensions, which is entirely on the table, who knows where the Dragons’ 2021 will end up.

If I’m a St George Illawarra administrator, I’d also love to hear from Paul Vaughan as to why he thinks he’s worth keeping around the place if this is how he’s going to conduct himself.

People don’t like being locked down. They’re sick of it. They’ve spent the better part of two years dealing with this and they’ve had enough.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

They don’t like thinking other people are getting special treatment and they don’t understand how strict the NRL’s COVID-19 protocols are.

Something like this being front and centre of all the local press will again unfairly soil the reputation of the NRL player group.

Us rugby league fans get pretty annoyed when fans of other sports take cheap shots about the off-field exploits of NRL players.

But bloody hell, they can make it tough to defend them.

The Crowd Says:

2021-07-07T15:07:13+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


I was more having a crack at the bubble integrity being more important than the lock down laws.

2021-07-07T10:05:26+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


AJ – instead of asking “What the hell were the Dragons players thinking?” You should be asking “Where the hell did the Dragons’ Origin players hide?” I suspect they are still hiding in Vaughan’s basement? Isn’t it strange that the 3 Dragon “origin” players were NOT at this mid year social event? One of those players is Tariq Sims for God’s sake, I’ll repeat Tariq Sims? He is of the Josh Maguire/Dylan Napa mould. Come on, he would have been the first to turn up and last to leave. The cops and neighbours most likely didn’t check Vaughan’s cellar. There needs to be an investigation.

2021-07-06T22:39:12+00:00

baha

Guest


A covid denier this late in the game??? :laughing:

2021-07-06T06:31:57+00:00

elvis

Roar Rookie


You don't like contributing members of society? Who is going to pay your pension if we don't reproduce? Someone might come into the NRL bubble where ever the players are. People are starting to see through the covid fear mongering by bed wetters like yourself.

2021-07-06T04:46:59+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Maybe he was just having a rest?

2021-07-06T00:51:54+00:00

Kent Dorfman

Roar Rookie


Great - now their partners were (allegedly) at the party. Be better if it were strippers running from the house. So much for the player bubble argument. https://wwos.nine.com.au/nrl/nrl-news-andrew-abdo-warns-more-penalties-may-apply-st-george-illawarra-dragons-covid/f4262c92-4672-41c4-afa2-cd7b8e20bb6e

2021-07-05T21:45:03+00:00

Rabbitz

Roar Guru


They had already breached the lockdown laws by gathering in a private residence. So no, it isn't a valid reason and I am sure didn't impress the police, NRL Integrity, V'Landys and Abdo.

2021-07-05T21:22:43+00:00

Wait a minute!

Guest


Shows the intelligence of Jack de Belin. Also throws his credibility when it comes to his recent court case into question again. The fact that he was there , shows incredible stupidity by him. Hiding , then lying about being there later on. No one could believe a word he says.

2021-07-05T18:53:36+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


Would they be breaking the law also?

2021-07-05T18:51:13+00:00

Chris Love

Roar Guru


Pretty good reason to scamper then no? At the point the police arrive they are either in breach of NSW lock down laws or allowing a police officer to breach the bubble.

2021-07-05T11:19:51+00:00

egbert

Guest


For me, the question, 'What were they thinking?" is not rhetorical. I would love to actually know what was going through their brains when this was being organised, and how they thought they could possibly get away with it, and how much of their misdemeanours are down to ignorance. Because you know if there a public comment by any of them it will be heavily spun 'We deeply apologise for our irresponsibility, we let the club down and the game down.. blah blah blah' without actually detailing the story about how it happened. I guess we'll have to wait until some careers are over, Matt Dufty's memoirs or Josh McGuire's biopic. On a sidenote, I think this is what Paul Vaughan will be remembered for now, which is a shame for a player who played Origin.

2021-07-05T09:14:53+00:00

Joey

Guest


And yet any one of us could have crossed paths with an infected person in the last 16 months, and then we go back to our workplace and are suddenly safe amongst familiar faces. It’s really a bit oversimplified for me, that we can reliably nail down all infected persons when the most common symptom is no symptoms at all.

2021-07-05T09:04:17+00:00

Joey

Guest


In that case, not good. As far as I read, it was a boys only thing.

2021-07-05T08:47:51+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Players were fined amounts commensurate with their contracts. Normie copped $50k. Beale publicly whipped with humiliation $2k.

2021-07-05T08:44:14+00:00

Joey

Guest


Yeah nice, genuine mistakes. I guess if only they’d stop making so many genuine mistakes on the field.

2021-07-05T08:40:30+00:00

Short Memory

Guest


Well, Joey, there's a couple of issues. One is their WAGS aren't part of that intense contact. So instead of potentially infecting just their partner, they're potentially infecting the whole squad. Then there's What's happened to the 2 Roosters players - went to the supermarket as allowed - and the supermarket in question then got added to the exposure sites list. If those had been 2 Dragons players at the BBQ... well, there goes your whole squad again.

2021-07-05T08:35:51+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


He and Norman both copped $50000

2021-07-05T08:31:42+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


$50000 for PV and Norman $305000 in total might take the smile off their faces.

2021-07-05T08:28:38+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


$305000 worth of fines between them Norman and PV 50000 each see NRL website for the full list.

2021-07-05T08:26:22+00:00

Davico

Roar Pro


Well looks like they have been hammered for it!! https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/07/05/st-george-illawarra-dragons-players-fined-$305000-and-given-match-suspensions/

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar