MATCH REPORT: 'Horrendous'! Rennie anger as 14-man Wallabies beaten at the death

By Tony Harper / Editor

What a cruel way to lose a Test and end a season. Australia, down a man from the 15th minute after a red card to Rob Valetini, led Wales with 90 seconds left after a Kurtley Beale penalty, but lost 29-28 after the siren.

As courageous and impressive as the Wallabies were to stay in the game, amid some bizarre refereeing decisions by Mike Adamson, a third loss from as many games on the European tour has taken the gloss off a promising domestic campaign.

Dave Rennie’s team played 14 times this season, winning seven and losing seven. Two of those wins came against South Africa and two against France but three losses to New Zealand, and defeats to England, Scotland and Wales will hurt.

Rennie, so often a peacemaker in reaction to refereeing decisions, was in no mood to cop it on the chin, angered by two events in particular. Kurtley Beale was sin binned for an intercept gone wrong while a similar Welsh attempt ended in a try.

“I thought some of the decision making tonight by the officials was horrendous,” Rennie said.

“It played a big part in the result. Kurtley Beale got sin binned for slapping the ball down. They did the same thng and it clearly goes forward and they get seven points out of it.

“Obviously really disappointed by the result. We’ll end up getting an apology next week no doubt but it won’t help the result.”

Australia got off to a flyer with two minutes gone before Kellaway crossed for the ninth try of a breakout first season in Wallaby gold.

After Taniela Tupou, restored to the team following his concussion against Scotland, did some impressive grunt work, Hunter Paisami slipped in a cute kick behind the Welsh defence. The ball sat up nicely for Kellaway to cross.

Wales had cut the gap to 7-3 in the eighth minute but with 15 gone, Valetini charged out of the defensive line and his head smashed into that of rival Adam Beard, drawing blood.

Adamson’s decision was never in doubt.

“He’s come from distance, he’s come at speed, there’s a high level of danger and a high degree of play,” said the referee, deeming there was no mitigation for the dangerous play.

While former Wallaby Drew Mitchell was aghast at the decision, and several more that followed, his Stan Sport co-commentator Morgan Turinui thought it was a clear red..

“It’s a shame it’s not 15 on 15 for what was truthfully a clear red card in the modern way that the laws are intrepreted,” Turinui said.

“It was reckless with a clear lack of technique from Rob Valetini.”

Valetini needed to get lower in his tackle, and was apologetic to his stricken rival as he made his way off the field.

Rennie said he had no issue with the red card.

But it was a different story 14 men became 13 within seven minutes when Beale headed to the sin bin, having been ruled to deliberately knocked on to stop a Welsh raid.

The hosts scored, against what Andrew Mehrtens described as “the Australian rugby league team”, on the next play as Ryan Ellis crossed after a lineout.

O’Connor kicked the Wallabies level before Dan Biggar gave Wales a 16-13 lead into the sheds.

Australia lost Tupou and hooker Tolu Latu to injury within minutes of the restart and then conceded a bizarre try that even left the scorer, Nick Tompkins, shaking his head in disbelief.

Tompkins went for an intercept from a Tom Wright pass and the ball went straight to ground. He grabbed the bounce and ran away to the try line while the Wallabies stopped, expecting a whistle for a knock on.

That never came, and the TMO backed the ref. Tompkins shook his head wrly when the try was confirmed, and Mitchell said “the referee has had a howler.”

“It makes a mockery of it,” said Mehrtens. “You saw Nick Tompkins’ reaction – he knows it’s just crazy.”

Welsh coach Wayne Pivac was adamant it was a fair try.

“I didn’t think it was a knock on personally, nor did the referee, the TMO or the touch judges,” Pivac said. “We were quite pleased with that call. It just shows in a game you can’t switch off and stop, you’ve got to play to the whistle and you tell that to five year olds.

“Pressure builds yellow cards and we’re good enough to create pressure against sides.”

With 58 minutes gone the Wallabies got on even footing as Gareth Thomas was sin binned for a swinming arm on Allan Alaalatoa, and the Wallabies took quick advantage of parity with one of their best tries this year.

Alaalatoa and Pete Samu set the plaform and Beale had an electric impact, a brilliant step cutting open the Welsh defence. His pace to Len Ikitau was sent onto Nic White who was able to crwal over between the posts after being cut down just short of the line.

Against the odds the Australians had cut the margin to just three points, but Biggar knocked over a penalty soon after to push it out to six.

The Wallabies kept coming and with 10 minutes left Paisami, with his final involvement, made a surging run deep inside Wales’ 22. From a subsequent phase Filipo Daugunu, back in the side after breaking his arm against France in July, took a pass from Wright to dive over in the left corner.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

O’Connor lined his conversion up three metres in from the touch line and it agonisingly swung back late to bang off the post.

Australia got another chance to take a lead and Beale nailed it after Will Skelton forced a penalty just inside the Welsh half.

But the hosts fought back. They were under the Austrlaian posts, on phase 19 when Adamson found a penalty and Rhys Preistland was nerveless.

James Slipper, who was standing in as Wallabies captain for injured Michael Hooper, said the red card put the team under too much pressure.

“Playing the game predominately with 14 then a 10 minute period with 13 – in Test matches you just can’t win when you put yourselves under that sort of pressurem” said Slipper.

“We put ourselves in a position to win that game, we showed a lot of character to fight tooth and nail with a man down. I couldn’t be prouder of the boys.

“It’s been a long year for us, most of us have been on the road since June. The boys will be pretty happy to get home and see their young ones.”

The Crowd Says:

2021-11-28T07:18:05+00:00

Honest Max

Roar Rookie


Cheika has the same effect everywhere. Starts great but soon the players are ruined and the organisation is a mess. Am Irishman told me in 2015 how it would turn out.

2021-11-28T06:55:19+00:00

Honest Max

Roar Rookie


That was always a penalty when I played.

2021-11-24T09:59:14+00:00

robel

Roar Pro


https://live.laws.api.worldrugby.org › document › World_Rugby_Laws_2021_EN Law 11 does not mention a yellow card for a knock on, only a penalty for a deliberate knock-on, i.e. Beale should not have been yellow carded. Law 9 foul play, #7, the sanction is a penalty for a deliberate knock-on. Law 8 doesn't apply because no penalty try was awarded. So again, how can Beale be yellow carded and the Welsh try stand.

2021-11-22T19:27:07+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


Misses the point mate. A coaches job is to get the right pathways going. That is one of their top responsibilities. He hasn’t done it. He basically had carte blanche when he came in. It was plain for all to see that the the wallabies with 35 or so extra players to select from in Japan and Europe can be top 3. He didn’t insist on scrapping the OS player rules and adopting the SA approach of using the money SA rugby saves for paying its top players - who get paid from OS clubs - to reinvest and create a strong feeder comp. Same model used by poorer soccer nations and smaller ones like the Dutch. That is the only model that can work for Aus while rugby is no 4. Persistent poor managment from ARU that started with taking the game off free to air and favouring provincial structures over club ones. He also has not rotated the players to blood new talent against weaker nations in a controlled way. This is particularly so in the front row, 10, 12 and 15. Much easier to do that in a strong squad. Instead he needs to overuse players like Hooper who will suffer in terms of the 2-3 years to the next RWC. Very easy to fix but Rennie lacks imagination and foresight.

2021-11-22T09:18:52+00:00

The Yabbie

Roar Rookie


Afam I have no idea what the rules are around that. When I played that was fine all day but I had welsh commentary and they were not impressed.....On Wright, he doesn't kick. He doesn't have genuine X factor, he's not that, that fast and he's not lets say brilliant. At best he's solid if everyone else if overperforming.

2021-11-22T02:53:39+00:00

Stin

Roar Rookie


I agree. That’s my point. Refs should not be the talking point.

2021-11-21T23:13:40+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


Thanks for agreeing with me - Rennie may be a nice guy, loved by all and by the media. Objectively the results are the results. All teams have injuries and players out - excuses. In my subjective opinion who plays 10 was one of the biggest problems of the 2019 RWC? What is the Rennie strategy at 10? Please explain this to me?

2021-11-21T22:59:46+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


Not an attempt to troll anyone - the initial comment was Rennie must go - I am not there yet. All teams have injuries, people out etc. The results are the results, that is objective. We just seem to have lots of different excuses for each loss. We see a coach who is not developing a 10, in my subjective opinion, a RWC winning team needs a top level test 10. Recycling old test players look like papering over the cracks. I simply don’t understand why there was so much criticism of Cheika FOR RESULTS but not Rennie and Johnson.

2021-11-21T21:30:03+00:00

Lachlan

Guest


Ban Rennie from Rugby for 4 moths. ( refer Rassie ban )

2021-11-21T21:00:53+00:00

MRP

Guest


I felt the real travesty in the Tomkins incident was that it was an identical incident to what Kurtley got yellow for, (actually a worse knockdown, as KB actually made the tackle). There was no consistency in the refereeing.

2021-11-21T20:44:09+00:00

Rucki Oaf

Guest


In rugby league it would be a knock on every single day of the week. Wouldn't even have gone to video.

2021-11-21T12:06:25+00:00

Stu

Roar Rookie


Not sure why Beale kicked the ball away and possession along with it with 90 seconds left to go and up by two points, having just run the thing way upfield away from our own half.. so Wales are gifted the chance to turn it all around and run it back to penalty territory to win the game, which of course they did. Classic brainsnap Kurtley! Any other pro team would have sat on the ball and ground out 90 seconds for the win. That was it, the game was won.. Cheers KB! :laughing:

2021-11-21T12:06:25+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


Accidental head knock - red card. Swinging arm to the head of a downed opponent - yellow. Makes perfect sense

2021-11-21T11:57:49+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


"Stop bashing the officials. Just accept the outcome" That's rich coming from you!!! :laughing: :laughing:

2021-11-21T11:52:23+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Might lose his beer gut! :laughing:

2021-11-21T11:50:32+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


Unless a team is about a 20 points better than the oppo it's pretty hard to take the ref out of the equation.

2021-11-21T10:57:23+00:00

GibbonRib

Roar Rookie


It's not though. If there's a head clash but the tackler didn't do anything wrong then there's no penalty, let alone a card. In this case it was completely avoidable, it was very poor technique from Valentini, and resulted in a dangerous collision.

2021-11-21T10:51:17+00:00

Fboy

Guest


Hoy these “accidental” head knocks are accidents because of poor technique. I was incredibly disappointed by the outcome but accept that it was awful technique and if you try to put a big shot on and it goes wrong like that you suffer the consequences. Most other teams now seem capable of being more disciplined in the tackle. And you can’t ignore that the bad technique put the Welsh player out of the contest. This can and will be largely eliminated from the game. Oz players need to adapt and understand this is not the NRL but the requirements of playing test rugby.

2021-11-21T10:47:36+00:00

Pogo

Roar Rookie


I think “lack of intent” is harsh and unfair. They have given a lot, and gone hard. Mistakes yes, inconsistent yes but I disagree that they are not giving their all

2021-11-21T10:41:56+00:00

Pogo

Roar Rookie


You should change your name objective, or is that irony? There have been a huge number of changes through the year caused by player unavailability and injuries. This last game fro example we were without Hooper, MK, QC, kerevi, hodge, banks to name a few. So to say it’s the coach is simplistic. I see a coach who has the respect of his players and in turn respects them. When not selected he explains to them personally why and when relevant communicates that to the media. There are players from the cheika era who were dropped permanently and never received a call, sms just read it in the media. No comparison.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar