Ashes Scout: Marnus in cross hairs over walk off, reports of new rift in Aussie camp, Waugh's 'issue' with Bailey

By The Roar / Editor

Play resumed in the Sheffield Shield match between South Australia and Queensland on Wednesday morning after the Karen Rolton Oval pitch was deemed unsafe on Tuesday.

Incumbent Test batter Marnus Labuschagne wasn’t pleased after being struck on the gloves numerous times on Tuesday with a wet spot on the pitch causing balls to leap at the Queenslander from a good length.

The Bulls were 1/87 after 50 overs when play began on Wednesday morning with Labuschagne (21) and opener Bryce Street (45) at the crease.

A day earlier, umpires Donovan Koch and Mike Graham-Smith called stumps early after inspecting the pitch and conferring with Labuschange, Queensland captain Usman Khawaja and his counterpart Travis Head.

The match had already been delayed on Tuesday due to rain.

The subplot to the clash is the supposed bat-off between Khawaja and Head, who are competing for a middle-order berth in the first Test after being included in the Ashes squad.

The decision to call stumps early on day one didn’t go down well with former South Australian and Test cricketer Chadd Sayers, who tweeted: “So when bowlers think it’s too flat, they just walk off?”

Former Test batter Greg Blewett quipped in response: “There wouldn’t be much play then! #sooks.” Blewett knows all about playing on bad pitches after copping a shocker in his Test career against the West Indies at the WACA.

Match referee Steve Davis explained why the game was halted on Tuesday.

“It’s not undulated,” Davis said of the pitch, per cricket.com.au.

“It’s an area where the ball is sticking a bit, so there’s obviously some dampness underneath.

“It’s only about a metre square, but obviously once you see a ball doing that, if you’re any sort of bowler you’re going to aim for that spot.

“There’s a potential of it being dangerous, so play has been suspended for today.

“It was obvious the umpires had some concerns, and the players had some concerns.

“There was a couple of people that were hit on the gloves and in the stomach area, and it was just behaving a bit unusually and that always gives you a bit of an alert.

“Both captains were very reasonable about it.”

Rift reportedly brewing between players and CA

Cricket Australia’s response to the Tim Paine scandal has reportedly angered his teammates.

According to a report in The Age, the players feel that Cricket Australia hasn’t done enough to support Paine in the wake of his resignation as Test captain last Friday.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

While allowing Paine to remain eligible for Ashes selection, Cricket Australia chairman Richard Freudenstein has said the wicketkeeper wouldn’t have survived as skipper in 2018 had the current board been in place when the sexting allegations were privately raised.

Test opener Marcus Harris said he was unaware of any tension between the players and CA on Wednesday.

“We [some of the Ashes squad] are obviously up here in quarantine in Queensland. I’ve been seeing some of that stuff play out in the media a little bit, but nothing that I’m aware of,” Harris said.

Cricket Tasmania released an extraordinary statement on Tuesday, describing CA’s treatment of Paine as “appalling” and “the worst since Bill Lawry over 50 years ago”.

The Australian Cricketers’ Association has also spoken out in defence of Paine, saying it was “saddened” that he felt the need to resign over a historical mistake when he’d been cleared of code of conduct breaches in Cricket Tasmania and Cricket Australia investigations.

Waugh takes issue with Bailey stepping aside

Meanwhile, Australian great Mark Waugh has taken issue with chief selector George Bailey recusing himself from a potential debate about Paine’s selection for the first Test.

Bailey, who played state cricket with Paine and is a co-franchisee of a Hobart gym with his good mate, told the Cricket, Et Cetera podcast that he would step aside and allow Justin Langer and Tony Dodemaide to decide Paine’s fate if it came down to a vote.

“I’ve got a bit of an issue about this,” Waugh told Fox Sports’ The Back Page.

“George Bailey is a great guy, very well-respected and played with a lot of these guys not that long ago so he’s got links with them. But if you’re chairman of selectors, it is your job to make the decision. You’ve got to make the tough calls.

“I find this really weird. What happens if it is one-all? Tony Dodemaide and Justin Langer are the other two selectors. What happens if they can’t agree? Who makes the decision then if George Bailey is not going to make it?

“I think this could come back to haunt George as well because there are a lot of players in the backend of their career who George played with – David Warner, Aaron Finch, Matthew Wade.

“He’s going to have to make tough decisions on these players and he is still quite close to them. This is going to have to be sorted out. Either George stays as chairman and makes the decisions or he steps down and is a selector, not the chairman.”

The Crowd Says:

2021-11-27T00:50:10+00:00

Rohan

Roar Rookie


I think your point is, CA had no business appointing Bailey as Chairman of selectors when there were glaring conflicts of interest with the current playing group, especially with the captain. And Bailey should not have accepted the position when he was obviously conscious of the high likelihood of that conflict coming to the fore immediately.

2021-11-26T00:54:19+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


That's a really good question. For well over a century, the various iterations of the Australian Cricket Board have self-served for sure and time & again, the players have been shafted. In this instance, I think the players both assumed and expected the Board to either say/do nothing and let the issue pass, or stick up for Paine, knowing two cricket administrations had looked at the issue and made rulings years earlier. in hindsight, you're right, the players were naive to expect anything different, but in their place, I'd have expected the same. Given this mornings announcement about Tim Paine, I'll bet there's some very angry Aussie Test players out there.

2021-11-25T23:48:35+00:00

Gus O

Roar Rookie


I’m only just become aware of Paine stepping down and the associated fiasco this week, so I’ve missed plenty. My question: is there no suggestion of a deal being done whereby Paine retains his spot for the ashes if he resigns the captaincy immediately and “voluntarily”?

2021-11-25T23:39:17+00:00

Gus O

Roar Rookie


I’m wondering when the playing group ever thought the ACB / CA administration “had their backs”? Time and again it has been anything but. Don’t the administrators always put their own interest first during their tenure as “owners” of the game?

2021-11-25T06:08:20+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Wait...what's the implication there, Head is a Taurus? And thus good captaincy material?

2021-11-25T06:02:17+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Audaciously chosen captains usually workout. Grab the bull by the horns.

2021-11-25T05:59:48+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


They both deserve to be there. Just a shame Harris has basically been guaranteed a spot not really on merit. :unhappy:

2021-11-25T05:53:11+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Head now securing his spot in the test team. I hope Ussie scores well, having come in early.

2021-11-25T05:28:33+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Doing great today. Not sure he'd be an auto VC if selected for the test side. That's a pretty audacious prediction Rowdy! :shocked:

2021-11-25T05:22:25+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Perhaps I'm suffering "Momentary Lapse of Reason"? ------- If he's selected l wouldn't be at all surprised if he's VC.

2021-11-25T05:10:51+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


you sure?

2021-11-25T05:07:53+00:00

Mick Gold Coast QLD

Roar Guru


Who would have thunk that might happen!!! :stoked: :silly: :laughing:

2021-11-25T04:58:28+00:00

Mick Gold Coast QLD

Roar Guru


I'm pleased to hear that nics. I have made another comment which may interest you, on a thread appearing yesterday but quickly crowded out today: "No room for Justin Langer on CA's five-person panel to make captaincy call" https://www.theroar.com.au/2021/11/23/no-room-for-justin-langer-on-cas-five-person-panel-to-make-captaincy-call/?comment_id=8262263#comments-section The game we grew up with, served as fathers and welcomed with much admiration, is disintegrating before our eyes. I say it is a damn shame the younger supporters will not experience the joy and simple pleasures it offered to us.

2021-11-25T03:29:00+00:00

Tom


Hunt was absolutely plumb if he didn’t hit it, didn’t look like he did to me. Renshaw and Marnus intimidating? Lol you make me laugh Don

2021-11-25T02:53:51+00:00

Insult_2_Injury

Roar Rookie


Couldn't agree more. When I was C of S (Not Australia, by the way) my policy was the discussions between selectors were in house and the player in question the only one to know of decisions. Sometimes decisions were heated, sometimes compromises needed, but not everyone needs to be aware of that. That can be criticised as not transparent enough by some, but there's no need to have a decision made for a certain situation being used for or against a player every time he is dropped or plays in a different role. My policy also included if the player made the conversation and reasoning public, then I or another selector was within their rights then to clarify if the story wasn't accurate. I always found it successful, because the players appreciated the privacy and chance to meet selection criteria without others second guessing them, or outright white anting which I'd seen in the past.

2021-11-25T02:30:19+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Just watching SA follow on. The LBW that sacked Hunt and the caught at silly leg off Carey's thigh pad were atrocious. It wasn't even a case of 'benefit of the doubt'. They were just not out. Renshaw's mouth and Labuschagne's mouth intimidate these umpires.

2021-11-25T02:25:11+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I like Harris' suggestion that the players have no issue either way...apart from wanting their mate treated with respect. It seems the players are allowing the media and social media have our fun as we wield "absolute truths" while they just get on with preparing for the Ashes.

2021-11-25T00:59:59+00:00

nics

Roar Rookie


As a "younger fan" I see plenty of issued with Smith retaking the captaincy.

2021-11-24T21:21:48+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


"Head Decapitates Chance @ #5" screams the "Adelaide Advertiser". Or whatever they really did write.

2021-11-24T21:21:29+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


Amongst many other things...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar