Ashes Scout: Clarke's 'no-brainer' keeper call, Smith reveals sweet revenge on legend, Stokes' near-death experience

By Tim Miller / Editor

With only one week to go until the Ashes begins, former Australian captain Michael Clarke believes there is only one choice the selectors can make to replace the departed Tim Paine as wicketkeeper for the first Test.

Welcome back to Ashes Scout, where The Roar keeps you up to speed with everything you need to know from Australia and abroad as the tension dials up to 11 and the countdown begins in earnest.

>> Missed the last edition of Ashes Scout? Catch up here

The identity of Paine’s replacement with the gloves following the former captain’s shock call to take a mental health break and rule himself out of at least the start of the series continues to be shrouded in mystery.

Vying for the top job are South Australian ‘keeper Alex Carey, Paine’s long-term heir apparent and the ODI gloveman; as well as in-form Western Australian Josh Inglis, who was named in Australia’s triumphant T20 World Cup squad after a dominant 2021 in all forms of cricket.

Aussie assistant coach Andrew McDonald did nothing to shed any light in a recent press conference, saying the wicketkeeper’s spot in the XI was ‘really still up in the air’.

“I think if it was clear then there would have been an announcement, so I’m sure that the selectors will be taking all the information in the last game today, I think, domestically before we switch out our focus into the Test match,” McDonald said.

However, Clarke, who captained Australia to a 5-0 Ashes whitewash over England in the 2013-14 series, believes picking Carey is now a ‘no-brainer’, following the Redback’s scintillating century in Sunday’s Marsh Cup match against Queensland, to emphatically end a poor run of form.

“The dude just made a hundred!” Clarke said on Sky Sports Radio’s Big Sports Breakfast.

“Talk about under pressure: Alex Carey walks out, under the most amount of pressure, everyone fighting for a job, people questioning, ‘Is he next in line?’… and he makes a hundred.

“Come on. This guy is ready.”

While admitting his knowledge of Inglis is limited to ‘a handful of short-form games’, Clarke believes the Western Australian is a longer-term option for international responsibility.

“I don’t know Josh Inglis at all… he looks like he’s very talented, he’s got all the shots in the world… he might have a bright future,” Clarke said.

“But right now, to me, it’s a no-brainer.”

Alex Carey of South Australia celebrates reaching a century during day three of the Sheffield Shield match between Victoria and South Australia at Junction Oval on October 12, 2019 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Kelly Defina/Getty Images)

McDonald isn’t letting Carey’s Marsh Cup ton do all the talking, though, saying Inglis has been ‘starved of opportunities’ for a similar game-changing knock himself.

“It’s white-ball cricket, but any form is good form as we like to say,” McDonald said of Carey’s effort.

“Obviously we’ve got Josh Inglis in camp with us at the moment, so he’s starved for match opportunities. Alex Carey was named in Australia A squad as a keeper as well. So we’ve got some options.

“And that’s the beauty of it, it’s always better to have options than no options. So look forward to whichever way that goes and the start of someone’s career.”

For his part, Inglis is confident his rapid rise into international contention – he wasn’t in either Australia’s 19-man Test or 18-man T20I squads named in January this year – has left him primed to make an impact should he get the nod.

“Last season was obviously a standout for myself – it’s probably the first really good season I’ve had,” Inglis said on Monday of a Sheffield Shield campaign that netted 585 runs, three centuries and an average of over 73, on top of an outstanding BBL with the Perth Scorchers.

“It’s quite crazy to think how far I have come in a short space of time. It’s really exciting for myself.

“I’m feeling really confident about my game at the moment. Given the opportunity, I feel like I’d do a good job.”

One way or the other, Australia will be welcoming a Test debutant into the Ashes cauldron next week.

Smith reveals legend’s sledge played a part in Ashes heroics

Newly minted vice-captain Steve Smith has lifted the lid on his battle with anxiety immediately following the ‘Sandpapergate’ scandal that saw him stripped of the captaincy and handed a one-year ban; and how a cutting remark from Australian great Ian Chappell set him on a path back to his brilliant best.

In his own column for News Corp’s Code Sports, Smith wrote how receiving the deputy role to Pat Cummins following Paine’s resignation had been ‘like a weight… taken off my shoulders’, after years of speculation over whether he’d ever return to a leadership position.

“There had been so many questions in recent years about, ‘Is Steve going to be involved in the leadership again?’ so to have clarity on it was quite a relief,” Smith wrote.

“It’s an absolute honour to be asked to vice-captain but, as I’ve learned along the way, you don’t necessarily need an official title to be a leader within a team.”

Smith, who is sharing his experiences in the aftermath of ‘Sandepapergate’ to schoolchildren as part of the Gotcha4Life mental health charity created by media personality Gus Worland, also opened up on his issues with ‘what I know now were anxiety attacks’ following the Cape Town catastrophe in March 2018.

“I had never been someone who shared how I was feeling with others, so when the controversy after South Africa exploded, I was not emotionally equipped to deal with it,” Smith wrote.

The darkest period was the time between being handed my ban and fronting the press conference to talk about it.

“There was a shortness of breath at times, to the point where it felt like I was struggling to breathe, and I know now that they were anxiety attacks.

“I had never experienced anything like it before.”

(Photo by Brook Mitchell/Getty Images)

Smith likens the feeling to ‘blowing into a balloon’, saying that ‘the pressure builds and builds and builds’, and that ‘you have to find a way to release it or you, like the balloon, will pop’.

He credits Worland and his work with Gotcha4Life in helping him become a more well-rounded person away from the cricket pitch.

“I lost a lot in that period [after Sandpapergate], and that was fair enough because what happened in South Africa was wrong. But I think I gained a lot at the same time and I think it’s made me a better person,” Smith wrote.

“I feel more balanced rather than just being cricket crazy the whole time.”

Smith also credits a comment from former Australian captain Ian Chappell during his time out of the game, claiming he’d never be the same player following his return, as fuelling his desire to get back to the top of the sport.

“I’m not sure that he will be as good a player as he was, because confidence is a big part of his game and that’s going to have taken a fair hit,” Chappell told Sports Sunday in late 2018. Smith took the jibe personally.

“In the first couple of series after my ban, I was probably more driven by a motivation to prove my critics wrong,” Smith wrote in his column.

“Ian Chappell had written a column saying I wouldn’t be the same batter after my year away from the game. I cut it out, stuck it on my bathroom mirror and looked at it every morning and night when I brushed my teeth.”

Smith went on to torment England in the 2019 Ashes series, piling on 774 runs at an average of 110.57 to be the hero of Australia’s defence of the urn.

“It felt like I was saying to the critics: ‘I haven’t lost it. I’m still here’,” Smith wrote of his sensational series.

“It was a good feeling after everything that had gone on.”

‘This might be the end’: The moment that had Ben Stokes fearing for his life

As his preparation for a Test return at the Gabba continues, England star Ben Stokes has revealed a bizarre recent incident led to a near-death experience.

Writing in The Mirror, the gun all-rounder, who hasn’t played any form of cricket since July after undergoing finger surgery and taking a mental health break from the game, has opened up on a frightening moment when he choked on a tablet, and was left fearing for his life.

“[The tablet] went down the wrong way, and got stuck in my windpipe causing me to choke horribly before the glands in my face went into overdrive to flush it out,” Stokes wrote.

“Until it actually came out, I thought this might be the end. We’ve all had those moments when something gets stuck in the throat.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

“Without going into too much detail I have never seen as much saliva as I did on Sunday morning, it was a genuinely frightening experience.

“The team doctor came to see me straight away and she explained what had happened with the body reacting the way it did. I’m glad it did, even though I was a mess.”

While Stokes didn’t reveal precisely when and where the incident occurred, it’s believed to have taken place in the team hotel on the Gold Coast.

Stokes has been a tormentor with both bat and ball for Australia since making his debut in England’s ill-fated 2013-14 series whitewash down under, but not even the most ardent baggy green fans would have been hoping for the 30-year old’s series to be ended in that fashion.

It wasn’t the only medical scare Stokes has had in recent days, with the all-rounder revealing a painful blow in the nets also left him fearing his tour could be over before it had begun.

“I got hit on the forearm by a ball from our batting coach Jonathan Trott. I was in agony, and I couldn’t lift it thereafter. I thought it was broken,” Stokes wrote.

“Thankfully the pain and reaction settled down once I was back in the dressing room and the physios could be sure it wasn’t actually a break.

“It was only after I got back to my hotel room that I took stock of what a day I’d had. The adrenaline had worn off and I was exhausted.

“Happy that I’m here to tell the tale, but hoping that my pre-Test dramas are now over.”

>> Check out the full Ashes fixture

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-01T16:07:33+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Agreed - it's great to have a few good candidates for the role.

2021-12-01T00:55:42+00:00

Rohan

Roar Rookie


If you want to clean up a mess, throw out the rubbish,

2021-12-01T00:53:16+00:00

Rohan

Roar Rookie


For what it's worth. I have been very impressed with the improvement in Phillipe's keeping recently. He clearly has been putting in a lot of work. To the quicks, his movement is early and in the right direction, his footwork has good cadence and is large amplitude, hands position also looks good. I have only seen him keep to spin in T20. Inglis now and develop Phillipe' too at test level. Iv'e been a big Carey fan for 3-4 seasons now. Selectors failed to get him in (another one), and he has't developed the top level skills, gets wrong footed too often, sad really.

2021-11-30T22:00:06+00:00

Rohan

Roar Rookie


Steve Smith is perfectly capable at 3 and averages 60 each time at crease, compared with 61 in at 4. He should be stepping up, not being protected, he should be playing for the team, not for himself. That way we shore up the top order and can develop strength in the middle order, which has been neglected for so long we have been putting our best batter in there, and attempting to find someone “safe” to follow just in case of collapse; it’s not working. Green at 4 and Renshaw or Head at 5. Green looks like he’s gonna deliver with the bat, I hope Pat Cummins can mentor his bowling match play, and turn him into a good shock bowler, that’s all he should be. Renshaw seems to have found himself lower down the order and bats well with the tail. I’m still not convinced by Head at test level, the best bowlers always seem to work him out. I think its a good idea to put a buffer between Smith and batters he has less confidence in because he can be guilty of holding the strike and his batting partner loses concentration.

2021-11-30T10:58:11+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Guest


Whiteman before his finger injury would taken the keeper's spot. Bancroft could keep for any other state. Phillipe has kept for Aus. Inglis is the best in Australia, Carey 2nd by a whisker and isn't there a rule that SA and WA can only have one player each in the Test team? So if Richardson comes in for Starc, that's WA's quota,if Head beats out Khawaja that's SA's. Does that mean Peirson gets the gig?

2021-11-30T06:48:06+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


I thought he was going to the gallows that’s the hatred & applause all rolled into one when young Adam walked out poor young man must have been wearing nappy

2021-11-30T05:39:42+00:00

Tempo

Roar Rookie


Hasn't this basically been the case for the last 20 years? Adam Gilchrist only played another 9 Sheffield Shield games after making his test debut. Multi-format players just don't play in the Shield much and selectors like picking the best players in multiple formats. I guess it's up to selectors to decide if Carey or whoever's keeping is up to the required standard for test matches. If it isn't, go with someone else who is playing more red ball cricket.

2021-11-30T05:38:16+00:00

13th Man

Roar Rookie


I'd go for that team except I'd still back in Lyon ahead of Swepson for the time being. I don't think anyone seriously thinks Lyons spot is under threat just yet.

2021-11-30T04:27:27+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


“ Stokes has been a tormentor with both bat and ball for Australia since making his debut in England’s ill-fated 2013-14 series whitewash down under.” This has become one of those ideas that has entrenched itself thanks to repetition, on the back of the trauma of Stokes’s Headingly innings. But it’s not really grounded in reality: Stokes’s batting averages in 3 series vs Australia were 34, 25 and 55, with an overall average of 38. His two tons other than Headingly were in a big loss in 2013 and the Lords draw in 2019. His bowling average vs Australia is 37. Saying he has been a tormentor across his career is a bit like saying Mike Gatting, Robin Smith and Derek Randall or John Emburey tormented Australia (hint: they didn’t, though none of them won a match off his own bat or ball as Stokes did on one occasion.)

2021-11-30T04:13:23+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


I don;t want to weaken one position to try and fix another. Labs has been a gun number three so lets leave him there.

2021-11-30T04:13:21+00:00


Agree, Inglis, 26. Carey, 30 and has already peaked most likely. Even if Tim Paine comes back the last couple of tests and goes to Pakistan next year, Inglis has a LOT of time to cement himself and play for a decade, if not more. Carey is merely a pretender for the long term keeper spot. We really dont want to waste another 20 tests like we did with Neville.

2021-11-30T04:11:13+00:00


Warnie just shoots his mouth off to make headlines and keep himself relevant. I'd genuinely take Clarke's comments with a lot less salt, given he isnt calling for players to be dropped every second week

2021-11-30T04:10:33+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


I think another contender, Pierson, may have actually put down a chance from Carey in that innings. Irony.

2021-11-30T03:39:42+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


I was a huge fan of Labs being selected from first uk ashes test . He had great lead up county form and intra aus and early lead up form . He was way more forward than inglis for selection . The irony is it took smith getting knocked out by archer to at lord’s to get a labs a start . I recall Jeff and I both wrote on here before the first test and listed labs In our starting xvs . Many disagreed with both of us . On Carey’s form in England I argued for him to be in first test like Alan border did , as a batsmen as he was red hot with bat . They wouldn’t pick him and I felt it cost us with bat as he was mastering uk pitches in the lead up big time. Coming in to this ashes I can’t vouch for inglis the same way he’s just had zero cricket in last few months despite his clear talent . Labs had huge lead up form as did Carey for the uk ashes . Admittadly with rain around this week the whole lead up to these ashes is a complete shambles but carry has had a way better preparation and has that international experience

2021-11-30T02:18:39+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Selectors have to take into account what they've seen in recent years, as well as what guys are producing now, be it in Shield games or where ever. We had the situation in 2019 where some bloke name Labuschagne scrapped into the Test side for the Ashes, on the strength of what selectors saw in the knocks he had in the Australia warm up matches. Granted he'd been playing cricket before that, but he was no chance to get a game till then. If Inglis looks a million bucks over the the next week and Carey doesn't, why not pick Inglis Like you, I'm not hugely fussed, but it come down to that.

2021-11-30T02:14:20+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


True enough. I'm sure the selectors individually, are at odds with each other over who to pick, just as we are. The nice thing is, any of these guys will do a terrific job, for sure.

2021-11-30T02:12:55+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


HR has a point Paul. Inglis hasn’t played for months. Paine for 9 months . Im not sure how many can’t accept that as a poor lead up to ashes . It has to be carey with any common sense at the moment. I do like Inglis a lot though and would not hesitate to select him later in series, maybe for batting, if we hold a winning lead to qualify him for Australia and prevent him from playing for England given he has a large chance of becoming Australias keeper in short to mid term (next 2 to 4 years ) or sooner if careys form is not good enough over 3 or 4 tests with gloves/bat

2021-11-30T02:08:32+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Paul, I wouldn’t put it in Clarkes words no and I think theres not much in it with carey and inglis but I think Carey has had a settled spring at home with some good knocks despite a few bad shield matches , he’s also keeping well enough but critically he has that international experience Inglis doesn’t have yet. I wouldn’t be upset if Inglis got picked actually but my instant pick would be carey given his last two years in general and his international exposure and experience. His 60* and 32 was a good pair and he had a soft tricky deck last shield match where the match was suspended so it wasn’t easy to bat on. Head and Labs were the only two to master it and that shows their worth for the test selection all be it on a non test match pitch. Theres no huge rush with Inglis and a non playing t20 build up doesn’t sit well with me although I think he will be the go to in the future (despite his english accent) . The white ball century on weekend was a great knock by carey. We have to go with him subject to the all Australian match unleashing ambiguous results again

2021-11-30T02:00:34+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Carey has at least played Shield cricket and he's keeping pretty well there.

2021-11-30T00:32:05+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


I realise that James but that doesn’t change the fact they played him knowing he wasn’t the best keeper in Australia but chose him based on his batting prowess. I’m not disagreeing with you!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar