'A great toss to lose': A few thoughts on the first Test

By Paul / Roar Guru

Isn’t it great to have Test match cricket back in our lives in Australia? It seems like forever since we could cheer on the national team, though it’s only been ten months.

New captain, new keeper, but the same old enemy. Here are a few thoughts on the match.

The Gabba Test has to be played before Christmas – the pitch served up for this Test has been a beauty. Batsmen on both sides have had to tough it out and the bowlers, when they’ve bowled well, have reaped rewards.

The pitch for the corresponding match last series was relatively tame by comparison and favoured the batsmen for far too much of the game. Coincidence it was a match played in mid-January? I think not.

Hopefully Cricket Australia takes note and asks the Brisbane curators for something similar in future Tests.

What a great toss to lose – Pat Cummins said he’d have batted if he’d won the toss, which would likely have been a mistake. As it was, he got first crack with the ball and made a series statement, bowling out England in 50 overs.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Hameed looks like a good opening bat – he looks like an old-fashioned opener. He left the ball extremely well and looked compact and composed at the crease. I guess the only question is whether he’s limited in his scoring options, but if he remains patient, I suspect he could make some useful scores this series.

Alex Carey has fitted in seamlessly – Brett Lee made the comment that the keeper had hardly been sighted which was a good thing and he’s right.

Carey had almost as good as start to his first Test behind the stumps, as his skipper did with the ball. And eight catches puts him into the record books for a keeper on debut.

(Photo by Mark Brake/Getty Images for 2022 T20 World Cup )

What was equally impressive was how well he marshalled the field, making sure the placements set were in the right positions. It clearly something the Australian brains trust has worked on, but it’s a good thing and takes some of the workload off Cummins.

When’s the last time England had a faster bowler than Australia? I’m happy to stand corrected, but I’d have to go back to the Devon Malcom days to remember when England had a bowler faster than any in the Australian attack.

Mark Wood is seriously quick. I hope the broadcasters do the right thing and show slow-motion footage of his action from both front-on and side-on. This guy has a terrific action.

However, England bowlers fell for the three-card trick – the long first session on the second day should have been a much tougher assignment for Australia than it proved to be, mostly because the England bowlers got it wrong.

The commentators were making lots of noise about the batsmen playing and missing, but in reality, the bowling was often too short, too wide of off-stump, or both.

Far too often, Marnus Labuschagne in particular was easily able to let deliveries go and if David Warner had been in his very best form, he’d have followed suit.

There’s no argument England created at least six or eight chances, but on that pitch, they should have created double that.

Mark Wood looked spectacular at times with the carry he got through to Jos Buttler, but that’s only because the ball was rocketing high, wide and handsome over the stumps.

When they pitch up consistently, the English bowlers troubled all batsmen, but that simply was not happening often enough. They need to get this right before they get to Adelaide, otherwise they could waste the new ball and allow Australia to make a big score.

Australia’s batting plan is not exactly subtle – Jack Leach came on and from ball one, there was clear intent to belt him out of the attack. No milking of runs, or hitting the odd boundary.

Apart from denting Leach’s confidence, it must have put Root in a tough spot, trying to manage his attack. He’d clearly like Leach to bowl long, containing spells to rest his quicks, but if there’s no containment, that forces his other bowlers to get through more work.

Root talked up Leach after the match as “a fine spinner” but I‘d be very surprised the see him in the English XI for Adelaide.

Jack Leach and Joe Root had bad days at the office (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Targeting Leach to the tune of 13 overs for 102 by Australia could also have long-term ramifications for the series. Tests are relatively close together and the England fast bowlers have already done more work than they would have liked.

Australia won the series in the first key moment – or rather, England lost it
Australia had managed to make 30 pretty sketchy runs when Ben Stokes managed to swing one back into Dave Warner, hit his back leg, then hit the top of off stump. Great delivery – well, no, because it was a no ball.

Steve Smith coming in against a newish ball is a very different proposition than the same batsman coming in with the opposition first innings total passed.

Speaking of Steve Smith – there’s a song by the Captain Matchbox Whoppee Band called ‘I Can’t Dance (I’ve Got Ants in My Pants)’.

That was the way Steve Smith appeared to be batting in the first innings. He’s clearly an eccentric with his actions but he seemed out of sorts. Hopefully he settles down and starts to bat less frenetically.

A small comment on Oliver Matthews’ excellent blog caught my attention – it was a warning about slow over rates by Australia and the author was absolutely right. In two full sessions, Australia got through only 50 overs and Nathan Lyon and Cameron Green, with his short run-up, bowled nearly 25 per cent of these.

It probably makes no difference if the team is bowling out the opposition, but if they’re not, getting through 80 or 82 overs in a day’s play could be costly, as Justin Langer and co found out last summer.

And 84 overs is all England managed to get through on day 2, despite an extra hour’s play and the spinners bowling 16 overs.

That was a fine batting partnership between Dawid Malan and Joe Root – England can take heart that Malan in Australia could be the answer they’ve been looking for at No.3.

Joe Root and Dawid Malan leave the field after Day 3 of the first Ashes Test (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

The England openers are a bit shaky, which is understandable against Cummins, Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood, but what they’ve needed is someone to stem the bleeding if they lose an early wicket.

It’s still too early to know if Malan can make the first drop role his own, but judging by his batting on day 3, he’s got the technique and patience to match the Australian attack.

When too much technology is simply too much
What’s with this nonsense about launch angles from the bat? I gather this is something some genius has picked up from baseball and decided it fits into cricket.

Listening to commentators rabbiting on about something, where they clearly have no idea, is really starting to hurt the ears, especially when it has no bearing on any part of the game.

What’s with the Travis Head moustache? Alan Border thought he was looking a bit of a Boonie but I thought he looked like a stumpy version of Tom Selleck as Magnum PI. It’s not a good look but if he gets a heap of runs as he did this match, who cares?

A small thing that could help Marcus Harris – I know it was only ten deliveries but I think Harris will take plenty of positives from his brief second innings. He played a couple of nice shots, including the winning boundary, and, most importantly, he remained not out.

Best remark of the series so far: in the first session of the match, Lyon had just bowled and Cummins brought on Cameron Green for his first over. One of the commentators said: “Do you realise this pair has nearly 400 Test wickets between them?”

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-15T10:22:33+00:00

Ball Burster

Roar Rookie


Your article only improves with age. I daresay someone will tell us about the launch angle, but in the meantime we must assume it's got something to do with whether the batsman has hit it over the fielder's head. NB: Captain Matchbox were excellent at Sunbury.

2021-12-12T20:09:02+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Good analysis Paul. I agree completely on England bowling too short. It’s such an easy trap to fall into in Australia. The bowlers get excited by the bounce and the plays and misses and bang it in. The problem is the ball moves too far by the time it gets to the batter. This was another reason why now of Broad or Anderson should have been to there to provide their experience to their young pace bowlers.

2021-12-12T08:30:56+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Cheers Paul. I tend to agree..

2021-12-12T04:11:56+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Good summary Paul. For me, the best thing to come out of the match was Cam Green’s bowling. He’s got all the tools as a bowler and finally it looks like he’s learning to bowl a testing length. If he can do that consistently, with his height and weight of delivery, he can be a very effective Test bowler in most conditions.

2021-12-12T00:02:19+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Queensland has elected to field 11 times from their 15 toss wins at the Gabba in the last 7 seasons. You'd thin the Bulls would be best placed of anyone to know the wicket and conditions.

2021-12-11T23:50:30+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Stokes no ball only counts if we say he was unlucky that the umpires detected it! Foot back 7-10 centimetres, no guarantee of bowling the same ball. The others still a bit hypothetical for me also.

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T22:11:17+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


completely agree about Brett Lee. If you're coaching youngsters who want to bowl fast, his is a great action to use as a template. Wood's action is tough to copy, mostly because the player has to be very strong to cope with the strain. He's already had plenty of injuries, whereas Lee had far less.

2021-12-11T13:18:17+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


The decision seemed to be made based on the 2002 Gabba test match where the wicket was a lot different, the weather was a lot different and Hussain bowled first. Then he got lampooned enormously for that, I would say Hussains decision was very bad but this was worse. Making a decision on whats going to get the best reaction if it goes wrong. The only way of knowing what Cummins would have done was if he won the toss, there was a launch with a giant ashes urn and a interview with both captains. Cummins was talking up the wicket, so maybe Cummins has played Root.

2021-12-11T12:36:39+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


- Warner split the slips early on. Arguable whether it should have been taken. - Warner bowled by Stokes. The "no ball". Ultimately England's fault, though umpires didn't help. Still... - Hameed fluffed Warner run out - Burns dropped Warner - Root had his slip cordon too far back and Labs nick fell short (Root subsequently brought the cordon forward which confirms it was an error by England and cost them Labs wicket early) 3 to 5 misses for mine. As I said, Australia took all first 10 opportunities presented. It only takes 2 or 3 misses from the opposition to set the match on a different trajectory.

2021-12-11T12:28:11+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Although England didn’t miss that many dismissal chances as some commentators suggested. Just Warner missed catch by Burns and missed run out by Hameed? But might have made a big difference.

2021-12-11T10:46:32+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Fair enough but Brett Lee always had a beautiful action I thought and he was quick. And of course going back to all the WI legends of old. Each to their own.

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T10:38:05+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I can see your point in one way about Wood's action, but it's a very aggressive way to bowl and I'd suggest only a very strong man would be able to bowl using this action and generate the pace he does.

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T10:35:05+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


did you see this little gem on the CA website "Joe Root's team docked five World Test Championship points and fined 100 per cent of their match fee for slow over rate" So you've just got hammered in the opening test of the series and not only that, you've got no money to show for your efforts? https://www.cricket.com.au/news/england-penalised-slow-over-rates-gabba-test-ashes-australia-world-test-championship-joe-root/2021-12-11

2021-12-11T09:08:59+00:00

peterj

Roar Rookie


Great article and analysis agree with nearly everything. However, I literally said to my mate this morning it’s no surprise that Wood spends so much time out as his action is horrid. He will barely be able to move when he’s finished playing. I’m certain one of the reasons why Jimmy Anderson is still playing and doing well in the right conditions, is that his action is so perfect. All the kids I coach that’s the action I tell them to mirror. Shame he’s such a (what travis head said )

2021-12-11T08:23:46+00:00

Simoc

Roar Rookie


I just saw a comment on the BBC that setting Australia a target of 20 runs was setting the bar a bit low and they need to aim a bit higher if they want to win. True. A target of 300 in the 4th innings would have been difficult. While I advocate batting first in a test this was an occasion where it didn't look the best option ( couldn't believe they left Broad out). The weather forecasts were way out which is back to normal after a month where they were right (eg rain, rain, rain). but they let Warner off and Head came off big time. Woakes wasn't as good as the others so Broad was a big miss there.

2021-12-11T08:09:32+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Hi Paul, Perhaps a bit of holding Green back, but he's been bowling decent spells - and multiple spells - for WA this season. So he's good to go re lengthy bowling. Jhye and Joel Paris (with Matt Kelly and Cam Gannon) tend to take the new ball). Green's sweet spot has been 3 over spells; WA has good pace depth to share the workload around. These are Green's bowling spells this Shield season. South Australia 1st innings (10th-86th) -5, 3, 3, 3 Tasmania 1st innings (6th-72nd) - 1, 5, 3, 3 2nd innings (22nd-44th) - 2, 3 South Australia 1st innings (28th-48th) - 5, 1 2nd innings (18th-65th) - 2, 5, 3 Queensland 1st innings (12th-45th) - 4, 4 2nd innings (14th-79th) - 3, 3, 3, 3, 3 Tasmania 1st innings (25th-96th) - 2, 3, 3, 2 2nd innings (11th-67th) - 4, 2, 3 ----- 89 overs across 5 matches/9 innings.

2021-12-11T07:09:09+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


And what a difference that Hazelwood catch made for young Green with his first wicket. I reckon the relief on Hazelwood’s face and when he did that slow two handed fist pump, was more about getting Green his wicket than taking the catch for Australia.

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T07:03:54+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I'm not sure there are any fortunate photos of Jack Leach AMD. :happy: I didn't listen to the ABC call, but it's a shame Chappelli appears to have become so negative. I wonder if it's not another occasion of a cricketer trying to have one season too many?

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T06:59:37+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Yeah, I'm not sure if they're still holding back on bowling Green because of his previous injuries. I thought he was underused in the second innings, more than the first.

AUTHOR

2021-12-11T06:57:07+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


“Quick off the mark Paul!” Not as quick as the editors Dave. From the time I got the email acknowledging they received the piece till I got the next one saying it was published was 21 minutes. You are spot on about those Hazlewood catches. I heard a comment from Steve Harmison who said he’d have taken those two on the second bounce.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar