FLEM'S VERDICT: Here's how you can shake the nightwatchman job forever, Scotty

By Bowlologist / Expert

Unfortunately for England, their innings on day two in Hobart summed up their whole summer.

There were plenty of promising starts – Zak Crawley hit a few fours, Joe Root made 34, Sam Billings and Chris Woakes put on a bit of a partnership – but no one went on to get a big score once again.

It was just an average, middle of the road score in a day-night Test, but it probably magnifies Travis Head’s first-day hundred.

What he did at 3-12 in tougher conditions, England were unable to do.

There’s been plenty of talk about the pitch, but I’d still give it a tick from my end. It’s quite hard underneath the grass covering, and aside from that first hour on day one and the last session on day two, I’ve always felt like the batsmen are in the game and they can score runs.

The conditions have certainly made for some entertaining cricket. It’s been a weird Test; it’s usually been bowler-dominated, the runs are low, but they’ve been scored at a pretty good rate.

What a day Nathan Lyon had, too… and he didn’t even need to bowl a single ball! First he came out and whacked 31 to get Australia above 300, and what a catch he took to dismiss Ben Stokes.

I think he needs to be the hooking batting coach for Australia. He got into such a good position for the shot, and then carved them up for those three sixes. I loved that.

To take that catch, seeing some of the drops from England this series, seeing our drops in the slips, was superb as well.

Captain Cummins was just super again as the spearhead of the bowling attack.

He’s had a couple of innings where he struggled to take his usual swag of wickets during the series, but even then I reckon the batsmen seldom get accustomed to his pace, bounce and movement. They’re constantly surprised by those three factors that he provides.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Scotty Boland probably had his most frustrating day of Test cricket bowling-wise, but he was let down by the slips. If he keeps bowling like that, though, things are bound to change. Mitchell Starc wasn’t at his best, but he’s a pink-ball superstar, so he still got a three-for.

Nightwatchman Scott Boland bats during day two of the fifth Ashes Test. (Photo by Matt Roberts – CA/Cricket Australia via Getty Images)

Speaking of the slip fielding, they really need to address that now.

Everyone’s talking about the way they space themselves out, and that they’re too tight. I’m not totally sure who organises that; I would have thought Alex Carey needs to have a big say as the wicketkeeper.

At times they definitely look a little bit too close together. They need to get that right.

We’ve already won this series, so these dropped catches aren’t going to hurt us significantly; but going to the subcontinent, if we’re not taking our catches behind the wicket, particularly early, it can cost you a series.

For England, at least they came out and they had a go last night. This was the best that Chris Woakes has bowled throughout the series, while the Stuart Broad-Dave Warner battle was again won by the Englishman to finish off Davey’s pair.

Without wanting to be negative and look back again, England had a chance on day one in Brisbane when they won the toss. Broad should have been playing ahead of Jack Leach, and if Root had chosen to bowl first, that first ball Broad would have been bowling to Warner and Marcus Harris.

Imagine what the atmosphere would have been like; he could have knocked them over in those swinging, seaming conditions.

The decisions made on day one at the Gabba continue to haunt them, particularly when Broad keeps bowling like this. What might have been for England.

As if it wasn’t enough for Boland to deal with all those dropped catches, then he had to go in as nightwatchman too!

As a young fella, I was thought to have quite a good technique; so I was nightwatchman for Victoria for the first three or four years, because they felt like I was reliable.

I hated it! I got hit a lot, so I made the decision to go to England and learn to play more shots.

All of a sudden I got labelled a stroke-player who was slightly unreliable, so I was never nightwatchman again!

So Scotty, I’d be playing my shots tomorrow, and you’d be hoping to pass that job back on to Nathan Lyon.

On the other hand, I don’t want him batting too long – get out before 70 (my Test best was 71)! I think Merv Hughes (72) would back me up there, and probably Paul Reiffel (79) as well.

England will need to almost bowl Australia out for under 200 to be a chance of winning the match. They only scored 188 in the first innings, and they haven’t scored 300 in the series.

But with Robinson now fit again after that back spasm on day one, that’s going to at least pose more questions for the Australians. They won’t necessarily be facing Root, so the bowling changes will continue to put pressure on.

The first hour’s massive – IF they can bowl as well as they did tonight. You’d take chasing anything under 300, but if they let Australia get to 200, I think that becomes too big a task, unless someone does a Travis Head.

The Crowd Says:

2022-01-16T13:35:45+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


A lot more bowling on far less forgiving pitches too. Between the hard pitches, the unhelpful surfaces and the heat, it's just a tougher job here. They can only be thankful that he wasn't here in an El Niño year.

2022-01-16T13:31:55+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Usually minimum of 20 innings seems to be the cut-off for batters. I’m not sure what the equivalent should be for bowlers, though Walters bowled 448.3 overs in tests (rather more than Cook’s 3.0 or Taylor’s 16.3). A cut-off of 100 wickets and 1000 runs is probably fair.

2022-01-16T11:10:59+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


MCG, SCG and now Tassie and Warner has 71 from his last 5 hits. Trending in the wrong direction and culminating here - - feel that - - and that can happen in 5 test series - - that he’s fallen right away and finished perhaps tired, and in a form slump. Ironic given how comfortable he looked in the first 2 tests and really felt like he recklessly threw away 100s. Anyway……I still maintain that I’ve seen it before that when he is ‘off’ it impacts his all round game, i.e. dropping catches and struggling with the bat.

2022-01-16T08:13:19+00:00

Stuckbetweenindopak

Roar Rookie


:stoked:

2022-01-16T08:10:12+00:00

Stuckbetweenindopak

Roar Rookie


I guess we will get better contrast from more darker or more lighter colour balls than we get from the pink ones.

2022-01-16T06:59:08+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Exactly. The guy might be 28, but how much experience has he had outside of English conditions, considering his test career just started recently? People forget about the common Stokes & Woakes style pace allrounders in county cricket who can bat anywhere from #4 to #8, and bowl a dozen overs a day as well. Not so common in Australia, where the three main pace bowlers have to back up for a lot more bowling!

2022-01-16T03:59:03+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


You'd probably need to say a minimum of 75 wickets or thereabouts. Otherwise, Ross Taylor and Alistair Cook are in with a shout.

2022-01-16T03:35:08+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Actually, in Starc's case.... :laughing:

2022-01-16T03:25:23+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


It’s interesting. No-one did it before the 80s. They started doing it in Tests I believe to con/convince the umpires into thinking there had been an edge for bat-pad catches off spinners. Since then it has spread like a disease against which there seems to be no immunity. If anyone did this when I played grade cricket in the 80s they would have been asked to pipe down in future, though hardly anyone ever did it. I can’t believe any really professional sports organisations with so-called professional coaches would allow this to continue.

2022-01-16T03:20:47+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


…Yelling at the bowler from mid-off “aim at the stumps” would be another useful addition to the repertoire!

2022-01-16T02:45:36+00:00

Rusty Brooks

Roar Rookie


It seemed to work well for the Windies team of the late Seventies.

2022-01-16T02:39:03+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Have been telling you for a long time Stuck to upgrade from your black and white TV :laughing:

2022-01-16T02:37:46+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Dress the players in pink and voila!

2022-01-16T02:34:41+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


It's just aimed at helping the fielder focus and I don't understand why the non-striker doesn't shout down the pitch "watch the ball" immediately after release :laughing:

2022-01-16T02:12:59+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Completely off-topic, but a note on all-rounders. You mentioned recently that the ideal all-rounder has a batting average above 40 and a bowling average below 30, and that no player meets this criteria at test level. You've neglected the Golden Arm himself! Doug Walters averaged 48.26 with the bat and 29.08 with the ball. Perhaps his number of wickets (49) disqualifies him?

2022-01-16T01:54:39+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


Broad, unfortunately for England, has completely lost his nerve against fast bowling.

2022-01-16T01:45:47+00:00

HR

Roar Rookie


I think you're right - the sustained effort required to take wickets on Australian pitches, combined with the temperature, have been a bit too much for him. He looked absolutely cooked in Adelaide.

2022-01-16T01:41:21+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


It's a reflex thing - but yes, not helpful as it can make the fielder tighten up

2022-01-16T01:40:06+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


Correct - Broad starts backing away after one short one. Get behind the line, watch the ball.

2022-01-16T01:37:10+00:00

hilsnz

Roar Rookie


Read somewhere he struggles to back up in County games too. Which beggars the question, why was he awarded a central contract and why was he selected for this tour when he hasn't put in the work to get himself fit enough to do his job?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar