Super Rugby tipping panel Week 1: Let us be more Pacific

By Brett McKay / Expert

Oh yes, we’re back.

Super Rugby Pacific is ready to kick off for 2022 and we will be right here alongside the competition as it works it way through a maiden campaign with a welcome Pacific flavour.

I’ve said this week that my gut feel is this is going to be a really tight competition, particularly around the fight for the 5-8 places on the table, which will naturally see teams taking points off each other every week.

And while that lends itself to a potentially wonderful year of rugby from a viewing perspective, it will make it awfully difficult to tip winners.

SUPER RUGBY WEEK 1 TEAMS

But that just makes the weekly Thursday staple all the more entertaining, as we cut the ribbon on the start of another year of Super Rugby tipping here on The Roar. How good!

LAST SEASON: Harry 56, Geoff 51, Digger 49, Brett 45, and The Crowd 31.

As the carryover champ, the Hairy Man has the honour.

Harry
Drua, Chiefs, Crusaders, Reds, Brumbies

Once upon a time, rugby was played without pods on attack. Forwards stayed in a group. Backs moved diagonally, dropping the pill. The mud won. Nobody knew a ref’s name. And as I said, no pods.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Now, attack schemes have props in pods making decisions for backs who play flat to the line and can catch one-handed while dying.

Similarly, writers used to just write. Now they cast pods. Podcasts. About pods. Casting aspersions.

Okay, so without much information on sequestered teams, but the reigning, and still undefeated champ, I will tip the following winners.

The Waratahs have adopted and adapted Flower of Scotland to sing about having a club in Sydney again. Drua by a heap.

Vinaya Habosi of Fijian Drua (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

The ruthless Chiefs will have too much for the canny Highlanders.

The Crusaders will, in theory, turn the Hurricanes orange. ‘Saders by more than plenty.

The Reds will run riot over the Rebels. The big Brumbies by ten over the plucky Force.

Sure thing
Everyone wants to be the next Mack Hanson.

Geoff
Waratahs, Highlanders, Crusaders, Reds, Force

It’s been an off-season like no other.

A severe dose of COVID, the ‘Tahs winning two trials, the Fijian Drua absolutely nailing it with their own beer, and everyone getting a good laugh out of watching the England rugby team scratching their heads wondering how Justin Langer could win the Ashes and get the arse from the players for being too intense, but they can’t do the same to Eddie?

Moana Pasifika will get pumped by the Blues, just not tomorrow as originally planned. And no joy either for the other newbies, with the ‘Tahs to get the job done against the Drua, who at least now have plenty of supplies on hand to drown their sorrows.

Assuming the NZ Herald’s Gregor Paul is on hand to help clean up the dog shit and beer cans from the ground, I’ll take a stab at the Highlanders edging the Chiefs. Meanwhile, at the Highlander’s real home ground, it will be the Crusaders, who can sometimes be slow starters, but not this year. They’ve listed an impressive 23, and will be too strong for the Wellington ‘Wee Winds’.

Later, in Brisbane, the Rebels unveil their secret weapon, letting local boy Sam Wallis loose against his own breed, but it’s too early for ‘Hail Mary’ bets against last year’s AU champions.

To Sunday, and there has to be one upset, so, built entirely on the premise that Izack Rodda is rabidly determined to show that he was right and Brad was wrong, I’m picking a triumphant return for the young ex-Brumbies to Canberra, this time decked out in Force blue.

Sure thing
After The Roar Rugby Podcast launched this week in pre-season trial mode, complete with a fringe squad player as a guest, I’m tipping now that they’re playing for points, the lads will go nuclear from here.

Digger
Waratahs, Highlanders, Crusaders, Reds, Brumbies

Well, there is a fair bit of negativity floating around about this new comp for one reason or another which is disappointing, but I have to say, bugger all that noise. I am excited and very much looking forward to it all.

Unfortunate that we have had to see the opening match postponed (Blues should take it, comfortably, when it does transpire) but I guess that is likely to be something we will have to get used to this season.

I am very excited about seeing the Drua in action. If they play with the same flair and style we saw in the NRC, they will be one to follow, however I suspect a resurgent and motivated Tahs will have a bit too much first up.

(Photo by Mark Evans/Getty Images)

Not really sure about the Chiefs, certainly a great looking pack but I suspect they will take some time to adjust without Damian Mackenzie to fall back on. I think the Highlanders will get up here and while I am excited about the Hurricanes and a number of the younger prospects, I just don’t think there is enough ‘smarts’ in the side, particularly in pivotal positions, and even more so with TJ injured.

A sneaky last-minute win in pre-season suggests there are no surprises to be had for the Crusaders just a week later and, sigh, a comfortable win seems likely for the red and blacks.

Back across the ditch, Reds look too strong for the Rebels with their injury concerns and playing at home while backing against the Brumbies in Canberra seems a tad silly, though it should be real tough encounter. Last year’s finalists to both start off with a bang.

Sure thing
Trevor Mallard will interrupt his James Blunt playlist to stream radio coverage of this weekend’s matches for the protestors to show he is not such a bad chap after all.

Brett
Waratahs, Chiefs, Crusaders, Reds, Brumbies

Well, I’m happy to provide an update for you all, having admitted in last week’s debut column for the year that I felt completely bloody unprepared for the rapidly approaching season.

Our experts Brett McKay and Geoff Parkes are off to a cracking start on The Roar Rugby Podcast as they tackle the state of play in the Six Nations and look ahead to the launch of Super Rugby Pacific. Click below to play or follow on Spotify.

And that update is that with a couple of columns now under my belt, a podcast teased and then launched to critical acclaim and much fanfare, and even a radio preview show for the ABC airing across the weekend, I can now confirm that I now feel somewhat better prepared.

For the first week of the season, I looked up and down the draw for the week trying to find an upset, and well… I just don’t think there’s one there this week.

I said on Tuesday that I do think the Drua will win in the first month, but I don’t think it’s this week and nor can I guarantee I’ll pick it anyway.

The NZ games look a bit obvious, which is obviously worrying, but I’m not sure the Highlanders and Hurricanes are quite yet good enough to beat more fancied rivals.

The Reds look too strong for the Rebels on paper, and I expect that to carry through on grass, and while I think the Brumbies-Force shapes as a really fascinating contest, I do think home ground advantage is at its strongest in Round 1.

On the topic of The Roar Rugby Podcast, a sincere thanks for all the feedback so far. It’s really cool to know so many of you enjoyed listening as much as we enjoyed putting it together. And if you’ve not tuned in yet, give it go!

Sure thing
This is going to my year, okay? And by ‘my year’, I don’t necessarily mean winning outright per se, just that I’m determined to see my tipping not become the aforementioned object of Gregor Paul’s affection this week. Call it a sure thing, call it a New Year’s resolution, all I know is I’m off to a good start.

Because the Blues will not disappoint me this week.

Round 1 Harry Geoff Digger Brett The Crowd
Overall 0 0 0 0 0
Last season 1st 4th 5th 6th 3rd
WAR v DRU Drua Waratahs Waratahs Waratahs Waratahs
CHI v HIG Chiefs Highlanders Highlanders Chiefs Chiefs
CRU v HUR Crusaders Crusaders Crusaders Crusaders Crusaders
RED v REB Reds Reds Reds Reds Reds
BRU v FOR Brumbies Force Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies

Get your tips in now – The Crowd’s tips will be revealed Friday afternoon AEDT.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-03-14T00:56:13+00:00

Ankle-tapped Waterboy

Roar Rookie


Hi Brett, apologies, I've been dealing with a medical matter. To unpack it in detail so the sequence answers "where did that come from?" so a bit of wordage here - The writer used "favouritism" which therefore says someone in power is able to influence the outcome. Otherwise some other word would have been used by the writer and condoned by the subeditor, if some other meaning was intended. So the first question for the reader upon reading this surprising sentence was "who has that power?" Knowledge of the game gives a choice of the administrators, bookies, and referees. Process of elimination - home and way advantage is handled by the way the draw is done. Rugby isn't corrupted like cricket. In the search for parties who can influence games through favouritism, the obvious choice is the referees. After all, claims of bias ring out everywhere at all levels and 2021 was a shockingly bad year for that. Given that we were just out of 2021 season and entering 2022, the writer's comment appeared to be an off-the-cuff thrown-in-for-good-measure ref-related comment, as by this stage across much of the rugby commentosphere it seemed commonplace to make an in-passing negative reference about the referees. Your comment "every contest has a favorite and an underdog" misses the point. Not only do we agree on that, but it does not explain why use the wrong word to describe the situation where one team is deemed objectively and without bias by observers as more likely to be the winner. Indeed, of all wrong words to pick, the one that introduces the concept of bias is possibly the worst! "Principal" and "principal" also get confused in common usage, but that doesn't mean the mis-use is correct. As said, I didn't read the ABC writer's byline; this is not about you. Further, from your articles on The Roar I acknowledge, accept, and appreciate your balanced approach to how referees ply their craft. However - and it ought not to be me who says this - words are the writer's professional stock in trade and selecting the right tool for the job is part of that. A tradesman saying spanner when they meant hammer is confusing and misleading, for example, even if they try to belt in a nail with a spanner. Also, more personally, gently telling me I'm off track when I raised this, rather than checking your own toolkit and usage, takes us into Through the Looking Glass: ‘When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, ... ‘it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.'

AUTHOR

2022-02-19T02:09:01+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


ATW, while it's true that favouritism has meaning around bias, in sporting parlance, it's also pretty commonly used in reference to likely victors in a race or a game or a season; you've surely come across this before. Literally every contest has a favourite and an underdog. Regardless, I'll just again say that if you truly read the artcile, I just don't know how you could have possibly thought that the use of "favouritism" as I did had any reference whatsoever to bias. Never mind the surrounding context, even just in quote you pulled out, I just don't see how you could possibly have interpreted that the way you have?

2022-02-19T02:01:40+00:00

Ankle-tapped Waterboy

Roar Rookie


Hi Brett - didn't read the ABC byline. Small world. The logic is that "favouritism" is about bias first and foremost, and bias by people in authority, as compared to "favourite status" such as the horse that is the favourite in the Melbourne Cup. If a writer wanted to communicate about favourite status then that would be the usage. On the other hand, writing about bias is when favouritism comes into play, that's what the word is for. I accept that the teams discussed have the status of favourites for the competition.

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T11:34:23+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Well, first and foremost, I wrote the ABC article. And you're right, the quote is correct. However, there is no mention of referees or refereeing in the article at all. None. The word does not feature on the page. That quote you've pulled out is very clearly talking about favouratism for the competition. I'm genuinely stunned you've read it otherwise...

2022-02-18T08:07:44+00:00

Ankle-tapped Waterboy

Roar Rookie


Hi Brett – happy new year! I did, and the quote is correct, and no matter which dictionary I look at, the truth is that the word “favoritism” = bias. Here’s the Cambridge: >”unfair support shown to one person or group, esp. by someone in authority: The teacher was careful not to show favoritism to any one student.” Really looking forward to this season kicking off! What are you wanting me to read closely on? Genuine question.

2022-02-18T06:34:34+00:00

Tez

Roar Rookie


I think, for the first time ever, that Brett and I agree ..... Tahs, Chiefs, Saders, Reds, Brums. My long term forecast is that the Rebels will be last among the Oz teams.

2022-02-18T04:08:10+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


No

2022-02-18T03:56:22+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


While it’s just leaving the station, get on the Blues bandwagon before it gains too much momentum Brett! We’ll convert you … ‘it won’t happen overnight,… but it will happen’

2022-02-18T03:26:26+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


I like it Chookman! The big question which we will know by mid season is "Tough as a wet pudding or touch as a brick with eyes"? :stoked:

2022-02-18T03:23:41+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Ferret its quite easy actually. Harry looked at the inverse function of the probability distribution and integrated its square root. The trignometric answer suggested all the planets had aligned with Andromeda, Pluto and Sedna. A rare occurrence which points to a sterling victory by the Boys from Fiji. Sadly the other tipsters failed maths in year 6. Simple, ain't it! :silly:

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T03:21:31+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Whenever... I tip against them, I'll wager strongly... :angry:

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T03:20:44+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


:laughing:

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T03:20:28+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Harsh. I did finish equal top two seasons ago.. :silly:

2022-02-18T03:17:38+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


It did look an error. Surely NO-ONE could be 14 behind Brett's tips. :laughing:

2022-02-18T03:04:31+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


Don’t bring math into this.

2022-02-18T03:01:56+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Riccardo …. This is OUR year … just starting off with a bit of a stutter, that’s all … we will pick up the bonus point win, “whenever”

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T02:26:09+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


It's a busy time for sports fans Ricco. The concept of 'seasons' feels long departed..

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T02:22:20+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Oh wow, no Thugby , the Crowd finished well ahead of me, that's a shocking typo there!! :laughing:

AUTHOR

2022-02-18T01:07:29+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Well it's easy Ferret, there's four of us, and Harry picked the Drua, while the rest of us didn't... :stoked:

2022-02-17T23:34:40+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


Good to see you back fellas... but... isn't it still cricket season? Overlaps are confusing for an old fella with dementia... Waratahs, Highlanders, Crusaders, Reds, Brumbies, Black Caps...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar