Welcome to the first edition of Coach’s Corner in 2022! First things first: there is a new feature on Fridays, and that is My Australian team of week. Here it is for round two of Super Rugby Pacific:
Number | Player |
---|---|
1 | Angus Bell |
2 | Lachlan Lonergan |
3 | Cabous Eloff |
4 | Matt Philip |
5 | Izack Rodda |
6 | Rob Veletini |
7 | Fraser McReight |
8 | Will Harris |
9 | Tate McDermott |
10 | Ben Donaldson |
11 | Manasa Mataele |
12 | Lalakai Foketi |
13 | Izaia Perese |
14 | Tom Banks |
15 | Jack Stachan |
16 | James Slipper |
17 | Billy Pollard |
18 | Allan Alaalatoa |
19 | Fergus Lee-Warner |
20 | Tim Anstee |
21 | Issak Fines-Leleiwasa |
22 | Reesjan Pasitoa |
23 | Jordan Petaia |
Okay, so that is out of the way. Plenty of questions circling around how potential young Wallabies should be managed, and prepared for Test rugby – especially when some key starters are plying their trade overseas and their availability is uncertain.
Rugbyrah touched on the question of overseas availability, and how to fit four or five top overseas players into the new three-man rule:
Jeznez immediately flagged up that “Marika Koroibete at 11 is one hell of a player to leave out.”
To remind ourselves of the platform for the debate. Tim Horan commented in a Tweet that Force number 10 Reesjan Pasitoa should be immediately promoted to the first Wallaby squad of 2022
“Reesjan Pasitoa has to be in the Wallabies squad in 2022. Early days I know, but he is a future star. At 20 years old….the time is right,” he said.
Ex-Wallaby coach Michael Cheika preferred a much more progressive time-line:
“In all seriousness, forget about young Pasitoa, let’s have a think about Noah Lolesio, or Quade Cooper, or James O’Connor, or these guys who are in situ right now, and give them the confidence to play.
“This lad (Pasitoa) is good – he’s got time on the ball, he’s getting the ball on the run so he’s drawing defenders even before he has the ball, you can see he’s got that ability. But let him really stamp his authority to become a top player in Super Rugby, with the Western Force.
“Then inject him into the Wallabies as a player who will make a difference from the off, instead of making him go in there and maybe struggle for a bit, and come out and earn his stripes.”
My own opinion is much closer to Michael Cheika’s than it is to Tim Horan’s. Firstly, it is good to remember that Tim Horan comes from the pre-professional era, in which it was still possible to pluck the Phil Kearns and Tony Daly’s of this world from the obscurity of club rugby and forge them into international players.
Cheika is a professional coach who has probably learned his lesson the hard way. He introduced the likes of Ned Hanigan too quickly to international rugby and Hanigan looked lost for a couple of seasons – fortunately he has been able to rewind and recover.
Pasitoa has shown some nice touches, but no more than that. He has not been as influential as Ben Donaldson at number 10 has been for the Waratahs so far, and he has done nothing to suggest that Quade Cooper and James O’Connor should be uprooted as the top two choices at number 10. Those would be the top three outside-halves at present.
Dave Rennie will be fairly certain of the first 25 players or so in his World Cup squad. It will be a question of filling the remaining gaps with players who can add extra value or a USP.
Two of those players are playing for the Force, who along with the Waratahs look like the biggest improvers of 2023. One is scrum-half Issak Fines-Leleiwasa, who made a startling contribution off the bench against the Rebels.
Assuming that Nic White ana Tate McDermott will be the top two choices for the World Cup, Issak Fines-Leleiwasa can offer real impact off the bench with his razor-sharp footwork and acceleration:
It is always one of the hardest tasks to work your way back infield off a side-line. On two phases out of three ILF stops the inside three defenders dead in their tracks, which means they cannot lead the defensive line forward with any speed or momentum.
His sharpness in and around the base of the ruck provides the energy you want injected into your attack in the last 20 minutes of the game:
In the first example, he draws a yellow card on Reece Hodge for a deliberate knock-on, in the second he sets up the final score of the game right on the hooter.
Another player who should come into the reckoning for one of those final spots in the World Cup squad is ex-Sevens star Tim Anstee. He has improved his level of physicality and tight ball-carrying, he has won two turnovers on the deck in the first two games, and crucially, he can win lineout ball on both sides of the throw:
The sheer footballing intelligence in that second example is exactly what the Wallaby coaching staff should be looking for. When the intended maul breaks up, Anstee immediately makes an adjustment, taking the ball through the line himself, releasing on the ground and picking it up again to drive over for an outstanding try.
The importance of ‘earning your stripes’ at Super Rugby level has been underlined by the development of young Angus Bell in New South Wales. Bell has endured some difficult moments indeed against both Taniela Tupou and Feao Fotuaika in the scrums in recent times, but at the weekend there was only one boss:
The big change is Bell’s long left arm bind. It reaches all the way down to Fotuaika’s hip, and that keeps his back straight and the forward drive low and powerful.
Lots of interest too, in France’s progress in the current Six Nations. Mused6 talked in glowing terms about the impact of the French number 8 Gregory Alldritt, while Ozinsa added “He’s a beast. Best 8 in world rugby right now, hands down.”
Oz also commented on the efficiency of the French backs in contact, asking: “Is it a product of coaching and the way they want to play, or have they chosen players who fit a mould?”
France have scored six tries from counter-attack (four more than anyone else) and 10 of their 13 scores have come within one or two phases. So, they need to get the opponent to give them the ball, either via the boot or through breakdown turnover.
Their 17 turnovers at ruck time are spread across nine different players, and three of those are backs (centres Gael Fickou and Jonatahn Danty, and left wing Gabin Villiere). Danty was a massive on-ball influence in the 2021 July series between Australia and France.
Possibly with tongue firmly in cheek, Just Nuisance predicted an England victory in Paris at the end of the tournament, while both JD Kiwi and The Neutral View from Sweden observed a similarity between Les Bleus and a good All Blacks side. That probably comes from the desire to attack from changes of possession (a New Zealand hallmark) and with strong ball-handling contributions from all 15 players.
Let’s look at the involvements of French prop Cyrille Baille in two of France’s early scores against Scotland:
Everyone can see Antoine Dupont’s brilliance on the counter, but Baille’s involvement is less visible, and every bit as important:
Baille does not run straight upfield in his midfield channel, he crosses to the far side ahead of five other French players in order to become principal receiver at the ruck after Dupont is tackled – the precise location where France want him to be.
Cyrille Baille’s contribution to the second French try was also essential:
Despite multiple offloads, the Scotland defence is still in good shape when the ball reaches Damian Penaud on the right side-line. The decisive intervention is made by Baille, running from midfield out to support his wing and received the offload, before making the critical assist just before he is forced out into touch himself.
Many thanks to all who asked a question, or helped develop the debate on the forum!
Jimbo81
Roar Rookie
2nd best team in OZ
Jimbo81
Roar Rookie
That’s Campbell. Now three wins in a row with an excellent JC
Jimbo81
Roar Rookie
Reds manifest destiny is to rule the rugby planet. They are better than Dave Rennie’s Wallabies.
Jimbo81
Roar Rookie
Too many years of this same flawed thinking on Hooper. Same results. Pretty obvious solution. Pick a 7 that secures the ruck first.
mused6
Roar Rookie
The horse had the Irish accent… my service returns aren’t great these days.
The Yabbie
Roar Rookie
So much negative bias towards the tahs. It’s school yard stuff and I have to remind myself I’m being given a wonderful opportunity to develop my sense of humour. The real reason why NSW has produced more wallabies than any other team is because there are more people. This is not rocket science. We supply other states with more players than any other by a fair margin too. That the last tah’s team didn’t win a match was to do with keeping Daryl Gibson on when he should have been flicked at the start in 2015. Plus other problems behind the scene I imagine; financial and management based. Only team 1m under budget for example.
The Yabbie
Roar Rookie
Jimbo how is it one man's fault if an entire team wins or loses. Coaches at international level the globe over, rate Hooper very well. Was it Graham Henry who last year said he was the first wallaby he'd pick? I agree on Lolesio, Wright, Banks.
The Yabbie
Roar Rookie
So Gordon has slipped ? I see TMac as a better running threat only.
The Yabbie
Roar Rookie
Not rugby but just read this and goes into detail about the latest scientific discoveries around nutrition. Must read! (podcast for METABOLICAL: Dr Robert Lustig) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcU0eEkV7Eg
ethan
Guest
Gzzz wake up on the wrong side of the bed? It's not about parochialism, its about having a more visually appealing format, and providing a little more information. I'm not here to argue which team has too many, but I am interested in which teams are bringing the goods in which position. Much easier to glean at a glance when the colours are different, then to comb through every name. And yes Jez, I know where the players come from...
Harry Jones
Expert
Good corner!
Adsa
Roar Rookie
Ponies
Nick Maguire
Roar Rookie
NB, maybe off topic but I think you will get this and enjoy it. https://youtu.be/MfWZc2Qvvlk Cheers
Carlin
Roar Rookie
Anstee has a lot to like about him as a loose forward. Good line-out option and with his 7s background he is going to be fit, fast and mobile around the field. I am really looking forward to see how he progresses especially now that he has had a couple of seasons of regular Super Rugby. French Rugby is in a good place at the moment. Baille's support play in your examples is a great example on why it is important to work hard off the ball and be in a position of support when your team needs it. Gabine Villarie is becoming one of my favourite players. He seems to get himself highly involved and is not scared to do some of the hard graft that some wingers wouldn't do. Thanks as always Nicholas.
Nicholas Bishop
Expert
It's also why coaches in big sports often recruit the same players from their previous clubs, because they know and trust they can deliver their vision.
Derek Murray
Roar Rookie
Hasn't always been the case
Nick Maguire
Roar Rookie
Agree, do the coaches know what good looks like, do players have clarity about what they are trying to do and the competency to achieve it
Nicholas Bishop
Expert
Front rowers nowadays would look at you aghast! :laughing: :shocked:
Nicholas Bishop
Expert
One thing I have learned over the years is that the best coaches are defined by how clearly they see the endgame - what they are trying to achieve, and how best to get there...
Nick Maguire
Roar Rookie
Yep, turning down those points last week was criminal, no tactical clarity about how to win a game of SR