NRL NEWS: Gus wants another rule change, Ponga says Dolphins no distraction, NRLW Dally M dual winners

By The Roar / Editor

Canterbury general manager Phil Gould is calling on the NRL’s rulemakers to get rid of seven-tackle sets, saying they “have got no place in our game”.

On his Six Tackles with Gus podcast, the former dual premiership-winning coach said the rule was brought in more than a decade ago as a way of preventing the negative ploy of deliberately kicking the ball over the dead-ball line and it’s morphed into a different beast which is destroying elements of the game.

“It’s created far more problems than it’s worth. The problems should have been perceived at the time but weren’t,” he said.

“It was a kneejerk reaction to a tactic a certain team was using at the time to a certain fullback but was never going to stand the test of time,” he added in reference to St George Illawarra intentionally kicking the ball over Storm star Billy Slater’s head to concede a 20-metre tap rather than having him running the ball back in broken play. 

“There were other remedies for that that could have been taken but as they usually do, they apply blanket coverage of the same rule to other aspects of the game.

“It’s led to the fact that no one can score from 10 metres out from the line. The fullbacks in the line, the markers don’t have to be square so they stand alongside so virtually they’ve got 14, 15 defenders plus the bunker to help them save tries

“That’s why people are struggling to score points from close to the line, simply because of this stupid seven-tackle rule.”

He said teams should not give up a seven-tackle set for a knock-on over the line or a field goal attempt. 

“How ridiculous, that’s not the rule was for, then why does the rule cover that?” he said with a croaky voice as he deals with a bout of COVID-19.

“This is again coaches interfering with the rules for the benefit of their own team and those that are in charge of making the rules, not seeing it coming.”

Ponga says his focus is on Knights

Newcastle’s superstar fullback Kalyn Ponga says he’s not distracted in the slightest by the emergence of Dolphins coach Wayne Bennett trying to entice him north to the newest NRL club.

Ponga, the Knights skipper, has an option in his favour for 2023 and 2024 in his current deal.

The possibility of exercising that option grew last weekend when it was revealed Bennett and Ponga had lunch the day after Newcastle’s 18-0 loss to the Sharks.

Ponga, the Queensland fullback, would be the big fish Bennett is trying to land in his roster for 2023.

But after his side’s 30-6 home loss to Manly on Thursday at McDonald Jones Stadium – the club’s third loss in a row – Ponga said he was not about to divulge his future in a media conference..

But he added that he was able to put his off-field life to one side when it came to training and playing with Newcastle. 

“I don’t know if you notice, but every time you ask me I don’t give you an answer. So stay patient, I’ve got people working on it. My focus is always here,” said the 24-year-old, who is into his fifth year with the Knights after joining them in 2018 from the Cowboys.

Wayne Bennett will be the first coach of the new Dolphins franchise. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

“It (the Bennett lunch) obviously happened but once it happened, I moved on and worried about the game. 

“It was disappointing the effort we put in at the end because we’d almost got ourselves back in a position to win,” added Ponga, who had scored a try early in the second half only for a 10-6 scoreline to balloon with Manly pouring on three late tries.

“So my focus now is reviewing the game, recovering and then moving to next week.”

The Knights, who have played four games in 19 days, have a longer turnaround before meeting the Dragons at WIN Stadium in Wollongong.

Coach Adam O’Brien said he was looking forward to having more training sessions instead of quick turnarounds. He also felt there was no issue with Ponga’s commitment despite meeting with another club.

“It wasn’t a lunch date …. look, it’s his right, it’s in his contract – a contract that we wrote,” O’Brien said.

“I’m comfortable because I don’t see a dip in any of his preparation, his hunger at training. That hasn’t wavered and usually I’ve got a radar out for that stuff,” he said.

“I want him to make the best decision with all the information on the table, then there’s no regrets. If he chooses to stay then he’s made the choice with all the facts.

“I’m really comfortable with all of that and so are his teammates.”

Boyle, Tonegato share NRLW Dally M

Broncos prop Millie Boyle and Dragons fullback Emma Tonegato created history when they were named joint winners of the NRLW Dally M Medal award.

They each earned maximum points in the final round of voting to tie on eight points at the top of the leaderboard.

Tonegato will be looking to add to the trophy cabinet on Sunday when St George Illawarra take on the Roosters in the grand final at Redcliffe but Boyle will be a frustrated onlooker after her Broncos were eliminated in the semis last weekend by the Tricolours in an enormous upset.

She scored four tries in six games for the Dragons this season and also added three assists while running for 967 metres, which was second only in the competition to Boyle (990).

Boyle missed a match due to COVID-19 which could have been her chance to win the award outright.

Tonegato also took out the tackle of the year award for her hit on Roosters centre Sergis in Round 5. 

St George Illawarra rookie Jamie Soward was named coach of the year, Gold Coast’s Brittany Breayley-Nati was a popular choice as captain of the year while teammate Shaniah Power took home try of the year honours for her individual effort against the Broncos in Round 4.

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-10T08:22:41+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


I agree teams should not receive a seven-tackle set for a knock-on over the line or a field goal attempt. All these minor sub-rules and exceptions are unnecessary. Rugby League has a history of changing in pursuit of the GGoA. In 1983 they changed the value of a try from 3 to 4, This devalued the penalty that encouraged the defenders to lay on a tackled player. The NSWRL's reason for the change was the belief that crowds would increase if there were more tries scored. Bombs away.

2022-04-10T01:40:20+00:00

Anthony Higgins

Guest


Are you kidding. Seven tackle set from a kick happens in all games. I’m in 100% agreement with Gus. I would also like to see a change to the challenge of a decision. Each team gets one challenge per game. That’s it. Save one challenge for the Clanger that might cost a game. I am over watching replay after replay of whether a ball was knocked on, back or sideways.

2022-04-08T14:05:00+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


Jeez Gus is good. Like he's seriously clever. He brings up a law regarding a play that happens maybe three or four times a weekend? Maybe less. But it ain't a huge amount. Compare that to the number of tackles and play the balls: the wrestling, ruck speed, strip's, dropped balls, captains challenges resulting, etc.. Poor lil 7T is just a baby by comparison. Gus couldn't give two hoots about this rule, but it's nice and quick, we all bite and he takes at least some of the focus on the dramas in the doghouse. Well at least a little bit. In summary: don't care either way about the 7 tackle thing, and run well this weekend Kyle.

2022-04-08T09:23:50+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


I still think we use the union rule for when it goes dead - ball goes back to the spot where it was kicked, or the 20, whichever is greater.

2022-04-08T09:04:09+00:00

Dan

Guest


Gus is 100% correct. 7 tackle set make no sense. Get rid of it except for kicks from more than 40 m out. A grabber behind the line takes an extra bounce and the opposition gets an extra tackle? And for field goals attempts?

2022-04-08T07:45:18+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


I think it's more the fact that conceding a 7 tackle set for an attacking grubber that goes dead, or a cross field chip that is marked inside the in-goal is a silly punishment for trying to score a try. If at the time they simply put in a rule that any kick outside the 20m that goes over the dead ball line or is marked, then you get a 7 tackle set, then I doubt we'd have an issue.

2022-04-08T06:07:00+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Yeah, you're right there. If Flano does have a blinder it will be, "I said years ago this kid was good, he just need managing properly."

2022-04-08T05:56:03+00:00

eagleJack

Roar Guru


I don't mind if you kick it dead it's a 7 tackle set. Adds an element of skill to the game. Also catching a bomb on the full in-goal should be 7 tackles, again it adds an element of skill to avoid kicking it too far. Last tackle options are predictable enough as it is. Bomb high, or grubber. You have to create something to reward the more skilful. It's a simple game. But the dropped ball over the line resulting in 7 tackles has to go. Worse is the dropped ball 1m out out that then rolls dead, becomes 7 tackle set instead of a knock on. That's just silly.

2022-04-08T05:50:07+00:00

eagleJack

Roar Guru


14, 15 defenders :laughing:

2022-04-08T05:44:16+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Gus likes to straddle both sides of the fence Phil. If Flanagan has a blinder against Penrith he'll take the credit. If he doesn't Barrett will cop the heat.

2022-04-08T05:41:45+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


:laughing: I'll have to do some research there Adam. Last known fullback at the Broncos was Boyd before Nui, maybe, just maybe, she played 1 game.

2022-04-08T05:40:09+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Gus ‘the great man’ Gould is right here Pet peeve of mine Maybe keep 7 tackle sets for long kicks that go dead to stop that coming back into the game, but it wasn’t meant for drop balls, going over the sideline or short kicks that go dead The punishment / reward of a seven tackle set doesn’t pass the logic test Drop the ball a metre out from the line and the opposition gets 6 tackles from the 10 Get over the line and drop it and the oppo gets seven tackles from the 20 metres

2022-04-08T05:34:28+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


I think Gus has forgotten how to count since getting covid

2022-04-08T05:32:09+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


I think he is. But the questions to him are getting a little bizarre

2022-04-08T05:30:55+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Has Emma Tonegato ever played for the Broncos? Otherwise no chance on a Griffin run side

2022-04-08T05:25:47+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Are teams really not putting in kicks behind the line into the in goal because they are worried about conceding a 7 tackle set? Seems inconsistent with why the NRL got rid of the 5 again rule coming out of a half.

2022-04-08T05:18:04+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Gus is all fired up for someone with Covid. First he lets off a salvo saying it was he who managed Kyle Flanagan's welfare saying Barrett asked for permission to select Kyle in 1st grade. At the same time taking a potshot at the Fox media who said it was cruel to select the halfback first up against Penrith. Now he wants a rule changed because it's stupid. Good old Gus.

2022-04-08T04:27:49+00:00

Dumbo

Roar Rookie


For once, I agree with Gus. Seven-tackle sets are an unnecessary complication.

2022-04-08T02:43:19+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


"My focus is here" Or in other words, I'm on my way to Redcliffe next year.

2022-04-08T02:42:40+00:00

Coastyboi

Guest


What Wayne wants, Wayne gets. He’s our most successful NRL coach.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar