'Without peer': What makes Simon Poidevin one of my favourite Wallabies

By Peter Darrow / Roar Guru

After recently reading about Anthony Kiedis, Stevie Nicks and Bruce Dickinson, there was little controversy in comparison with the research for Simon Poidevin. But that is often the case when comparing rock stars to sportsmen, an exception being Andre Agassi, who was probably the rock star of the tennis world.

The only blemish on a stellar rugby and corporate career was when Poidevin was banned from providing financial services after he dropped his battle with the corporate regulator over alleged share market manipulation. Sports fans possibly want their heroes to be as squeaky clean as possible, whereas the opposite applies to rock stars.

Poidevin’s only other move to raise eyebrows was his change in career paths from financial services to being the Australia and New Zealand president of health and wellbeing platform Total Brain.

Sportsmen may not provide us with literary excitement, but they do entertain in other ways. Simon Poidevin is one of Australia’s great rugby players and will be remembered for the ‘triple treat’ – along with David Campese, Nick Farr-Jones and Michael Lynagh, he’s one of only four Wallabies to have won a Rugby World Cup, a grand slam and a series in New Zealand against the mighty All Blacks.

If you are comparing achievements, it’s hard to beat those three. Poidevin also captained the Wallabies on four occasions – he wanted more, but that didn’t eventuate due to others preferred, including Farr-Jones and Andrew Slack. He was a man who made his own decisions, retiring in 1988 and then coming out of retirement 42 days later to play in the Bledisloe series. He made himself unavailable for the 1990 tour of New Zealand but returned to the team for the 1991 season.

There was one piece of information that would have made for stunning news had it eventuated. After the World XV matches in 1986 the Cavaliers (All Blacks) were on their way to South Africa. There was speculation Jock Hobbs may have had to withdraw from the squad, which led to Andy Haden and Murray Mexted asking Simon Poidevin if he wanted to tour. Unfortunately – or fortunately – Hobbs was able to tour, so Poidevin missed out.

(Photo by Barry Batchelor – PA Images/PA Images via Getty Images)

Poidevin reflected in his biography For Love Not Money that, “What an experience it would have been! I chuckled a few times imagining myself not just playing alongside four or five All Blacks but being one-out in the whole All Black team. Alas, the invitation never came.”

Simon Paul Poidevin was born in 1958, a country boy from Goulburn NSW. Upon finishing school, he joined the Goulburn Rugby Club, from where he left for Sydney and eventually the Randwick Club. After representative appearances Poidevin made his Test debut against Fiji in 1980.

After the series win against the All Blacks in 1986 he described the win as “more satisfying and even greater than the grand slam, the high point of his career” (prior to the 1991 Rugby World Cup). Poidevin went on to play 59 Tests for his country, which was a record at the time.

“For his commitment, competitiveness, discipline, will to win and determination to perfect skills, Poidevin is without peer in modern rugby.” Alan Jones.

Simon Poidevin was a fitness fanatic who took great pride in playing for his country. He relished the opportunities to play against the All Blacks and never took a backwards step against formidable foes such as Wayne ‘Buck’ Shelford and Andy Haden. A bone-crunching tackle by Englishman Micky Skinner in the 1991 World Cup led to Poidevin replying, “Do your bloody best pal”.

He was a fair player but was very strong and uncompromising with a determined attitude.

Peter Jenkins wrote in Wallaby Gold: The History of Australian Test Rugby that, “There was an aura about the flanker, a respect for how he approached the game, the passion he injected and the pride with which he wore the jumper.”

I will always remember the absolute respect New Zealand supporters had for Poidevin and his unwillingness to back down. He was a player to be feared. He mightn’t have been as exciting as a rock star, but he was a mighty fine rugby player.

Simon Poidevin, another favourite Wallaby.

The Crowd Says:

2022-08-13T01:28:36+00:00

Big A

Roar Rookie


na man - he was too small to play blind side - we had blokes like David Codey and Willie O to do the hard stuff nobody sees - that's why i think Holloway is the fix we've been waiting for at no.6

2022-08-12T21:12:30+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


Wasn't it both?

2022-08-12T07:27:33+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


I am. I stand by my comments. Poido would have been a rubbish touch footy player

2022-08-12T07:10:14+00:00

Big A

Roar Rookie


@Ozinza Give it a rest man – you’re talking about one of the legends of the game

2022-08-12T07:07:33+00:00

Big A

Roar Rookie


openside

2022-08-05T22:38:57+00:00

BrumbieBob

Roar Rookie


Good story Peter. I was playing at the same club (Uni of N.S.W.) as a colt when Poido was picked for the 1980 Fiji test. It meant a lot to us as kids to look up to Wallaby from our own ranks. I guess he was our clubs rock star.

2022-08-05T13:27:32+00:00

Gauss

Roar Rookie


Yep. He had hands like feet.

2022-08-05T12:48:32+00:00

Morsie

Roar Rookie


Not many in that day did.

2022-08-05T12:48:01+00:00

Morsie

Roar Rookie


I was certain it was Brooke but am happy to be corrected. Piling into Shelford = bonus points.

2022-08-05T07:37:12+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


My only criticism of Poidevin is that he wasn't a good ball runner. Which might be a surprising observation of someone who spent so much of his club career at Randwick. But then, not everyone who played for Randwick was required to be a ball runner. Nor can every flanker be a Michael Jones or George Smith, who could be the first man to a ruck or maul, secure possession, then set off running before passing. But in all other areas Poidevin was supreme. He had a professional attitude to training & fitness in an amateur era where many players weren't as fit as they should have been. He had a tremendously indomitable, never-say-die spirit which was inspiring to his team mates. I think it's safe to say he is among Australia's best 4-6 flankers of all-time. Historically & chronologically, our greatest-ever flankers are: Tom Richards, Aub Hodgson, Col Windon, Greg Davis, Simon Poidevin, David Wilson, George Smith & David Pocock. The last 4 could play both open & blind, so plenty of flexibility in selection. Windon & Davis were considered openside in style, while Richards & Hodgson were considered blindside in style. So much talent to distill into 3-4 all-time teams.

2022-08-05T02:57:16+00:00

Patto

Guest


George Smith, David Wilson, David Pocock. Forget that 4th pretender.

2022-08-05T02:55:35+00:00

Waikato Draught

Guest


Hahaha :laughing: Hooper is not better than Sam Cane .Delusional. I would want that non combative 7 in my All Black team.

2022-08-05T01:05:33+00:00

FatOldHalfback

Roar Rookie


I have a rugby friend of a friend who played on the wing for Drummoyne when they were in the Shute Shield. One day against Randwick not only did Campese score 4 or 5 tries on him but the one time when he did get the ball in space Poido buried him over the sideline, he would say that a year later he could still feel the hit.

AUTHOR

2022-08-04T23:59:36+00:00

Peter Darrow

Roar Guru


Poidevin did recount a story about Wayne Shelford elbowing Glen Ella in the head, they both got into a brawl in front of the main stand where to Poidevin's embarrassment his mother was sitting.

2022-08-04T23:32:30+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Too right! I loved watching him play. Only met him once, top fella!

2022-08-04T22:25:40+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


Hooper is better than decent. If he were a Kiwi I'd pick him ahead of Cane.

2022-08-04T22:23:40+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


More like the minds distracted by girls they are trying to impress.

2022-08-04T21:50:52+00:00

Sinclair Whitbourne

Roar Rookie


He had a memorable contest with Chris Roche for the openside role; good as the latter was, they got it right with P. Hard to think of a big game where he didn't deliver, even when others had an off day. Thanks for the article.

2022-08-04T18:39:25+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Tough player but he lacked basic skills. I saw him butcher a 2:1 against Scotland that I’d have expected a 10yo to get right. Of course there is an element of toughness required to be a legend of our game and he had it but to graduate to the next level, I’d expect a player to have the core catching and passing skills down pat. Not sure Poido had that

2022-08-04T11:27:48+00:00

Morsie

Roar Rookie


Favourite Poidevin moment. Sydney (or NSW) v All Blacks, Concord Oval. Zin Zan Brooke high siffarmed flattened one of the Ellas, a red card for certain in today's game. Poidevin piled into him with a ferocity not seen since Ray Price's day and they went at it toe to toe. What a memory.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar