REACTION: 'Gutted', 'hugely disappointing' - Shocking Taniela verdict after another heartbreak

By Tony Harper / Editor

Australia were brave but ultimately bowed, a late decision to go for a win over a draw coming to nought in Dublin.

The Wallabies paid a heavy price in the 13-10 defeat with Taniela Tupou suffering a suspected Achilles injury – an issue that can take nine months to recover from and could leave him in serious doubt for the World Cup.

Coach Dave Rennie surveyed the carnage afterwards. Hunter Paisami had a potential medial ligament damage while Andrew Kellaway and Rob Valetini suffered foot injuries. Dave Porecki was concussed, leaving Australia’s stocks reeling ahead of their final match of the tour against Wales.

A Bernard Foley error after the siren as Australia probed for a try to win the game was the final act in an absorbing battle between the Wallabies and the world’s No.1 ranked team.

Ireland went ahead 13-10 with four minutes to play. Australia had a chance to kick a penalty to secure a draw but acting skipper Michael Hooper opted for a lineout. A penalty concession from Jake Gordon ended one raid, then after they nabbed the ball back Foley dropped a pass under pressure.

Harry Jones, Brett McKay and Jim Tucker discuss the game in our Instant Reaction podcast

“I’m gutted,” said captain James Slipper. “Test matches are won off big moments and we lost that one and it’s going to hurt for some time. We responded from last week, but Ireland are No.1 and it’s hard to win here. We brought the effort but came up short.”

“It’s fine margins, lack of discipline, lack of focus,” said Drew Mitchell on Stan Sport. “There is a lot to like from Australia. Physically they aimed up and got good impact from the bench. Will Skelton was immense.”

So too was Jordie Petaia who came on in the third minute for injured Paisami and scored the Wallabies’ 70th minute try that levelled the scores.

“Jordie Petaia if he stay fit for the next 12 months he’ll start in the No.15 jersey at the Rugby World Cup,” said Wallabies World Cup winner Tim Horan on the Stan Sport coverage. “He’s an outstanding player, an X factor player.”

Morgan Turinui added: “He’s a light and shade player and we’ve seen so much of the lightness this evening.”

The try was set up thanks to a smashing run by Skelton, and Foley levelled the scores with a conversion from wide right.

Mack Hansen of Ireland attempts to keep the ball in play during the Bank of Ireland Nations Series match between Ireland and Australia at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. (Photo By David Fitzgerald/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

While the defensive grit of the Wallabies can’t be faulted their year long issues with discipline and bad luck continue.

Folau Fainga’a, on for Dave Porecki after a head knock, gave away one of the most senseless yellow cards in a season where the Wallabies have had 13 plus one red card.

After referee Ben O’Keeffe had warned both captains after a couple of head roll penalties that the next culprit would head to the sin bin, Fainga’a produced another one. James Slipper gave his hooker a resigned slap on the shoulder as he started the trudge off.

“Why are you doing that?’ asked Sean Maloney for the whole of the Australian rugby community. Morgan Turinui’s response was brutal: “The reason why is because you lack the discipline and maturity of a Test player.”

With Fainga’a off the field Australia were soon reduced to 13 players for several minutes. They somehow survived as Ireland’s Aussie-born winger Mack Hansen started injecting himself into the action.

Hansen looked to have put Jamison Gibson-Park over for a try but he had been pushed into touch in the lead up thanks to a superb covering tackle by Bernard Foley.

Discipline is one issue but the Wallabies have also been cruelled by an astonishing injury list.

The loss of Tupou, who was gripping behind his knee in serious pain, is just the latest top line player – with the Queensland prop every bit as important to Rennie as Quade Cooper and Samu Kerevi who are sidelined with long term issues.

“Teams are having success against the Wallabies by disrupting them at the breakdown, putting them off their game plan,” said Justin Harrison.

“Again the Wallabies found a way to win that match, we get lineout turnovers start to get some direction and oomph and just at the end… This is the knife edge that international rugby is right now. It’s hugely disappointing for a team who put everything into getting a result.”

The Crowd Says:

2022-11-24T19:38:09+00:00

frisky

Roar Rookie


A willy decision by Hooper. Take the points to avoid loss nd then maybe there will be time to try something after the restart. What is the percentage scoring success rate from lineouts??

2022-11-21T02:43:34+00:00

Gepetto

Roar Rookie


Foley was a disaster at #12 outside Quade under Coach Clown and Noah only acts as first receiver a few times each game according to Nick Bishop's count. Those guys just get in the way of the better players with attacking ability.

2022-11-21T00:07:42+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Absolutely right. PEYPER AND BOK. You see them and you just know the wallabies will get less of the 50/50 calls.

2022-11-21T00:05:00+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Very balanced and fair wrap. I don’t understand why Hodge isn’t on the bench. He can play anywhere in the backline except 9.

2022-11-21T00:02:33+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Yes. Gordon. You could replay that maul 100 times and not see that penalty again.

2022-11-20T23:52:20+00:00

Toulouse Lautrec

Roar Rookie


Yeah you're right, it was a close loss, let's just call it a win! Can we also claim the WC if we are gallant losers?.......oh, no, actually we still lose........ Did New Zealand feel good about losing the cricket WC on a count back of the fours they hit? probably not Did we feel good in 2003 losing by a drop goal? again, probably not. No a loss is still a loss. But good for you feeling so chipper about not getting thrashed!

2022-11-20T23:28:33+00:00

Toulouse Lautrec

Roar Rookie


Holloway is fine. I think his ceiling is a solid 6-7 rated player, few mistakes, but will never dominate his opposite or be a game breaker. Same with Neville and Hannigan. Solid players, but that's about it. Frost's athletic ability, Bobby V's power and strength, Skeltons mass and sheer brutality, Phillips heart and grunt, even Harry's engine, speed and sheer continual drive give them something extra that can create more opportunities.

2022-11-20T21:58:14+00:00

Toulouse Lautrec

Roar Rookie


ok, they're still a very good team, just lack a lot of fluidity in attack. Apologies for the over-dramatisation.

2022-11-20T21:55:31+00:00

Toulouse Lautrec

Roar Rookie


that's ok, just commenting that we had a lack of ball carrying forwards. Slips and bobby V love a trundle, Holloway always sits out wide. Meant the Irish forwards could set their line and eat our ball carriers for breakfast. No deception, no pop passes, lack of options. It was lacklustre. You may think differently, that's fine, it's an opinion website.

2022-11-20T21:03:08+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


7s are typically the worst player in the pack for hitting it up

2022-11-20T20:59:21+00:00

Tony H

Roar Pro


That's not what anyone got pinged for mate.

2022-11-20T14:16:49+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


I’ll take that. Because it shows us punters that Rennie is a man of his word. He said players will be held accountable and I don’t believe him. He needs to prove it.

2022-11-20T14:14:57+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


For hot about Swinton. Even more congested.

2022-11-20T14:09:50+00:00

Qualify

Guest


Maturity is separate from age. Example - Foley is a lot older than both of them but still can't handle pressure. Kellaway is one of the most confident wallaby players I've seen in a long while.

2022-11-20T13:15:07+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


That’s what we need to avoid - having preconceived ideas that don’t change as players change and improve

2022-11-20T13:07:04+00:00

Rodkafer

Roar Rookie


I thought his D was pretty good today

2022-11-20T12:10:41+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


Don't get the negative view of Holloway..he is a six doing a lot of hard work for the team.

2022-11-20T12:07:41+00:00

Olly

Roar Rookie


Holloway was good to me. Defended well, a few good runs into the teeth of the defence and worked well in the lineout. Good effort to steal a lineout from Ireland.

2022-11-20T11:56:28+00:00

cs

Roar Guru


It’s disturbing how often we agree these days PeterK, so it feels good to be able to say that I think you’re wrongheaded about Marky at 15. Actually, we sort of still agree, for I also think he’s got the goods to be a great 15. Yet it might also limit his involvement, somewhat in the way it does Kellaway (a top shelf 15 who has had his best games on the wing). As MN is developing his style, he’s finding the freedom to intervene across the park, whereas 15 not only has a stricter operating framework, it’d be making him run further to get into the play. For mine, MN and MK on the wings, with Kellaway harbouring further strike power while keeping things tidy at the back.

2022-11-20T11:47:20+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Skelton made Bundee look like a cricket stump.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar