The NRL has conceded a bunker blunder in Canberra’s one-point win over Wests Tigers, saying Raider halfback Jamal Fogarty’s second try shouldn’t have been awarded.
Canberra edged the Tigers 20-19 on Friday night at GIO Stadium but the NRL’s head of football Graham Annesley on Monday said a 48th minute try given to the home side should instead have being a Tigers’ penalty.
He also said the penalty in the 76th minute was correct against Tigers second-rower Isaiah Papali’i, who took out Fogarty’s legs as he attempted a field goal.
“In our view the penalty was certainly warranted,” Annesley said.
In the earlier incident the home side were leading 12-0 when Fogarty put a kick through into the in-goal.
Raiders forward Emre Guler collided with Tigers halfback Luke Brooks, pushing him over in the chase, with Fogarty running through to ground the ball.
Referee Gerard Sutton awarded a try, which was reviewed by bunker official Adam Gee.
“Had this just being a collision where they bump into each other and someone falls it’s probably a different story but in this case it’s a push, an extension of the arms that turns this into an illegal action that should have been acted upon,” Annesley explained in his weekly briefing.
“It was reviewed by the bunker and in their view Brooks stops competing for the ball … but there’s no rule that says you have to keep running at a certain speed.
“This was an error by the bunker and the try shouldn’t have been awarded.”
Annesley also said referee Chris Sutton’s decision to reverse a call on the advice of touch judge Wyatt Raymond during Sunday’s Penrith – St George Illawarra match was incorrect.
Sutton signalled play-on after a fumble by Dragons winger Mat Feagai, which was scooped up by his teammate Tyrell Sloan.
However the whistleblower then changed his mind and called back the fullback, ruling a knock-on.
With Sunia Turuva scoring for the Panthers on the next set, interim Dragons coach Ryan Carr slammed the call, which happened in the second half with his team trailing 12-14.
Annesley said Sutton had made the correct decision before following the late advice of the touch judge.
“The referee had clear vision of the incident … and instead of backing his own judgement he takes the advice of the touch judge and pulls the play up,” Annesley said.
“He (Sutton) will be gutted by that as are the Dragons and certainly the NRL, we dont want to see things happening but they can’t be undone.”
Standing in front of his wife, kids and teammates, some legendary Canberra Raiders figures and a bustling media pack, Jarrod Croker admits his 300th NRL game finally feels real.
It looked a near-impossibility at times when he managed just 13 games in two years due to a slew of injuries, but Croker will become just the second Raider to join the 300 club when they host the NZ Warriors on Friday.
The club’s all-time leading try and points-scorer could well sell out GIO Stadium, a testament to the impact he’s had on the Canberra community since debuting back in 2009.
CEO Don Furner estimated hundreds of children would have started playing rugby league to wear Croker’s trademark headgear and recreate his try-scoring heroics – but realistically it’s probably more like thousands.
“There isn’t any other bloke in this room who doesn’t want to do the same thing, we’ve got so many good role models at this club and the area,” Croker said on Monday.
“Canberra’s a big country town and we’ve got a bunch of boys here who just want to do what’s best for Canberra, that want to get out there and help the kids as much as they can.
“The green jersey is (about being) a role model for the community, and if one player can come in and be the next Josh Papali’i or Jack Wighton then that would be great as well.”
He joins Jason Croker in the Raiders’ 300 club and the speed with which Jarrod pointed out the two weren’t related suggests it’s an error he’s dealt with more than a couple of times.
“Everyone’s thinks he’s my dad – he’s a mate of mine,” Croker said.
“You think of legends of the club and ‘Toots’ (Jason) is one of the first ones that comes to mind.”
Croker admitted he’d been forced to reckon with the prospect of never reaching the milestone.
After off-season knee surgery heading into 2022, Croker toiled away in NSW Cup before hurting his shoulder in his sole NRL appearance, sustaining that injury in a typical desperation try-saving tackle.
“There’s no good going back (to NSW Cup) and kicking stones and I’ve tried to help out the younger guys there and let them know what the jersey is about,” he said.
“There were definitely some tough moments and a few moments where I didn’t think I’d probably get to this, but as soon as I got back on to Suncorp Stadium (versus Brisbane in round six), there was nothing else I wanted more.”
Coach Ricky Stuart said his legacy would never be forgotten around the club.
“Some of the hardships you had to go through to get here over the last two or three years just typifies your hardness, your relentlessness, your uncompromising work,” he said.
“I love how you’re a one-club player. I love … how loyal you are and the love you have for this jumper, this club.”
RLFan
Roar Rookie
Not much consolation for the Tigers, who lost the game as a result. They have been on the wrong end of a few such calls in the past. It would be interesting to know the stats on 50/50 calls as I think they would heavily favour the top teams. Last Sunday, in the Bulldogs against the Roosters, Suaalii was charged and will miss three matches for lifting his knees, which resulted in the Dogs losing their Captain for the rest of the match. For that there wasn't a sin binning or even a penalty. In other games there have been worse decisions for the Dogs, players sin binned on separate occasions, for hip drop tackles, which were not charged by the judiciary. I am sure many other teams have a similar list of grievances, unconscious bias or conscious bias - it should stop.
Phantom
Roar Rookie
perhaps try reading the article.
Tony
Roar Guru
That would bring the crowds back
Phil
Roar Rookie
Have to agree with Annesley on the Brooks incident. The Canberra player deliberately pushed Brooks and as Annesley says there is no rule which says how fast you must run. We had human error before the age of the bunker and human error with the bunker. Just get rid of the bunker.
Noel
Roar Rookie
Are they on that much? Sheesh, might be time I consider a career change... I'm used to never getting anything right, having kids, and all... In fact, I excel at it.
Red Rob
Roar Rookie
But he is allowed to push a ref under a bus, it seems.
Muzz Manyana
Roar Rookie
So these mu ppets are on $300k plus a year and don't know the rules. FFS!
souvalis
Roar Rookie
Had the Tigers got those points they'd be sitting in front of the Cows on the ladder, one out one back and under double wraps.
Fraser
Roar Rookie
Yet Annesley had no issue with the Campbell Graham push in the back try against The Dolphins, arguing there was no deliberate action (there was a clear push). "Although Campbell Graham is coming from the back of Aitken, it’s legitimate for a player from the kicker’s side to do everything he can to get to the ball,” Annesley said. “You’re entitled to get through defensive players to try to get to the ball, and there will at times be contact and collisions when they’re doing that. “In a collision like that where there’s no deliberate action to take a player out, then I think it’s perfectly legitimate for the try to be awarded.”
Sunshine Tiger
Roar Rookie
So what else is new Townsville last season comes to mind, tigers always in the firing line
Red Rob
Roar Rookie
Except Brooks had given up on the play and no other Tiger was close to saving it. How did they get the rough end?
Red Rob
Roar Rookie
Have I got this right? The try should have been disallowed and the bunker is being criticised because Brooks was pushed over even though he’s given up on the play?
Phantom
Roar Rookie
Yet again the team lower on the ladder gets the rough end of the stick
Noel
Roar Rookie
That's the point. They didn't miss it. They just didn't think it warranted a penalty, because they ruled that Brooks had given up. Unfortunately, as Annesley says, there's no such rule.
Muzz Manyana
Roar Rookie
I'm not sure how they missed the push on Luke Brooks. Every single angle at home clearly showed the infringement. It stood out like do gs balls.