ANALYSIS: Api out of Origin after breaking jaw in run-in with Tino's bumper bars - and Maroons forward might yet cop ban

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

The Titans cruised to a 28-12 victory over the Tigers, but nobody who watched this game will be thinking too hard about the score.

The biggest event of the game, with potentially drastic implications for Origin, happened in the 15th minute, with Api Koroisau taken to hospital following a collision with Tino Fa’asuamaleaui that left him with a broken jaw.

Damien Cook will now likely replace him in the Blues squad for the clash at Suncorp Stadium, with Reece Robson an alternative option.

The hooker sustained the injury while attempting to tackle the Queensland forward, catching the forward’s ball-carrying arm direct to the face.

Fa’asuamaleaui was put on report for the incident, which is his second in the last month for Dangerous Contact while carrying the football, leaving his participation in Game 2 also in doubt.

He collided heavily with Bulldogs hooker Reed Mahoney ahead of Game 1 of Origin, but was merely fined for the incident and allowed to play for the Maroons.

Fa’asuamaleaui will sweat on the charges from the Match Review Panel, and might well review his technique after another incident that was probably avoidable.

“I’ve been running like that since I came into the NRL,” he explained after the match.

“There’s been a couple of times where the player has put their head into the wrong position and come off second best, but I’m just going out there to run as hard as I can to get quick play the balls. 

“It’s a contact sport at the end of the day. I’m hoping he’s alright and I hope I’m alright too. The media make me more worried than anything, building it up.”

On what was a horror night for the Tigers, they also lost Luke Brooks to a hamstring injury, leaving them without their best two players, and their two team leaders, for the foreseeable future.

“He plays the game tough and fair,” said Tim Sheens. “I’m not going to accuse the kid (Fa’asuamaleaui), though they put it on report so they went back and looked at it. Unfortunately, without sin binning, we couldn’t activate our next man so we played a man short.

“The jaw’s broken and badly broken. His bottom teeth are just loose so it’s going to be major surgery. 

“Losing Brooksy with a hamstring means a major reshuffle next week. The medical staff are looking at it at the moment, but he’s had it before you’re looking at 3-4 weeks if you’re lucky and it’s not a bad rupture.”

They were never a chance tonight. Without Koroisau, Sheens’ men struggled to create anything meaningful beyond individual moments – notably one outstanding try from Jahream Bula.

The Titans were competent, went about their work with relative ease and banked points at crucial moments. AJ Brimson, on return from injury, was excellent and Fa’asuamaleaui and Moeaki Fotuaika laid the platform. In Game 100, Philip Sami scored and topped the count with a mammoth 270m.

It wasn’t always spectacular stuff, but after a series of dispiriting defeats, Justin Holbrook will take that every day of the week.

“It’s exactly what we needed,” he said. “I’m really happy with the win tonight. It was great, and it’s what we had to do. We know what we’ve done a few times this year. It’s great to play for the full 80 and get a good win.”

The Titans have just about enough

The prognosis ahead of this game was not awe-inspiring. Last year’s meeting on the Gold Coast was the worst game of the year. The Titans can’t defend and the Tigers can’t attack. 

Within the first ten minutes, we got a strong indicator that this wasn’t likely to be a stellar showing. 

The Tigers dropped the ball in yardage, only for the Titans to drop it back on the second tackle. No worries: the Tigers dropped it straight back. The Titans then forced two repeat sets – although only by taking five drives within good ball – before eventually a moment of quality saw AJ Brimson get over.

Ten minutes later, another calamity of errors, but on the other side. The Tigers missed touch with a kick, but stole the ball moments later and, after two brazen hold downs resulted in set restarts, scored through the simplest crossover of the year.

Had the defence been by anyone other than the Titans, it would have been embarrassing, but for the Gold Coast, it’s just Thursday.

It was that kind of game for a large part of the evening. Whenever Wests did something silly, which was frequently, they could usually rely on the Titans to let them off the hook. 

In the end, the great quality of the Titans in good ball told out. They created two tries in the first half – one good, one horrendous defending from the Tigers – that gave enough of a lead to defend.

The Tigers have struggled to bank points all year and all of their nous seemed to depart with Koroisau.

It’s a shame, really, because the constituent parts weren’t that bad. Both backrowers were threatening with the ball, as if Fonua Pole, and the young gun combo of Jahream Bula and Junior Tupou have so much upside given where they are in their careers. 

Though Brooks continued his decent form of late, but was largely doing it on his own in good field position. It’s not enough, even against a defence as dubious as the Titans.

Compare to the likes of AJ Brimson and Jayden Campbell – and Sam Verrills, who laid on the clincher – and it is night and day.

Neither of these sides are good, but as the scoreline shows, one is still a lot better than the other.

Tino’s bumper bar problem

It would be tough to call it a trend, but this isn’t the first time that Tino’s ball-carrying technique has got him into trouble.

Indeed, it’s not even the first time in the last month, given that he laid out Bulldogs hooker Reed Mahoney in similar fashion in Round 12.

That incident was much more cut and dried than this, and Tino was fined for his part in it, but it is now worrying for the Titans – and Queensland – that the judiciary might see them as successive events and upgrade this latest sanction into a ban.

Whether it’s a foul or not is up for debate. On both occasions, Fa’asuamaleaui had a huge height advantage over the tackler and is perfectly entitled to lean into contact to bump them away, as well as using his arms to protect himself.

But he’s not allowed to turn his arm horizontally, and to use it for any reason other than defence. 

It will worry Fa’asuamaleaui that the judiciary has taken a dim view of similar incidents in the recent past, with Queensland’s Julia Robinson given two games for a raised arm that caught Isabelle Kelly in the throat in Women’s Origin last week.

On that occasion, there was no penalty either, but the injured player was taken to hospital. Once again, the Maroons will wait on the charges dropping, and then be forced to fight them if necessary.

The Crowd Says:

2023-06-11T11:57:38+00:00

langparker

Roar Rookie


Mate, he’s quick & elusive but they pick him up & carry him back 10 metres every time he returns a kick. Gotta get a bit more variety in his game & improve his passing game. Plenty of those quick young guys come in, look a million bucks until the video watchers wake up to them. It was a cracker of a fend on Tino though!

2023-06-09T10:13:50+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


I must have different angles, I don't see horizontal in anything.

2023-06-09T10:00:48+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Radley would have head butted him

2023-06-09T08:04:18+00:00

Bloke7

Roar Rookie


This case maybe but it doesn't make my point any less valid. This one is like the majority of hip drop tackles that seem relatively harmless but they still get sinbinned for the hip drop. , However, when it goes really wrong the raised elbow has the potential to be a lot more dangerous

2023-06-09T05:44:51+00:00

Muzz Manyana

Roar Rookie


Radley would be sidelined for weeks.

2023-06-09T05:17:07+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


He didn't raise his forearm

2023-06-09T05:16:39+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


Every guy who says raised elbow hasn't even watched the replays

2023-06-09T03:37:56+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


That is one obviouspart. Plus mid season is typically the interest slump for sports. That's part of the reason I think behind the length between matches. Keeps eyeballs on league and allows each match to built up then tapered from. Putting it post GF would be a mistake as your then trying to hold peak interest for several consecutive weeks and you either can't build to the GF or have to have interest tapering in the origin period.

2023-06-09T03:28:13+00:00

NQR

Roar Rookie


Suallii’s shoulder charge to Dearden’s head no penalty a fine then illegal late hit concussed CNK and he had concussion with time out for recovery. Mahoney was concussed and taken off. Suallii warned and fined for raising knees on 3 other occasions. He’s finally got a 3 week suspension. Kaufusi has had 7 weeks suspended but no player suffered an injury other than winding? Nanai has served a total of 2 weeks for his 2nd tipping tackle no injury to either opponent, then 4 weeks for hip drop and a player sustaining an injury. API lifts up the legs of opponents every 2nd tackle but it’s not a dangerous tactic? Then you have Haas hip drop 1 week player hurt player out for 8weeks? Jai Arrow out for 6-8weeks offender gets 1 week? Carrigan hip drop 1st offence player injured 4 weeks. It all over the place but there’s a pattern to who gets suspended quicker and longer. Then you have Billy with a shoulder charge yet there are shoulder charges every week not charged now. How do they ignoring the contact on Cobbo from Tedesco in Origin 1. Under Freddie’s duty of care rules Was Teddy also guilty of shoulder charging Fafita in the head?

2023-06-09T03:07:58+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It won’t happen that way The next young low profile player from a bottom of the tackle club who does it will be rubbed out as part of a “crackdown” because we need to get this rubbish out of the game Probably someone like Harrison Edwards, maybe the young Haas, Pole from the Tigers, Molo from the Dragons. Be ironic if it was Tino’s younger bro… someone like that Keep the bumpers down kids… you haven’t earned the right to break jaws and scramble brains with your forearms yet…

2023-06-09T03:04:44+00:00

Iron Fist

Roar Rookie


Cook was always going to be there for game 2, either at #9 or #14. He should have been for Game 1 and I’m sure Freddy and his advisors immediately recognised their folly in the aftermath of that match. There must be two acting half’s and Reece Robson will be in one of those jerseys now. As for the halves, it should’ve been Cleary and Hynes in Game 1, and I agree it should be Reynolds and Hynes in Game 2. FB – Teddy; LW – JAC; LC – Mitchell; RC – Crichton; RW – To’o; FE(L) – Hynes; HB (R)- Reynolds; AH – Cook; MF – Murray; LF – Martin; RF – Olakau’atu; PF – Paulo; PF – Haas; IC – Robson; IC – Yeo; IC – Leniu; IC – Tatola. Murray must play as an MF and work when Cook is on the on the field, so Yeo and Murray positions dependent on which Acting Half’s are starting or on the bench.

2023-06-09T03:00:59+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


From the field!

2023-06-09T02:42:09+00:00

Iron Fist

Roar Rookie


Tino hit Api even higher! The NRL have confirmed it's play-on. Gives every prop in the game clarity that they can lead and initiate contact with their forearm to an opponent's head.

2023-06-09T01:27:32+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


The non Tino - takeaways from this game i had; Even if Api stays on, I think the Tigers lose given a good percentage of ball still has to go through Wakeham and he had a worse than ordinary night... Except for his line drop outs and short kick offs.. which were pin point perfect.. but nobody bothered to chase them. The Campbell intercept play I thought was quite telling. Papali'i is still on his opponents tryline watching the play when Campbell is tackled 80m down field. Would PApali'i ever have caught Campbell? Know. But Papali'i would have taken another 2 or 3 tackles to get back if the tigers were able to hold on. It should anger Tigers fans given Papali'i baulked at coming to the tigers after signing. And it should anger them further that they lost their halfback to a hamstring injury on the same play, because he was actually trying.

2023-06-09T01:07:46+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


That is a very tough one. On any other part of the paddock it’s a shoulder charge. Two blokes flying in together at 90* angle both aiming for 1 sq ft of grass is very hard for the defender. I know from a Sharkies POV the fact they were beaten the following week isn’t much consolation. To answer the question, I wasn’t surprised he got off but I didn’t think he should have.

2023-06-09T01:01:00+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Just by the comments on here there is a lot of doubt between guilt and innocence. Most agree it was worse last week than this and I lean on the side of the outcome being worse than the action. I genuinely feel for Api and the Tigers and TBH makes me a little more concerned about the team Freddy may pick. However, I am also glad to see the MRC has cleared him, not as a Qlder but as a long time player/fan/part time coach and occasional juniors touchie. To say this was up there with the likes of JWH or NAS is simply wrong. It is a really unfortunate outcome but not illegal.

2023-06-09T00:52:54+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Agreed. What about Billy’ shoulder charge on dear old Feki defended successfully as merely a collision.. Tighter ?

2023-06-09T00:42:58+00:00

langparker

Roar Rookie


So, no charge at all from the judiciary, as it should be. Surely you can run with the ball & not have to somehow tuck your arms & elbows behind your back so defenders get a better shot at you. Some outlandish comments on here, what planet is Panthers living on.

2023-06-09T00:41:12+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


I reckon that is a pretty lose parallel.

2023-06-09T00:19:40+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Boy... a lot of calls here to rub people out based on outcome, rather than the action itself.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar