ANALYSIS: Hynes gets last laugh on Gus as Sharks go on feeding frenzy against fragile Bulldogs

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Nicho Hynes was supposedly a bit fragile after his Origin debut, according to Phil Gould. The Sharks half had the last laugh on Sunday afternoon with Cronulla taking Gould’s Bulldogs to the cleaners in a 48-10 thumping.

Hynes was agile, Canterbury’s defence nothing but fragile.

Gould was there in his guise as Channel Nine commentator and the Canterbury general manager was bemused on several occasions as his team dished up dopey errors.

For Hynes there is of course a world of difference between taking on the bumbling Bulldogs as opposed to the marauding Maroons but at least he bounced back after a below-par performance seven days prior in Cronulla’s 54-10 shellacking from the Storm.

After two losses on the trot, Craig Fitzgibbon’s side is back up to an 8-6 record and fifth spot on the ladder but it will take much more than a cakewalk against Canterbury to prove they are legitimate title contenders.

Nicho Hynes. (Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Hynes sight for sore eyes

On his 27th birthday, Hynes started the match nervously after his controversial dumping from the NSW team, kicking a bomb out on the full and dishing up a forward pass.

But he rebounded as the ball did likewise off his knees, picking it up to run 90 metres only to be denied by a Jake Averillo try-saving tackle. But the Sharks posted first points on the next play when Teig Wilton surged through the scrambled defence. 

“It’s been a bit of a challenging week but I’ve tried to block out all the news and worry about controlling what I can control and that’s what I tried to do today,” he told Fox League.

“Last week we took it personal because the Storm forward pack rolled through us a fair bit and had a lot of offloads. We really wanted to stand up today.”

Fitzgibbon said Hynes “got the balance right” in his game.

“You want your playmakers to make plays but he’s also responsible for us getting into the style of footy we want to play, not shooting ourselves in the foot with high-risk stuff,” he said. “I thought he tackled strong and ran the ball a lot.”

The second-year coach was pleased with his team’s response after their Melbourne mauling and that they “earned the right to play better footy”.

One-way traffic at Shark Park

After Hynes’ early efforts set up Wilton drawing first blood, front-rower Braden Hamlin-Uele and winger Ronaldo Mulitalo touched down as the home side stretched out to an 18-0 lead.

Kyle Flanagan, recalled to halfback for the first time in two months to cap off a week of redemption stories for the family, touched down to reduce the deficit to 14 but Cameron McInnes and Jack Williams touched down to make it 30-4 at half-time.

If Canterbury fans expected their team to show some fight in the second stanza, they were sadly mistaken.

Rookie prop Tom Hazelton sparked raucous celebrations when he registered his first try in the NRL, Briton Nikora touched down in his 100th game and when Jesse Ramien joined the rout, it was 48-4 at the mid-point of the second half.

At one point after his team had managed to take the ball no further than five metres from their goal line after three plays, Dogs captain Reed Mahoney hoofed the Steeden downfield to try to get his team out of trouble.

A Kurtis Morrin barge-over try late in the contest made the final scoreline slightly less embarrassing.

Slightly.

Defence was soft, however you describe it

Fragile is the term du jour but whichever way you describe it, Canterbury’s defence was paper thin.

Flimsy, flimsy, frail or another word starting with F would also be accurate descriptions.

They had their line broken 10 times in the first hour of play before the Sharks took their foot off the accelerator in the closing stages.

Dogs fans are suffering deja vu with the Cameron Ciraldo era so far unfolding very similar to the Trent Barrett and Dean Pay iterations following the Des Hasler experience of front-end gain followed by back-end pain.

Canterbury have been banged up this year due to injuries with Viliame Kikau, Josh Addo-Carr, Luke Thompson and Bailey Biondi-Odo spending large chunks of the season in the casualty ward and losing Matt Burton to NSW 18th man duty was a body blow heading into Sunday’s trip to Cronulla.

But even after their umpteenth roster overhaul, the results are not turning around.

“We’re not having much go right for us at the moment,” said Ciraldo, surprisingly not too downcast in the post-match media conference. “I was happy with the way we finished. It was ugly enough but it could have got uglier in the last 10-15 minutes. I liked how we didn’t give up.”

He added that the previous hour they made too many errors. “It’s all around the fundamentals, the basics of the game. You sort of expect that with young guys, going through those periods. But it doesn’t make it any easier.

“How much they’re hurting in there, makes me realise we’re on the right track.”

They are mired in 15th spot with just five wins from 15 starts after conceding the most points in the NRL, earning the unwanted honour on Sunday of becoming the first team to let in 400 for the year, up to 407, well clear of the next worst, North Queensland on 374.

“They’ve been out-competed in a number of areas, and that’s really disappointing,” former Bulldogs captain Micheal Ennis said on Fox League commentary.

The Bulldogs have not sniffed the finals since 2016 and have not finished any better than 11th.

And that drought won’t end this year. They’ll be hard pressed to avoid the wooden spoon at this rate.

The Crowd Says:

2023-06-19T11:03:57+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Unfortunately RL is a small world.

2023-06-19T11:00:16+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Mate that was us Eels fans circa 2015. Practically word for word, just changed the names.

2023-06-19T10:57:24+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Yes but Bennett had a blank slate to work with, he didn’t have to spend 2 or 3 years fixing a salary cap mess.

2023-06-19T10:52:50+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Baz had certainly helped our attack this season.

2023-06-19T10:51:48+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Where did he say that TPJ is better than RCG. He is on record saying that he thinks RCG is in the top 3 middle forwards in the game. And Moses is a better option than Reynolds or Hynes.

2023-06-19T09:09:57+00:00

Renegade

Roar Guru


The guy thinks Pangai Jr is better than RCG and that Moses is a better option than Hynes or Reynolds….. the master of hindsight is only right after the fact “I’ve said all along blah blah blah”…. Even though he never said it.

2023-06-19T09:09:41+00:00

Noel

Roar Rookie


Well... Technically he's not running around just now... Toby Sexton is quality too. But Trindall has been very good for a few years now.

2023-06-19T07:47:43+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Sam Walker ?

2023-06-19T06:53:28+00:00

Blings

Roar Rookie


Isn’t Bennett putting Gould and Ciraldo to shame up North?! First season of the entire club and the Dolphins are competitive most weeks, if not winning 50% of their games. Ciraldo and should have had 2-3 years (with a giant, established Sydney club) and are worse this year than any of the last 7 that they have not made the finals - bizarre!! Never hear Bennett complaining of injuries even though the Dolphins have been decimated as well.

2023-06-19T06:06:21+00:00

Noel

Roar Rookie


I reckon Trindall is the best half running around in second grade since O'Sullivan left the Panthers.

2023-06-19T06:03:17+00:00

Noel

Roar Rookie


For years at the Broncos, we all imagined what TPJ might do if he ran, full tilt, in a straight line... The stuff of genuine nightmares. We all hoped he would just watch replays of Shane Webke in his prime, and we would quietly listen for the penny to drop.

2023-06-19T05:13:35+00:00

Ferret

Roar Rookie


On a side topic - are we so short of NRL TV commentators that we have to have a CEO commentate on his own club?!? Or coaches (Shane Flannagan) commentate on his past, current and future club? Or ex-players on their old clubs? (Or Brandy, Fittler, Slater, Smith etc etc) I'm not blaming them for being biased (indeed I'd worry if they weren't) but it's a worry that Ch9 & Fox figure they can lump us with the old boys. As a neutral its annoying, if you're a fan of the opposition it must be infuriating. Maybe one for colour comments but never rostered onto a game where there is a conflict of interest. It's bad enough when they commentate through their wallets.

2023-06-19T05:12:48+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Maybe, but they seemed to take all the bigger players ( who aren’t that big ), off together. The majority of Cronulla players to score & make breaks were forwards. Cronulla weren’t really forced to look any further than to give the ball to the forwards.

2023-06-19T04:57:30+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Pangai, Pele, King, not little boys and Burto is the biggest 7 in the universe. Lacked a little junkyard in them yesterday.

2023-06-19T04:49:56+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Yep ! The Dogs were pretty terrible yesterday . Firstly, they are too "Burton centric" and when he is not there they are pretty well clueless. Burton himself is too kick happy , so backline moves are rare. Good wingers like Kiraz get little ball apart from dummy half runs out of defence. Flanagan tried hard yesterday but is lacking real NRL ability. Karl Oloapu has potential but is a couple of years away from realising it. Perham is not NRL quality. Nor is Brayden Burns. Averillo & Alamonti will develop. TPG is just not having a consistent impact leading the forwards. Patolo is big baby but might develop. Pele can develop with time. Mahoney is hard working 9 needing more support. King is a good worker but has little impact. Preston is a beauty and my rookie of the year. Morrin is all enthusiasm but needs more experience. Waddell is a mistake-a -thon. They need Kikau & Thompson back to provide a bit of starch. But they need a halfback & Fullback most of all.

2023-06-19T03:31:21+00:00

RedcliffeFan

Roar Rookie


The pattern continues. Cronulla look great in putting an ordinary side to the sword after yet again failing against a good team - and failing badly. Their next block of matches all look like potential wins so it will be some time before it is clear whether their fragility against top eight sides continues. I am betting it will - unfortunately.

2023-06-19T01:54:11+00:00

Farmyard Friend

Roar Rookie


Tomorrow never comes? Reminds me of the pub signs “Free beer tomorrow”.

2023-06-19T01:47:26+00:00

quoinkey

Roar Rookie


Nico is definitely a superstar but so many are fragile these days. Is my memory just selective or are there more injuries to the halves and fullbacks these days?

2023-06-19T01:34:37+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Size was the key. Too small as a group of players. Not saying they are bad players, just too small together. Could see that the way Cronulla forwards poured through all over the place & on the try line. Morrin plays above his size & is a keeper. Preston has been a real find this season, but thought he looked on a few times yesterday & didn’t attempt a tackle.

2023-06-19T01:18:45+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


I don’t mind that, if it’s so? Take a look at the Panthers assistant coaches when they are doing well, then bypass them . Though it didn’t stop Parramatta hiring Barrett as an assistant coach. Then wasn’t Ciraldo the key to Penrith’s defence?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar