Biltong vs blarney: World Cup classic battle leaves both teams with a sense of final destiny - and a key area they must fix

By Harry Jones / Expert

SAINT DENIS – With an hour to go before the Pool B bragging rights kickoff, old Paarl Gym cricket teammates Schalk Burger and Jean de Villiers were getting made up by the Springbok cosmetologist under the hot lights of Stade de France on a cool night.

The Bleu fortress had turned green already, with most of the 80,000 partisans already inside, eating and sledging and hoping.

Dark and light green mixed and mingled in that lovely rugby way: a family from Cork sharing chips and chirps with a Cape contingent. The original social network: a rugby match between the best of rivals.

A pack of big Bok fans, we will call them the Biltong Squad, had mauled their way to the barriers and asked Burger, whose quick makeup job was far faster than de Villiers’ ornate Mona Lisa job.

“Schalla! Biltong?” they bellowed, the red faced leader with brown paper bags of the good stuff in hand.

If all the currencies finally tank into a crypto diamond big hole and we are bartering again, that succulent saddle-salted shred of steak will be the new dollar. In the north rugby village before the match I watched gendarme search Saffa backpacks for the precious staple of treks the world over. Biltong confiscation will be Fabien Galthie’s quarterfinal game plan.

Standing with mic in hand just behind his former captain and provocateur, Burger motioned for the pass.

The bag of biltong came out of the big fan’s hand perfectly. It spiraled towards blazered Burger.

At the very last instant, de Villiers reached out and snagged it as his mascara was being applied, ripped it open and stuck a stick in his mouth like a cigarette. The Interception King still has it; Burger had to bow.

South Africa would have dearly loved an interception to break open a match in which they built the narrow edge but failed to convert.

The score is final and fair and a deserved win for stout Irish defence must be lauded for its poise and composure. Johnny Sexton’s kicks to the line and to the poles were the work of a master.

As Catherine Phil MacCarthy wrote about the Aviva’s trees, but could have been saying about the old number ten:

“Mature trees defy wonders of the boom, promise irretrievable Dublin.”

Meanwhile, if the Bomb Squad did the second half job it is made to do, the Tee Squad for South Africa left 11 realistic points on the green field.

Coaches love to show a team where they can improve. The Boks crossed the gainline on half their carries; the Irish only on a third. South Africa had more chances at the line than the Irish, and forced penalties in kickable positions.

The referee giveth and the referee taketh away. If the tryline maul sack was dubious to end the game, Manie Libbok’s and Faf de Klerk’s radars were the more dubious.

Do their job and it is a 19-13 win. Irish rebuttals about fixing their leaky lineout are not analogous to kicks at posts because that is the one moment your opponent is stuck watching you work for 90 seconds. The Bok locks were up early and often in Ronan Kelleher’s sights; and Andy Farrell gave Paul O’Connell an earful at the half.

In the second half, the Boks turned off the lineout leaping contest and seemed to work on maul defence.

In a rematch, South Africa may not be as profligate off the tee or as experimental in casting and tactics.

The French television crew kept showing sharpshooter Handre Pollard at ironic moments; perhaps foreshadowing their own quarterfinal story on the 15th of October here.

Irish fans around me all said the same thing as they shook my hand: “See you in the final.”

Tadhg Beirne Of Ireland Recovers The Ball From The Base Of The Ruck During The Rugby World Cup France 2023 Match Between South Africa And Ireland At Stade De France On September 23, 2023 In Paris, France. (Photo By Matthias Hangst/Getty Images)

Whether that is a statement about French dependence on wounded Antoine Dupont or a compliment to how well the Boks stymied their juggernaut attack (keeping Ireland to 13: any team would take that), there was a feeling of a heavyweight rematch on the night.

Unbeaten Ireland needed to keep winning by any means necessary. Their warmups were regimented. Sexton is already a coach. Not a second was wasted.

In the match, the Irish loose forwards were relentless, Bundee Aki was a steamroller, James Lowe launched kicks that seemed to exit the hole in the top of the stadium, and tricky Mack Hanson continued his unlikely assault on reason and sense.

With the exception of the lineout, one wonders how much better they could play.

At final whistle, the mostly Irish crowd let loose into song after song; the players embraced as if it was a quarterfinal win at last.

Damian Willemse of South Africa is dragged away from speaking to Jonathan Sexton of Ireland after the first South African try during the 2023 Rugby World Cup Pool B match between South Africa and Ireland at Stade de France in Paris, France. (Photo By Brendan Moran/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

The cost will be counted in days to come; several looked out on their feet.

The Boks were loose all night. In warmups, Duane Vermeulen was showing off his gridiron spirals, 7-1 casualty Willie le Roux was doing backheels, and Deon Fourie was enjoying his throwing practice, even taking a moment to munch on extra biltong from that same intercepted bag.

Rassie Erasmus was on the pitch for an hour taking drop goals and hugging anyone he could catch. Bryan Habana was speaking French to anyone who would listen. The Bok warmup song was vibe; the Irish had headbanger songs.

It is difficult to imagine Erasmus and Jacques Nienaber being disappointed with the Bok defence, and they are pragmatic enough not to trust Libbok to save their biltong in a power matchup with France.

They will be able to show two ‘tries’ that should be converted and any cultural downside of bringing Pollard back in was just solved; Farrell and O’Connell can address their lineout and the Dan Sheehan versus Ronan Kelleher set piece debate is also done.

In the end, kicking out of hand (low by both sides; 20 Irish and 19 South Africa) and aerial contest was superb, but small moments (a slip at scrum, an invisible ball at maul, a caroming penalty off a pole, and timely steals by dogged Ireland) and key execution were the difference.

As we streamed into the fresh air and navigated the overrun trains, defended by the dysfunction of overburdened machines, Ireland was singing and hugging; Bok fans were quiet and thinking of what comes next at this very stadium.

Did we just see a preview of a final? Or will the biltong be confiscated again?

The Crowd Says:

2023-09-26T06:56:48+00:00

ShortBlind

Roar Rookie


:thumbup: Thanks for the tip Matt. Used to live in CH never heard of KK, will look him up. :thumbup:

2023-09-25T10:32:46+00:00

Bopeti

Roar Rookie


totally agree - with nothing on the line except bragging right RasNie were trying things. As has been mentioned the Irish can only fix their line outs and SA reverted to maul defence in the 2nd half. This is not by accident but by design. Id even tin hat it that SA would rather play France especially given theyve now experienced an 'away' game as Sat mustve felt like Dublin.

2023-09-25T10:28:32+00:00

Bopeti

Roar Rookie


Yet Irish first choice hooker missed 4 throws....where the boks missed Marx was at the final maul where he knows when to release or press forwards.

2023-09-25T09:25:09+00:00

Carlin

Roar Rookie


Epic battle. Great intensity and physicality by both teams. Ireland deserved the win on the back of some brave goal line defence in the first half but did think their wobbly lineout was going to play into the Springboks hands earlier on. I thought Bundee Aki and James Low both had big games. Aki with his ability to break through a couple of times and Lowe seemed to have a big moment every time the ball got near him especially with his defence winning a couple of crucial turnovers and some of his kicking (I think he did kick one out on the full). Thanks Harry.

2023-09-25T09:07:07+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


AD a big loss. They’re saying he’ll potentially be back for quarters but I can’t see it if he’s fractured his face. No training then step into a physical contest? Fair play if he does.

2023-09-25T08:56:09+00:00

CheetahBok

Roar Rookie


Okay then :stoked:

2023-09-25T08:48:40+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


They have not always been. Tries were 3 points until the 70s, four points until the 90s. Why are 3 points for a penalty goal better than 2? Before the 90s you couldn’t lift in the line outs. Before the 60s you could kick the ball out on the full outside the 22 and the lineout would take place where the ball crossed the line. Imagine how dull that could be. Would you have said don’t change it? If you don’t like the comment don’t read instead of getting personal. You’re clearly not capable of critical thought.

AUTHOR

2023-09-25T08:44:12+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


It’s always been the best matchup bc FR is borderline obsessed w NZ + relies on the precise style that works worst vs SA. Now, AD is a question mark whilst Pollard is back. You’d think SA will be able to handle (counter with) long kicks.

2023-09-25T06:24:32+00:00

Chucked

Roar Rookie


I actually agree with most of these points. o’Keefe let away far too much. NZ would have lived BOK in their game against the BOKs if he refereed like this

2023-09-25T05:58:59+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


How do you feel about Boks potentially playing France in quarter?

2023-09-25T04:43:02+00:00

pm

Roar Rookie


I felt a bit like that watching it. Might be more their fans dominant presence at the match. I doubt Farrell is carried away. But I remember England doing something of a victory lap to celebrate their semi- win four years ago. That felt too happy.

2023-09-25T04:35:21+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


Bok wing taken out jumping - no sound from anyone. Before last irish penalty - Porter laying on the wrong side than enables ireland to counterruck - no penalty. bok try - thats the kind of forward pass u expect barnes to miss :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: EE lifted above horizontal at maul - but in any super rugger match, lift of even a single leg was penalized - not forgetting the maul was collapsed and ball given to ireland. last maul - ireland prop swimming but no call. every time boks sent the irish scrum down no penalty but only time boks went down penalty 2nd half irish line out works - coz boks dont contest and most throws crooked but not called - watch the very first throw to Henderson!!! if letting a game flow means - not applying the laws , then why have a ref in the middle - as the commentary said let Sexton coach and rule the game :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: as for JVF and Aki complaint - before the step on hand , he was grabbing both feet of bok prop . era before cameras and bans would have got a kick to face for that shyt :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly: :silly:

2023-09-25T04:08:11+00:00

MattTheContrarian

Roar Rookie


I'm not sure if thats a complaint? :laughing: Thought the reffing team was pretty good myself. Didnt listen to Josh van der Flier crying that Ox stepped on his hand, was rational, played some good advantage. No cards. I mean. I cant be the only one?

AUTHOR

2023-09-25T04:04:11+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Yes, it was worth it to both sides to do a bit of work against best competition thus far.

AUTHOR

2023-09-25T04:03:15+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


14 and 15 October offers us rugby heaven, really. SA matches up with France quite well, and IRE-NZ has become a proper grudge match. I cannot wait for it; tickets done, hotels overpaid, flights in pocket. Let’s go!

2023-09-25T03:13:40+00:00

CUW

Roar Rookie


@ HARRY JONES this was a rubbish reffing performance by the team. it looked as if they were under WR instructions - THIS IS THE MATCH DONT EFF IT UP !!! noone else will be allowed to take so much time to get set at a line out. noone else will be allowed to godown at scrums. noone else will be allowed to backchat at ref at every decision. noone else will go thru a match without any TMO interferance. noone else will be allowed to play a match like a sunday evening throwabout!!!

2023-09-25T02:23:54+00:00

Bluesfan


Yip he is such a great player and adds so much value to the Boks. If Boks had fully fit Pollard, Am and Marx - that's a team to go all the way and win the WC. Frankly WC starting to remind me around the U20 WC and how the North has become so strong and now would not be surprised if both Boks and AB's are out in the QF stage.

2023-09-25T02:09:31+00:00

Jonty Shonty

Roar Pro


Goal kicking a big issue. And Marx is a huge loss for sure.

2023-09-25T01:08:51+00:00

Fiordla d

Roar Rookie


Both sides supporters patting each other on the back and buying tickets to the final expecting to face each other are effectively at this stage writing off Scotland, England, France, Wales, Fiji, NZ and Argentina. France are a very strong team with huge home crowds, Dupont is good but they've got decent replacements who have time to prepare. He may even play if they make the final. Looking at the likely quarter finalists there's plenty of potential for either the Boks or Ireland to not make the final. After all the RWC fairy tale only ever happens for one team not two.

2023-09-25T00:37:23+00:00

Bluesfan


You would hope so and sure Bok coaches have some fixes in mind But big issues still remain for the Boks: 1. Goal Kicking - Is Pollard fit enough to start a game and/or can you afford to carry him on the bench? 2. Break down presence - without Marx big issue. 3. Hooker - Fourie clearly not up to it. But any alternative - do you want him throwing 5 metres out on your or opposition tryline in last 5 minutes? Clearly see how badly Marx's injury has hit Boks - just a great player but so pivotal to Boks gameplan.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar