Marnus form slump becoming a concern as Aussies grind Pakistan into Perth dust with all-round dominance

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Australia should have no trouble wrapping up the First Test at Perth’s Optus Stadium but they have a new concern developing at the top of the order with the once-prolific Marnus Labuschagne amid a rare slump.

The star No.3 fell cheaply for the second time in the match when he was out for one in the second innings on Saturday when Australia elected to bat again rather than enforcing the follow-on after bowling Pakistan out for 271, a mammoth 216 in arrears.

Labuschagne looked tentative in his brief stay at the crease and departed for two when he top-edged debutant seamer Khurram Shahzad from the 18th ball he faced. 

He received treatment after a Shahzad delivery leapt up off a crack and struck him on the right hand but managed to continue before falling in the next over he faced from the rookie. It was later confirmed that he had gone for scans on the injured digit.

Marnus Labuschagne looks dejected after being dismissed. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

The 29-year-old Queenslander has registered just 736 runs from 23 innings in 2023 at a modest average of 35.04.

After his career average was a superb 60.82 after the two-Test series cakewalk against the West Indies 12 months ago, it has now dipped to 52.15, his lowest in four years since he established himself as one of the world’s premier red-ball batters.

Labuschagne, who made just 16 in the first dig before he was trapped in front, has scored just one ton and three half-centuries this year to slip from No.1 in the world rankings to fifth, with Travis Head and Usman Khawaja poised to leapfrog him if his meagre returns continue.

Since blasting 163 against the Windies in Adelaide last December, he’s been out for 30 or less on 14 occasions in 26 innings.

There is no question about Labuschagne’s spot in the team but after Cricket Australia chose him as one of two players to receive a three-year contract, the team can’t afford his downswing to continue with a new top-order player set to join the line-up next month when David Warner retires.

Labuschagne was sent off for scans by the team medicos – if they confirm a break and he’s ruled out of the Boxing Day Test, all-rounder Cameron Green would likely return to the side at No.4 in the line-up with Smith elevated a spot.

“He was just with the doc and physio for the last hour just chatting through it and doing a few tests on the finger,” teammate Josh Hazlewood said. “(It’s) pretty sore I think.”

Warner, who stamped his ticket to his retirement farewell at the SCG with his first-innings century, also fell early in the second innings after Pat Cummins elected to have a rest alongside his fellow bowlers after needing 102 overs to bowl the tourists out midway through day three. 

The 37-year-old left-hander also skied an attempted pull shot before troubling the scorers, also off Shahzad’s bowling.

Usman Khawaja (34) and Steve Smith (43) swung the momentum back to the Australians to navigate their way to 2-84 at stumps, a lead of an even 300.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Smith needed treatment after copping a nasty blow to the forearm but he said after stumps that he was fine.

“It’s all right, a bit of a bruise, but I’ll live,” Smith told Fox Cricket after play.

“That was challenging there. The light got a bit dark, and Shaheen’s got a whippy action with his wrist, so it was quite hard picking up the length of those, but I got through it.”

With the Perth turf starting to show variable bounce, the Australians will feel comfortable setting Pakistan a target anywhere north of 350 and are likely to bat into the second session on day four before trying to finish the job.

After resuming at 2-132, Cummins knocked over Shahzad early after he had fulfilled his nightwatch duties before Imam-ul-Haq and Baba Azam crawled along for 21 overs while putting just 48 on the board.

Following his first-innings 90, Mitchell Marsh underlined his all-round value by dismissing Babar with a well-executed outswinger for 21 and Imam fell 14 runs later when he tried to smack Nathan Lyon out of the stadium but only proceeded in gifting Alex Carey a stumping opportunity.

Imam’s rush of blood was bizarre considering he had provided stout resistance for the previous 198 deliveries.

Mitchell Starc made short work of Sarfaraz Ahmed (three) and apart from cameos from Saud Shakeel (28) and Agha Salman (28 not out), the lower order offered little resistance with the final seven Pakistan wickets falling for just 90 runs.

Nathan Lyon looked set to chalk up his 500th Test wicket milestone as the tail folded but Travis Head burgled the last dismissal when Shaheen Shah Afridi mistimed a slog to Khawaja. 

It was a team effort by the bowling unit with Lyon leading the way with 3-66 from 24 overs, with Cummins (2-35) and Starc (2-68) offering solid support and Hazlewood, Head and Marsh chiming in.

“It’s a good day to sit in the air-con for us quicks,” Cummins told Fox Cricket when asked why he didn’t tell Pakistan to bat again.

With the temperatures in Perth hovering at 35 degrees, it was a popular decision among his fellow bowlers.

While Lyon is just one wicket away from becoming the third Australian to take 500 in Tests behind legends Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath, Starc is now within striking distance of another baggy green icon in Dennis Lillee, needing just 21 more scalps this summer to move into fourth on the all-time list.

MOST TEST WICKETS BY AN AUSTRALIAN

708 – Shane Warne
563 – Glenn McGrath
499 – Nathan Lyon*
355 – Dennis Lillee
335 – Mitchell Starc*
313 – Mitchell Johnson
(* denotes: still playing)

The Crowd Says:

2023-12-18T22:01:44+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


The Kiwi pitches have tended to be pretty flat. I remember watching Jofra Archer play there a few years ago and the poor guy was hardly able to get the ball to bail height. That said, they played a series draw with England last year, so might be offering something a bit more sporting this time round.

2023-12-18T10:27:13+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Those two lads could team up against the Kiwis in the test series. A possibility but it depends on the kiwi hierarchy. Do they choose a spin friendly deck? Nullify our pace most likely.

2023-12-18T09:07:05+00:00

DTM

Roar Rookie


I can't imagine they would do that. Who would they choose? You wouldn't want another off spinner so that rules out Murphy, Rocchiocolli, Chris Green, Manenti. Our leggies (Swepson, Sangha and Zampa) can't bat. Perhaps Agar but Khunemann couldn't be considered as an all rounder. Then there's Connolly and McKenzie but they are miles away from test cricket. Who else?

2023-12-18T01:12:53+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


Who are we to argue with she who must be obeyed

2023-12-17T22:32:23+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


And Trumble took 2 Hat Tricks. The last was the final 3 balls of his career

2023-12-17T22:30:01+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


And the really stark figure for Clarrie was that he was the first and fastest to 200 wickets and it took over 60 bowlers and about 80 years for someone to do it quicker. The guy was a freak of nature.

2023-12-17T13:15:17+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


422 if you include his 67 in WSC Supertests. http://howstat.com/cricket/Statistics/WSC/BowlingAverages.asp

2023-12-17T13:14:15+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Lillee took 67 wickets in 14 Supertests. Though he was behind a few others on averages - Le Roux, Procter, Imran Khan, 3 West Indians and Max Walker.

2023-12-17T13:10:35+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


The point is that aggregates mean little compared to averages, or wickets per Test. Alistair Cook scored 80% more runs than Bradman. Lyon has taken just twice the number of wickets as Grimmett in more than three times as many Tests over roughly the same number of years, for an average of 24 compared to Lyon’s 31, in an era when runs per wicket were similar.

2023-12-17T11:47:24+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Less issues about selection.

2023-12-17T11:42:03+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


I have pointed this out more than once. The best opposition available. Would have taken him to 440 wickets.

2023-12-17T10:54:39+00:00

Andrew

Roar Rookie


Please elaborate. His away average is 37.62. That is 23% above the global average.

2023-12-17T10:17:44+00:00

Johnno

Roar Rookie


Lillee’s games are reduced because he played a few years of World Series Cricket, which aren’t included in official figures. He took 80 something wickets in that by memory.

2023-12-17T10:15:43+00:00

Rolando

Roar Rookie


And which state do you reside in/follow?

2023-12-17T10:09:41+00:00

Rolando

Roar Rookie


In the last 5 year Marnus has been that number 3 ( away from home).

2023-12-17T09:43:17+00:00

Rolando

Roar Rookie


A little consternation in relation to this. I think Steve Smith’s lack of consistent big scores ( especially when needed against tough opposition) is more a concern. The current love for Travis Head ( and before him Cam Green) is at least partly because Steve Smith has been unable to lift Aus out of a predicament ( unlike Mike Hussey for example). SS’s flashy scores against England a number of years ago need to be thrown into relief.

2023-12-17T08:43:05+00:00

Andrew

Roar Rookie


In the last 5 years a number 3 batter away from home averages 30.32. Marnus this year has averaged 35.5 away from home in the two most difficult destinations. He averaged 39.875 in Pakistan and Sri Lanka. His home form has been exceptional. There is no form problem with Marnus.

2023-12-17T06:05:38+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Continual focus on aggregate wickets and runs is so wide of the mark when comparing players of different eras. Starc not in the same ballpark as Lillee who simply didn’t play as many Tests per year. Also misleading when comparing Lyon to the likes of Grimmett and O’Reilly.

2023-12-17T06:05:14+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Continual focus on aggregate wickets and runs is so misleading when comparing players of different eras. Starc not in the same ballpark as Lillee who simply didn’t play as many Tests per year. Also misleading when comparing Lyon to the likes of Grimmett and O’Reilly.

2023-12-17T05:59:20+00:00

The Knightwatchmen who say Nii

Roar Rookie


Second best game after cricket, for mine. And it's a close run thing.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar