The farcical nature of the Pre-Season Challenge was on display at Belmore Sports Ground on Friday when the Roosters and Rabbitohs clashed while fielding NSW Cup standard line-ups.
Later in the night, the Bulldogs and Sharks rolled out near full-strength sides in a much better quality contest but for Canterbury coach Cameron Ciraldo, he has a few glaring headaches before the start of the regular season as his club tries to qualify for the finals for the first time since 2016.
Bulldogs 6, Sharks 12
Halfback, fullback a headache for Ciraldo
If Cameron Ciraldo thinks Drew Hutchison is the answer to their halfback problem, he’s asking the wrong questions.
The former Roosters playmaker struggled in the first half with a poor defensive read to concede the opening try, bombing a Bulldogs four-pointer with a poor pass and giving a couple of his runners hospital passes as they were crunched by the grateful Sharks defence.
For all the millions spent on new recruits in the past few years, the Dogs still haven’t solved their highest priority – finding a halfback who can harness their talented stars.
Josh Curran runs the ball for the Dogs against Cronulla at Belmore. (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)
Whether Ciraldo goes into Round 1 with Hutchison or ex-Titans playmaker Toby Sexton alongside Matt Burton, chances are the half will become the latest in a long line of playmakers who have been handed the role but have been chewed up and spat out of the kennel’s revolving doggy door.
Sexton only got 16 minutes of game time at the end when Burton was given a breather so he is highly unlikely to be given the keys to the team for their trip to Parramatta to kick off the season.
Fullback is Ciraldo’s other problem spot with former Rabbitohs utility Blake Taaffe making a string of fundamental errors at the back.
Stephen Crichton came to Canterbury from Penrith hoping to establish himself in his preferred position of fullback but after being selected for his club debut at centre, he was benched after 20 minutes.
He should have been running at fullback every training session in the pre-season and getting a chance to establish some on-field combinations from the back in this game but Ciraldo seemingly has other plans for their marquee signing.
As things currently stand, the Dogs are on course for another season of disappointment with not even a sniff of the playoffs in their nostrils.
For the Sharks, they played as you would expect their professional outfit to operate.
Even with Nicho Hynes in cotton wool for Round 1 after blowing off his summer cobwebs in the All-Stars game last week, they looked solid as always.
Second-rower Teig Wilton looked strong, touching down for the opening try, in his comeback from a knee injury which cut short his 2023 campaign.
They will be strong again this season but whether they can knock over the top dogs, not teams like the Bulldogs, will be the lingering question hovering over them until they prove otherwise.
“That was way too easy … paper thin,” said Fox Sports analyst Cooper Conk when Wilton sliced past Hutchison to draw first blood on the scoreboard.
Briton Nikora prevented Canterbury equalising on the half-hour mark with a diving cover tackle on ex-Sharks centre Bronson Xerri but was banished to the bin for holding on way too long afterwards.
The hosts eventually capitalised on their numerical advantage with Jacob Preston crashing over just before the break.
With both coaches emptying their bench to give extended squad members a taste of NRL action, the attack in particular was ragged for each team even though both sides muscled up in defence.
The winning try from a Bulldogs passing error with winger Chris Vea’ila sprinting away for an early birthday present the night before he turns 21.
Burton may have a judiciary drama to deal with after he was placed on report for a high shot in the second half – it goes without saying (or typing in this instance) that if he is suspended for Round 1, the downward Dogs will be at even longer odds to upset Parra.
Sharks forward Jesse Colquhoun could also be missing when they open their account away to the Warriors after limping off with a foot injury.
Rabbitohs 10, Roosters 46
Young Chooks ready for step up
Because the two clubs are involved in next weekend’s Las Vegas opening round double-header, they were missing their top players and virtually unrecognisable teams duked it out.
A similar scenario will unfold at Brookvale on Saturday evening when Manly and Brisbane trot out reserve-grade squads.
The NRL is trying beyond all logic to fashion some sort of pre-season tournament as a way to drive up the broadcast rights when the next deal is up for negotiation but it’s impossible to come up with a format for 17 teams over two rounds that is workable or interesting.
Bless those Fox Sports commentators for following orders from above by spruiking the permutations of what each result means in the grand scheme of the Pre-Season Challenge standings which are determined not just by wins but the amount of tries scored and an array of stats which are then divided by the number of spanners in a Sidchrome toolkit.
With the four Vegas teams running dead in Round 2 and the Panthers in Wigan as they try to add the World Club Challenge to their bulging trophy cabinet, there are a dozen sides in contention for the $100,000 carrot which has been dangled in front of the clubs to treat this competition seriously.
From the evidence of last year and this pre-season, coaches have not changed their pre-season routines one bit with even the teams unaffected by the vagaries of Vegas giving their stars just one hit-out before rotating through their fringe first-graders and young prospects coming through the ranks.
For the match itself, veteran prop Dylan Napa was the only Rooster with NRL experience but it was the uncapped players in their pack who caught the eye.
Powerful lock Salesi Foketi is one to watch – he scored a try, made 224 running metres and topped the tackle count for his side with 34.
Alex Young runs the ball for the Roosters against South Sydney at Belmore. (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)
Dominic Young’s younger brother Alex turned out on the wing but was relatively quiet as his fellow outside backs cashed in on the Roosters’ dominant performance.
Fullback Callum Gromek crossed for two tries as the Roosters raced to a 20-6 lead at half-time before registering a comprehensive 46-10 triumph.
In the grand scheme of things, this result will not matter for either club but for Roosters fans, they can be assured that the club has yet another crop of young prospects ready to step up to the top grade with Jared Waerea-Hargreaves, Joseph Manu, Joseph Suaalii and potentially Angus Crichton leaving Bondi Junction at season’s end.
Worlds Biggest
Roar Pro
Taafe was in the halves in the South’s junior teams coming through and think that’s his spot. The problem with the Dogs is when you have two halfbacks then you don’t have one. Hutchison is not a 7 whilst Sexton is solid and nothing more at this stage. Given all the wraps Ciraldo has garnered as an up and coming coach, very surprised he hasn’t settled on a halfback which is the teams most glaring need.
Forty Twenty
Roar Rookie
Small players need a weapon or two to do well in 1st grade. I can't see where Taafe is above average at anything. If he was one of the quickest players around he would stand a good chance but he isn't.
SSTID
Roar Rookie
I like Taafe, but he is definitely not a consistent full time NRL first grade player. As Tetley said, he is too small for fullback - the 2022 GF proved that. Half-back might be his best position, but then he will be defending against big bodies in the centres and I am not sure he is up to that role. He is a good fill in player, but that is about it. We all rise to our natural pecking order. I recall the superstars of my high school football side who were a very good side and the best the top players got to were reserve grade for St George. The players who are good in the NRL really are at much higher level than anyone else.
Paul Suttor
Expert
their defence seemed better but the Sharks didn't throw too much at them, jury well and truly still out on whether they'll be better in defence this year ... surely they cant be worse than last year
Paul Suttor
Expert
that is definitely worth a whirl
criag
Roar Rookie
The Roosters v Souths game didn't mean much in terms of result, but it did have a lot of entertainment value, and some up-and-coming prospects showing some really good stuff at times, with some 'beautifully constructed' tries. Not sure how long the NRL's attempt to re-create a pre-season competition will last.
Duncan Smith
Roar Guru
Didn't you last week write about the Bulldogs' terrible defence? At least they only conceded 12 points. May be worth a mention.
Forty Twenty
Roar Rookie
Trouble with Taafe is that at his best he's solid and fairly handy but that puts you a long way back from most other fullbacks who are matchwinners in their different ways.
Tetley
Roar Rookie
Blake Taaffe could make the switch to halfback. He's nippy and has got the hands and kicking game. He's not big enough for fullback. Give Crichton a crack.
Ferret
Roar Rookie
Totally agree that, based on last night's showing, the Dogs don't have a halfback to take them to the 8. Both Hutchison and Sexton looked a level below NRL standard at #7. Burton runs and has a big boot. Not convinced he's a 5/8 either and certainly not with mediocre halfbacks inside him. Reed Mahoney is a defensive machine, but not overly creative at 9. Taafe had a mixed night (at best). The Dogs recruitment / re-build looks woeful. Maybe there is some talent coming through the lower ranks, but serious questions for Ciraldo and Gould to answer in 2024.
souvalis
Roar Rookie
Puru should play NRL this year and big tank Tuku wont be far off either. Defence for both sides was good but nothing complicated was ever thrown up at either of them. Entire Shark backline phoned it in.
Danno1
Roar Rookie
Sorry for the solid block of writing the new paragraphs havent appeared like the version l submitted...
Danno1
Roar Rookie
With the dogs I thought Taafe was very good in the first half but had an absolute nightmare in the second, seemed confidence was gone after his first drop. Mahoney needs to improve his dummy half passing game, lots of poor passes. Kikau aimed up in defence but l only remember him running with the ball twice, am hoping that was a tactic for the trial, otherwise a waste of talent The half issue remains, all our options are just OK. On the positives Salmon was a real workhorse in the middle in defence, Curran will be a very good buy, Hughes looks a likely lad and Xerri has surprised me considering his time out of the game. The dogs will need to play a different type of footy this year with the squad they have, it can’t be one out hit ups and try to take the space because they lack the size, they do have a lot of forwards with decent footwork and good hands, will they develop a game to utilize that? Last night was very much a continuation of last year and that’s a concern.
Tony
Roar Guru
The Dogs only lost by 6, so maybe it's the Sharks that have the problem?
Tony
Roar Guru
If they just played in their official strip there'd be no problem. I'm waiting for the day when both teams run out in the same jerseys.
Paul Suttor
Expert
Hutchison is the ideal bench utility but in the fair dinkum dept, if he is your starting halfback, your team is unlikely to be a finals contender. Burton is best as a secondary playmaker creating breaks and unleashing huge kicks rather than being the main on-field general
Paul Suttor
Expert
a mate of mine reminded me of that line the other day at cricket when the DL method was a possibility as rain threatened
Paul Suttor
Expert
Salmon seems better as an edge forward backing up Kikau and Preston ... Curran would be a better option as starting lock
Paul Suttor
Expert
Sharks tailed off significantly in the 2nd half when they took off their main guys. Cam McInnes is no longer a dummy-half option & should stick to lock based on a couple of those terrible passes he threw
Dumbo
Roar Rookie
Oh, and the other thing I took from the Dogs v Sharks match is that although NRL Central is happy to make unnecessary changes to the rules, every time somebody has a thought bubble, Graham Annersley is still INCAPABLE of issuing a statement that prevents two clubs wearing almost identical coloured strips.