Australia gave up their advantage on day two of the Second Test with their unreliable middle order again failing to put New Zealand away in Christchurch with the match now precariously placed.
With the wicket flattening out, the Black Caps enter day three on 2-134, a lead of 40, and have a golden chance to set Australia a decent victory target if overnight duo Tom Latham and Rachin Ravindra can get going.
Australia should have dominated Saturday’s play to establish a match-winning lead but their middle-order woes, which have been a problem all summer, continued to surrender the advantage they had built up on the opening day.
On the back of Travis Head getting out cheaply on day one to continue his miserable summer, Mitchell Marsh was dismissed for a duck and Alex Carey was again out sweeping for just 14 when his team needed him to stick around with Marnus Labuschagne.
In a welcome return to form, Labuschagne looked on course for his first hundred since the fourth Ashes Test last July but fell just before lunch when Glenn Phillips claimed a screamer in the gully.
Mitchell Starc (28) and Pat Cummins (23 not out) swung freely to make amends for the middle-order stumbles but Australia ended up with a lead of 96 when they had a chance to bat the Black Caps out of the game.
Carey’s spot in the team is coming under scrutiny and after Josh Inglis replaced him in the ODI side during the World Cup, the Western Australian keeper could be closing in on a Test debut next summer.
Adding to Carey’s woes, he dropped a diving chance off Josh Hazlewood late on day two which should have sent Latham on his way for 59.
The South Australian left-hander was named in the ICC Test team of the year for 2023 and his glovework has for the most part been exemplary, but his batting has become unreliable and he is too often falling to the sweep, whether the conventional style or reverse.
Alex Carey ducks under a bouncer. (Photo by Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)
He swept the second ball he faced from Phillips in Christchurch in what looked like a premeditated shot and spooned it to Latham in one of the softest dismissals imaginable.
With the Australian selectors needing to regenerate the Test team with younger players due to the fact Cameron Green and Labuschagne (just) are the only players under 30 in the line-up, Carey cannot afford to be reckless with the bat.
In his past 27 innings, Carey has registered just four half-centuries at an average of 23.38 and at 32, his career is at the crossroads.
The Black Caps batted with much more certainty in the second innings after their paltry effort of 156 on day 1.
Latham grinded his way to 65 by stumps off 154 deliveries with Ravindra navigating his way to 11 in a short stay at the crease.
After opener Will Young nicked off to Mitchell Starc for one, Kane Williamson dropped anchor for New Zealand with customary poise.
Latham fed off Williamson’s stability but soon after reaching his half-century, the world’s top-ranked Test batter was brought undone by the first ball of a Pat Cummins spell which caught his inside edge before clattering into the stumps to end their 105-run partnership.
“It’s a good wicket. It did quite a bit on day one. It is a good surface. There is that bit of pace and bounce. If you can find gaps you get value for runs,” Williamson said.
“It’s nice to have a lead. We’ve just got to see how many we can get. There are no targets at this stage, it’s just batting and implementing plans.”
Matt Henry was again the star with the ball for New Zealand, taking 7-67 on his home ground, as the home side bounced back after nightwatchman Nathan Lyon (20) put on a frustrating half-century stand to start the day with Labuschagne.
Wrecked 'em
Roar Rookie
Keep writing these articles mate. Every time you reckon someone's place is in jeopardy they come out & score plenty. Perhaps it's time to look for another angle for a story.
Nick
Roar Rookie
Why? They both have about the same batting average. That's not improving the team.
Nick
Roar Rookie
What you are saying is because our top 5 have been rubbish the number 7 is under a cloud?
Harvey Wilson
Roar Rookie
One innings does not equal form. Marnus got 6 in the second innings. It was a blip.
qwetzen
Roar Rookie
Error! Not Scott. The other one. Ben Sears.
qwetzen
Roar Rookie
Speaking of actors... Scott Kugglewatsit looks like he was separated at birth from Veeps' Jonah Ryan (Timothy Simons).
Pierro
Roar Rookie
Hi Matt , when the rest of the batsmen are doing better than Carey then ill get concerned about carey. They all failed by and large first innings and second innings outside of a few innings so far. Carey is keeping really well . Lets see how it unfolds tomorrow and next summer first
matth
Roar Guru
But that ongoing average of 23 is a real concern
Rowdy
Roar Rookie
The bikketh tin runneth drieth
Micko
Roar Rookie
Head has always been hit & miss.
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
NZ playing with more certainty in the second innings because the pitch has flattened out. Australia should have had a lead of at least 150, probably more, given the way it played . A series of some of the most ordinary shots to get out by an Australian team I can remember, apart perhaps from the openers. Travis has become hit and miss - a disconnect from his usual instincts for knowing when his shots are going to come off. The less said about Carey the better, again. Marnus’s was bad too - no footwork and a back cut in the air near a fielder. Sure he batted well enough before that, but the reason the best players make really big scores is by not hitting it in the air when you don’t need to. Green’s shot to get out was poor defence, ditto Marsh.
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
Need to think about which batters can play good spin well.
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
You call getting out capitulation, not having backbone? They had little chance as their bowling was a fraction of the Indians’ quality on those tracks. Three of the four best spinners in the world plus arguably the best quick against two complete rookie spinners.
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
Reckon we’ll be chasing 300+ though.
Steele
Roar Rookie
I’d argue that ‘new’ old ball cost Aus the last game.
qwetzen
Roar Rookie
Put Smith back into the middle order to sure it up In his last 13 inns at #4 Smith averaged 33.5.
Steele
Roar Rookie
You could also argue there isn’t a lot between their respective batting. FC records are similar, however Carey isn’t even averaging 30 for Australia. I’d swap them, but it may not mean more runs. I just think Inglis deserves the chance, he’s also in form.
Pierro
Roar Rookie
Hes keeping so well it won't happen 13th man. Especially with 9 months. For the record he was very susceptible to spin and got anxious against it yesterday but then again I have to wonder how Inglis would have gone as well ive seen him have some poor periods with he bat on international ODI tour as well . International matches another level.
13th Man
Roar Rookie
He just doesn’t have the game to be an opener - I’d like to see him go to 5.
13th Man
Roar Rookie
I don’t entirely disagree but he does need to contribute more with the bat or his place will come into question - particularly if Inglis keeps making runs at shield level. Competition for places is a good thing - I don’t quite understand the reluctance to ever consider alternatives.