Five talking points from Richmond vs Hawthorn

By Josh / Expert

The AFL Finals series is officially underway, Richmond having won their way through to a home preliminary final with a comfortable 31-point victory over Hawthorn. Here’s my five talking points from the match.

Hawthorn blow their chances early
If Hawthorn ever had a serious chance of winning this match then they gave it away in the early minutes when Luke Breust and Shaun Burgoyne both failed to convert set shots you’d usually back them in for.

Breust again missed what looked like a sitter late in the second quarter which would have kept the Hawks in touch with the Tigers at a time when the game was starting to slip away from them.

In the first quarter, in particular, it seemed it was the Hawks who were better prepared for the game, playing finer football and setting up more realistic opportunities.

They managed to put themselves narrowly ahead at the first change, but should really have ended the first term at least two goals in front.

Could they have gone on to win from a position like that? We’ll never know for sure, but it certainly would have helped.

Daniel gives Hawthorn some Rioli envy
Hawks fans have seen a Rioli ruin an opposition team’s night at the MCG so many times that it must have been a little shocking to be on the other end of it for once.

After his start to the season was delayed by injury, Daniel Rioli has been in solid form through the home-and-away, but once again has risen to the top in finals.

Last year he broke out on the big stage to kick a career-high four goals in a preliminary final against GWS, on Thursday night it was three against the Hawks in a qualifier.

But his three goals were not simply three goals – they were three little waves of a magic wand, all turning nothing into something and the first two in particular came at times when the match was still a serious arm-wrestle.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Dustin Martin kicks an absolute worldie
Only one game in and already the best goal of the finals series has been kicked, as Dustin Martin slotted one from the boundary line that science is still yet to explain.

The match arguably turned out to be a bit of a fizzer – threats of an all-time epic tactical takedown from Alastair Clarkson petered out sooner rather than later, and the Tigers were predictably triumphant after halftime.

What instead made the game a memorable one will be the handful of incredible goals kicked by the Tigers – they were playing like millionaires, and I suppose for someone like Dustin Martin that is probably a very fair way to play.

There could have been a few more too were it not for the pesky post getting in the way, or Damien Hardwick’s beloved goal review system. One thing is for sure, Richmond are not lacking in confidence this September.

Lynch mind games don’t shake Tigers
I for one found it very curious that the news about Tom J Lynch knocking back both Hawthorn and Collingwood happened to break in a week where both sides would benefit from Richmond being a bit distracted.

The news that Lynch was locked and loaded at Tigerland – although, seriously, we’ve known this was happening for a while – blew up and created a lot of discussion this week about the impact free agency has had on the league.

The conspiracy theorist in me would think that perhaps Hawthorn and Collingwood have known for a while which way this one was going, but saved leaking the news for the most opportune moment in the hopes it would get into Richmond’s heads.

Or, maybe it was just a coincidence. Either way, it didn’t seem to trouble the Tigers at all. If anything, their fans have moved past dreaming of back-to-back and are already talking threepeat.

Hawks stare down a second straight-sets exit in three years
Two years ago the Hawks were unceremoniously dumped out of finals in straight sets after a heartbreaking miss after the siren from Isaac Smith was followed by a rapturous upset semi-final win from the flag-bound Western Bulldogs.

This year they face as simillar scenario as the Hawks will next week have to host the winner of tonight’s match between the Melbourne Demons and the Geelong Cats, and whoever it is will be coming in red hot and full of confidence.

A hamstring injury to Ben Stratton last night looks set to rule him out for likely the rest of Hawthorn’s finals campaign – he could perhaps return in time for the grand final if the Hawks qualified, but any earlier would be a miraculous recovery.

Losing a key defensive cog like Stratton will be a serious bow to Hawthorn’s hopes of stay alive, and even though they’ve had wins over both the Dees and Cats during this year, my gut feel is that whoever wins through tonight will end the Hawks’ season in a week’s time.

The Crowd Says:

2018-09-10T02:41:30+00:00

Bruce

Guest


Strats went down what halfway through the 3rd? Richmond well on their way by then mate. Final quarter was entirely junk time.

2018-09-08T01:07:50+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Naaaah. Didn't have much to do down back. Ball was at the other end most of the night.

2018-09-08T01:06:33+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Before they developed the belief in themselves that they could beat top 8 sides. Something Collingwood still can't do.

2018-09-08T01:04:47+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Swans have been better away from Sydney this year. Haven't you noticed?

2018-09-07T09:00:31+00:00

Peppsy

Roar Guru


No coincidence that Richmond ran away with it after Stratton went down, if it was Rance instead it may have gone the other way

2018-09-07T08:56:47+00:00

Peppsy

Roar Guru


to be fair, they were also down a mullet in Q3. Down 2 for a good bit of it.

2018-09-07T07:32:23+00:00

Mango Jack

Roar Guru


He's still good enough, and the year off has probably extended his playing career. I thought he played OK last night. Generally kicks a couple when they need it. Not enough sadly.

2018-09-07T07:26:34+00:00

Mango Jack

Roar Guru


Take that, Peppa Pig!

2018-09-07T06:59:32+00:00

Aligee

Roar Rookie


Ah ok, they asked me and i said 7, but they must have found it on 7 mate and didnt tell me i was wrong - happens a bit in my house :), or alternatively they told me and i didnt listen - that also happens a bit.

2018-09-07T06:58:04+00:00

gameofmarks

Roar Guru


And the 6th talking point is......Roughy won't be at Hawthorn next year..... He has been a great footballer, but it looks like he he riding that very slippery slope out of the best 22...

2018-09-07T06:25:52+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


Who cares if the Hawks go out in straight sets. To make it to the top 4 is a mammoth effort for a club going through a massive list restructure. Most "experts" had them missing finals and falling further than last year. Any way, I wouldn't be quick to write Hawthorn off. They beat Geelong recently in a match they controlled until a late lapse, crushed Melbourne earlier in the year. C

2018-09-07T06:17:31+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


46k on the digital channels is very good, for example, the 2nd highest rating show for the night, Peppa Pig, got 41k in Sydney and 50k in Brisbane.

2018-09-07T06:13:01+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Shown on 7Mate in Perth.

2018-09-07T05:55:17+00:00

Aligee

Roar Rookie


Seems low for Perth, i know my youngest son got home from school and wanted to go for an obligatory kick, wandered home about 5:30 (WST) to my wife watching Ozarks and turned it over to 7 to catch the first goal, turned it back to Ozarks on netflix with about 10 minutes to go. Normal friday footy gets around 100k on 7mate, pretty sure thursday night AFL finals was on 7 (main channel)

2018-09-07T05:50:18+00:00

Aligee

Roar Rookie


Yep you got it, i like seeing the most recent comments and more than likely it would be the most popular thread and morphed into something else etc etc. The site seemed to be far more open, ATM it reminds of a house you walk into that is crammed full of stuff and you feel entrapped in it. Not a fan ATM

2018-09-07T05:41:34+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


More rubbish. Do you think if you keep writing this the media will take up this non issue and give Collingwood some hope when it doesn't conne up against Richmond during the finals?

2018-09-07T04:49:45+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


The Bachelor and Goggle Box were better games

2018-09-07T04:47:02+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


It wasn't broken so they fixed it.

2018-09-07T04:33:12+00:00

Sean1

Guest


Agreed, but apparently some muppet said the Tiges were cherry ripe to be knocked off this week being in the worst current form for the last 14 months! Even though they haven\'t lost for 2 months lmaoo.

2018-09-07T04:29:41+00:00

Pablo

Guest


Josh, nice summary of the game but I preferred Dusty's underground handball on the wing than his kick, both of which resulted in goals and underlined his x factor which, apart from Franklin and Dangerfield, most other sides don't have. Don't agree with your straight sets exit prediction for the Hawks. Yes they did look outclassed for a period and lost on the scoreboard and inside 50 count. But they won the count for possessions, clearances, stoppages, contested possessions, tackles and hit outs. Their mid field of Mitchell, O'Meara and Shiels were all good. Richmond played very well last night. They matched the Hawks tackling and aggression early on and then their cream rose to the top. I will be surprised if another team gets within 31 points of Richmond this year. Geelong and Melbourne have both come up short against the Hawks this year. They have both been inconsistent against good sides. Will the team that wins tonight be able to do that again next week against the Hawks? Bring on the Cats as I'd love to see little Tommy Hawkins crying again after another defeat by the Hawks in a big game.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar